The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of gear

Best Sandals for Women of 2020

Thursday October 1, 2020
  • Share this article:
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more

On the hunt some new summer kicks? We've purchased and tested dozens of pairs in the past 6 years, with the 14 best women's sandals in this 2020 review. We spent months trying out these products side-by-side. Miles of urban hiking, backcountry jaunts, neighborhood strolls, bike rides, and even trail runs have acquainted us with every strap and buckle. At this point, our intrepid team of nonstop explorers knows what makes for the right sandal in any situation and for every foot shape. We rate each option on key factors like comfort, adjustability, and, yes, style. Then we consider their cost to refine our final recommendations. This review includes options for varied adventures, long-haul hiking, and lazy camp days.

Related: Best Flip Flops for Women of 2020

Top 14 Product Ratings

Displaying 1 - 5 of 14
≪ Previous | Compare | Next ≫

Best Overall Sandal for Women


Bedrock Cairn Adventure - Women's


Bedrock Cairn Adventure minimal
Editors' Choice Award

$105.00
at REI
See It

88
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Comfort - 20% 8
  • Traction - 20% 9
  • Adjustability - 20% 9
  • Stability - 15% 8
  • Versatility - 15% 10
  • Style - 10% 9
Weight per pair: 1.06 lbs (size 9/10) | Sole: Vibram XS Trek Regolith
Minimal design combined with great feel
Lightweight
Excellent for all-around use
Adjusts to many foot types
Toe thong can press when going downhill
Thin sole

The highest scorer in our test and a standout in every metric, the Bedrock Cairn Adventure offers a unique style, employing a thong construction combined with an ankle strap. This design provides a surprising, barely-there feel by eliminating pressure points on the side of the foot. This Cairn also sports a hearty Vibram sole that gives the wearer little hesitation when scurrying up and down steep slabs with a heavy pack. Add in a comprehensive adjustment system, a lightweight feel that adds both versatility and style, and it was easy to crown this pair our favorite sandal. The Cairn Adventure is a do-anything champ, and if you're looking for a companion on your way to the crag, beach, and bar, this is the shoe for you.

It's hard to find things to complain about with the Cairn Adventure, but no product is perfect, so we'll give it a go: this model has a fairly thin, flexible sole, so if you're looking for a cushy pair of kicks with a ton of support, this ain't it. You also can't wear socks with these due to the thong-style toe strap. The strap isn't comfortable for everyone, though we loved it. If you can get over these issues, we're pretty sure you'll love this shoe. If you need more support, Bedrock also makes a cushier version, the Cairn 3D PRO II Adventure, that has a molded footbed and an extra-grippy sole for your wildest outdoor wanderings. Most people will find that the regular Cairn Adventure meets their needs just fine, and it'll save you a few bucks.

Read review: Bedrock Cairn Adventure - Women's

Best Bang for Your Buck


Teva Original Universal - Women's


72
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Comfort - 20% 8
  • Traction - 20% 8
  • Adjustability - 20% 6
  • Stability - 15% 7
  • Versatility - 15% 7
  • Style - 10% 7
Weight per pair: 0.73 lbs (size 10) | Sole: Rubber
Soft and comfy footbed
Stylish and fits many foot types
Good traction
Unstable
Not hearty enough for heavy-duty adventuring

This retro-looking option delivered strong performance across most of our testing metrics and comes in at a surprisingly friendly price. The Teva Original Universal is comfortable, simple, and easy to adjust, and it offers great traction across a variety of terrains. It's a particular rockstar in watery environments. If you're looking for laid-back, old-school style, you've come to the right place: this model looked great in the '80s, and it looks just as good now. Even more compelling, it comes in a ton of awesome colorways so you can find the option that suits you best.

Though the Original Universal is one of our first picks as a casual or recovery sandal, its floppy sole and imprecise adjustment mechanisms make it inappropriate for heavy-duty days in the backcountry. It feels unstable over super technical terrain or when wearing a heavy pack, and when you really crank down on the straps to achieve a secure fit, they rub and get uncomfortable. If you're looking for footwear to take you everywhere, this probably isn't it, but for casual and light outdoor use, the Original Universal is a great value.

