The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of outdoor gear

Black Diamond ATC XP Review

A simple design suited for building proper belay technique.
Black Diamond ATC XP
Best Buy Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:  $22 List | $20.36 at Amazon
Compare prices at 4 resellers
Pros:  Good friction control when rappelling and lowering, smooth paying out rope
Cons:  0.2 oucnes heavier than the Verso, you must hold the weight of the climber when they weight the rope
Manufacturer:   Black Diamond
By Jack Cramer ⋅ Review Editor  ⋅  Jan 31, 2016
  • Share this article:
71
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#5 of 13
  • Catch and Bite - 30% 6
  • Lowering and Rappelling - 30% 9
  • Feeding Slack - 15% 9
  • Auto Block - 10% 0
  • Weight and Bulk - 10% 9
  • Durability - 5% 7

Our Verdict

The Black Diamond ATC XP was one of our favorite manual belay devices and our Best Buy award winner for that category. At $22, it's not the absolute cheapest option. However, we believe the basic features it includes increase its value and warrants the modest added cost. The ATC XP is designed in the classic tube shape but with a pair of toothed grooves on one side for greater friction. According to BD, these grooves offer three times more stopping power than the smooth-sided, original ATC. We preferred the ATC XP over the similar Petzl Verso because it is more durable and required less hand strength to lock off a resting climber.

Its other competitors are the Petzl GriGri+ or 2 and the Black Diamond ATC Guide. The GriGri+ is our Editors' Choice winner for the best overall belay device. It is better than the ATC XP for gym belaying, sport climbing, and any situations where you have long belays, are locking off frequently, or the climber is falling a lot—or all three combined! However, you cannot do a two-strand rappel with a GriGri, so most climbers will still need a tube-style device even if that is their main one. Here's where the ATC XP comes in. At only 2.2 ounces, you can throw it in the lid of your cragging pack and forget about it, until you need it!

The ATC Guide is the better device if you're multi-pitch climbing and want to belay off the anchor, and it was our Top Pick for Multi-Pitch Climbing award winner.

New Colors — February 2017
Keeping things fresh, the ATC-XP is now offered in two new colors. Keep scrolling to check them out!


Compare to Similar Products

Our Analysis and Test Results

New Colors — February 2017


Black Diamond released new colors for the ATC XP, though the design remains the same as the model that we tested. You can get it in black (left) and blue (right).
Black Diamond ATC XP
Black Diamond ATC XP

Hands-On Review


The ATC XP is a classic tube-style manual belay device with additional friction grooves on one side. It got a nice redesign in 2012. Machined windows were added to the sides that reduced the weight by 30%.

Performance Comparison


An ATC XP basking in the sun overlooking the entrance to Yosemite Valley.
An ATC XP basking in the sun overlooking the entrance to Yosemite Valley.

Catch/Bite


With two friction modes, the ATC XP allows you to match the holding power to the circumstances. When top-roping with large, stiff gym ropes, regular friction mode can save you lots of energy. Flip it around and use the teeth for greater holding power catching a lead fall. We thought the ATC XP provided a similar bite to Petzl Verso. However, once someone was hanging on the rope, the XP locked off better and required less hand strength to keep the rope from sliding through.


Tube style devices require a great deal of hand strength to hold the weight of the climber, which can be fatiguing. This is one reason for the popularity of the active assisted devices and probably also why Black Diamond recently released the ATC Pilot. The Pilot is a "passive" device that pinches the rope against the carabiner, taking a lot of the pressure off your break hand - though you still have to hold on to it! While this offers more security than the ATC XP, the Pilot is a single-strand only device, so it's not as versatile as the XP.

Lowering/Rappelling


During lowering and rappelling the performance difference between the ATC XP and Petzl Verso is was very small.


Both are capable of rappelling two strands and provide a similar amount of resistance. The ATC XP though felt ever so slightly less jerky.

Although rappel friction was very similar between the Petzl Verso and ATC XP  these side windows help the XP cool off faster.
Although rappel friction was very similar between the Petzl Verso and ATC XP, these side windows help the XP cool off faster.

Feeding Slack


Feeding slack with the ATC XP and Petzl Verso was nearly identical. After trying both with a variety of ropes and in blind tests with our friends, we believe the ATC XP does so slightly more smoothly. Compared to paying out rope with the ATC Pilot or other assisted locking devices, we prefer the simplicity of a tube device like this one.


Auto-block (resistance belaying a second)


It's not safe to belay a follower directly off an anchor with this device and we did not score it for this category. We compared other auto-block capable devices in our review, and you can see our scores for each one below.


Weight/Bulk


The ATC XP weighs in at 2.2 ounces. This is just a touch heavier than its chief rival, the Petzl Verso.


Size-wise it's also a bit larger, with a longer wire cable and a wider main body. Neither of these differences was big enough to affect our purchasing recommendation. Overall it's tied for being the second lightest and smallest.

The body and wire loop on the Black Diamond ATC XP (left) are both larger than the Petzl Verso (right). The difference wasn't large enough to have a significant impact on our scoring.
The body and wire loop on the Black Diamond ATC XP (left) are both larger than the Petzl Verso (right). The difference wasn't large enough to have a significant impact on our scoring.

Durability


The aluminum used to make the ATC XP feels harder than that on the Petzl Verso. After six months of use, we think it will last longer — the friction teeth certainly seem to.


Many climbers learn the sport with an ATC XP or similar tube device before moving on to more sophisticated models when they specialize in a particular climbing discipline. We believe the XP will last the average climber several years, plenty of time to sort out what device to upgrade to.

Best Applications


We like this belay device most for climbers new to the sport or for experienced shoppers that appreciate simplicity. New climbers can learn the basics of belaying with the added safety margin of strong stopping power. Experienced climbers can enjoy affordable function in a compact, reliable package.

The affordable ATC XP is our recommendation for beginners or anyone that wants a simple  compact belay device.
The affordable ATC XP is our recommendation for beginners or anyone that wants a simple, compact belay device.

Value


At $21.95, the ATC XP is a competitively priced belay device. Although there are cheaper options available, we believe the added braking power of the XP is worth the added cost. The price is identical to the Petzl Verso; however, we believe the XP is more durable and a better value.

Conclusion


The Black Diamond ATC XP is our favorite basic tube belay device. It's light and durable, and the two friction modes increase its versatility for different rope or friction situations. We like it most for new climbers still ingraining proper belay techniques or for experienced folks looking for a simple, reliable device that can do everything pretty well. There are cheaper devices available, but we believe the $21.95 MSRP is justified. It's also frequently on sale, so consider checking the "Where's the best price?" links at the top of this page to find a good deal.

Other Versions and Accessories


Black Diamond also makes our Top Pick for multi-pitch climbing, the ATC Guide. This device is similar to the ATC XP but with the ability to belay a follower from above directly off an anchor. A toothless tube option is available too as the classic Black Diamond ATC ($18).


Jack Cramer