The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of outdoor gear

The Best Fleece Jackets of 2019

The Campshire is perfect for hanging around the campsite relaxing or doing a few (but not too many) chores.
By Matt Bento ⋅ Senior Review Editor
Thursday May 16, 2019
  • Share this article:

Out on the hunt for a new fleece jacket for this summer? After researching over 65 different models, we selected 18 of the top fleece for a rigorous side-by-side comparison. We wore these fleece on backcountry ski missions, multi-pitch climbing adventures, on dates and out to concerts and film fests. Some fleece were so comfortable we even wore them to sleep. We tested a variety of weights and styles to find out which ones are right for layering and which make a weather resistant outer layer. If you're heading to hike up Mt. Whitney or are just looking to stay warm at night this spring and summer, keep reading below to see which were our overall favorites for a variety of uses.

Related: The Best Women's Fleece Jackets of 2019


Compare Top Products

Displaying 1 - 5 of 18
≪ Previous | View All | Next ≫
 
Awards Editors' Choice Award Top Pick Award  Best Buy Award  
Price $159.00 at REI
Compare at 3 sellers
$113.40 at Amazon
Compare at 3 sellers
$126.75 at Backcountry
Compare at 3 sellers
$92.99 at MooseJaw
Compare at 2 sellers
$149.19 at REI
Compare at 4 sellers
Overall Score Sort Icon
100
0
81
100
0
78
100
0
77
100
0
76
100
0
74
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros Perfect fit for most active uses, ideal weight for many conditions, great hood designUltra breathable, very comfortableBreathable, awesome balaclava feature, great fitGreat warmth for the weight, excellent fit, good hood, affordableGreat hood design, handwarmer pockets, water resistant
Cons Not as stylish as some other fleeces for around town, not as warm for its weight as some high-loft modelsNot very warmExpensiveZipper sticks, not as breathable as the R1Not as warm as other jackets, not as breathable as jackets with gridded fleece
Bottom Line A perfect layering piece that regulates body temperature so well you'll leave it on from summit to sleeping bag and everywhere in between.This jacket is your best choice for high exertion activities in the winter.Arc'teryx's take on the half zip has some solid advantages over the R1.This jacket performs almost as well as our Editors' Choice and is more affordable.The Fortrez is a sleek fleece that layers well and has a unique and useful balaclava feature.
Rating Categories Patagonia R1 Hoody Deviator Hoody Konseal Hoody Marmot Preon Hoody Fortrez Hoody
Warmth (20%)
10
0
7
10
0
6
10
0
5
10
0
7
10
0
6
Comfort (20%)
10
0
8
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
7
10
0
9
Breathability (20%)
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
6
Layering Ability (15%)
10
0
10
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
8
Style (5%)
10
0
4
10
0
3
10
0
7
10
0
5
10
0
8
Weather Resistance (10%)
10
0
7
10
0
5
10
0
8
10
0
7
10
0
8
Weight (10%)
10
0
9
10
0
10
10
0
8
10
0
9
10
0
8
Specs Patagonia R1 Hoody Deviator Hoody Konseal Hoody Marmot Preon Hoody Fortrez Hoody
Type Lightweight Lightweight Lightweight Midweight Midweight
Weight (oz.) 10.4 oz 9.65 oz 12.4 oz 13.95 oz 13.2 oz

Best Overall


Patagonia R1 Hoody


81
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Warmth - 20% 7
  • Comfort - 20% 8
  • Breathability - 20% 9
  • Layering Ability - 15% 10
  • Style - 5% 4
  • Weather resistance - 10% 7
  • Weight - 10% 9
Weight: 10.4 oz | Type: Lightweight
Slim fit for easy layering
Balaclava-style hood
Thin, stretchy underarm panels increase breathability
Extra long hem fits well under waist belt strap or a climbing harness
Very little weather resistance
Too techy for around town

The classic Patagonia R1 Hoody has been part of the uniform for mountain guides, search and rescue personnel and outdoor enthusiast season after season. Why? Because it has everything we need from a mid layer and nothing we don't. One chest pocket, a balaclava style ninja hood, and thumb loops make this jacket all function and no fluff. The Polartec Power Grid fleece consists of hundreds of tiny gridded squares that keep you warm while the channels in between vent hot air and moisture. Unzip the 2/3rds length zipper when you're moving, zip up the balaclava and stay toasty when you're not, it's that easy.

