The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of gear

Best Hiking Boots for Men of 2021

Our team of testers are passionate about testing the top hiking footwe...
Photo: Ryan Huetter
Friday January 22, 2021
  • Share this article:
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more

We have been testing hiking boots for a decade, with 80+ models bought and tested. This 2021 review analyzes 17 of the best models available. Our review team is a group of avid hikers, and they want to share their experiences with you. This team of alpine guides and backcountry enthusiasts spent months hiking through mountains, deserts, and forests, both on the trail and off, before scoring, ranking, and passing final judgment on all models we tested. The resulting review has in-depth details on specific performance areas, as well as recommendations for your hiking goals and budget.

Related: Best Hiking Boots for Women of 2021

Top 17 Product Ratings

Displaying 1 - 5 of 17
< Previous | Compare | Next >
 
Awards Editors' Choice Award Top Pick Award Top Pick Award Top Pick Award  
Price $229.95 at Backcountry
Compare at 2 sellers
$249.95 at Amazon
Compare at 2 sellers
$219.95 at Backcountry$160.26 at Amazon
Compare at 2 sellers
$194.99 at Amazon
Compare at 2 sellers
Overall Score Sort Icon
80
79
77
76
74
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros Comfortable out of the box, fast and nimble, great stability, support, water resistanceBest choice for rock and snow travel, durable, breathes wellAmazing comfort, stable, great tractionComfort of a trail runner with more support and stability, good all around performance, lightweightVery durable, stable, great foot protection
Cons Not as good for warm or hot environments, priceyWider fit, not the best lace locking systemNot as capable in off-trail terrain, rockered sole feels unnatural at firstCould be more breathable, not great traction on smooth rockHeavy, diminished breathability
Bottom Line This boot is a capable beast of stability and protection without weighing you downFor hikers venturing off trail into rocky or snowy terrain, this boot offers stability and traction that no other boot doesThe ultimate in comfort for on-trail enjoymentA proven performer from short walks to intense thru-hikes, with shoe comfort in lightweight boot formA modern take on a classic boot, with full grain leather and high top protection for hiking in all conditions
Rating Categories Salomon Quest 4D 3 GTX Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX HOKA ONE ONE Kaha GORE-TEX Salomon X Ultra Mid 3 GTX Vasque St. Elias FG GTX
Comfort (25%)
9
7
9
8
8
Stability (20%)
9
9
8
7
8
Traction (15%)
8
10
7
8
7
Weight (15%)
4
6
7
9
4
Water Resistance (15%)
9
8
7
7
8
Durability (10%)
8
7
7
6
9
Specs Salomon Quest 4D 3... Scarpa Zodiac Plus... HOKA ONE ONE Kaha... Salomon X Ultra... Vasque St. Elias...
Weight per Pair (Size 11) 3.30 lbs 2.65 lbs 2.45 lbs 2.28 lbs 3.26 lbs
Boot Type Midweight Hiker/Backpacking Boot Midweight Hiker/Backpacking Boot Midweight Hiker/Backpacking Boot Midweight Hiker/Backpacking Boot Midweight Hiker/Backpacking Boot
Width Options Regular Regular Regular Regular and Wide Narrow, Regular, and Wide
Waterproof Lining Gore-Tex Performance Comfort Gore-Tex Gore-Tex Gore-Tex Gore-Tex Performance Comfort
Upper Nubuck leather and textile 1.8mm Suede Perwanger Leather Waterproof PU coated leather Nubuck leather
Last Board/Shank 4D Advanced Chassis BZ last None Molded shank TPU Shank
Midsole Dual density EVA PU + 3D EVA-MP EVA Injected EVA A.S.E. Midsole with EVA Cushioning Pods
Sole ContaGrip Vibram Drumlin / Mont Vibram MegaGrip Non-marking ContaGrip Vibram Frontier
Warranty 2 year 1 year 45 day 2 year 1 year
Sizes Available 7 - 13 US 37 - 48 EU 7 - 14 US 7 - 13 US 7-14 US, wide and narrow options
Color Options Yes No Yes Yes Yes

