The NordicTrack T6.5 S was easily the best treadmill we tested. With a large 55" L x 20" W running surface, a speed range of 0-10 mph, auto incline, and connected features, the competition didn't stand a chance. This model has the longest and widest belt along with the highest top speed, making it a great option for all fitness levels, including hardcore runners. The belt runs smoothly at all speeds and transitions feel seamless. It has ten levels of auto incline (up to a 10% grade), Flex Select cushioning, and 20 pre-programmed workouts. This smart treadmill can sync to your device with a Bluetooth connection or an auxiliary plug to play music through its integrated speakers. It can be operated manually, and it also works with the iFit app where there are loads of training programs, hikes, and runs to follow along with and keep you motivated. When used with iFit, the T6.5 S adjusts speed and incline automatically with the chosen trainer and program. Your iFit subscription gets you access to 130 trainers with programs for walking, running, cycling, strength training, yoga, and more. The large console features heart rate sensors, quick-jump buttons for incline and belt speed, and an easy to read 5-inch wide LCD screen that displays all of your workout information at a glance. The belt folds up easily when not in use, with a soft drop system and transport wheels that make it relatively easy to move around. It has a 300 lb weight limit and it comes with an excellent warranty.
The NordicTrack T6.5 S is the heaviest and largest of all the models we tested. It takes up a fair amount of space, even when folded, and it is quite awkward to move up or down stairs or fit through doorways once it is assembled. It also had the most involved assembly by far, and it took over 1.5 hours to complete and required two people for several steps in the process. While the iFit app is a great at-home training tool, it does add an additional monthly or yearly cost to the machine ($15/mo or $180/yr for an individual or $39/mo or $396/yr for a family subscription) that is hard to overlook. The T6.5 S doesn't come with a fancy screen to stream the iFit workouts, but it does have a device shelf so you can follow along on your own smartphone or tablet. Regardless, we feel this is an excellent treadmill that would make a great addition to anyone's home workout routine.
If you're on a budget, we feel the Sunny Health and Fitness SF-T4400 is a solid option to consider. This affordable model may not boast all the fancy bells and whistles of the more expensive competition, but it still provides a great workout. It has a 49" L x 15.5" W running surface and a speed range of 0.5-9 mph that makes it suitable for walking and running workouts. It comes with 9 pre-programmed workouts to follow if you choose, and it has three levels of manually adjustable incline. It has control buttons on the handles to start/stop and adjust the belt speed, as well as quick-jump speed buttons, program, mode, and start/stop buttons on the console. The bright LCD screen displays time, distance, speed, calories burned, and heart rate (when using the heart rate sensors on the handles), and you can set time, distance, or calorie goals for a manual workout. The console also features a device shelf for your phone or tablet and 2 water bottle holders to keep liquids at arms reach. The SF-T4400 has transport wheels to facilitate moving it, and the belt folds up or down easily with a soft-drop system.
At just 15.5-inches wide, the running surface is relatively narrow and it requires attention to not accidentally step on the side rails while running. We found the SF-T4400 to work best for walking and running at slower speeds. While it is nice to have 3 manually adjustable incline levels, the need to adjust it by hand makes doing any sort of hill workout a more complicated process. It also has a weight limit of just 220 lbs. Despite these gripes, we feel this is a good, affordable option for walkers or slow-moderate pace runners.
The Sunny Health and Fitness SF-T7515 impressed with its auto-incline and smart features. This treadmill boasts a whopping 12 incline settings from 0 up to a steep 12% grade. It has a 49.5" L x 16.5" W running surface and a speed range of 1 to 8 mph. While it doesn't have the fastest top speed, we found it suitable for walking and runners who average 7.5 minute miles or slower, which is most users. It comes with 12 program workouts where it adjusts speed and incline automatically as you go, and you can also set time, distance, and calorie goals to countdown during a manually controlled workout. The console has an LCD screen that shows speed, time, calories, program, incline, and heart rate info at a glance. There are quick-jump buttons for both incline and belt speed, as well as incline and speed adjust buttons on the handles by the heart rate sensors. The SF-T7515 also has Bluetooth and an auxillary input to connect to your device to play music through its integrated speakers or take phone calls as you exercise. It comes equipped with a soft-drop system that makes it very easy to fold up and lower the belt, along with transport wheels to help move it around. It has a maximum user weight limit of 250 lbs.