The most recent iteration of the R1 has a few changes that will delight the fast and light folks out there and possibly disappoint the more casual user. The hem is now longer, tighter, and stretchier, which keeps it from riding up under a hip belt or climbing harness. Though super functional and easier to layer under a ski bib, it looks pretty silly over a pair of jeans. You may even want to consider sizing up from the old R1. A few testers who liked to wear their old R1 24/7 and 365 feel the newest R1 is too tight and restrictive, preferring the Arc'teryx Konseal for its more relaxed fit. Another, less divisive improvement, are the stretchy underarm panels that increase this fleece's breathability, keeping the R1 on the top of the heap when it comes to active insulation.

Read review: Patagonia R1 Hoody

Best Bang for the Buck


Marmot Preon Hoody


Best Buy Award

$92.99
(26% off)
at MooseJaw
See It

76
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Warmth - 20% 7
  • Comfort - 20% 7
  • Breathability - 20% 8
  • Layering Ability - 15% 9
  • Style - 5% 5
  • Weather resistance - 10% 7
  • Weight - 10% 9
Weight: 13.95 oz | Type: Midweight
Comfortable hood
Breathable gridded fleece
Inexpensive
Sticky zipper

The Marmot Preon has a similar look and feel to our Editors' Choice Award winner; while it can't match the performance of the venerable R1, it's less expensive and has a few distinguishing features that may cause you to prefer it over the R1. Unlike the R1 hoody, the Preon has a full-length zipper and two zippered hand warmer pockets. The hood offers an exceptional fit, and it's not balaclava-style, so it doesn't cover your mouth when fully zipped.

This jacket doesn't breathe as well as our Editors' Choice or have as good of a warmth-to-weight ratio as lighter contenders like the Outdoor Research Deviator. However, for the money, this is an excellent choice for climbers, skiers, hikers, or anyone on a budget who needs a dedicated mid layer. Made from a whopping 94% recycled polyester, the Preon will have you feeling good inside and out.

Read review: Marmot Preon Hoody

Top Pick For Breathability


Outdoor Research Deviator Hoody


Top Pick Award

$113.40
(40% off)
at Amazon
See It

78
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Warmth - 20% 6
  • Comfort - 20% 9
  • Breathability - 20% 9
  • Layering Ability - 15% 9
  • Style - 5% 3
  • Weather resistance - 10% 5
  • Weight - 10% 10
Weight: 9.65 oz | Type: Lightweight
Insulated torso
Super lightweight
Arms and back are thin, breathable fleece
Tight fitting hood
No zippers on the handwarmer pockets

The Outdoor Research Deviator Hoody slides into the fleece category but is essentially an insulated vest with thin Polartec power grid fleece on the back, sides, and arms. The combination works wonderfully, keeping our core warm with Polartec Alpha Insulation while letting our back and armpits blasts all the heat away. This can feel a little on the chilly side if you're not moving, but while skinning or hiking up a steep hill with a backpack on, our testers were pleased with their not-too-hot not-too-cold temperatures. This jacket is comfortable enough to sleep in, and we feel it could be the ultimate backcountry mid layer.

As far as pure warmth goes, you'll need to have a warmer jacket on deck to put over the Deviator. Its sized snug for thermal efficiency and for layering, so you don't want to wear anything thicker than a t-shirt or light base layer underneath. This jacket wasn't a tester favorite for around town due to its sleek techy look.

Read review: Outdoor Research Deviator Hoody

Top Pick Weather Resistance


Patagonia R1 TechFace Hoody


Patagonia R1 TechFace Hoody
Top Pick Award

$118.00
(30% off)
at Patagonia
See It

72
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Warmth - 20% 6
  • Comfort - 20% 7
  • Breathability - 20% 8
  • Layering Ability - 15% 5
  • Style - 5% 8
  • Weather resistance - 10% 10
  • Weight - 10% 8
Weight: 13.8 oz | Type: Lightweight
More durable than the Original R1
Water-repelling DWR coating
Generous stretch for mobility
Fits over more insulating layers
Not as good an insulator as the original R1

The Patagonia R1 Techface Hoody is a very different jacket than our Editors' Choice award winner. While not as warm as the original R1, the Techface is more breathable and more weather resistant. We could stand in the rain with this fleece jacket and stay dry thanks to the DWR finish and the brimmed hood. If you're looking for a dedicated cozy mid layer, do not apply, but a for a lightly insulated wind layer for climbing on breezy days, the Techface nails it.