Read review: Teva Original Universal - Women's

Best for Distance Hikers


Chaco Z/Cloud 2


Top Pick Award

$65.73
(40% off)
at REI
See It

81
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Comfort - 20% 6
  • Traction - 20% 9
  • Adjustability - 20% 8
  • Stability - 15% 9
  • Versatility - 15% 9
  • Style - 10% 8
Weight per pair: 1.44 lbs (size 9) | Sole: Non-marking ChacoGrip
Long-lasting
Versatile
Very supportive
Not comfortable for all feet
Weighty

The Chaco Z/Cloud 2 scores near the top of the charts across the board, but its durability and comfort specifically make it a great choice for distance hiking. This model features one of our review's best traction performances, combining underfoot traction with foot-to-shoe interaction that allowed testers to feel comfortable and secure no matter the terrain. With a comprehensive adjustment system that can hug each foot area, this product is a favorite. We love that its toe strap provides extra support on the trail but can also fold down as needed to accommodate socks.

Though we love them, Chacos don't work for everyone. Their footbed is sculpted and doesn't break in much, so if you have flat feet, these are unlikely ever to feel comfortable. The adjustment system is tricky to figure out at first, and it's not conducive to quick readjustment when you need it. These also aren't the lightest options we tested, though we feel that their extra heft lends stability during long days on the trail. All in all, if these fit your feet and you're ready to get out after it, we're pretty sure you'll be in love.

Read review: Chaco Z/Cloud 2

Best for Adventure Travel


KEEN Clearwater CNX


Top Pick Award

$49.48
(55% off)
at Amazon
See It

72
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Comfort - 20% 8
  • Traction - 20% 8
  • Adjustability - 20% 6
  • Stability - 15% 8
  • Versatility - 15% 7
  • Style - 10% 5
Weight per pair: 1.18 lbs (size 11) | Sole: Non-marking rubber
Sturdy comfort
Great water performance
Versatile
Does not fit wide feet well
Nonadjustable ankle strap

KEEN has long been a purveyor of sturdy footwear options that score high in versatility despite their bulky profiles. The KEEN Clearwater CNX upholds the brand's standard for adaptability while bucking the trend for bulk, and its sleek footprint made it our top choice for adventure travel. The Clearwater takes up minimal space in your carry-on and provides near-full coverage, making it a versatile option for rugged terrain. The footbed manages to achieve a comfortable level of squish while remaining supportive enough for all-day use.

Our one gripe with the Clearwater is the lack of a heel strap adjustment, which makes quick on-and-off and use with heavy socks difficult. Some testers also find this model, shall we say, stylistically challenged. That said, style is subjective, so check out the photos and decide for yourself. Overall, if you're looking for something durable that can handle rough terrain and water with ease, this is a sure winner. You might just love their performance enough that you forget about the way they look.

Read review: Keen Clearwater CNX

Best for Minimalist Trail Runners


Luna Oso Flaco Winged


Top Pick Award

$110.00
at Amazon
See It

70
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Comfort - 20% 5
  • Traction - 20% 9
  • Adjustability - 20% 7
  • Stability - 15% 8
  • Versatility - 15% 6
  • Style - 10% 7
Weight per pair: 0.88 lbs (size 9) | Sole: Vibram Megagrip
Super traction
Great stability
Minimal and lightweight
Uncomfortable
Not versatile

Most people are looking to raft, bike, hike, and lounge in their sandals, but what if you're a little crazy and you're on the hunt for something that will let you run free? Well, friend, then check out the Luna Oso Flaco Winged. This super pared-down, thin-soled kick has outstanding traction and a secure strap system built to keep minimalist runners happy. After a few skeptical test runs, this model fully converted our lead tester to minimalist running, and she now puts dozens of miles per month on them as her primary trail shoe. If you're interested in dipping your toes into the minimalist running waters, the Oso Flaco is an excellent introduction.

When you're not running, the party screeches to a halt. This model is pretty uncomfortable — something about the running motion seems to align the straps better with the foot, and this magic fades when you slow to walking speeds. The strap system is difficult to adjust at first, and it's too thin-soled to be comfortable on bike rides. If you're looking for an all-around sandal and not just an intro to running free, give this model a pass or, at least, be sure you can try them on before buying to ensure you like the way they feel.

