We buy all the products we test — no freebies from companies. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission, which helps support our testing.
Hiking is our jam. We've trail-tested 129 unique pairs of the best hiking shoes since 2012, and in this update we compare the 18 best men's models available today. Our experts covered hundreds of miles in these shoes, from dry, high alpine hikes to wet, muddy rock-strewn paths. Day hikes and multi-day adventures informed us on key performance areas like traction, all-day comfort, and support to bring you relevant and helpful comparisons. For moving light and fast, hiking shoes can be a better choice hiking boots, but choosing the ones to suit your needs isn't always easy. Our review guides you to the ideal shoe for your foot, whether you want the lightest pair, a trail-running hiker, or just a screamin' deal.
The Hoka Anacapa 2 Low GTX is our favorite men's hiking shoe. They are supremely comfortable, with the support and durability to keep you moving on the trails. They are waterproof with a high flood height, so no need to fear those shallow stream crossings.
The Columbia Crestwood is a budget-friendly hiking shoe that performs well in many conditions. It is ready to go right out of the box and excels in warm, arid climates. These hikers are a go-to for those new to hiking, and their lightweight build feels much like a tennis shoe.
While most shoes come in women's and men's versions, they don't always perform the same. To address this, we also conduct in-depth testing of the best women's hiking shoes. If you want something burlier, check out our hiking boots review. Additionally, we have extensive reviews of hiking gear and backpacking gear to help you get ready for all manner of adventure.
Editor's Note: On November 1, 2024, we added updates to previously tested shoes, added new models, and added new tests for several metrics.
The Hoka Anacapa 2 Low GTX is definitely the most overall comfortable hiker in this year's test. We have reviewed a lot of hiking shoes, but these ones stand out for their overall performance across every single metric. Not only are they soft and pliable thanks to high-quality mesh and nubuck leather uppers, but they are built on a responsive CMEVA midsole that absorbs impacts on the trail. Additionally, they easily conform to the foot with time and do not require much of a break-in period. The support provided by the cushiony midsole and slight rocker is much appreciated when hiking on firm surfaces. Our lead tester, Ryan Huetter, noted, “My foot sits low in the shoe, making them feel stable, while the wide outsole resists rolling.” These shoes weigh in at 1.99 pounds for a size 11, which is middle of the pack. The stability and durability provided by these shoes sacrifice a little bit of weight, but that is a sacrifice we are willing to make for a well-built shoe. Using the well-known waterproof and breathable membrane, Gore-Tex, they are also highly water resistant and boast a three-inch flood height. Additionally, this Gore-Tex membrane let our feet breathe on warm days. They are grippy thanks to a Vibram Megagrip outsole, with our testing team saying, “They have great traction through mud, over wet rocks, and walking through stream beds.” and “The large surface area is great on dry trails and through boulder fields.”
Surprisingly, we have little critical to say about the Anacapa. However, we found ourselves grabbing the Salewa Mountain Trainer Lite GTX when there was going to be sustained scrambling involved, as the Hoka's wide platform doesn't do well in less secure, technical environments where precise edging ability is required. We also had to get used to the Swallowtail design as it extends beyond the natural heel more than other shoes do. During our first few wears, we had unbalanced heel strikes, but this went away with time and practice. If this heel design is more than you'd like, the Salomon X Ultra 4 Gore-Tex has a more traditional style and performs well in technical terrain. All in all, the Anacapa 2 is a high-scoring model and is the shoe we would heartily recommend to someone looking for a super comfortable option for most hiking applications.
The Columbia Crestwood initially caught our eye for its low price point, but really “wowed” us when we put them on and took them for a stroll. They use a Techlite midsole that is reasonably supportive but is not overly stiff. Our feet felt comfortable as we trekked on uneven terrain. Weighing 1.83 pounds for a size 11, they are among the lightest in our lineup. These shoes use a suede leather and mesh upper that is pliable and breathes well in arid climates. We enjoyed wearing these on day hikes on our local trail system, but we also took them into moderate off-trail terrain and found them to do surprisingly well for a budget shoe. These shoes feel more like tennis shoes, and we had very little break-in. Our tester, Ryan Huetter, mentions, “Fitting much like a well-loved pair of sneakers, they are easy and enjoyable to walk in.”
The Crestwood is not as supportive as many other shoes in this review, like the Salomon X Ultra 4 Gore-Tex that feature a stiffer midsole construction. This lighter construction will limit the Crestwood's usefulness in really demanding terrain. They are also not waterproof, and their flood height is only one inch, so those seeking a shoe that will keep their feet dry in wet climates may look to another shoe such as the Merrell Moab 3 Waterproof. However, if you live in a warm and dry climate, you likely won't need a waterproof shoe. For those looking for an entry-level shoe that won't break the bank and offers good performance in mild and moderate hiking terrain, we enjoy the Crestwood and recommend it for its bargain price.
