We buy all the products we test — no freebies from companies. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission, which helps support our testing.
We've been testing rain jackets for 13 years, and in that time, we've tested more than 60 of rain jackets designed for men. This review features 17 of the market's top contenders, which we purchased ourselves and pitted against each other in rigorous side-by-side and real-world tests. We wore them in heavy downpours, snow, and sleet, and we soaked these jackets in controlled shower tests to assess their performance. We've identified the pros and cons of each model and offer unbiased and honest recommendations to help you get the best possible option for your needs.
The highest-scoring rain jacket in our test is the Arc'teryx Beta LT, which offers incredible waterproofing, a great fit, and is one of the most durable jackets we tested. This model has pit zips so you can dump heat quickly and our testers find it quite comfortable. However, it's certainly a splurge.
If you're seeking a more affordable rain jacket, our top choice is the Helly Hansen Loke, another comfortable jacket with armpit zips. Helly Hansen's proprietary 2.5-layer membrane isn't quite as protective as the Arc'teryx Beta LT's 3-layer Gore-Tex membrane, but this jacket will certainly keep you dry in the average rainstorm — and for a nice price. Read on to see all of our favorite picks.
Need to stay dry head to toe? We've also tested rain pants and top-ranked umbrellas, as well as hardshell jackets if you'll be running into burlier weather or need a designated shell jacket for hitting the slopes.
Editor's Note: We updated our men's rain jacket review on November 8, 2024, to share updates on the Arc'teryx Beta LT jacket, which is now called the Beta SL and has some material updates.
Great mobility, amazing breathability, waterproof chest pocket, helmet-compatible hood
Excellent side vents, comfortable, excellent water resistance
Super stretchy material, above average breathability, nice interior feel, lightweight, stuffs into its pocket
Great storm protection, above average breathability, no clammy feeling, packs tightly into reversible stuff pocket, helmet-compatible hood, less crinkly
Stretchy material, great freedom of movement, pleasant cut, solid storm protection, lightweight, compresses into its pocket, good value
Stretchy, very breathable, excellent adjustable hood
Storm-worthy, durable, versatile, good breathability and ventilation, waterproof pockets
Durable, long-lasting DWR, good storm-worthiness, minimal clammy feel
Lightweight, breathable, inexpensive
Insanely lightweight, tiny compressed size, stows tightly in a reversible pocket, hood design maintains great peripheral vision, respectable stormworthiness
Good breathability, comfortable feeling internal fabric, stretchy material allows mobility, respectable weight and packed size
Pit zips, waterproof zipper, inexpensive, stows in pocket
Better breathability than others in its price range, decent ventilation, roll away hood, nice pit zips, affordable
Great value, cut for layering, compresses into its pocket, respectable weight, hood tucks away nicely into the collar
Comfortable, affordable, athletic fit, good wrist cuffs
Cons
Less breathable, stiffer fabric, expensive
No ventilation options, expensive, doesn't stuff into its pocket
Doesn’t pack into pocket, less waterproof than top models, above average weight
Pocket zippers are not waterproof, does not stow in pocket
Average weather protection, easy to overtighten hood and squeeze ears
Average freedom of movement, less stretchy than most other air-permeable models, fit, low handwarmer pockets could be more functional
So-so breathability, hood doesn't fit very well over a helmet
Less waterproof than others, opposite-facing zipper
Heavy for a "minimalist" design
Heavier, stiff fabric, average packed size
Zipper isn't waterproof, fabric wets out faster, thin material is less durable
Average breathability, minimal hood, only one pocket, not as versatile in the traditional sense
Pockets pinch under a waist belt or harness, hood doesn't fit over a helmet, on the more expensive side, weather resistance could be better
Limited breathability, sleeves feel short
No chest pocket, not quite as breathable as models that use a non-coated membrane
Less durable, poor breathability, DWR is short-lived
Bulky, warm, limited hood adjustment
Bottom Line
A top-tier rain jacket with excellent water protection, adjustability, and durability from hood to waist
This function-focused jacket is exceptionally versatile and offers some of the best performance in our review