Read review: Luna Oso Flaco Winged

Best for Camp Sandals


Xero Z-Trail - Women's


69
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Comfort - 20% 6
  • Traction - 20% 7
  • Adjustability - 20% 7
  • Stability - 15% 6
  • Versatility - 15% 7
  • Style - 10% 9
Weight per pair: 0.64 lbs (size 10) | Sole: FeelLite rubber
Very low weight
Easily slips into a weekend pack
Style points
Minimal cushioning
Slick footbed when wet
Heel strap velcro is short

The super lightweight Xero Z-Trail impressed us with its performance, comfortable materials, and stylish design. While we wouldn't recommend this as a primary hiking sandal, it's a great option for light hikes, and it transitions from town to trail with ease thanks to its sleek, non-technical look. It is also among the lightest models we've ever worn, so it's easy to tote just about anywhere. These factors are why we love the Z-Trail as camp sandals — this is the perfect option to tuck into your pack and slip on at the end of a long day on the trail.

The lightweight, minimalist design of the Z-Trail means that these won't offer the cushioning or support of the bulkier models in our review, so if you're not into the barefoot feel, these probably aren't for you when logging lots of miles. The footbed is slippery, especially when wet, so we don't recommend these as a primary river shoe either. But for minimal zero-drop comfort and good adjustability, these are worth a gander.

Read review: Xero Z-Trail - Women's

Notable for At-Home Style and Comfort


Olukai Upena



$89.95
at Amazon
See It

63
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Comfort - 20% 10
  • Traction - 20% 4
  • Adjustability - 20% 4
  • Stability - 15% 6
  • Versatility - 15% 6
  • Style - 10% 9
Weight per pair: 1.07 lbs (size 11) | Sole: Non-marking rubber
Delightfully comfortable
Take no time to break-in
Stylish
Not suitable for technical use
Minimally adjustable

The Olukai Upena is somewhat unique in this review in that its design is not really for rugged use. While this model can't compete with the more technical options in the backcountry, it deserves mention for wearing at home and around town. It is one of the most comfortable and stylish models we've ever worn, and our testers rarely take it off around the house. Its footbed is slightly molded and supportive enough to remain comfortable walking to the coffee shop and on easy bike rides around the neighborhood. If you're not planning to do any water sports or trail hiking, but are looking for a stylish footwear option that's more supportive than a flip-flop, the Upena deserves your attention.

The Upena is a bit pricey, as is typical from Olukai. However, rest assured you're getting a well-crafted shoe made with premium materials. Olukai sandals are also surprisingly water-friendly, despite having leather components, due to the Hawaiian influence and focus. Still, the Upena falls short in the adjustability category and isn't nearly as rugged as other options in this review. If you need something to take you on a rafting trip or a thru-hike, this simply isn't it. On the other hand, if summer for you means beaches, bistros, and bars, this is one model to consider.

Read review: Olukai Upena


We love playing outside in sandals  especially when they're grippy and comfortable like this model.
We love playing outside in sandals, especially when they're grippy and comfortable like this model.

Why You Should Trust Us


This review is brought to you by expert duo Joanna Trieger and Shey Kiester. Joanna uses her home in Reno, Nevada as a base of operations for various Sierra Nevada excursions. You can find her bike commuting on workdays, which she has done without exception for the past five years. Joanna travels nearly 4,000 miles per year under her own steam, from long-distance hiking to running to bikepacking, and her preferred type of footwear is — you guessed it — the sandal. Forming the other half of the team is Shey, an accomplished alpine climber and writer. She holds a degree in creative writing and English rhetoric from the University of Alaska and has written for Alpinist, American Alpine Journal, and Backpacker, among others.

Reviewing this category began with no shortage of market research. The team started with several dozen pairs up for consideration and down-selected to the best 14 models available. Once all models were purchased and in-hand, months of testing in a variety of settings ensued. We dispatched sandals to testers who wore them in wet and dry conditions, with and without packs, and around town. About 70% of testing took place on hiking trails, while the rest happened around town and on the bike. After gathering our findings, we are pleased to share this comprehensive review, which we think is a great tool if you're in the market for women's sandals.

To truly compare the performance of the models in our review  we test them side-by-side. Here  we're getting ready to traction-test (from left to right) the Luna Oso Flaco  OluKai Upena  KEEN Rose  Bedrock Cairn 3D PRO II Adventure  Chaco Z/1 Classic  Teva Original Universal  and (worn by our lead tester) the Bedrock Cairn Adventure.
The Cairn 3D PRO II offers everything we love about the Cairn Adventure  plus a little extra grip and support for watery  rugged environments.