Best Overall Hiking Boots


Salomon Quest 4D 3 GTX


Salomon Quest 4D 3 GTX
Editors' Choice Award

$229.95
at Backcountry
See It

80
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Comfort - 25% 9
  • Stability - 20% 9
  • Traction - 15% 8
  • Weight - 15% 4
  • Water Resistance - 15% 9
  • Durability - 10% 8
Weight: 3.3 pounds | Upper: Nubuck leather and textile
Comfy
Beefy yet nimble
Stable and speedy
Excellent water resistance
Many seams could present durability issue in long-term
On the heavier side
Not for light hiking

The Salomon Quest 4D 3 GTX is the benchmark in this category. This model has long defined what top-shelf hiking boots can and should aspire to be, providing users with top-of-the-line performance across every single one of our review metrics. With ample comfort and support, the Quest 4D is a backpacker's dream, and it lets you carry heavy weight with confidence. Those venturing off the trail will be happy with the Quest's traction and durability, and in wet weather, this boot is almost without peer. Built for hardcore hiking and built to last, we found extremely little that this boot can't do.

The Quest 4D is not a lightweight boot, so it is best suited for those trips where extra support and stability are needed. These are not our recommendation for short hikes on easy terrain, as they are overkill for such application. It also has several exposed seams, so some might question its long term durability. However, one tester has a pair of these boots with over 500 backcountry miles and counting without significant deterioration. We have tried to find a better model for several years and failed for all-around backpacking and hiking utility. The Salomon Quest is the real deal.

Read review: Salomon Quest 4D 3 GTX

Best Bang for the Buck


Keen Targhee II Mid


70
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Comfort - 25% 7
  • Stability - 20% 7
  • Traction - 15% 7
  • Weight - 15% 8
  • Water Resistance - 15% 6
  • Durability - 10% 7
Weight: 2.4 pounds | Upper: Waterproof nubuck leather
Incredible value
Exceptional toe and foot protection
Above-average traction
Big-time comfort
Durability
Low stability for less-than-robust ankles

Great boots are not always the most expensive, and the Keen Targhee II Mid is the best example of this. Featuring excellent construction with quality leather materials and a rock-solid sole that chews up the trail miles, we love to hike in these boots. Comfortable out of the box, they also do not sacrifice anything when it comes to fit, and they are an attractive option for those with wider feet.

This model was not the best at keeping the water out, as we had some issues with leaking near the toe box, but in all but the wettest conditions, these should hold their own just fine. We also felt insecure when off-trail with a heavy pack, and in these conditions, a taller boot with more support is warranted. But for the price, we couldn't ask for a better boot.

Read review: Keen Targhee II Mid

Best for Lightweight Hiking


Salomon X Ultra Mid 3 GTX


Salomon X Ultra Mid 3 GTX
Top Pick Award

$160.26
at Amazon
See It

76
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Comfort - 25% 8
  • Stability - 20% 7
  • Traction - 15% 8
  • Weight - 15% 9
  • Water Resistance - 15% 7
  • Durability - 10% 6
Weight: 2.28 pounds | Upper: Leather and textile
Great support
Low weight
More comfortable than most
Impressive durability for the weight
Less traction on wet rock
Not as rugged as many heavier models

We don't always need a big, beefy boot made of full-grain leather to take out on a hike. For day hikes and light backpacking trips where added support is beneficial but not as critical as comfort and weight, then look to the Salomon X Ultra Mid 3 GTX boot. It is a taller version of the venerable hiking shoe of the same name and maintains its trail-ready performance with some added ankle protection. While there are lighter boots in our review, they did not provide as much well-rounded capability and are mostly suited to on-trail adventures, while the X Ultra 3 Mid has better traction, is more supportive, and is more durable.

This is a really great boot for the value it provides. It did well in all of our testing criteria and did not have any major downsides. We feel that in loose terrain, it did not do as well as some of its competition, but for lighter-duty hiking use, which is what most of us likely do, this boot gives phenomenal value for money and is a great choice for long-distance hikes as well as for local walks around the park.