The Salewa Mountain Trainer Lite GTX embodies the important elements of a good hiking shoe. It is a midweight shoe at 2.16 pounds, built from Salewa's 3F System: Kevlar® cables, mesh, and TPU. Comfortable in all conditions, the Pomoca MTN Trainer Lite outsole was more than capable at handling all terrain we threw at it. Whether it was loose scree, mud patches, or hardpack trails, the superb traction kept us upright. These shoes have great waterproofing, with a Gore-Tex Extended Comfort liner and a 3.5-inch flood height. We had no trouble crossing shallow streams. Our lead tester has abused his pair on long-distance trail hikes in the mountains and in the desert, has used them as approach shoes to access rock climbing venues, and even mentions he “found them to be supportive enough to be good work shoes.” This is one of the best models we tested for scrambling around in the mountains, climbing off-trail, and up to summits that involve 3rd class terrain.
The Mountain Trainer is one of the stiffer soled shoes in our review, a trait that many will benefit from, but they are not nearly as flexible and easy to walk in as some of the other lighter shoes. That said, a break-in period is required, though it is much shorter than a boot break-in. Should comfort be what you are searching for, the Hoka Speedgoat 6 is worth taking a look at. We also find them a bit uncomfortable initially, but they are not nearly as difficult to break in as an old-school boot. Likewise, the Hoka Anacapa 2 was comfortable right out of the box. The Salewa Mountain Trainers are still a great choice as an all-purpose hiker, but we recommend them for those who want to venture onto challenging off-trail routes.
Some comfort issues with tongue and heel construction
Quicklace lacing system might turn some off
Average durability
The Salomon X Ultra 4 Gore-Tex hiking shoe is built to chew up even the roughest trails. These shoes are made especially for rugged terrain, requiring high-performance ability on various surfaces. Built on an AVD-C Chassis, the support offered by these low-top hikers is top-tier, and the combination of SensiFit technology and the Quicklace lacing system allows the shoe to conform to your foot. Cinching the laces makes these shoes quick to put on and generally convenient. We love how confident our footwork feels thanks to the deep-set lugs on the outsole and what a difference solid waterproofing, thanks to a Gore-Tex membrane, can make to hiking comfort. For all of these attributes, it is surprising that these shoes come in at such a low weight, a measly 1.76 pounds for a pair of US size 11. This new iteration of a well-known and well-regarded classic shaves off nearly a quarter pound per pair. Our lead tester, Ryan, states, “This is a light and effective shoe with a lot of attributes that support its price tag.”
While the Quicklace system is mostly convenient, it sometimes slips or becomes hard to release. To avoid a tripping hazard, the laces must be tucked into the storage pouch on the tongue or behind other laces. Due to the extended heel tab, we found these shoes to feel taller than other models. This tab led to rubbing on the Achilles area when wearing thin or low-cut socks, especially when going down steep slopes. While this is a very worthy hiking shoe, especially for its weight and overall performance, continued testing has highlighted several small imperfections that keep us from giving it our top award. The Oboz Sawtooth X Low Waterproof is another shoe worth mentioning for its performance in rugged terrain, though not nearly as light as the Salomon.
Year after year, the La Sportiva Spire GTX continues to be one of our favorites. This capable hiking shoe performs admirably on all terrain, from on-trail walks to long-distance thru-hikes over rough cross-country routes. Supportive and comfortable, we are also impressed with their weight. While there are certainly lighter models out there, at 2.06 pounds per pair, the Spire gives us a lot of hiking performance and without sacrificing comfort. The cushioned midsole kept our feet happy mile after mile, and the beefy Vibram XS Trek outsole bit down on loose surfaces. The deep and widely spaced lugs shed mud and avoid caking on debris. These shoes have a unique Impact Braking System, which helps grab onto the ground during steep descents. We had no trouble running in these shoes, yet they aren't soft enough that we would only run in them. We gladly pick these up for hikes and runs.
The Spire GTX is a shoe we recommend to people who want to easily switch between hiking and running while out on the trail. It is the most effective option in our lineup as a trail running shoe, though it contains so many hiking shoe attributes that we classify it as such. Fastpackers, speedy thru-hikers, and those who prefer softer, more forgiving on-trail footwear will like this shoe. If you're looking for something that excels off-trail, the Adidas Terrex Swift R3 is an excellent option. These have a premium price tag attached to their great performance. The Columbia Facet 75 OutDry is much cheaper and has a sneaker-like style, offering comfort and great traction. However, they aren't as durable or supportive as the Spire.
