Mammut redesigned the passive locking Smart device for 2018, and our testers were impressed with the result. Retailing for only $35, the Smart 2.0 offers you the security of an assisted braking device at an affordable price. It's also lightweight and compact, but it's not the most versatile option. The 2.0 is for single-strand use only. The Smart Alpine (double-strand auto-locking device) has yet to be updated, so we'll have to wait and see if the improved changes on the 2.0 make it to the Alpine. There is a bit of a learning curve with this device, and while Mammut also sells a "Smarter" clip-on attachment to prevent misuse, we think brand new belayers will probably have an easier time with the Petzl GriGri+ and its anti-panic mechanism. If you've worn out your last GriGri and aren't looking forward to spending $100-150 for a new one, our Best Buy winner, the Smart 2.0 will save you a lot of money.
Mammut Smart 2.0 Review
Cons: Learning curve, limited use, uncomfortable when lowering
#11 of 13
Compare to Similar Products
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Mammut Smart 2.0 is a "passive" assisted belay device. That means that there are no moving parts inside the Smart that cam or pinch the rope to slow it down. Instead, the rotation of the device against your carabiner is what creates the pinch. This device is rated for use with 8.7 to 10.5mm ropes, and Mammut recommends using their Smart HMS carabiner with this device (it has a safety gate to prevent cross-loading and unscrewing). We didn't have one of those on hand and tested it primarily with a Black Diamond Gridlock carabiner. Note that part of the way these passive lockers work requires a certain diameter on the carabiner that you are using, so you should ideally pair them with the recommended carabiner or with a larger H or HMS type locking carabiners from another manufacturer and not the smaller Type B or Basic locking carabiners.
We thought the catch and bite on this device was superior to that of the tube style devices, and we gave it an 8/10 for this category.
We always kept our brake hand down when belaying with the Smart, which is the recommended technique. Use of the old-school tube-style belay technique is not recommended (where you bring the brake rope above and parallel with the lead side to take in or give out slack. In fact, studies done on the older Smart show that without the hand in the proper brake position the device alone won't stop the climber (though the drop test video of the 2.0 does show it engaging without a tensioned brake hand). Mammut designed an extra little piece called the Smarter, that attaches to the top of the Smart and prevents the ropes from getting too close. They recommend this attachment for newer belayers who are still learning best practices. We didn't test the additional piece — it seems like a good idea, but it does costs an additional $13 and looks like something that can easily get lost.
The main advantage to the Smart and other passive devices over a traditional "tuber" is that you don't have to hold down so hard on your brake hand when the climber has weighted the rope. This doesn't mean that you can take it off completely, just that the device is pinching the rope enough that you can relax your grip a little. We did try opening our hands slightly in some situations to see if the rope would slide through or not, and it always held tight. That's a little more piece of mind that the device is working, but again you should always maintain control of the brake end.
The Smart 2.0 requires a different method for lowering than most other devices. Since the device is "locked" when the climber weights the rope, loosening your grip should have no effect. There is no lever to pull back on, rather the device itself is the lever. While keeping your brake hand on the rope you pull up on the lever with your other thumb, which changes the orientation and reduces the pinch, and the rope starts to feed through.
We didn't like the lowering on this device as much as we did we its closest competitor, the Black Diamond ATC Pilot. The track on Smart is a little longer than on the Pilot, but the rope didn't always want to stay on it, and it was tiring to have to push up with our thumb so much. It also didn't feel as intuitive as lowering with the Pilot.
Mammut doesn't want you to lower by encircling your guide hand around the device and pushing the palm against it to break the pinch, which is how you lower with the Pilot. We did try lowering that way anyway, but the housing on the Smart has metal edges that dig into your palms a little when pushing on it. The Pilot's housing is all plastic and has a better hand feel than this one. If we were looking for a device solely for top roping, we'd go with the Pilot first over this one. However, we like the way the Smart feeds slack better (see below) which is why it edged out the Pilot for our Best Buy award.
If you've been belaying the same way for 20 years, you may not like this device — and/or you might end up short-roping your partner a bit while you get used to it! Belaying with the Smart 2.0 might take some getting used to, as it's completely different from most tube style devices and most active assisted braking devices. While you can pay out slack slowly as with a tuber, when you want to give a lot of slack you have to disengage the device by pushing upwards on the lever with the thumb of your brake hand (with the rest of your hand still around the rope). This lets you pull up lots of slack with your other hand relatively smoothly.
While not as smooth or intuitive as a tuber at first, once you've become accustomed to the technique it works well, particularly when compared to the Pilot. The lever on the Smart is more sensitive to pressure and doesn't require as much force as the Pilot to disengage it. We had to press quite hard on the Pilot and keep a consistent outward pressure, whereas the Smart needed less pressure and fed smoother. We tested this device with a newer 9mm and a "fuzzy" 9.7mm and found that it fed slack out much easier with a skinnier rope. This device is ambidextrous though, so lefties might appreciate its feed even more.
Auto Block (resistance belaying a second)
We did not test this model for its auto-block resistance as it is not designed for this purpose. If you like this model but want something that you can belay off an anchor with, check out the Mammut Smart Alpine. It can accommodate two ropes and has the necessary loop for belaying off the anchor. It was one of our favorite options for using in auto-block mode as it provided less resistance than the ATC Guide, Petzl Reverso, or Edelrid MegaJul. However, the setup is a little complex so be sure to read the instructions carefully.
This device weighs a scant 2.7 ounces, which is a significant difference from the heavier assisted braking devices.
It is a few ounces lighter than the Black Diamond ATC Pilot, but a hair bulkier, so we called it a draw for this category. If you are looking for something lighter to replace your GriGri with, this could be what you are looking for.
We expect the Smart to have a lifespan similar to a tube-style device. (Note that we assessed wear after four months of regular use, but have not used it through its entire lifespan yet since it was only released this year.)
The parts that will see the most wear are mainly stainless steel, though the track on the lever is plastic. We weren't sure what concerned us more, the plastic lever on this device or the plastic housing on the Pilot. The rope needs to run off the end of the track on the Smart and not the sides, which have right-angles and could sharpen if you lower with the rope off to the side. Note that if you've been using the same belay carabiner on your GriGri for five years, you can't expect it to last as long with the Smart. The wear on the GriGri is all inside the mechanism, whereas the rope runs through your carabiner on the Smart and will wear it down similar to a tube device.
This device is great for single-pitch climbing uses. We preferred it for lead belaying rather than top-roping. It also felt better with skinnier ropes, so if you're still climbing on 10.2mm lines, you might have a harder time feeding slack with the Smart 2.0.
The Smart 2.0 retails for $35, which is a bit less than the ATC Pilot ($45). If you choose to buy the "Smarter" add-on, it will bring the total up to $48. Alternatively, you can purchase it with the Smart HMS carabiner for $45, which is a good value.
Passive assisted braking devices have elicited a lot of "whys?" from people when they spotted us testing them out at the crag. Think of them as a cross between a GriGri and an ATC. If you're partial to tube-style devices but want some extra holding power and security, then the Smart 2.0 is a great choice. If you've always used a GriGri but are open to trying something lighter and less expensive, the Smart also fills that bill.
OutdoorGearLab Member Reviews
Most recent review: August 21, 2018
Have you used this product?
Don't hold back. Share your viewpoint by posting a review with your thoughts...