Read the review: Salomon X Ultra Mid 3 GTX

Best Comfort


HOKA ONE ONE Kaha GORE-TEX


HOKA ONE ONE Kaha GORE-TEX
Top Pick Award

$219.95
at Backcountry
See It

77
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Comfort - 25% 9
  • Stability - 20% 8
  • Traction - 15% 7
  • Weight - 15% 7
  • Water Resistance - 15% 7
  • Durability - 10% 7
Weight: 2.45 pounds | Upper: Waterproof Leather
Supreme comfort in the footbed and upper
Lightweight yet great stability
Unique lacing system increases adjustability
Can feel sweaty on hot days
Take a long time to dry out
Funky looks not for everyone

HOKA ONE ONE is best known for its running shoes, but they have quickly become one of the favorite brands for those looking for supreme comfort in their hiking shoes and boots. The Sky Kaha GTX is a high-top boot that feels much lighter than its looks let on. With a rockered sole that uses an almost comical amount of midsole construction, these boots are the most comfortable underfoot that we tested. The high ankle coverage protects from accidentally rolled ankles, and the inner Gore-Tex membrane makes these boots full waterproof.

Despite its tall stature, the Sky Kaha GTX performs like a lighter boot and is best recommended for on-trail hikes and moderate off-trail terrain due to the rockered sole and its performance in more technical applications. We like the waterproofing and find the Gore-Tex to be very effective, but once wet, these boots take almost a full day to dry out due to the leather upper. Like many of the lighter hiking boots, we expect this model's lifespan to fall short of incredible. Still, this boot's performance in comfort and stability will outweigh any questions of longevity for many people.

Read the review: HOKA ONE ONE Kaha GORE-TEX

Best for Scrambling


Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX


Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX
Top Pick Award

$249.95
(7% off)
at Amazon
See It

79
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Comfort - 25% 7
  • Stability - 20% 9
  • Traction - 15% 10
  • Weight - 15% 6
  • Water Resistance - 15% 8
  • Durability - 10% 7
Weight: 2.7 pounds | Upper: 1.8mm Suede Perwanger
Good all-around performance
Low weight
Durable
High price tag
Requires continued maintenance of leather outer

The Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX is our go-to boot for technical scrambling and off-trail travel. It is essentially a lightweight mountain boot, but it does so well that the average hiker can also benefit from its superior performance. It's full-leather upper offers excellent durability, while the supportive Vibram sole gives a stable platform. Impressively waterproof, it is ready to handle the most challenging terrain you might encounter, even being able to pair with a light crampon for use on firm snow on an early season hike.

This boot is amazing in technical and rough terrain, but it gives up some comfort in favor of this specific performance. The rigid sole does not bend as easily as others, making it harder to walk up smooth slabs of rock. But, if you're looking for a cross-over hiking/mountaineering boot that you use on the long trail approach and more technical 3rd and 4th class terrain when peak bagging, the Zodiac Plus is worth checking out.

Read the review: Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX


Year after year, we put the best boots out there toe to toe to find...
Year after year, we put the best boots out there toe to toe to find out which ones are the top performers.
Photo: Ryan Huetter

Why You Should Trust Us


Our expert panel of testers is led by Ryan Huetter, a full-time AMGA/IFMGA certified mountain guide with a bachelor's degree in Outdoor Adventure Management. Ryan uses hiking boots extensively, which are a crucial professional tool, hitting the trail almost daily and logging thousands of trail miles in the last ten years. He is joined by Ross Robinson, who has hiked and backpacked the world for over a decade. He has lived and backpacked in Thailand, Peru, and Germany, with at least 500 miles hiked in each country. Ross is a Senior Review Editor at OutdoorGearLab, and led our hiking boot and hiking shoe testing from 2014-2017. Since 2014 Ross has personally tested more than 50 boots and shoes over 1000 trail miles.

Our testing took place in some of the most rugged and iconic mountain ranges in the country, including the High Sierra, the Cascade Range, volcanoes and deserts of southern Peru, and the desert country around Moab. The review draws on 20 hours of research followed by months of testing and 350 miles of hiking. For example, the score in the Traction metric is an average of each product's scores on dry rock, wet rock, scree, mud, and scrambling.

Related: How We Tested Hiking Boots

Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge

Analysis and Test Results


We believe that all good hiking boots can be effectively assessed using six key traits. By developing a scoring system to quantify performance in each of these metrics, we can objectively identify each pair of footwear's strengths and weaknesses. Comfort, stability, water resistance, traction, weight, and durability are the metrics our testers used, and each metric was assigned a percentage of their total score. This will help you, as the consumer, to make an educated choice on your hiking boot purchase. Below, we elaborate on each one of these test metrics.