The hood is sized to fit over a helmet, and the whole jacket accommodates warmer mid layers easily underneath. We think this fleece looks pretty slick, and the black model we tested looked great with everything we paired it with. The Techface is right at home everywhere from windy summits to the bar.

Read review: Patagonia R1 Techface Hoody

Best for Windy Locales


Arc'teryx Fortrez Hoody



$149.19
(25% off)
at REI
See It

74
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Warmth - 20% 6
  • Comfort - 20% 9
  • Breathability - 20% 6
  • Layering Ability - 15% 8
  • Style - 5% 8
  • Weather resistance - 10% 8
  • Weight - 10% 8
Weight: 13.2 oz | Type: Midweight
Cool hood design w/integrated balaclava
Handwarmer pockets
Wind and water resistant
Not as warm as higher-lofted models
Less breathable than models with gridded fleece
Expensive

The Arc'teryx Fortrez Hoody attempts to be a two-in-one option for windy or drizzly weather where you're still wearing your fleece as an outer layer. Made with Polartec Power Stretch with Hardface Technology, it does a great job of shedding light drizzle while also cutting down on the wind. This is particularly noticeable compared to the gridded fleeces like the R1 that let the wind rip right through you. The coolest feature is its balaclava though; it's attached to the hood and can be worn across your face, as a neckwarmer, or tucked behind your head if you don't care for it at certain times.

The "hardface" on the exterior does keep a little more of your moisture in, making it less breathable than a gridded option. The Fortrez is lightweight, but not that warm overall - it's a layer for moving in and not keeping you warm at camp at night. But if you're ice climbing on a "drippy" day with a cool breeze blowing? The Fortrez Hoody will keep you warm and dry!

Read review: Arc'teryx Fortrez Hoody

Top Pick for Comfort


The North Face Campshire Hoodie


Top Pick Award

$112.86
(24% off)
at Amazon
See It

69
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Warmth - 20% 9
  • Comfort - 20% 10
  • Breathability - 20% 4
  • Layering Ability - 15% 5
  • Style - 5% 10
  • Weather resistance - 10% 6
  • Weight - 10% 4
Weight: 22 oz | Type: Heavyweight
Like wearing a blanket
Warm, thick hood
Long fleece fibers collect dirt and sticks
Too heavy for backcountry trips

The North Face Campshire Hoodie became an instant tester favorite this season thanks to its supreme blanket-like comfort and high pile fleece that promotes rest and relaxation. For hanging out in camp or cooking around the campfire, this hoody can't be beaten. A huge kangaroo pouch with a velcro closure secures all sorts of camp amenities; gloves, headlamps, lighters, and snacks all disappear into the huge front pocket. For your cold hands, there's a big hand warmer pocket behind the kangaroo pouch. Top it all off with a huge noggin encompassing hood, and you're ready for late nights at the fire with your friends.

The downside of all this luxury? The Campshire is heavy and nowhere near as packable as lightweight options like the R1 ore the Outdoor Research Deviator. For long expeditions into the backcountry, the Campshire needs to stay at home, but it will be there for you when you come in from the cold.

Read review: The North Face Campshire Hoodie



Why You Should Trust Us


This review is crafted by OutdoorGearLab Senior Review Editor Matt Bento. A member of Yosemite Search and Rescue since 2016, Matt previously spent years on the road as a full-time climber. Still climbing avidly, Matt now divides his time between Tuolumne Meadows and Bishop in the Sierra Nevada of California. Whether making camp on the road, warming up at a belay, or covering ground off-trail, fleeces are an important and versatile component of Matt's kit in many situations, and his outdoor experience has given him a critical and appreciative eye for their finer points.

Searching for the best fleece started with ample time researching the market, to see which products were worth ordering for field testing. We looked at over 65 different models, from various manufacturers, before carefully selecting the 18 that we discuss here. These, we came to understand, are the most exceptional in their categories. Testing consisted of both field use during a winter in the Eastern Sierra, and controlled lab tests. Seven pre-determined performance areas which we consider essential in a fleece jacket's function guided our tests. The test method chosen was that which best served the performance characteristic of interest - for example, the warmth was primarily tested in real conditions outside, while water resistance was evaluated with a spray bottle used on the fleeces side-by-side.