Related: How We Tested Sandals for Women

Analysis and Test Results


Adventure sandals are unique footwear that attempt to cover the large gray area between hiking shoes and flip-flops. This category offers more performance (and maybe a little less fashion) than a flip-flop while maintaining more breathability (and in some cases, more versatility) than a hiking shoe.

Related: Buying Advice for Sandals for Women

All of the products in this review strap securely to the foot and sport patterned soles, making them versatile enough for off-the-pavement forays. This review identifies the best models for specific activities, like travel, hiking, water sports, and even running. All the models here are top performers, and their scores in each of our metrics represent how they fare compared to one another. Below, you'll find in-depth explanations of the designs we reviewed and how we tested for each parameter.

Value


It is important to keep in mind that some of the most durable models we tested are on the more expensive side. The Chaco models are among the most expensive in this review, but they are built to last. If you expect to put in a lot of time in your shoes and anticipate rough-and-tumble activities that will test your footwear's durability, Chacos are worth it.


Another pricey option that's worth splurging on is the Bedrock Cairn Adventure. Our lead tester wore this pair almost daily for two years. She used it as her primary shoe for hundreds of miles of use per month of biking, hiking, and around-town before the front lugs wore down enough to need replacing (check out the Bedrock Cairn Adventure review for more on that process). That said, the Teva Original Universal offers acceptable durability for less than half the price of the Chaco or Bedrock models.

If a sandal is durable and comfortable enough to replace a hiking boot for long trips into the backcountry  it's worth spending a little extra.
If a sandal is durable and comfortable enough to replace a hiking boot for long trips into the backcountry, it's worth spending a little extra.

Comfort


If your shoes are uncomfortable, you're less likely to wear them. Because of this, comfort is one of our most important metrics and is worth 20% of products' overall scores. We rated our sandals based on how long they took to break in and whether there were any lingering points of discomfort after the break-in period. We analyzed how the footbed and strap materials feel against the skin and tested for comfort while wearing a heavy pack, with wet feet, on smooth and rough terrain, and while walking up and down steep trails. Some models perform well in one area and poorly in another, while our highest-scoring models perform well across the board.

Keep in mind that, to an extent, comfort is subjective. Where applicable, we have noted whether or not a shoe's comfort is affected by the foot shape of the tester, and we indicated which foot types were likely to work with which models.


Although we try to be as objective as possible with our comfort ratings, this metric is dependent on what kind of activities you plan to participate in while wearing your shoes. If you intend to wear your shoe during long stints on the trail with a heavy pack, seek out a model with excellent support and traction. On the other hand, if you're looking for an exceptional travel shoe that is lightweight and breathable, look for options with slim profiles and comfortable straps.

The KEEN Clearwater and the Bedrock Cairn Adventure both take home high comfort scores. The close fit and supportive-yet-supple footbed of the Clearwater garner top marks, while the barely-there feel of the Cairn Adventure earns it a high score. The other burlier Bedrock we tested, the Cairn 3D PRO II Adventure, also takes home a high score here. It's very similar to the regular Cairn but with a cushier sole.

The Bedrock Cairn Adventure is one of the most comfortable models we tested. Its wide straps with multiple adjustment points give them a barely-there feel  and even our high-arched testers found the zero-drop footbed comfortable.
The Bedrock Cairn Adventure is one of the most comfortable models we tested. Its wide straps with multiple adjustment points give them a barely-there feel, and even our high-arched testers found the zero-drop footbed comfortable.

Though we don't recommend it for technical applications, the Olukai Upena stands out in the comfort category. The straps and footbed feel delightful against the skin, and it takes no time at all for this model to feel cozy. It is the first shoe we would reach for when lounging around the house or taking a walk to the coffee shop.

The Upena is so comfortable  we never want to take it off  even on the couch.
The Upena is so comfortable, we never want to take it off, even on the couch.

The Xero Z-Trail is the most minimalist product in our review, so its comfort isn't based on its cushioning. The Z-Trail's materials feel great against the skin, and this model feels broken-in almost instantly. We especially like slipping these on after a long day of running, hiking, or skiing since they're extremely lightweight and don't pinch the feet. It is one reason why this model is a great pick for use as camp sandals. Note that this shoe is not cushioned, which is why it doesn't score top marks in this category.