Related: Buying Advice for Hiking Boots


Value


The price of some models can be shocking, but the most expensive boots did not automatically rank the highest following our rigorous testing. We mostly preferred models in the middle of the price range of boots tested. The Keen Targhee II comes in well below average on price yet offers compelling performance that outpaces about half the competition. The Salomon Quest outperforms every other product at only a bit higher-than-average price.

Ready to put down some miles? We hiked hundreds of miles to test...
Ready to put down some miles? We hiked hundreds of miles to test these boots for you.
Photo: Ryan Huetter

Comfort


The single most important factor when deciding on a hiking boot is comfort. Gone are the days of painfully breaking in heavy leather boots. With many more synthetic materials being utilized today, hikers can choose from a wider range of boots that have much better comfort in the uppers as well as underfoot with more cushioned midsoles. With an ever-growing number of hikers questing on many of our nation's popular thru-hikes, a comfy pair of boots is the first step in preparing for such an endeavor. The HOKA Kaha GTX defines initial comfort. The Salomon X Ultra Mid 3 GTX is comfortable for a midweight boot and feels great from day one, requiring no break-in period. The lightest models, such as the HOKA Speedgoat Mid 2 GTX, are unbelievably comfortable while on firm trails and paved paths. However, the weight savings derived from a thinner sole means that foot comfort is compromised while on uneven and rocky terrain.


We noted three primary attributes when considering comfort.

How the foot feels in the footbed

How does it feel when laced up and standing? Are there any pressure points when laced, and how large is the toe box? Does your foot feel it when you step on that pointy rock on the trail? After several hours of hiking, which models still made our feet feel great? The X Ultra Mid 3 and Moab Ventilator 2 are among the most comfortable straight from the box, while the Kaha GTX is off the charts in this aspect. The Quest 4D 3 did the best job keeping our feet happy after many miles and hours with a moderate pack. Also worth noting is the Altra Lone Peak 4 Mid RSM, which has both a zero-drop sole height as well as an extra-wide toe box that allows the foot to spread out and relax, an especially nice feature when the miles are stacking up and your feet are beginning to swell in an otherwise snug-fitting boot.

It is worth spending the time to find out a bit more about your own feet, as we all have different foot volume and arch height, and these traits change as we age. Certain models fit low, medium, or high volume feet the best. Insole thickness and shape will also have a lot to do with initial comfort impressions. Sometimes that space can be reduced or taken up with an aftermarket insole, though we tend to recommend finding a boot that fits as well as possible first and then fine-tuning the fit as necessary.

The Salomon Quest cruises through a high altitude desert, with...
The Salomon Quest cruises through a high altitude desert, with enough breathability to keep our feet from sweating too much. This boot also held up very well throughout all our tests, showing virtually no signs of wear at the end of our trial.
Photo: Ross Robinson

How the ankle collar feels, and how the lacing system works

We noted the number and type of lacing eyelets, how the heel box holds the back of the foot, and whether there's any slippage. The Salomon model featured our favorite lacing systems. The fit and construction of the ankle collar are super important when logging many miles or traveling steep grades. The Targhee II and Moab Ventilator 2 have shorter cuts that deliver minimal ankle stability but are quite comfortable.

Hiking in the dry high desert, you want to be sure your boot is...
Hiking in the dry high desert, you want to be sure your boot is breathable.
Photo: Ryan Huetter

How well the boot breathes, keeping you cool and dry

Blisters form due to heat and friction, and damp skin has lots of friction. Hikers have developed many tricks and techniques to keep blisters at bay, including Mole Skin, duct tape, foot powder, and other black magic. Our perspective? Choose a boot with better breathability. Wearing boots with a waterproof/breathable membrane always limits the ventilation ability of the footwear, though we found models like the Altra Lone Peak 4 to breathe quite well due to an advancement in the waterproof fabric they use in their upper.

Our testers put each model through the wringer, measuring their...
Our testers put each model through the wringer, measuring their level of breathability in all types of terrains and climates.
Photo: Ross Robinson

Overall, the HOKA ONE ONE and Salomon models are the clear comfort champs, thanks to their soft and flexible materials that still impart good stability. Comfort scores contribute 25 percent of each product's total score.