A very solid jacket with excellent breathability that provides strong waterproofing in all but the most extreme of situations
A reliable all-around shell with great ventilation features in a fairly light, durable, and stormworthy package
Constructed with a super stretchy material and offering superb mobility, this is the ideal rain shell for demanding activities
This jack-of-all-trades jacket offers some of the best weather protection and durability for an air-permeable model
A solid all-around option for the price, with great mobility and respectable storm protection
This is an extra-stretchy, air-permeable rain jacket that is a phenomenal choice in inclement weather when maintaining mobility is a top priority
This is one of our favorite do-anything jackets, offering excellent weather resistance, functionality, and durability
A durable jacket with a function-focused design that will keep most wearers satisfied without putting too big a hole in their wallets
This affordable rain jacket will keep you dry enough in most situations and has many of the same features as more expensive models
Light and compressible, this jacket is ideal for trips where low weight is paramount
This jacket maintains a steady level of breathability regardless of activity level and nails a sweet spot between weight and durability
This low-cost, high-value rain jacket has many of the same features as its expensive competitors at a fraction of the price
A great jacket with an excellent price tag that offers above-average breathability
A great price on a reasonably solid jacket that performs similarly to others in its price range
An excellent price, but it doesn't offer nearly as many outdoor activity oriented features as other models we review
Updated Version Available
Since our test period, Arc'teryx replaced the Beta LT in their lineup with the Beta SL jacket. This new version uses PFC-free 40D Gore-Tex ePE material, with 70D Gore-Tex ePE on high-wear areas like the shoulders, where backpack straps may rub. Our review now points to the Beta SL, and we're currently testing it for a future update of this article.
The Arc'teryx Beta LT scores at or near the top in almost all metrics we tested and is our favorite overall. Built of a three-layer N40p Gore-Tex with a DWR finish, it has exceptional waterproofness for soggy week-long backpacking trips and also excels as a shell in colder weather. This jacket offers equal or better storm protection than some hard shells in a lighter, more mobile package. The helmet-compatible StormHood is also highly adjustable, and WaterTight Vislon zippers, including at the pockets, bring peace of mind in a downpour. The features are intuitive and user-friendly, and the waterproof coating stands up to heavy use. Although no other option in our lineup matched the Beta LT for both superior weather protection and all-around superb performance, two other Gore-Tex contenders came close and even topped the LT for breathability and comfort: the classic Beta (also from Arc'teryx) and the Foray Super Stretch from Outdoor Research. Notably, all three jackets sit at the top of the pile when it comes to cost, with the Beta LT taking the top prize. But, lead tester Ben Applebaum-Bauch is quick to point out, “If you want to save some cash at the register and top-tier weather resistance is your end game, far less expensive options do exist.” Consider the Marmot Minimalist or the Patagonia Torrentshell 3L, which each sells for nearly half the cost of the Beta LT and performs admirably in a storm, even without all the added comfort and breathability features the three pricier jackets offer.
Shoppers should bear in mind that the Beta LT is a burlier model at 13.3 ounces, so those who run warmer won't be able to “dump” heat as quickly, even with the pit zips. Also, the fabric is a bit stiff and crinkly. Although this doesn't inhibit motion too much, it is noticeable over other jackets that move more quietly and smoothly against the body. Options that breathe and flex more readily than the Beta LT include the OR Foray Super Stretch, the Outdoor Research Foray II, or the Rab Kinetic Alpine 2.0., making them great choices if you know you run warm. Lastly, this superbly designed and feature-rich rain jacket comes with a hefty price tag. Still, if you require a waterproof shell worthy of meeting demanding conditions, our test team unilaterally agreed, “This rain jacket is undoubtedly worth the upgrade for its premium performance.” If you're shopping for an ultra-lightweight model to stuff in your backpack for the occasional light rain, Outdoor Research Helium weighs substantially less than the Beta LT.