The Merrell Moab 3 is a fine hiking shoe that excels in warm weather. This comfy shoe uses soft pigskin leather and mesh in its upper, making it cozy to slip into. It fits snugly, making it feel supportive around the foot and below thanks to a molded nylon shank. This is the non-waterproof version, though we also have good things to say about the Moab 3 Waterproof. This lack of waterproof membrane means they are best suited to hiking in warm, dry or arid environments. We would far rather grab a pair of these shoes for a desert hike than a pair that have a Gore-Tex lining, as they expel heat much more efficiently. These shoes have practically no break-in time thanks to the Air Cushion midsole, and they are even comfier within a few miles of wear.
They are not the lightest shoe, and they do feel a little bit clumsy due to this weight, so we found them to be most useful on simple and moderately challenging trails, and a little out of their league in more demanding off-trail travel or with a really heavy pack weight. If you find yourself in mud, you might find these lugs get caked quickly. However, most other on-trail surfaces are no problem for the Moabs. If you often hike in wet or muddly climates, the Salewa Mountain Trainer Lite GTX can tackle this climate with no trouble, though the waterproof liner doesn't breathe as well as those without. All in all, the Moab is a hiking shoe we turn to often, especially in warm climates, and they are a fraction of the price of most top performers.
Headed into warmer weather? The non-waterproof Merrell Moab 3 are our favorite for arid climates.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Compare Products
A burly hike like this one is best enjoyed with a lightweight and technically-minded shoe like the X Ultra 4 GTX.
Credit: Jen Reynolds
How We Test Hiking Shoes for Men
Since the category of hiking shoes (or shoes that could easily be hiked in) is broad, our review staff and editors spend much time sifting through the countless models before settling on the top shoes for testing. This starts with extensive research, ultimately selecting interesting, exciting, or highly regarded models. We then buy each pair and ship them out to our expert review staff, who spend untold hours hiking around. We hike for our living, so it is an enjoyable task, though we use our predetermined metrics to judge each pair and see how they perform against each other. Once we have walked many miles in each of these hiking shoes, we tally up our results and write the thoughtful, in-depth reviews that you, as a GearLab reader, have come to know and expect. For more on our test process, see our How We Test article.
Men's hiking shoes were tested across six performance metrics:
Comfort (25% of total weighted score)
Support (20% weighting)
Traction (15% weighting)
Weight (15% weighting)
Water Resistance (15% weighting)
Durability (10% weighting)
We performed more than 10 individual assessments on each hiker, and our testers wore each pair in the real world for a minimum of 20 miles to determine long-term wear and changes in performance over time as they break in and potentially wear out. Each shoe was scored on a scale of 1 through 10 for each metric, resulting in an overall score. While looking at the overall score to see which models were the best across all metrics is useful, you should also pay attention to how each shoe performs in specific applications.
In testing hiking shoes, we hiked plenty of trails, measured their waterproofing, dialed in on comfort and support, among many other tests.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Why Trust GearLab
This review was tag-teamed by Ryan Huetter and Ben Applebaum-Bauch. Ryan is a full-time mountain guide who spends more than 200 days a year hiking, climbing, and recreating on and off-trail. As an IFMGA Certified Mountain Guide through the American Mountain Guides Association, Ryan is an outdoor professional, and hiking on a trail is his daily commute. Ben started his outdoor career as a guide on multi-week backpacking and cycling trips. He is an avid distance hiker, completing thru-hikes of iconic American trails, including the Pacific Crest Trail, Long Trail, Oregon Coast, Pinhoti, and Superior Hiking Trail.
We tested these shoes in all types of conditions, from wet trails to dusty playas.
Nimble and fresh-feeling in the Aerios FL GTX.
Capable and comfortable, the Toa Gore-Tex takes rough conditions in stride.
Our team spent many miles on the trails testing these hiking boots, all to find out which were the best.
Analysis and Test Results
We tested thoroughly, taking meticulous notes along the way so that we could score them all using a set of pre-defined testing metrics to help you find the right hikers for you.
What's the Best Value?
Many purchase decisions require us to prioritize one consideration over another. For example, you might prefer something lightweight with hiking shoes, but chances are it won't be as supportive. If you're wondering about the trade-off between the price and our estimate of the product's value, this review can help.
One of our favorite value options, the Columbia Crestwood, gives a great performance for a very reasonable dollar amount. And, for just a tiny bit more, the Columbia Facet 75 provides great all-around performance and a little more comfort. Though the Keen Targhee IV is now available, the Keen Targhee III Low is still available and can often be found at a great price. The Moab 3 is another option that we love to take on the trails that has great value.