Stability


The biggest reason to wear a hiking boot rather than a trail runner or a hiking shoe is for increased stability. The higher the ankle is cut, the more resistance the boot will provide to rolling ankles. These boots also have thicker and more supportive soles, giving added protection against sharp rocks, a notable weakness in a lighter shoe. Looking at stability, our review team considers torsional stability in the sole, height, and security of the ankle cuff, width of the sole, and stiffness below the footbed to determine the rating for this metric. This review covers boots that barely rise above the ankle to much taller ones that provide unparalleled ankle support. Your needs may not require the full-on stability of a high-top model, and a mid-cut boot may give a better blend of flexibility, mobility, and support.


Also, consider that for many of the lighter weight models, such as the HOKA ONE ONE Speedgoat Mid 2 GTX, the stability of the boot relies upon the compression gained from a sound lacing system. Soft and supple materials that do not have much structural integrity on their own become more rigid and supportive when wrapped tight around the ankle while other boots like the Lowa Renegade have thick leather that offers much more structural support. For those who are experiencing the aches and pains of life on the trail, such as those hiking in retirement, stability will be an essential asset.

In addition to the many miles we hiked, we took a couple of measurements to quantify how well each product supports the ankle and resists lateral rolling. First, we measured the height of the ankle collar from the footbed to its tallest point of the instep. The Quest 4D 3 has one of the tallest ankle collars at 6.5 inches. We also measured the width of the sole at the forefoot. A wide forefoot provides a more stable platform and resists rolling.

Consider edging ability when looking for a boot to travel through...
Consider edging ability when looking for a boot to travel through rocky terrain.
Photo: Ryan Huetter

Finally, we grabbed the sole by the heel and toe and twisting side to side to get an idea of its torsional stability, which is the boot's ability to resist twisting of the sole on uneven surfaces. Better torsional stability translates to less foot-fatigue on rough terrain, especially when carrying a load. Overall, we awarded the Salomon Quest 4D 3 GTX a top score in this metric. It ticked all the boxes (tall ankle collar, wide forefoot, torsional rigidity) in the lab and gave us tons of confidence to speed through rough terrain. The Lowa Renegade also received accolades in this metric, which comes as no surprise with a plastic/urethane shank, as these mid and heavyweight models focus on stability and support. Also notable is the Scarpa Zodiac Plus. The least stable by this test was the Altra Lone Peak 4 Mid due to its wide toe box and lack of any torsional stability.

Hiking through the bog was a great way to test for support and...
Hiking through the bog was a great way to test for support and stability in slippery conditions.
Photo: Ryan Huetter

Traction


The amount of traction your hiking boots provide you is one of the most important aspects of a boot's performance, and the type of sole you decide on is going to have a lot to do with the type of terrain you are planning on traveling through. Consider the difference between a Formula 1 race car and a dirt bike. The types of tires used in these two (very fun to drive) vehicles are quite different and specialized for the type of surfaces they operate on. Hiking shoes are no different. Soles can have softer or denser rubber compounds, which will conform better to different terrain types. Softer smears on rock better, while harder rubber edges better and resists wear. We also look at the patterning of the lugs. While a boot with many very deep lugs on a narrow mountain boot will excel in loose rubble (our dirt bike), the broad, shallower lugs found on a wide boot will provide more surface area to contact firm trail surfaces (our Formula 1 car). Now, you don't always have to choose one or the other. You can have it both ways, but when researching these models, do recognize that some are much more specialized than others and, depending on your application, might be the better tool for the job.


During our backcountry exploits, in a wide variety of terrain types, we were able to test for traction on wet and dry trails, damp and dry rock, snow, and mud. It should come as no surprise that the models made by the companies that are known for their quality rock climbing footwear rose to the top in regards to traction. The Scarpa Zodiac Plus came in at the top of the pack in this category, though the La Sportiva Trango Tech GTX is nearly as capable and flexes slightly better in the forefoot, making it the better choice for smearing on rock slabs. The La Sportiva TXS GTX is another good option and might be an attractive middle-ground between comfort and traction. It blends some of the qualities found in these other climbing-oriented boots but makes them more approachable to the average hiker.