The Helly Hansen Loke is a bargain raincoat with above-average performance, retailing for just a quarter of the price of the Arc'teryx Beta LT. Made of 2.5-layer Helly Tech with a PFC-free DWR finish, it offers decent storm protection in average conditions, and the pit zips and loose mesh pockets make for a reasonably breathable fit. It is super lightweight at only 9.5 ounces and packs down small into its own pocket for easy and convenient carrying when the sun is shining. Though its hood and waist toggles are basic, they get the job done, providing enough adjustability to get a solid seal; a combination of elastic and velcro offers the same protection around the wrists. The only smaller option in our lineup, the 6.5-ounce Outdoor Research Helium, will cost you a good 50% more and delivers similarly average scores for storm protection and breathability.
Don't get us wrong; there is a noticeable difference in quality between the Loke and other top-performing jackets. For instance, the zipper is not waterproof - instead, the jacket relies on a velcro front placket/storm flap that sits over the top to keep moisture out, which it does successfully if it's not raining too hard for too long. Its long-term durability is also questionable. While the mesh pockets are breathable, they also strike us as more easily rippable, running the risk of items unknowingly going missing. Still, expert tester Ben Applebaum-Bauch reports, “If you are in the market for a rain layer for less intense climates and want to save a few bucks for other goodies, this is an excellent option to have in your closet.” That said, if price is not an issue, it's hard to top the overall performance of the Arc'teryx Beta LT. Or, for a happy medium between price and high-quality rain protection, the Patagonia Torrentshell 3L is where our team would direct you.
Comfort is not typically a draw in a rain jacket, but the Outdoor Research Foray Super Stretch makes a case that it should be. The two layers of recycled Gore-Tex Paclite are mixed with a stretchy Gore-text back panel to create an exterior shell that is incredibly flexible and breathable yet still holds up well in wet conditions. Both sides of the jacket have full-length, double-zippered TorsoFlo vents that run from the bicep to the hem. In conjunction with the rear elastane panel, this combination allows the Foray Super Stretch to maintain temperature very well. If you're planning on bringing your jacket along for climbing, biking, or spring skiing, keep in mind that it weighs in at a hefty 15 ounces - more than many other top-quality options we tested. But tester Craig D'Innocente is quick to note, “A few extra ounces aside, this jacket not only receives top scores for mobility and airflow, but it also has a hood that easily fits over most helmets, making it an excellent choice for high-output adventures of all kinds.” The only other jacket that came close to matching its activity-ready performance is the Rab Kinetic Alpine 2.0, which weighs just half an ounce less and retails at a similar cost but with only average storm protection in comparison. The Super Stretch, in contrast, features a YKK Aquaguard zipper down the center, a single watertight chest pocket, and two zippered hand pockets (including one with a handy key clip). So, in the event you get absolutely drenched out in a storm, you can have confidence that your phone and other valuables will remain as dry as the rest of your torso.
The OR Foray Super Stretch is super comfy and mobile, but it probably wouldn't be the first one we'd reach for when expecting to travel through torrential downpours. Other models we tested feature better waterproofing. If you want the best of all worlds, you can't go wrong with either of the far pricier Arc'teryx Beta options. Or, the Outdoor Research Microgravity AscentShell and Marmot Minimalist make excellent, well-balanced alternatives and come with much more approachable price tags. That said, our team was happy to report, “The Super Stretch performs exceptionally well in anything shy of extreme stormy conditions - perfect for use as a rain jacket, a windbreaker, a light jacket, or even a warmer-weather ski shell.” However, potential buyers should take note that it isn't very packable. Its heft makes it less than ideal for backpacking. For those counting ounces for long trips, the Mountain Hardwear Stretch Ozonic provides terrific mobility and weighs a few ounces less.
The Rab Kinetic Alpine 2.0 is the most breathable model we've ever tested. No other rain jacket matches its blend of comfort, durability, and freedom of movement while maintaining top-tier airflow, though the Outdoor Research Foray Super Stretch comes mighty close. The primary advantage of this jacket is its 3-layer Proflex recycled polyester knit build and the high level of breathability it offers, regardless of user temperature or external environmental factors. Also, this jacket is notably stretchy and offers excellent articulation and an athletic cut, making it an ideal choice for a wide range of activities.