What a great day for a dog walk on the area's beautiful trail network! The Crestwood shoes are a stand-out budget buy for these kinds of walks.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Comfort
Comfort is king when it comes to all hiking footwear. There is simply no reason to choose a shoe that does not feel great right out of the box. Everyone's foot is different, and we recommend ordering a few different shoes and keeping the ones that fit the best. Luckily, we are past the days of excruciating break-in periods; modern hiking shoes are lighter and use less rigid materials, which allows them to be ready to hit the trail from the moment you lace them up.
We take extensive notes on how each shoe feels when we test for comfort. We start by scrutinizing material stiffness, ease of entry and removal, lacing systems, and roominess. A shoe should not need to be broken in if it's made from synthetic fabrics such as mesh and PU-coated nylon, which is now quite common. The material should wrap around the foot without feeling bulky or clunky, and it should not have any stiffness leading to discomfort while walking, such as a tongue that cuts into your ankle. Comfort also relates to fit, and we relate the fit to individual foot volume so that you can get an idea of how loose or snug a pair of shoes might be. Shoes like the Hoka Anacapa 2 Low and La Sportiva Spire rose to the top of the more traditional hiking shoes, and for those that like trail running shoes, the Hoka Speedgoat 6 and Columbia Facet 75 were also high scorers.
We want our shoes to protect us from the jarring impacts that hiking trails have.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
We consider the entire shoe and cover everything, including the way the cuff feels around the ankle, the width of the shoe, the insole quality and arch support, the size of the toe box, as well as any improvements to comfort and protection, such as a molded toe cap or bumper, like you might find on the Keen Targhee IV Low.
Useful features, like the molded toe bumpers seen on the Danner Trail 2650 GTX, protect the foot and make the shoe more comfortable.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Finally, we looked at how well each model breathes. Dry feet are comfortable feet, and a good design keeps everything dry when splashing through puddles while still breathing well on warmer days. We took each model to the local gym to walk on a treadmill at the same speed (3 mph), at the same incline (moderate), and for the same distance (1 mile) in the same socks (no fear, we cleaned them between trials). Afterward, we noted how hot our feet were, then removed the shoes to check for sock dampness and sweat accumulation on our feet. The products without a waterproof membrane — the Hoka Speedgoat 6 breathes the best by far since it is entirely mesh, followed by the Merrell Moab 3 and the Columbia Crestwood. These models use large mesh panels but still have some suede leather for durability. The Vasque Juxt does not use a waterproof membrane of any kind, but the lack of mesh means it does not breathe as well as the others.
Thirteen miles in, our feet feel great, thanks to the Speedgoats! The perfect shoe for the approach hike to this backcountry climb. The rest of us are feeling the miles, though!
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Of the shoes with waterproof membranes, the La Sportiva Spire breathes the most, likely thanks to the added air ventilation below the insole. The Columbia Facet 75 was a solid contender in this regard — lots of mesh along the upper allows it to breathe quite well. Some users will need to choose a shoe with a waterproof lining based on where they hike (wet environments), but if you live in an arid climate, then consider one of the shoes without a liner so that your feet will breathe better and not get as sweaty and damp.
The Moab 3 can slosh through a bit of water, but are really meant for dumping heat and breathing well in hot weather.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
The Hoka Anacapa Low 2 GTX is the most comfortable shoe in our review. It provides luxurious comfort with a cushioned midsole that helps shield your feet from the jarring impacts of firm surfaces like rocks and packed down trails. Our testers didn't need to break them in; they were comfy from day one. For more off-trail-ready comfort, the Spire GTX was a tester favorite.
The notoriously sharp rocks of McGee Creek Canyon, brutal on thin soles, were a breeze to navigate thanks to the supportive Spire GTX.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Support
How much support a shoe provides depends on several factors, including the thickness and materials of the midsole, the thickness of the outsole, the shape of the last, and, to a lesser extent, the insole. An ideal hiking shoe is stiff from heel to midfoot but flexible upfront. Most models we reviewed include a shank between the midsole and outsole, increasing stiffness and protecting the foot over rough terrain. Stability is also affected by the forefoot width and ankle collar height.
If ankle protection and support are a key concern for you, consider a pair of hiking boots. While not always the most comfortable option for day hikes, the extra weight and warmth might be worth it if it stops you from rolling your ankle. We've outlined our picks for men and women and rounded them up in our best hiking boots review.
To investigate stiffness underfoot, we tested the lateral torsion of each model. Reliable torsional support reduces the risk of injury in uneven terrain and when carrying a load. Holding the front of the shoe in one hand and the heel in the other, we twisted the shoe, similar to wringing out a towel. The more twist resistance, the greater rigidity in the sole. This rigidity improves a shoe's support when moving through talus and rough terrain or scrambling and hopping boulders. The Salewa Mountain Trainer Lite is one of the stiffest contenders in a group that varies widely in this aspect. Similar to the Keen Targhee IV, it can be hard to find burly support in the form of a midsole stiffener without sacrificing comfort.