The Xero Z-Trail is a great camp sandal  because slipping them on after a long day feels so great. Here  our tester relaxes after swapping her trail running shoes for the Z-Trail.
The Xero Z-Trail is a great camp sandal, because slipping them on after a long day feels so great. Here, our tester relaxes after swapping her trail running shoes for the Z-Trail.

In the middle of the spectrum are the Teva Original Universal and the Chaco models. Chaco's offerings are incredibly supportive, and the comprehensive (although complicated) adjustments allow for round-the-foot support. However, because of a raised footbed that proves uncomfortable for flat-footed users and a hearty sole that takes time to break-in, we took docked some points. The Z/Volv X2 has a slightly lower-profile footbed molding, which makes this a better choice for those with low arches. The Teva Original Universal's wide straps and squishy footbed lend comfort during light use, but these same straps and footbed become uncomfortable under the strain of technical trails. Again, it all depends on what activities you plan to undertake.

The Chaco Z/Volv X2 is Chaco's attempt to pare down its classically chunky offerings. The Z/Volv X2 is made of a PU compound that the company says is 20% lighter than its classic sandals. We measured the model to be about 15% lighter than the Z/Cloud 2. The footbed is also less contoured, which may satisfy the complaints of those with flat feet. We tested the Z/Cloud 2 and the Z/Volv X2 side-by-side and were barely able to detect these differences, but they are there. If you've been avoiding Chacos because their weight and molded footbed feel uncomfortable to you, you might be happier with the Z/Volv X2.

Traction


With the common trend of slapping sticky rubber (like that found on modern approach shoes) and Vibram soles on the bottom of outdoor footwear, shoe traction has significantly improved. Traction is a major selling point for shoe manufacturers, so we are naturally curious how well each pair gains purchase on varying surfaces. Our testers scrambled slick granite from Donner Summit to Yosemite to Bishop. Each product was subjected to a slip test while carrying a heavy pack and in wet conditions. We also evaluated the traction between the bottom of the foot and the footbed, which is a big factor in how grippy you'll feel over uneven surfaces. The highest performers inspire enough confidence for quick travel even over steep, slick terrain. This score is worth 20% of the total.


The Chaco and Bedrock models and the Oso Flaco Winged earn the highest traction scores. The Cairn Adventure is a go-to on steep approaches thanks to the trusty rubber and large lug design of its sole. The Cairn 3D PRO II Adventure is an even grippier option that excels in watery environments. The Chaco models also provide outstanding traction even when traveling with a heavy pack, and we found their footbeds to have even better traction than that of the Cairn Adventure. The Oso Flaco's combination of deep lugs and a flexible sole allows for amazing traction on uneven terrain, though it loses out on top marks due to its slippery footbed.

This Luna model offers outstanding traction due to its deep  strategically placed lugs.
This Luna model offers outstanding traction due to its deep, strategically placed lugs.

Following closely behind the leaders is the Clearwater CNX. KEEN's proprietary rubber is up to most tasks, handling loose pebbles on steep terrain well while traveling both up and downhill. This model receives lower marks because it tends to inspire insecurity on the steepest downhills. The Teva Original Universal also offers surprisingly good traction for a budget pick, especially in wet environments.

The Teva Original  provides surprisingly great traction in and out of water  despite its budget price.
The Teva Original, provides surprisingly great traction in and out of water, despite its budget price.

Adjustability


This metric is based on the number of adjustment points sported on each model, how well they conform the product to the foot, and how easy they are to adjust. This metric spread the competition across the board, as the adjustment methods vary from model to model. This metric is also worth 20% of the overall score.


The Cairn 3D PRO II Adventure and Bedrock Cairn Adventure receive top adjustability scores. These models employ a unique combo of adjustable ankle straps and a sliding top strap, as well as a high hook for even more adjustment. All of these combine to give a considerable amount of adjustment potential, and testers could lock in the best fit quickly. Once that fit is locked in, adjusting the Cairn Adventure to take it on and off and loosen or tighten it for different applications is a cinch.

The Xero Z-Trail is intuitive and easy to adjust, and we appreciate being able to tighten one of its straps without having to batten down everything. However, this model's heel strap is short, which could be an issue for wide feet.