Unfortunately, the Kinetic Alpine 2.0 just can't match the weather protection of top performers on extended rainy days. So, if you plan on hanging out in a chronically wet camp, we'd steer you toward a Gore-Tex option like the aforementioned OR Foray Super Stretch or either of the Arc'teryx Beta models. That said, this jacket is certainly acceptable for a few hours of wet hiking, snowshoeing, ice climbing, or ski touring. The excellent breathability also means you'll cool down much faster than you would with a more traditional rain jacket. It isn't that the Kinetic doesn't offer solid weather resistance; there are just a handful of burlier models that perform better for hanging out in constant rain. This jacket is well-suited for aerobic activities (including hiking, backpacking, and ski touring), where some added wet protection is needed. For a more affordable alternative with similarly stretchy, responsive traits and impressive water protection, take a look at the Outdoor Research Foray II or the lightweight Mountain Hardwear Stretch Ozonic Jacket.
This review is the result of over 400 field hours of hiking, backpacking, mountaineering, and camping in wet weather. We tested these jackets in the Cascade Mountains, Rocky Mountains of Colorado, temperate rainforests of Western Washington, and the damp and humid Midwest and East Coast. When the precipitation wasn't pouring from the sky, it was pouring from our showers, where we had timed spray tests with each product to figure out their limits in controlled side-by-side tests. Testing in rain or the shower, we paid close attention to each jacket's water resistance, how well the material breathes, limitations of mobility, comfort level, longevity, and measured weight.
We rate rain jackets on five performance metrics:
Water Resistance (30% of overall score weighting)
Breathability (25% weighting)
Comfort and Mobility (20% weighting)
Weight (15% weighting)
Durability (10% weighting)
Why Trust GearLab
This review is headed by Ian Nicholson and Ben Applebaum-Bauch, with an update by Craig D'Innocente. Ian is a professional internationally licensed IFMGA/UIAGM mountain guide who has spent over 2,000 days guiding in the Pacific Northwest, Alaska, the Andes, the European Alps, and beyond. Ian estimates he has worn a rain jacket over 800 days over the last two decades because he guides and lives in the rainy and wet Pacific Northwest.
Ben spent over a decade in blustery northern New England. He has guided backpacking, cycling, and canoeing trips all over the region, as well as maritime Canada. He is also an avid thru-hiker, completing treks of some of America's most iconic long trails, including the Continental Divide Trail, Pacific Crest Trail, Long Tail, Colorado Trail, and several others. Having spent more than 500 nights in the backcountry, he knows the value of a reliable waterproof rain jacket. Craig is a seasonal worker in natural resource management, working in the summer with the US Forest Service and in the winter as a ski repair technician. Spending most of his time outdoors, he understands the value of a solid piece of hiking gear, especially one that lasts multiple seasons and serves in a variety of conditions.
Analysis and Test Results
Our selection involves a wide range of products, from budget-friendly to the most stormworthy. We also select models that excel at specific applications or have particular attributes — for example, the lightest and most packable or the stretchiest, most mobile jackets. Each is evaluated across several important metrics to determine which are the best overall and which are best for specific applications or types of users.
What's the Best Value?
The answer to “ Is this piece of gear worth the money?” is rarely crystal clear, as so much depends on the user. However, to quantify value, we compare a jacket's overall score to its retail price. Items with high price tags also ideally perform exceptionally, and of course, we are always on the lookout for products with disproportionately high scores relative to their price.
The Arc'teryx Beta LT is both one of the most expensive jackets in the category and also the highest scorer, making it a good value. The Patagonia Torrentshell 3L and Helly Hansen Loke are two more high-value options on the market today. Both offer great functionality and will keep you dry in most rainy conditions. Neither are as high quality as our top-scoring models, but they are roughly half the price of higher-end products without a massive drop in performance.