Awkward and uneven terrain necessitates excellent support, and in this slot canyon the X Ultra 4 didn't let us down.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Those who desire a hefty underfoot structure may also find the Facet 75 OutDry a solid option. With an especially wide base that our testers found to reduce the likelihood of ankle rolls, it felt similar to the Hoka Anacapa 2 Low. The Facet also comes with a robust heel guard, which secures the back of the foot. We were pleased that all the shoes we reviewed flexed sufficiently in the forefoot. While this flex and softness of materials can help with comfort, if the design is not well executed, it can leave you feeling uneasy and vulnerable. The Speedgoat 6.0 and Keen Zionic Speed have similar running shoe construction, but we felt very tippy and unsupported while wearing the Zionic.
The Salewa Mountain Trainer Lite offers excellent ankle support thanks to its stiff sole and a 3F system that cradles your foot.
Credit: Jen Reynolds
Additionally, we measured the forefoot at its widest point on each shoe. Wide bases provide a stable foundation for powering through each step. The Hoka Anacapa 2 Low has the widest of all the forefoot widths at 5 inches, and the Merrell model tied with the Columbia Facet for the second broadest forefoot at 4.75 inches. We also measured the height of the ankle collar (from the footbed to the highest ankle point) to check ankle stability. While ankle protection is more of a thing with hiking boots, we still appreciate a pair of hiking shoes that offers more stability than a typical trail runner.
We love shoes that have a hefty midsole, such as the BOOST midsole featured on the Terrex Free Hiker, which protects the feet during rugged use.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Lastly, we also considered the quality of the insole. Some manufacturers view the insole as just an opportunity to add cushioning and improve the fit of the footbed. We appreciate manufacturers that take the insole as an opportunity to add support to the heel and arch. The stiffest insole award goes to the Keen models, while the Salomon, Vasque, and Merrell products also beefed up their insoles by adding a second, more dense layer of foam to the back half of the foot. This extra support does not take away from comfort in the footbed. While many hikers see buying third-party insoles as automatic, hiking shoes are not cheap, and we like included insoles that aren't either.
An array of insoles from pairs we tested.
Credit: Ross Robinson
We also like to consider the stack height of the shoe, as in how tall you are standing above the ground, as this can decrease the feeling of stability unless that height is remedied by a well-designed heel cup, or by the width of the shoe. We found that a model like the Anacapa 2 did a much better job at improving stability despite being quite tall than the Oboz Sawtooth X Low, which did not extend the ankle collar high enough.
Traversing the Olympic High Divide, the Mountain Trainer Lites provide additional stability on challenging sections of the trail.
Credit: Jen Reynolds
Traction
Traction is a fundamental trait to consider in a hiking shoe. The basis for a shoe's traction is the outsole. Made from rubber compounds and molded into different shapes called lugs, the amount of grip the shoe's outsole directly relates to how secure you will feel, whether you're walking the dog on a local trail or scrambling up peaks deep in the backcountry. Depending on your application, you may want a shoe with softer or harder rubber. Soft rubber will conform better to smooth surfaces such as rock slabs, while harder rubber will resist deformation and bite into loose terrain better while also lasting longer. Some companies outsource their rubber selection to well-known companies like Vibram, while others choose an in-house or proprietary rubber blend.
Outsole Materials
Materials Used
Hoka Anacapa 2 Low GTX
Vibram Megagrip rubber
Salewa Mountain Trainer Lite GTX
Pomoca MTN Trainer Lite
Salomon X Ultra 4 Gore-Tex
Contagrip MA rubber
La Sportiva Spire GTX
Vibram XS Trek with Impact Brake System
Columbia Facet 75 OutDry
Adapt Trax
Keen NXIS EVO Waterproof
KEEN.ALL-TERRAIN rubber
Adidas Terrex Free Hiker GTX
Continental rubber
Oboz Sawtooth X Low Waterproof
Trail Tread rubber
Adidas Terrex Swift R3 Gore-Tex
Continental
Merrell Moab 3 Waterproof
Vibram TC5+
Keen Targhee III Low
Non-marking rubber
Hoka Speedgoat 6
Vibram Megagrip with Traction Lug
Merrell Moab 3
Vibram TC5+
Columbia Crestwood
OmniGrip
Vasque Juxt
Vasque OTG
Danner Trail 2650 GTX
Vibram 460 with Megagrip
Keen Targhee IV Low
Keen.Rugged
Keen Zionic Speed
Nonmarking TPU rubber
Lug pattern and shape will also impact your shoe's ability to hold on to the terrain you are on. Wide and shallow lugs give more surface area contact, making them more appropriate for packed trails and firm surfaces, while deeper and sharper cut lugs will provide a better grip on loose trails, mud, and snow. Shoes such as the Salomon X Ultra 4 and the Adidas Terrex Free Hiker Gore-Tex 2.0 Low have great traction on various surface conditions.