Related: How We Tested Fleece Jackets

This fleece definitely puts function over style.
The close-fitting  scuba-style hood keeps your ears and neck warm and fits under a helmet.

Analysis and Test Results


There are many different outdoor activities where a fleece jacket comes in handy: hiking, climbing, skiing, snowshoeing and running, not to mention just lounging around the house or camp, or running errands around town. But the fleece jacket you wear on a winter run is not the same layer that's going to keep you warm around the campfire. We've broken the different categories down below to help you better understand what different types are out there and what their best uses are. We rated each fleece on its warmth, comfort, breathability, layering ability, weather resistance, weight, and style, all of which we discuss in detail in the remainder of this article and in each individual review.

Staying warm and comfortable is the name of the game when it comes to shopping for a fleece jacket. But, you'll also want to consider how breathable the layer is and if it offers any wind or water protection, depending on the environment you plan to use it in. And if you're planning a "fast and light" mission or a long thru-hike, then the weight is also an important factor. So, before you make a random purchase based on whatever color or design catches your eye, you should first carefully consider why you are buying a fleece jacket, what activities you'll most likely use it for, and what type of weather conditions you'll be using it in. If this seems like a lot of thought to put into a simple layer, you should know that many of today's options are technical masterpieces whose prices can reach well into the triple digits — not the kind of money we want to shell out lightly or without significant thought.

Related: Buying Advice for Fleece Jackets

With so many contenders  the competition is fierce! Read on to find out which jacket came out on top.
With so many contenders, the competition is fierce! Read on to find out which jacket came out on top.

Value


Purchasing a fleece jacket often involves a series of tradeoffs: if you want something super warm, it probably won't be that breathable, and if you want some additional weather resistance to it, like a hard facing material on the shoulders, that'll make it heavier. While a bigger price tag doesn't always correlate to better performance, the more expensive models typically have newer materials in them that are lighter and more breathable while still providing warmth. Often (but not always) pricier models have a slimmer fit, articulated for better range of motion and easier layering.

Our Editors' Choice winner, Patagonia R1, is actually one of the less expensive options, while also managing to be the best performing. Little has changed about the R1 over the last couple of years, but it continues to be a tester favorite, not because of new technologies, but because of solid, thoughtful design. The length of the hem, the snugness of the hood, even the position of the thumb loops, are all little details that seem to work for most people. The Marmot Preon is our Best Buy winner; it had a good overall score and is nearly half the price of the jackets from Arc'teryx and Patagonia.


Warmth


Warmth is one of the key things to consider when buying a fleece jacket. The purpose of this layer is to help trap and retain our body heat on cold days, and the warmth rating that we've given each model counts as 25 percent of their overall score. The warmth is mainly determined by the thickness of the material (thicker is usually warmer), but many other features can add or detract from it. Elastic cuffs, drawstring hems, and tighter weaves that help block the wind all add up to additional warmth points. Keep in mind that if you want to use your fleece as part of a layering system, then a jacket can be too warm, so warmth may not be your top priority.


The warmest model that we tested was The North Face Denali 2. This is a heavyweight layer, and its 333 g/m² material did a great job of trapping and retaining our body heat. The model that we tested did not have a hood, but in the Denali's case did not make much of a difference. If you need a warm and toasty outer jacket and prefer fleece to a synthetic or down jacket, then this is the one for you. However, it was also the heaviest and bulkiest model we tested and did not perform well during periods of active use.

The Campshire hoody is great for tooling around camp but too heavy to carry into the backcountry.
The Campshire hoody is great for tooling around camp but too heavy to carry into the backcountry.

The North Face Campshire Hoodie uses a high lofted fleece, keeping out testers comfy and almost as warm as theDenali, but feels softer and less boxy. While it is an excellent fleece for hanging out in, it's too heavy and doesn't layer well enough to earn a spot on our packs during backing packing trips or ski tours.

The Hatcher is warm and weather resistant thanks to its wool/polyester blend but didn't breathe as well as lighter weight models.
The Hatcher is warm and weather resistant thanks to its wool/polyester blend but didn't breathe as well as lighter weight models.

The Outdoor Research Deviator Hoody, The North Face Proprius Summit L2 Proprius Hoody, and the Arc'teryx Adahy are all very lightweight and breathable, but not our favorite insulators. The super light Outdoor Research Deviator Hoody refuses to be categorized, combining a Polartec Alpha Insulated chest and shoulder with a fleece back and arms. The result is a super light "fleece" that can keep your core warm while still being very breathable.