While we love that the SF-T7515 comes with 12 program workouts, they are not shown on the console or the display and you need to keep the manual handy for reference. The programs are also mostly on the slower side and geared more towards walking than running. We also found the 16.5-inch width of the belt to be a bit narrow, and a careful, attentive approach was required to not catch the side rails while running. The 8 mph top speed will probably be adequate for most users, but super fit runners or those looking to push their limits may be left wanting.
The MaxKare Folding is a reasonably priced treadmill that we found to be a great option for shorter users with its shorter belt length and lower handle height. The 42" L x 16.5" W tread surface is on the shorter side, but we found it to be more than adequate for walking or moderate pace running with a shorter stride. The top speed of 8.5 mph works well for a range of fitness levels, from casual walkers up to quick 7-minute milers. The MaxKare has 3 levels of manually adjustable incline, as well as a unique cushioned belt that we found to feel great underfoot. It comes loaded with 15 program workouts, as well as three countdown modes for time, distance, and calories burned. The console has an LCD screen that displays relevant workout information, 12 program profiles, quick-jump belt speed buttons, and two bottle holders. The handles also feature heart rate sensors along with start/stop and speed buttons. The MaxKare has a weight limit of 220 lbs.
The MaxKare looks and feels like it was designed for shorter people. In addition to the shorter and relatively narrow running surface, the handles that extend from the console are quite low. Our tall testers needed to hunch over slightly to reach the heart rate sensors or use the button controls on the handles. The running surface dimensions also left little margin for error, and we found it to best for walking or running at a moderate pace with a shorter stride. Also, this treadmill has 15 workout programs, although only 12 of them are shown on the console. This means you'll need to keep the manual handy to reference the remaining three. All that said, we were pleasantly surprised by the performance of this small but mighty and reasonably priced model.
The Goplus SuperFit is an impressively compact and convenient 2 in 1 treadmill. It can be used with the handrail folded down as a walking treadmill, or in the upright position as a jogging treadmill. In walk mode, it has a speed range of 1-4 km/h, and can be used anywhere, including under a desk in your home office. In run mode, the speed range increases up to 1-12 km/h (7.5 mph max), making it suitable for moderate running speeds. The handrail has a quick release lever, making it easy to switch between modes. When the handrail is folded down the SuperFit is very slim and small, and it can can easily be stored under a couch, bed, or in a closet when not in use. Its integrated transport wheels and smaller size and weight also make it easier to move around than the competition. It has a small LED screen at the front of the tread belt that displays time, distance, speed, and calories burned. There are no controls on the handrail, instead, it uses a small handheld remote to change speed and start/stop a workout. It also has a small Bluetooth speaker and a phone holder so you can listen to music while you exercise. Despite its diminutive size, the SuperFit has a weight limit of 265 lbs.
While it is very convenient and storable, the SuperFit is not without its faults. The 40" L x 16" W belt surface is the smallest of all the models we tested. We found the size of the belt limited it to walking and running with a relatively short stride and at moderate speeds. Taller users, those with a long stride, or anyone who wants to run fast may find the belt to a bit too small. The folding handrail is a nice feature, but if you attach the handles to it, you will need to remove them to fold it into the down position. This requires the use of a tool and is somewhat inconvenient. Additionally, the display only provides speed and distance information in km/h and kilometers and can't be changed, which can be very confusing for those used to miles and mph. Otherwise, we feel the SuperFit is a good option for the user who values convenience, versatility, and storability for walking and light jogging.