Midsole inserts made of molded plastic also contribute to a shoe's traction by giving the user a more stable and secure platform to edge upon, making a dime edge seem like a much broader ledge to use as a foothold.
The X Ultra 4 is one of the most supportive shoes in our review, we feel confident traveling over varied terrain.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Each model was tested side-by-side on five separate surface types to determine the shoes' overall traction score. We even wore different shoes on each foot to compare them directly when trekking through the test areas. First, we walked up and down dry granite slabs. Most models performed well in these scenarios, with the Salewa Mountain Trainer Lite GTX and La Sportiva Spire GTX sticking best to the steepest slopes. Both pairs have lugs that allow for lots of surface area contact. We walked back and forth across the same wet rocks in mountain brooks and streams in our wet rock test. The Salewa Mountain Trainer impressed us on both wet and dry rock.
Descending the loose scree of Baxter Pass in the Sierra Nevada, the La Sportiva Spire GTX's Impact Brake System provided confidence-inspiring stability with every step.
Credit: Jen Reynolds
In our traction tests, we also hustled up slopes of loose sediment, and the more aggressive tread of the Salomon X Ultra 4 dug in better than the rest. We found a trail covered in mud from the thawing snow on the eastern side of the Sierra in Spring. Again, the X Ultra's deep and multi-directional lugs cut through the mud efficiently, finding hidden rocks or more stable soil to gain purchase. We also chose a smooth granite slab, sprayed it with water and tested each pair of shoes to see how it did on a standardized example of wet rock you might find in the backcountry.
Matching shoes to your most common trail conditions helps you achieve the most out of your outsoles. Consider the ground you hike most often.
Finally, we walked up and down some gentle snow-covered slopes warmed into a slushy state by the midday sun. The Salomon X Ultra 4 was a champ while kicking in steps in the snow, especially when going up. Coming down, we again loved outsoles with heel brakes, which tended to catch a sliding foot. The Spire GTX also did well in the snow. Overall, the X Ultra 4 showcases the best all-around traction, while the Salewa Mountain Trainer has the most purchase on rock, a boon for rugged alpine travel.
Smearing up smooth rock on an off-trail section of Mt. Whitney requires precise traction control. The Sportiva Spire performed very well.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Water Resistance
It's no secret dry feet provide more comfort and warmth than wet ones. Moisture and water in the footbed also increase the likelihood of blisters. The trade-off for solid waterproofing is lower breathability, warmer feet, and a higher price tag. Most of the shoes we reviewed have waterproof liners except for the Columbia Crestwood, Keen Zionic Speed, Vasque Juxt, and Hoka Speedgoat 6.
While flood height doesn't account for the whole picture of waterproofing, it is important if you frequent stream crossings. The flood height refers to the level at which water pours in, whether that be the top of the shoe or an opening near the tongue. The Keen Targhee III has the best flood height of 3.75 inches. This shoe has recently been updated to the fourth generation, and the flood height dropped to 3.25 inches. The Mountain Trainer, Spire, and Adidas Terrex Free Hiker each have a flood height of 3.50 inches, which is plenty high for shallow streams.
Waterproofing Materials
Materials Used
Hoka Anacapa 2 Low GTX
GORE-TEX Invisible Fit
Salewa Mountain Trainer Lite GTX
Gore-Tex Extended Comfort
Salomon X Ultra 4 Gore-Tex
Gore-Tex membrane
La Sportiva Spire GTX
Gore-Tex Surround
Columbia Facet 75 OutDry
OutDry
Keen NXIS EVO Waterproof
KEEN.dry waterproof membrane
Adidas Terrex Free Hiker GTX
Gore-Tex membrane
Oboz Sawtooth X Low Waterproof
B-DRY waterproof membrane
Adidas Terrex Swift R3 Gore-Tex
Gore-Tex membrane
Merrell Moab 3 Waterproof
Waterproof membrane
Keen Targhee III Low
KEEN.dry waterproof membrane
Hoka Speedgoat 6
None
Merrell Moab 3
None
Columbia Crestwood
None
Vasque Juxt
None, just a gusseted tongue
Danner Trail 2650 GTX
Gore-Tex membrane
Keen Targhee IV Low
Keen.Dry membrane
Keen Zionic Speed
None
Beyond flood height, we also considered how readily the upper absorbs water and their performance in our waterproof challenge. After a couple of months of hiking, we headed to a small mountain stream in the Eastern Sierra. We checked for leaks and splashed around in water deep enough to cover the forefoot. We walked around and flexed the forefoot to see if the added stress caused any leakage. After five minutes, we removed the shoes to see if any water made it inside. A handful of models emerged from the water on top, including the Salomon X Ultra 4, La Sportiva Spire, Salewa Mountain Trainer, Keen NXIS EVO Waterproof, and Hoka Anacapa 2 Low GTX.