Off trail rock scrambling provides a great test for traction and...
Off trail rock scrambling provides a great test for traction and stability.
Photo: Ryan Huetter

Moving on to loose terrain, we tested these boots in off-trail travel on High Sierra backpacking routes and alpine climbing approaches and descents. In the looser ground, we found a narrower midsole offered better edging performance, rolling over less when plowing through scree and hopping over talus. Our favorite pair to take into the boulder fields and scree slopes were the Scarpa Zodiac Plus boots, with their blend of stiffness and a nimble sole. It is perhaps the best boot in this review for technical rock climbing, with a sticky climbing zone in the toe and a sole that ascends steep rock with ease.

Our expert testers putting the boots traction performance to the...
Our expert testers putting the boots traction performance to the test in loose scree conditions.
Photo: Ross Robinson

With a record-breaking snowpack in the Sierra Nevada, we had lots of opportunities to test these boots in snow and mud. The best performers had stiffer soles for edging, and serrated lugs to kick steps in mature summer snow, and that indeed dislodged mud. The Quest 4D 3 was a favorite of testers, followed by the Scarpa Zodiac Plus.

We scramble around on high-angle terrain to test the traction of...
We scramble around on high-angle terrain to test the traction of these boots in steep, rocky conditions.
Photo: Ryan Huetter

While these are different traction scenarios, we assigned all the products an overall traction score. We discuss how each one performed during the traction tests, as some sole types were high performers in certain terrain types but did not compete as well in a range of environments. We weighted traction 15% of the total score.

Weight


Weight is an important factor. The heavier the boot is, the less efficient you will be throughout a long day hiking. In general, lighter is better, but only up to a point. You have chosen a hiking boot for its improved stability, support, and traction over the lighter hiking shoe or trail runner models, so don't give up too much of these key traits just to get the lightest boot possible, as there will be diminishing returns. When looking for your next pair of hiking boots, don't just look at the weight alone. Weight is better seen as a tie-breaker once you narrow down your options.


The HOKA ONE ONE Speedgoat Mid 2 GTX is the lightest product we tested at 1.74 pounds (US men's size 11), a weight that was unheard just a few years ago in this category. The Altra Lone Peak 4 is only slightly heavier. While the Salomon X Ultra 3 Mid weighs more than both of these models, it is much more capable as an all-around boot, from day-hikes to thru-hikes. It did exceptionally well in all of our metrics even though it was bested in the weight metric by a few others. With most other models falling just shy of three pounds per pair, these lightweight hikers are quite exceptional when the terrain does not demand as much stability and support.

Trust but verify. We weigh each one of our test models ourselves on...
Trust but verify. We weigh each one of our test models ourselves on our scale.
Photo: Ryan Huetter

Those with more backpacking experience and robust ankles can often get away with a lighter weight hiking boot, provided that they are not carrying loads more than about 30 pounds. For beginner and intermediate backpackers, and especially those hauling considerable weight, burlier mid and high-top boots are going to be the safest option. We awarded 15% of the total score to weight.

A lightweight trip along the Sierra High Route was a great place to...
A lightweight trip along the Sierra High Route was a great place to take a light but fully functional boot like the X Ultra 3.
Photo: Ryan Huetter

Water Resistance


We all want dry feet when hiking. Dry feet are key to avoiding blisters and staying warm when hiking in the cold and wet. And wet feet are far from comfortable. Almost all of our test models feature some waterproof/breathable fabric membrane, except for the Merrell Moab Ventilator, which we chose to test for use in hot and dry climates. Most models use a Gore-Tex brand membrane, while Altra uses an eVent fabric, and Keen uses a proprietary KEEN.Dry membrane.


First, we measured what we call the "flood level" of each product. A typical design feature of hiking boots is a gusseted tongue. Not only do the gussets keep rocks and debris from entering the shoe, but the waterproof membrane also extends through this gusset. We measured the depth of water one wades into with each boot before it floods in over the top. The Quest 4D 3 comes in with a height of 4.5 inches.

To our extensive knowledge, no footwear remains waterproof forever...
To our extensive knowledge, no footwear remains waterproof forever, but we expect the waterproof lining of this boot, the Keen Targhee II, to give way before most of the other competitors.
Photo: Ross Robinson

Second, we took each boot through the stream test. Fording streams is a better test than standing around in the water, which is a task a rain boot would be better suited for. The apparent lack of waterproofness in the Moab Ventilator took it out of contention in this metric, and others had varying degrees of performance. Most impressive were the Salomon Quest 4D 3 and the Lowa Renegade.