The Xero Z-Trail (left) and the Bedrock Cairn Adventure (right) are both minimalist sandals  but they have very different adjustment systems. The Z-Trail's strap criss-crosses the foot and can be adjusted at several points  while the Cairn has a thong-style strap with two side branches that can be adjusted. Both sandals have a Velcro heel strap.
The Xero Z-Trail (left) and the Bedrock Cairn Adventure (right) are both minimalist sandals, but they have very different adjustment systems. The Z-Trail's strap criss-crosses the foot and can be adjusted at several points, while the Cairn has a thong-style strap with two side branches that can be adjusted. Both sandals have a Velcro heel strap.

The Chaco models — the Z/Volv X2 and the Z/Cloud 2, the Z/1 Classic — have continuous straps that flow in and out of the shoe's sole and over the foot. These models are supremely adjustable so that you can get the right fit. However, making adjustments is time-consuming, and since adjusting one strap means adjusting them all, quick tweaks are out of the question. It also takes time to get the hang of adjusting these, so plan to spend some quality time getting your Chacos just right before you hit the trail.

Adjusting Chacos on-the-fly is simple thanks to their single side buckle  but dialing in the initial fit is a little trickier.
Adjusting Chacos on-the-fly is simple thanks to their single side buckle, but dialing in the initial fit is a little trickier.

At the bottom of the pile are the KEEN models. The Clearwater CNX and Whisper include a simple pull-to-tighten feature at the top of the foot that attempts to mimic a shoelace design. However, this system doesn't allow for toe box micro-adjustments or the ankle, making it difficult to dial in the fit.

The KEEN Whisper's heel strap is too loose to keep the foot in place  so our heels slid back off the footbed.
The KEEN Whisper's heel strap is too loose to keep the foot in place, so our heels slid back off the footbed.

Stability


Stability is what sets most sandals apart from flip-flops. Feeling stable while hiking, especially with a pack on, is essential, so this metric is worth 15% of a product's overall score. To perform well, contestants need to feel stable and secure in nearly all outdoor settings and during long days of city walking. Sufficient arch support, a solid sole (that's minimal enough to feel light but not so flimsy that it feels insubstantial), and well-fitting straps contribute to this metric. Each model's Stability score is a collective assessment of performance across a range of terrain.


Several models receive high marks for stability, including the Cairn 3D PRO II Adventure, Cairn Adventure, all three Chaco models, and the Clearwater CNX. All these products have durable soles that allow for quick movement across rugged terrain, and their strap systems eliminate concerns about slipping on steep hills.

If you'll be tackling terrain that includes steep  uneven rock climbs and rushing river crossings  look for a stable model  like the Bedrocks.
If you'll be tackling terrain that includes steep, uneven rock climbs and rushing river crossings, look for a stable model, like the Bedrocks.

The Cairn Adventure is an excellent choice for users looking for a more minimal sole with less support, allowing for more feel. On the other end of the spectrum, the Chaco models offer thick soles and maximum support. The Cairn 3D PRO II Adventure is a happy medium. The Xero Z-Trail has the most flexible sole in our review and doesn't offer footbed molding or support, so it loses points here, but we still feel its straps hold the feet in place well enough for light hiking without a pack.

The Chaco Z/Cloud 2 (left) and the Bedrock Cairn (right) both provide impressive stability  but their approach couldn't be more different. The Chaco has a thick  supportive sole  while the Bedrock's sole is more flexible and nimble.
The Chaco Z/Cloud 2 (left) and the Bedrock Cairn (right) both provide impressive stability, but their approach couldn't be more different. The Chaco has a thick, supportive sole, while the Bedrock's sole is more flexible and nimble.

When hiking with a heavy pack, models with thicker soles will help you better handle the added weight over rough terrain. We felt most stable in the Chaco Z/1 Classic and the Chaco Z/Cloud 2 while carrying a loaded backpacking pack.

The Chaco Z/Cloud 2 kept us comfortable  even when carrying backpacking weight. However  those with low arches may find that this shoe doesn't conform to their foot.
The Chaco Z/Cloud 2 kept us comfortable, even when carrying backpacking weight. However, those with low arches may find that this shoe doesn't conform to their foot.