Testing the waterproofness of each pair of shoes using a standardized test in a bucket allows us to check the flood height as well as how long they keep water out.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Many of the models that we tested come in both standard and “waterproof” options (a designation in the name like “GTX” for Gore-Tex or “Dry” usually gives it away). Popular liners include options from Gore-Tex or eVent, while some manufacturers, like Keen, use a proprietary membrane. We chose to test the waterproof versions as much as possible because the average hiker often encounters wet conditions, from water crossings and muck to slush and precipitation. However, most manufacturers produce waterproof and non-waterproof versions of their hiking shoes. If you don't need the protection, the non-waterproof versions are almost always cooler, more breathable, and cost less.
Waterproofing isn't always necessarily a good thing. If you hike in regions where there isn't much water, you probably don't need a waterproof shoe. While advances in waterproof membranes have improved and are still somewhat breathable, none are as breathable as a non-waterproofed shoe. For warm weather we love the Merrell Moab 3. These are also available in a waterproof version, but we highly recommend considering these if you aren't going to be crossing streams or snow fields.
If heavy dew and water crossings are common where you hike, consider choosing a dark color option for your shoes. This allows them to dry quickly under the sun.
The Merrell Moab 3 is the shoe we opt for when no water will be encountered, as they are very breathable.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Weight
Light is right for footwear. One of the benefits of a hiking shoe over a full boot is the significant weight shed from every step while still providing a bit more stability and durability over a trail runner or tennis shoe. To compare the different models accurately, we weigh each one ourselves on a digital scale straight out of the box.
The different pairs in our lineup ranged between 1.34 to 2.66 pounds. That pound and a half difference might not seem like much on paper, but we noticed it underfoot. The Hoka Speedgoat 6.0 is the lightest pair that we tested and manages to provide solid comfort and support, despite the impressively light weight.
As the lightest shoe in our review, we were always happy to wear them on long hikes (we thought they were long, they pup didn't think so!)
Credit: Ryan Huetter
The Facet 75 OutDry is also a very light pair, though it's worth noting that it does not have the rugged structure that some of the more supportive models will be able to provide. The Salomon X Ultra 4 only weighs a touch more at 1.76 lbs and offers more longevity and stiffer support. We think this balance of low weight and support is unmatched in all models we have tested and a big reason the X Ultra 4 wins favor among our testers. On the opposite end, the Keen Targhee IV is the heaviest pair we tested, but it's also incredibly stable and clearly built with longevity in mind.
The heaviest shoe in our review, the Targhee IV, tips the scales at 2.66 lbs.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
While weight is an important trait, you do not always have to choose between weight and performance. The Spire GTX weighs a hair over 2 pounds but is among the more comfortable, stable, and supportive options. The Vasque Juxt weighs just over 2 pounds and is equally nice underfoot. Most of our favorite shoes hover right around two pounds. More than two pounds and the shoe will likely boast better durability thanks to heavier, natural materials, as well as improved support thanks to a burlier midsole construction.
The Columbia Crestwoods balance weight and cost, and you end up with a pretty light shoe that doesn't break the bank.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Durability
The are many trade-offs when designing hiking footwear, and the cost for a more durable shoe is commonly more weight. When a manufacturer focuses on making lightweight shoes, durability is less of a focus. Full leather uppers tend to be more durable than synthetics but also weigh more. Rubber-covered toe boxes increase durability in that high-wear area but also add to the shoe's weight. Durable, dense rubber soles are also heavier than softer rubber. Your footwear takes more punishment than any other kind of hiking gear you wear, making craft, materials, and design an important part of choosing a pair that will age well.
While we didn't test each product's entire lifespan, we put a minimum of 20 miles on each shoe and checked them at the end of the testing period for any signs of weakness or wear. We looked at protection in high-wear areas, rubber density of the sole, materials and construction of the upper, quality of stitching, and other unique characteristics of each shoe. We also talked to fellow hikers on the trails about their shoe experiences.
The exposed stitching on the heel of the Juxt is vulnerable to damage when scraping against rocks.
Credit: Ross Robinson
The hikers we found to be the most durable were the Hoka Anacapa, Keen Targhee IV, and Oboz Sawtooth X Low. These shoes have impressively robust mesh on the upper and a solid interface between the upper and the sole. We experienced zero delamination issues, even after trying hard to beat these things up. Nothing seemed to phase them.