The face mask built into the Arc'teryx Fortrez Hoody can be used as a neck gaiter or tucked away behind your head.
The face mask built into the Arc'teryx Fortrez Hoody can be used as a neck gaiter or tucked away behind your head.

In addition to hoods, a snug hem can make a difference for warmth. The Arc'teryx Fortrez Hoody and the lighter weight Konseal had a unique hood with a built-in neck gaiter that helped keep us warm up top, but the loose bottom hem with no cinch cord let cold winds rip right up the jacket. Elastic cuffs, like those on the The North Face Summit L2 Proprius Hoody, also help trap in the warmth. Finally, hand warmer pockets are another addition that helps keep you warm when your hands start to freeze over. Pockets will help keep your hands warm at a moment's notice, and every model that we tested except the Patagonia R1 Hoody and the Black Diamond CoEfficient Hoody had them. The Marmot Preon is similar to the R1 and features two zippered handwarmer pockets while the Outdoor Research Deviator Hoody has cozy hand warmer pockets without zippers. The lack of zippers keeps the jacket light and comfy, but make sure you store anything significant in the zippered chest pocket.

Hand warmer pockets keep your hands toasty and secure your phone  keys  and energy bars.
Hand warmer pockets keep your hands toasty and secure your phone, keys, and energy bars.

Comfort


Fleece is, by nature a soft material, and it typically makes for very comfortable jackets. While all of the different models that we tested were made with materials that were quite comfortable, some stood out from the rest. The soft and warm The North Face Campshire Hoodie was our favorite fleece in terms of comfort. The soft textured micro-fleece lining on the Arc'teryx Kyanite Hoody also had a cozy and soft texture, particularly compared to The North Face Denali which is made with a scratchier and harsher fabric that was quite noticeable and much less cozy. However, comfort is not only differentiated by texture, but also by the fit.


The Campshire features a seemingly bottomless kangaroo pouch  perfect for gloves  headlamps  or snacks.
The Campshire features a seemingly bottomless kangaroo pouch, perfect for gloves, headlamps, or snacks.

Regarding fit, The Arc'teryx Covert Hoody was a little short for the torsos of most of our testers. A shortcut is problematic because shorter jackets tend to ride up over a climbing harness or a waist belt on a backpack. ThePatagonia R1 Hoody has an ideal cut, with long enough lengths in the arms and torso. The Marmot Preon and the Patagonia Performance Better Sweater scored high in this metric. Why? The Preon because it is soft and tailored, but not constricting fit, and the Better Sweater because of its stretchy side panels that allow for increased ease of movement and breathability. The Arc'teryx Fortrez Hoody scored well in the comfort metric but lost a point for being a little tight across the shoulders. The Outdoor Research Deviator has a great fit, stretchy enough for comfort, but still form fitting for layering. We also really like the Arc'teryx Konseal; the fleece was soft, and the basic and slim-fit design suited us well. The Arc'teryx Adahy, one of the lightest fleece we reviewed, is also the stretchiest, making it an excellent fit for many shapes.

Figuring out the right fleece for your body type is the key to comfort, and we've described the fit of each fleece in the comfort section of each individual reviews. A well fitting jacket will still provide full coverage when you lift your arms above your head. The sleeves should stay in place, but we appreciated some stretch that allowed us to pull the sleeves up.

The soft and comfy  the Arc'teryx Covert Hoody has a short hem and rode up  exposing our backsides to the breeze.
The soft and comfy, the Arc'teryx Covert Hoody has a short hem and rode up, exposing our backsides to the breeze.

Breathability


Whether you are using your fleece jacket as an outer layer or a mid-layer, its ability to breathe or vent your perspiration to the outside is an important aspect to consider. Rigorous activity produces heat within the body, which then sweats to cool itself, but that sweat has to go somewhere, or else you end up a soaking mess. In general, fleece material is superior to other options, like cotton, in that the material is hydrophobic and won't absorb your sweat. But the thickness of the fleece and the tightness of the weave will affect how much air and moisture can move in and out of it.


The most breathable models that we tested were the Outdoor Research Deviator and the Patagonia R1 Hoody. The Coefficient Hoody combines an ultra-thin fleece with a Polartec insulated torso; this makes it extremely breathable, while still locking in a little warmth around the core. The Patagonia R-Series uses Polartec's Power Grid fabric, which is made of hundreds of cubes of fleece separated by thin channels. The cubes keep you warm, while the channels offer a virtually non-existent barrier for your moisture to vent through.