Water Resistance
A rain jacket's primary job is to keep you dry in wet weather. With that in mind, We extensively tested each contender in the rain, wind, sleet, and snow, as well as in controlled environments to assess zippers and other openings (e.g., cuffs) to see how long they take to wet out.
All of the products that we tested meet the technical requirements for waterproofing. However, this doesn't mean they all perform at the same level. These jackets feature a waterproof fabric that is seam-taped to create a complete seal. What differentiates the performance of each is how well and how long they keep out water. This is the result of several factors but generally refers to specifics of design aspects such as the number of layers of fabric, type of membrane, hood style, cuffs, pockets, front/primary zipper, pit zips, and other vents.
As mentioned above, a jacket's ability to keep its wearer dry has a lot to do with the make-up and construction of its waterproof insert (more frequently called a membrane) and its Durable Water Repellent or DWR treatment. This treatment is factory-applied to the fabric's exterior and makes the water bead when it lands on the surface of the jacket, allowing it to roll off. Even though both nylon and polyester are hydrophobic, if they aren't treated with a DWR, they will become covered with a thin but continuous film of water and will frequently appear wet — this is referred to as “wetting out.” Therefore, we consider the longevity of the DWR coating and its ability to resist wetting out after extended periods.
The Arc'teryx Beta LT, Marmot Minimalist, and Patagonia Torrentshell 3L offer the group's most robust weather resistance. These models all do an excellent job of sealing out precipitation in all forms and have well-designed wrist cuffs and hoods that cinch down to keep the elements out. In addition, the original Arc'teryx Beta and Outdoor Research Microgravity AscentShell offer good DWR and resist wetting out — both over time and during a single day out in heavy weather.
The Black Diamond Stormline Stretch and Outdoor Research Foray II are a duo of contenders that offer reliable protection, but we did notice some wetting out under extraordinary conditions. Similarly, the Outdoor Research Foray Super Stretch offers a comparable statline to the Foray II with increased comfort.
Breathability
Our water resistance metric compares how well each jacket keeps its wearer dry from the outside. In contrast, our breathability and ventilation metric quantifies how well each model keeps its wearer dry from the inside by allowing sweat, moisture, and heat to escape. Though some models may not always feel like it, all of these multi-layered fabrics are breathable, allowing water vapor to wick through the material from the inside to the outside, where it can evaporate.
We also look at how effectively each model dumps heat and moisture and how effectively vents like pit zips or meshed pockets work, even if you're in a downpour. By prioritizing real-world venting functionality, our review team noticed some of the more significant differences between models and ventilation designs.
What's the deal with DWR?
DWR (durable water repellant) is a coating applied to the outside of many rain jackets. Despite what its name implies, DWR is not meant to keep you dry (that's the job of the main waterproof membrane (usually Gore-Tex or some other proprietary fabric). Though DWR is responsible for the really satisfying beading that you see on the outside of a jacket, its primary role is to keep water off of the fabric surface so that it can remain breathable from the inside and effectively release sweat while keeping out precipitation.
Another feature to consider is a jacket with air-permeable fabric. Air-permeable is a new buzzword (and a technical term) in the outdoor industry, and it refers to a material that allows air to pass through at all times. This is in contrast to most waterproof-breathable garments, which rely on a heat and/or pressure differential to force moisture through the material. Air-permeable jackets are not necessarily more breathable than Gore-Tex — they just have a static level of breathability, whereas Gore-Tex and eVent both have fluctuating levels of breathability, depending on the aforementioned pressure differential between the inside and outside of the jacket. Air-permeable jackets, on a micro-level, aren't technically windproof. With that said, they feel windproof, though they are cooler than most folks are used to when you stop moving. We feature a couple of air-permeable models in our review, namely the Rab Kinetic Alpine 2.0 and Outdoor Research Microgravity AscentShell.
Effective venting options like pit zips, side zips, core vents, or other zippered ventilation designs can prove incredibly useful for users who run warmer or for variable weather. Besides a jacket's front primary zipper, pit zips are the next most effective ventilation tool for dumping heat and moving moisture, with the advantage of not letting much moisture back in. Pit zips generally allow more moisture to escape than “core vents,” a fairly generic term for mesh-lined pockets that you can leave open to let a little moisture out.