Why You Should Trust Us
Our treadmill review was led by Our Senior Mountain Bike Review Editor, Jeremy Benson. Despite an addiction to long rides on two wheels, Benson mixes up his fitness routine with weekly trail runs and has been known to jump into the occasional 10k running race. His home gym includes a treadmill, which he uses during the long cold winter months to stay fit and break up the monotony of skiing every day. Gearlab review editor and photographer, Laura Casner, also tested and provided feedback for this review. Casner is a seasoned marathon and ultra-marathon runner. While working in the running industry in NYC, she began road running and racing marathons. In 2010 she qualified for the Boston Marathon but quickly traded city streets for trails after running her first of many ultra-marathons. For over a decade, Laura has supplemented her outdoor training with indoor workouts on treadmills at home, commercial gyms, and hotels.
After researching the most popular and highly regarded affordable treadmills on the market, we purchased 5 for testing. At GearLab, we don't just regurgitate manufacturer's specs and consumer reviews, we rigorously test each product to identify their strengths and weaknesses for ourselves. After assembling each treadmill, took our own measurements before testing them for two weeks on walks and runs of varying lengths and intensities. While testing, we analyzed the controls, features, ease of use, and the quality of the exercise experience each model offered. At the end of our test period, we compared notes and zeroed in on our favorites.
Analysis and Test Results
In order to compare the treadmills in this review, we focused on several key performance attributes. Since getting exercise is the primary objective of using a treadmill, we feel the quality of the exercise experience is the most important element of its performance. During testing, we also analyzed each model's ease of use, features, ease of assembly and storability, and noise level.
All of the models we tested qualify as being relatively affordable, although they come at a range of prices. Price and performance often go hand in hand, as is the case with the NordicTrack T6.5 S, our favorite model. At the other end of the price spectrum, the Sunny Health and Fitness SF-T4400 costs significantly less and still provides a good workout.
Our analysis of exercise quality is multi-facted. It primarily includes objective measures like the dimensions of the running surface, speed range, program workouts, and incline levels. It also includes the quality and smoothness of the belt at various speeds, the difficulty of the workout programs, connected features, and the ease of reaching the controls while using the machine. All of these elements play a role in the overall quality of the exercise experience.
The NordicTrack T6.5 S was head an shoulders above the competition with an excellent exercise quality. This model had by far the largest tread surface at 55" L x 20" W, making it much easier to walk and run without fear of catching the edge or needing to adjust your stride. It also had the largest speed range, 0-10 mph, making it suitable for everything from walking to running 6-minute miles. Add to that 10 levels of auto-incline from 0 to 10% and connected features that allow you to use the iFit app or play music through the integrated console speakers, and it was easy to call the T6.5 S the best in the test.
The Sunny Health and Fitness SF-T7515 was our next favorite model in this metric. It had the second-largest tread belt at 49.5" L x 16.5" W, as well as a speed range of 1-8 mph and 12 levels of auto incline. It comes with 12 programs that adjust speed and incline as you go, plus it can connect to your device through Bluetooth or an auxiliary plug so you can listen to music through its integrated speakers while you exercise. Not far behind was the Sunny Health and Fitness SF-T4400. This model had a long but somewhat narrow tread belt with dimensions of 49" L x 15.5" W, and a speed range of 0.5-9 mph. It required a little more attention to foot placement, especially when running, to avoid catching an edge. That said, it was suitable for a large range of fitness levels, from walkers up to sub-7-minute milers, plus it comes with 9 workout programs.
The MaxKare Folding has a nicely padded belt, 15 workout programs, and a speed range of 0.5-8.5 mph, but it lost a little ground to the competition for its relatively small belt size, specifically its short, 42-inch length. While it was fine for walking or running with a short stride, we found that extra care needed to be taken when running at higher speeds or with a long stride. Likewise, the Goplus SuperFit was also a little underwhelming. Its shortest in the test, 40-inch, belt length was its biggest drawback, leaving little margin for error when running. The location of the LED display at the front of the belt was also somewhat challenging to see, and the belt had a somewhat inconsistent, jerky feel at lower speeds.