Notice how much leather is used on these shoes, which will help them take a beating over time. You might pay for that durability in weight, though.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Mud and sand left on the upper create premature wear, so cleaning and treating your footwear increases its life expectancy. Warm water and a soft brush is your best tactic for cleaning. Nikwax offers a line of leather and fabric conditioners, including products for suede leather and synthetic fabrics. Common wear areas, like the flex points on the forefoot and seams that are prone to scuffing, can be reinforced. Applying Gear Aid Seam Grip or a similar sealer keeps out dirt and sand, prolongs use, and has the added benefit of keeping water out.
We hope this review helps you find the right shoes so you can tackle any terrain or objective you dream up.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
How to Choose Hiking Shoes for Men
Types of Hiking Footwear
Our testing team carefully evaluated everything from comfort to overall durability of each hiking shoe model in this review. There are a few different types of hiking footwear that is appropriate in different terrain choices. Below we identify the main options as well as their best applications on the trail.
Credit: Salomon
Trail Running Shoes: Trail running shoes are essentially beefed up running shoes that are designed to deal with more varied terrain that might be encountered than just running on pavement, yet they have become quite popular as shoes to be worn while just out hiking. They are built with lighter weight materials, and have a midsole that flexes to the shape a the terrain rather than adding stiffness like a more traditional hiking shoe. They may forego waterproofing membranes for greater breathability. For day hiking, or even backpacking with lighter weight packs, a top-rated trail running shoe is a great option to consider.
Credit: Merrell
Hiking Shoes: Hiking shoes are built for the trail. They feature midsole construction that helps to resist the jarring impacts of foot strikes while hiking on trails, often employ waterproof membranes to improve their utility in varied environments, and have better traction to deal with the many surface conditions that may be encountered. These shoes will provide much more comfort and protection when hiking on rockier trails, and will give more support for those carrying backpacks up to 25-30 pounds.
Credit: Backcountry
Hiking Boots: Hiking boots provide the highest levels of foot protection. They most often feature a shank, or stiffener, to impact more stability to the midsole which is useful in challenging terrain. The materials used in the upper are commonly heavier-duty than one might find in a trail runner or a hiking shoe, so durability is improved. One of the biggest hallmarks of a pair of hiking boots is the tall ankle collar, which provides extra support when carrying big loads or when traveling over uneven ground, which can also be beneficial for those with known ankle issues. All this protection comes at a cost, though, as hiking boots are usually much heavier than the average hiking shoe.
Weight and Fit
Ever heard the phrase, “light is right?” This is often a good saying to live by when selecting the best hiking footwear for your upcoming trail objectives. As previously mentioned, trail running shoes and lightweight hiking shoes can offer a ton of energy savings, yet they sacrifice the additional security and protection of a beefy outsole and substantial ankle cuff. Modern technology is allowing for lighter and lighter options that can still offer performance, comfort, and support on the trail; selecting the best support-to-weight ratio can make a huge difference in your hiking experience. Planning on wearing your shoes with thick socks? Sizing up can offer a little more wiggle room for winter socks. This can also help prevent blisters and toe jams that often occur with long downhills.
The lightest shoes by a mile, the Hoka Speedgoat 6 is almost a half pound lighter per pair than the next lightest shoes we checked out.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Waterproof Performance
No one wants to hike for an extended period of time with wet feet. It is important to consider the locations that you'll be hiking in order to properly select a water-resistant shoe over a breathable mesh option. If you're planning to hike in the Pacific Northwest you'll likely want a high-performing waterproof shoe. Planning to hike near the desert at low elevations? You'll likely want to forgo the additional heat provided by a water-resistant design and opt for a more breathable mesh in order to maximize comfort on the trail. Most shoes in this review feature a breathable waterproof membrane or a chemical treatment on the upper that allows water to bead off of the upper. Waterproof membranes can be a great choice for those hiking in colder climates while they can be a disadvantage for those who are seeking breathability in hot and dry climates. Most brands offer the same shoe in both a waterproof and non-waterproof option so that you can select the best option for you.
Our testing team carefully evaluates the water resistance provided by every hiking shoe we tested, whether crossing creeks or fully submerging, we tested the limits of each design.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Conclusion
A good pair of hiking shoes is one of the best things that you can treat yourself to if you want to get out on the trail. We tested each one of these pairs vigorously so that you can have the best information about how to choose the right pair of shoes, and find the ones that are going to match you hiking needs perfectly. Low-cut hiking shoes are our favorite for the days that we don't need a lot of extra support, such as overnight backpacking with lots of weight, or traveling in really gnarly cross-country terrain. We hope that you have found this advice on how to choose the best hiking shoe useful, and be sure to read up on each individual pair so that you can slide your feet into the right shoes for your next adventure.