The Clearwater CNX receives high marks in this category for its supportive footbed combined with round-the-foot strap attachments. Thanks to this design, it performed the best on steep terrain in terms of shoe-foot integration. Unfortunately, despite looking similar, the KEEN Whisper loses points here because its exceptionally wide footbed and ineffective heel strap allow the feet to slosh around, leading to a feeling of instability. Those with wider feet may not experience this problem as bad, but the heel strap is not enough to stop a foot of any width from sliding back.

Three of the KEEN models — the Clearwater, the Whisper, and the Rose — come with the classic KEEN Foot Bumper, a bulbous rubber add-on to the front of the shoe that provides unrivaled toe protection.

The classic KEEN foot bumpers  shown here on the Whisper (left) and the Clearwater (right).
The classic KEEN foot bumpers, shown here on the Whisper (left) and the Clearwater (right).

Versatility


Sandals are often pushed to their limit on the hiking trail and then, on the same day, taken out on the town paired with a summer dress. It requires them to be nimble and flattering enough for social events while still maintaining a high level of traction and support for a wide variety of outdoor pursuits. Models that score the highest in this metric take on everything from steep, loose trails to water sports and easily transition to the bar patio or a backyard barbecue afterward. This metric accounts for 15% of a product's overall score.


The Bedrock models take home the top scores in this metric because they score well in the rest of our performance categories, AND they are low-profile enough to pair with a skirt or skinny jeans. The Chaco models are not far behind, but their bulk makes them harder to style. Conversely, the Teva Original Universal and the Xero Z-Trail are not up to the rugged backcountry use of the Chaco, but they're super stylish, so they transition easy from light outdoor pursuits to wearing around town.

The Chaco Z/Volv X2 is a great option for cycling around town as well as for long treks in the wilderness.
The Chaco Z/Volv X2 is a great option for cycling around town as well as for long treks in the wilderness.

Although some other models like the Clearwater perform well across various activities, they lack the style points to cross over into town use. Style-forward models like the Upena score low here because they can't hack anything more than very light activity on the trails.

The KEEN models perform well for rugged use  but they're tough to transition to town because of their bulk and their geeky style.
The KEEN models perform well for rugged use, but they're tough to transition to town because of their bulk and their geeky style.

Style


Yes, judging looks is a subjective game. But most of us factor in style when choosing footwear, so we feel the need to include this criterion to comprehensively evaluate our test group. Since everyone's sense of style is different, we recommend skimming through photos to form your own opinions about each model's style. To evaluate this metric, we consider how each option looks in the backcountry and around town. All-around style earns high scores in this metric because we don't want to change shoes between the hike and the watering hole. This metric accounts for 10% of each product's overall score.


The sandals that best bridge the backcountry/city gap are the Teva Original, Xero Z-Trail, Cairn Adventure, and the Chaco models. When we surveyed family and friends to ask which options they found to be the most stylish, these were the top scorers. All of these are low-profile, with both flashy and more neutral color options. They look at home both on city streets and in the mountains. While not ruggedly trail-ready, the Upena is urban and attractive, perfect for lazy summers at the cafe, park, or even dressed up for a night on the town.

Though they're not great for technical pursuits  Olukai makes one of the most stylish models we tested.
Though they're not great for technical pursuits, Olukai makes one of the most stylish models we tested.

The KEEN models are among the least stylish of the bunch. Our testers agree that these options are clunky and awkward to pair with a sleek outfit. When we surveyed friends and family and asked them to rank the style of each model from 1 (ugly) to 10 (super stylish), some respondents tried to give the Whisper a zero, and one lobbied for the Rose to receive a -1, which is why they score so low in this category.

Conclusion


The footwear in this review is meant to walk the line between casual flip-flops and serious hiking shoes. For the most part, these models strap to your feet more securely than a flip-flop while allowing for more ventilation and water use than a hiking shoe. Perfect for the summer and even shoulder seasons, a great pair of sandals can accompany you on hikes, in the water, and around town. Our review is here to help you evaluate the different models available so you can find the pair that will best fit your lifestyle, feet, and wallet. Get your feet in the pair that's right for you, and we'll see you on the trails!

Free toes  free mind. Find the sandals that work for you and hit the trails!
Free toes, free mind. Find the sandals that work for you and hit the trails!

Joanna Trieger & Shey Kiester