The top performer for venting is the Outdoor Research Foray Super Stretch. This jacket utilizes an updated Gore-Tex called “Paclite 2.0”, which, in conjunction with a rear mesh panel, offers great ventilation. When needed, the side vents can open to the entire length of the torso, far outclassing most other vents in the lineup.
The most breathable air-permeable model is the Rab Kinetic Alpine 2.0, which uses Proflex. Though it can wet out under high pressure (as it did in our shower test), it also kept us cooler longer than other traditional membrane models. The Outdoor Research MicroGravity is an air-permeable model that uses AscentShell technology to achieve a similar effect. Other breathable options are the Marmot Minimalist, Arc'teryx Beta LT (with traditional pit zips), and Helly Hansen Loke.
Comfort and Mobility
If a jacket isn't comfortable, you probably won't wear it, no matter what other features it has. In the comfort portion of this metric, we consider the small features that make a given product more enjoyable to wear and the feel of the interior material. We note small features like a microsuede patch at the chin or soft fabric where the hood rests on the brow, which are design inclusions that create a nicer wearing experience. We also consider the ease of use of each feature, comparing cinch cords for the hood and how easy to access and adjust they are. Some jackets add larger fabric pull tabs to the zipper — rather than small pieces of cord — to make them easier to adjust with cold fingers or gloves.
For mobility, we compare how each model moves in use and how restrictive it is, depending on the activity. We tested each model's overall freedom of movement. We also compare how well a model's hood maintains peripheral vision and how it moves with the head. We look at each jacket with our arms stretched out straight forward, up, and to the sides and measure how much each one pulls back from our wrists and if the hem of the jacket pulls up around our waists.
The models with the best range of motion are the ultra-stretchy Rab Kinetic Alpine 2.0 and the Outdoor Research Foray Super Stretch. Though the number of stretch models continues to grow, the Kinetic Alpine is the stretchiest we have ever seen and offers nearly restriction-free movement. The only thing worth noting is that it has a slimmer fit aimed at more technical pursuits. Those who want to add more than one thin layer underneath should consider sizing up. With a larger fit and huge vents, the Super Stretch is a great option for a wide variety of activities and layering configurations.
Next in line for the best freedom of movement and mobility are the Outdoor Research Foray II and Black Diamond Stormline Stretch. The former has a soft, thinner, more supple feel and moves well with the wearer, while the latter is made with high-stretch fabric that is super comfortable. The Outdoor Research Microgravity AscentShell and Arc'teryx Beta LT are both a little stiff but make up for it with roomy but well-fitting fabric. The Outdoor Research Helium and Helly Hansen Loke are much thinner than the average jacket, offering a supple, lightweight shell that doesn't restrict movement.
A good range of motion makes a huge difference in a rain jacket
Features
If you're wearing your jacket around town, having room in the pockets for gloves and a warm hat or a phone and keys can be nice. Interior pockets can offer additional peace of mind, and each jacket has a slightly different take on hoods, toggles, zippers, and cinch cords.
Hood Design
A good hood will keep your head dry without chafing the chin or limiting peripheral vision, and the effectiveness from jacket to jacket can vary wildly. Our favorite hoods are on the Arc'teryx Beta LT, Arc'teryx Beta, and Rab Kinetic Alpine 2.0, with the OR Super Stretch, OR Foray II, and Patagonia Torrentshell 3L not too far behind.
The hood on the Rab Kinetic Alpine 2.0 is of special note because it features an internal elastic band designed to ride directly on the forehead. It turned out to be comfortable and effective, maintaining top-notch peripheral vision.
From beanies to baseball caps, each one of these jackets featured hoods that cinched down over a range of headwear, maximizing the hood's ability to turn with its user's head — instead of turning into it — though our hands-down favorite hood is on the Arc'teryx Beta LT, which has a toggle at the back of the head that is easy to manipulate and great coverage without limiting visibility.