Most of the boots were waterproof enough to handle the usual wet...
Most of the boots were waterproof enough to handle the usual wet crossings you find out on the trail.
Photo: Ryan Huetter

No waterproof membrane that is used to protect the foot can withstand continuous exposure to water, and all will eventually wet out, so we also considered the ability of the boot to dry out once fully inundated. The best performer here was the HOKA Speedgoat Mid 2 GTX, with its heavy use of nylon mesh in the outer, it dried out in an impressive 30 minutes after being sopping wet.

Reviewer Ross Robinson rock hopping across a river that carved out...
Reviewer Ross Robinson rock hopping across a river that carved out the Colca Canyon in southern Peru, one of the deepest canyon systems in the world.
Photo: Ross Robinson

Durability


No boot will last forever, especially with heavy use. Synthetic fibers will fray and begin to wick moisture, soles will delaminate and wear thin, and the boot will lose structure and become soft. That is the trade-off for getting to wear boots that are made of modern materials. Many hikers praise their boots purchased decades ago that have endured 20 years while failing to mention that the pair weighs four or five lbs and may have cost a small fortune.


We were happy to find that all of the models in this review held up well through the months-long testing period. No boot suffered damage to the point of losing function. That said, we expect any hiking boot within the price range of these models to last a couple of seasons of on and off use. Materials used vary from mesh to full-grain leather, and we found that the less reliant on synthetic materials a boot is, such as the Vasque St. Elias FG GTX or Lowa Renegade, the better it would perform when pitted against rough wear.

The materials used in the lightest boots will not provide as much...
The materials used in the lightest boots will not provide as much long-term durability as more robust materials like leather or suede.
Photo: Ryan Huetter

While our review boots did not specifically begin to break down within our relatively short testing period, we researched reviews and talked to users to see how the models made of the lighter weight materials fared over time. We consistently find that the lighter weight models have a useful lifespan of around 250-300 miles before durability issues start to creep in, and the midsole materials break down from use and do not provide the foot with the same support. This is one of the inherent issues with lighter boots, so only consider that as one data point in your consideration. We love the Hoka ONE ONE Sky Kaha GTX but found that after about 200 miles, the lugs began to delaminate, as they are not molded in one piece to the outsole of the boot. Lots of reviewers online noted that the Altra Lone Peak 4 does not hold up well to long-term abuse, which is easy to understand due to the lightweight fabric upper. The Arc'teryx Acrux TR uses a specialized SuperFabric that is essentially a synthetic membrane that is combined with an epoxy-based resin, which held up much better than we would have expected from the first glance. We can't say that it gives us a lot of confidence, though.

No boot is immune to damage, but we rated the St. Elias and Zodiac as the boots that stood out as the most durable pieces we reviewed thanks to their reliance on thick, durable leather outers rather than flimsy synthetic materials. The Merrell Ventilator boots scored the lowest scores in this category. We assigned durability 10% of the total score, admitting that a season of testing is a short amount of time to flush out the exact differences in longevity.

Noting that any boot will be susceptible to normal wear and tear, there are important things that we can do to improve the lifespan of our footwear.

Applying waterproofing sprays or seam-sealer is beneficial to...
Applying waterproofing sprays or seam-sealer is beneficial to maintain the longevity of the water-resistance of your new boots.
Photo: Ryan Huetter

Conclusion


Hiking boots are a crucial piece of gear to consider for your backcountry adventures. A poorly fitting pair will turn an otherwise unforgettable trip into a miserable slog filled with blisters and sore feet. Thankfully the days of uncomfortable boots that are heavy and take a lifetime to break in are over. All of the boots in this review have their place on the trail, and some will work better than others depending on your specific needs and goals. So take your time to read through our assessments, then treat yourself to a pair of supportive, weight-appropriate, and comfortable boots for your next trail outing.

We hope this extensive review helps you find the perfect boots and...
We hope this extensive review helps you find the perfect boots and allows for many miles of happy trails in them.
Photo: Ryan Huetter

Ryan Huetter and Ross Robinson