Ease of Use
In general, the treadmills in this review are all relatively easy to use. They all have main power switches near their power plug that need to be switched on before use and turned off when not in use. Starting a manual workout is straightforward, and each model has its own subtleties in its operation. During testing, we found that features like quick-jump speed buttons, controls on the handles, and auto-incline improved the overall ease of use of some of the models.
One of the easiest treadmills to use was the Sunny Health and Fitness SF-T7515. It was simple to start a manual workout by pressing the start button on the console, and adjusting speed and incline was a snap thanks to the quick-jump incline and speed buttons on the console and the convenient controls on the handles. Choosing a program workout or setting a time, distance, or calorie goal was a snap, and you also have the option of creating three custom user programs. Connecting your device through Bluetooth or an auxiliary plug allows you to use the integrated speakers to listen to music or take a phone call, with easy to reach controls on the console.
The NordicTrack T6.5S was also impressively easy to use, although connecting to the iFit app adds an extra step in the process. This is only a concern if you choose to use the app, as manual and program workouts are quick and straightforward to start. Should you follow a trainer-led workout on the app, however, the machine automatically adjusts speed and incline for you. Otherwise, the large console has quick-jump speed and incline buttons and volume controls for the integrated speakers.
Both the MaxKare Folding and the Sunny Health and Fitness SF-T4400 were generally quite easy to use, although they lost a little ground to the competition with their manual incline adjustments. Both models had quick-jump speed buttons, as well as speed and start/stop buttons on their handles. The Goplus SuperFit was a bit of an outlier in this metric, as it relies on a remote to control it. The small Bluetooth remote is used to start and stop a workout, as well as adjust the speed when in use. While it is easy, you need to keep the remote in hand if you intend to adjust speed while running or walking. The fact that speed and distance can only be displayed in km/h and kilometers also made it more challenging to understand for those used to non-metric speed and distance.
All of the models we tested come with a variety of features intended to enhance the exercise experience or their user-friendliness. These features vary from model to model and include things like integrated speakers, Bluetooth, bottle holders, heart rate sensors, and more. Most models have at least a few basics, while our favorites come with all the bells and whistles. All of the models we tested fold to reduce their footprint when not in use and have transport wheels to facilitate moving them around. Four of them also have soft-drop systems to lock the deck in the raised position and lower it slowly to the ground.
Not surprisingly, the most expensive model we tested, the NordicTrack T6.5 S, was the most feature-packed. Not only does it have the largest belt surface and widest speed range, but its large console has an easy to read 5-inch wide LCD screen, heart rate sensors, a device shelf, 2 bottle holders, and integrated speakers. It can connect to your device through Bluetooth or an auxiliary plug, and it works with the iFit app to get access to thousands of trainer-led workouts. You will need your own screen to view the iFit workouts, but the machine adjusts speed and incline on its own when connected to the app. Additionally, it has 10 levels of auto-incline, quick-jump buttons for incline and belt speed, Flex Select belt cushioning, and an excellent warranty.
The Sunny Health and Fitness SF-T7515 was the runner-up for its wealth of features. This model's console has a large LCD screen that displays relevant workout information, along with quick-jump buttons for incline and speed, integrated speakers, and speaker controls. It also has Bluetooth and an auxiliary plug to connect your device to the speakers to listen to music or take calls. There are two bottle holders, heart rate sensors, and speed and start/stop buttons on the handles. It's also got 12 levels of auto-incline, as well as 12 program workouts, 3 custom user programs, and 3 countdown modes for manual workouts.