Pockets
It is tough to understate the utility of pockets, as everyone uses them at least sometimes. They are unquestionably helpful in keeping track of small items, keeping certain things close at hand, and are a convenient place to warm your hands. Not all pockets are created equal, though, and their size and location can greatly impact their overall usefulness. For example, lower handwarmer pockets are great for around town but can be a nuisance and rendered nearly or entirely unusable while wearing a harness or heavy pack.
Weight
Light is right for many, and weight is a crucial consideration for almost any gear. All of our testers value lightweight clothing and equipment, but not at the expense of basic functionality. If you're thru-hiking, climbing technical terrain, or riding your bicycle from coast to coast, weight is likely one of your primary concerns. For burlier adventures, soggy backpacking trips, expedition-type mountaineering trips, or even daily use, you'll want to consider durability and stormworthiness just as much as weight.
Additionally, the ability of a jacket to pack up compactly is beneficial when out and about. In reality, most folks carry rather than wear their rain shell nine times out of ten, so the smaller it packs, the more room you have for other items.
Every contender in our review weighs a pound or (much) less - the average weight in our review is closer to 12 ounces, with some models dipping down under 7 ounces.
The Outdoor Research Helium weighs in at a featherweight of 6.5 ounces. It can be stuffed into a built-in reversible chest pocket with a clip-in loop, a nice feature for climbers carrying it on their harness. It could also be useful for anyone wanting to clip their jacket to anything else, like the outside of a backpack.
The final sub-10-ounce contender is the Helly Hansen Loke, one of the most affordable full-featured jackets in the category and weighs just 9.5 ounces.
Approximately half of these models stuff into one of their own pockets, and others can be rolled and stuffed into their hoods. Our rating for packed size considers the compressed size and the ease of using the integrated stuff pocket. Some compress relatively small but require wrestling to get them stowed; others fit comfortably into their stuff pocket.
Durability
A rain jacket must stand up in the long run. Materials technology trends toward thinner, lighter fabrics. However, this sometimes requires a tradeoff between durability and resistance to abrasions, punctures, and overall longevity. This is particularly true among the lightest models, which are far less durable than products weighing three to five ounces more.
Nearly all rain jackets' exterior material (also known as the face fabric) is either nylon or polyester. Though we like to talk about other aspects of rainshell jacket construction, this external material plays a huge role in overall durability. For the most part, the lighter the face fabric is, the easier it tears or the faster it is to abrade. Most of the jackets we tested use 30-50 Denier face fabric, with the 50D shells being notably more robust than the 20-30D. All but the Columbia Watertight II feature ripstop material. A ripstop weave doubles up on the thread at intervals, providing a grid of strong fibers to stop tears from growing once a tear has occurred. This is a significant advantage and why many outdoor products utilize it.
The top performer in the metric is the Arx'teryx Beta LT. It has burly face fabric, and its triple-layer tech makes for a thick, slick shell that easily resists snags. It has metal zippers and even high-quality plastic toggles in the hood and waist. The Marmot Minimalist and Patagonia Torrentshell 3L have comparable performance. Both use 50D polyester ripstop face fabric, the former with a much longer-lasting Gore-Tex Paclite membrane and the latter with proprietary H2No Performance Standard fabric.
We also like the triple-layer Outdoor Research Microgravity AscentShell, the stretchy Rab Kinetic Alpine 2.0, and the The North Face Dryzzle Futurelight. For 2-layer technology, the Outdoor Research Foray II and Outdoor Research Foray Super Stretch are our top picks for their excellent face fabric. Notably, the Super Stretch does not compromise durability in order to offer great mobility.
Conclusion
Determining which rain jacket is right for you might seem complicated. Though staying dry is the goal, aspects like breathability, hood design, and level of mobility can make a big difference in daily use. Our metrics are meant to help you narrow down your options and decide based on the design characteristics that are important to you. Stay dry out there!
—
Ben Applebaum-Bauch, Ian Nicholson and Craig D'Innocente