Both the Sunny Health and Fitness SF-T4400 and the MaxKare Folding have similar lists of features. They both have LCD screens, quick-jump speed buttons, and heart rate sensors. Both also feature 3 levels of manually adjustable incline, 2 bottle holders, and a handful of workout programs. The SuperFit has the least features of all the models we tested. Perhaps its best feature is its unique folding design, 2-in-1 versatility, and super small collapsed size. Beyond that, it has a phone holder, a Bluetooth speaker, and a small LED screen.
All of our test models arrived in a large box with some assembly required. After removing each treadmill from its box and protective packing materials, we finished the remaining assembly ourselves. All of them came with adequate assembly instructions, and most come with all of the tools required to complete the remaining tasks. Most models were relatively easy to prepare for use, with one exception. Once assembled, all of these treadmills can be folded to reduce their footprint by more than half when not in use, and all of them have integrated wheels to facilitate transport.
The Goplus SuperFit arrived almost completely assembled. The only remaining steps to finish the job included attaching the phone holder to the top of the handrail, attaching the handles, lubricating the belt, and pairing the remote with the treadmill. It took approximately 15 minutes to finish the assembly. Once complete, it is up to you whether to fold the handrail up or down depending on how you wish to use the machine. It should be noted that you will have to remove the handles to fold the handrail down for storage. Once folded down, the SuperFit measured 52" L x 27" W x 5" H, easily the smallest of all the models we tested. This small treadmill could easily be stored under a couch, bed, or in a closet when not in use.
Both of the Sunny Health and Fitness models and the MaxKare Folding required slightly more assembly. All three of these treadmills took about 25 minutes to assemble once removed from the box and their packing materials. The remaining steps included folding up the front support arms and securing them, folding the console into place and securing it, and lubricating the belt. The tread deck on each of these models is easily folded up or down thanks to a locking soft-drop system. Their footprint is reduced by more than half when the deck is folded up. Lowering the deck is as easy as releasing the soft-drop mechanism with your foot, then allowing it to lower to the floor.
The NordicTrack T6.5 S had the most involved assembly process and by a significant margin. This is the heaviest treadmill we tested, and moving it in the box and removing it from the box is definitely a task for two people. Once out of the box, the remaining assembly took approximately 1.5 hours to finish. Much of the assembly can be completed by one person, although the assistance of another person is needed for tasks like feeding the cables through the support arm, installing the console, and attaching the soft-drop piston under the tread deck. The T6.5 S does come with a couple of allen wrenches, although you will also need a screwdriver and a socket set or adjustable wrench to finish the job. Due to the weight and size of this model, we recommend assembling it in the space where you plan to use it, as it can be difficult to fit through average size doorways or move up and down stairs.
To analyze the noise that each treadmill made, we used a sound level meter to record the decibel level at varying speeds. We placed the meter 24-inches above the floor and diagonally 18-inches away from the motor next to the tread deck. We recorded the decibel readings at 1, 4, and 7.5 mph with a tester walking or running. Interestingly, all of the treadmills were quite close in this test, with only a few decibels separating them. Oddly enough, despite the close meter readings, a few of the treadmills seemed marginally louder to the ear when in use.
Most of the models we tested were in the low to mid-40-decibel range when running at 1 mph, which increased to the low 50s with a user walking on it. One exception was the NordicTrack T6.5 S which was 49 decibels at 1 mph that increased to 56 with walking footfalls. At 4 mph, nearly every model was in the mid 50 range, with an increase to the low to mid-60s with a user walking at a very brisk pace. When increased to 7.5 mph, or 8-minute mile pace, the decibels increased into the 60s with no runner and the upper 60s with a runner on the belt. According to our meter readings, the MaxKare was the quietest at 7.5 mph, followed closely by the SuperFit. Despite the results of this test, both testers agreed that the SuperFit sounded the loudest when in use. That said, none of these treadmills were particularly loud to begin with.
There can be a lot to consider when searching for a new treadmill. There are loads of options on the market, and we hope this detailed comparative review helps you find the right model to meet your needs and budget.
— Jeremy Benson, Laura Casner