The sun is out  but it still isn't warm enough for our tester to shed this breathable jacket (the Black Diamond Coefficient) on a cool sunny day in the Owens River Gorge. The Coefficient was the only jacket to score a perfect 10 out of 10 for breathability.
The sun is out, but it still isn't warm enough for our tester to shed this breathable jacket (the Black Diamond Coefficient) on a cool sunny day in the Owens River Gorge. The Coefficient was the only jacket to score a perfect 10 out of 10 for breathability.

This technology is used in both their R1 and R1 Techface models. The R1 is a light enough layer to wear for just about any aerobic activity in cold weather, from running and hiking to climbing and ski touring. Climbers are notorious for climbing without a shirt, even in the most frigid conditions, as many can't stand to feel the slightest bit hot or sweaty when trying to "send." Hikers may also experience similar situations when on the trail for longer days. But we kept the R1 on even on mild days, and its breathability was so effective that we never felt uncomfortable or sweaty. While the Proprius Hoody and Adahy are slightly more breathable due to being so thin, the R1 is a warmer, more comfortable fleece. The new Patagonia R1 Techface Hoody is thinner and even more breathable than the original R1, but it doesn't make for a cozy mid-layer like our old favorite.


The Preon is also breathable, but a heavier weight than the R1 and not as suited to aerobic activities. The same goes for the "hard-faced" Fortrez Hoody and the Techface R1. While these jackets are made of a tighter, more weather resistant weave, they are so thin that they still vent well.

The Adahy is incredibly stretchy and didn't restrict our range of motion. It also breathes well but isn't very warm.
The Adahy is incredibly stretchy and didn't restrict our range of motion. It also breathes well but isn't very warm.

In addition to the weave and thickness of the material, some other features can help a jacket breathe better. The stylish Patagonia Performance Better Sweater Hoody has thin panels on the sides and under the arms to mitigate to the tight fleece weave on the rest of the jacket. Other jackets have pockets lined with a thin mesh, as opposed to fleece, which can be unzipped for added airflow.

Thin panels under the arms increase the Better Sweater's breathability.
Thin panels under the arms increase the Better Sweater's breathability.

Layering Ability


A fleece is an essential part of a layering system, usually residing between a light base layer and a less breathable insulated jacket or down puffy. You can learn more about layering systems with our Introduction to Layered Clothing Systems article.


We tested each model with a variety of other jackets and base layers and rated them on how easily they layered and their level of comfort. Thinner models, like the Patagonia R1 Hoody, the Outdoor Research Deviator Hoody, and the Arc'teryx Konseal, layered easily under everything we tried them with. The thumb holes were also a bonus, as we didn't have to worry about the sleeves riding up when putting on another layer.

Layering up with the Base 4.0 from Under Armour. The mid-layer pictured here is the Patagonia R1 Hoody  which won the Top Pick in our review of fleece jackets.
Layering up with the Base 4.0 from Under Armour. The mid-layer pictured here is the Patagonia R1 Hoody, which won the Top Pick in our review of fleece jackets.

However, you can't wear more than a thin baselayer underneath these slim fitting jackets. The North Face Summit L2 Proprius Hoodie, Arc'teryx Adahy, and the Arc'teryx Fortrez Hoody were all easy to layer as well.

Most of our testers feel that the Hatcher has a baggy fit  better for layering under instead of over.
Most of our testers feel that the Hatcher has a baggy fit, better for layering under instead of over.

The models that didn't fare so well were the heavier and bulkier ones, like the Patagonia Synchilla Snap T, The North Face Campshire Hoodie, the Mountain Hardwear Norse Peak, and The North Face Denali 2. They have a boxier cut, long arms that bunch around the cuffs, and are made with a thicker material. While we had no trouble putting them on over other fleece, they were not so comfortable to wear under another jacket like a shell or winter puffy jacket. The Patagonia R1 Techface Hoody is sized much bigger than the insulating R1 Hoody because it works best as a weather resistant terminal layer.

Weather Resistance


Weather resistance only counts for 10% of our scoring. Fleece isn't traditionally known for its water-resistant properties; we don't expect a fleece jacket to keep you dry, but some fleece are certainly more weather resistant than others.


Weather resistance is vital if you're looking for a fleece you can use as an outer layer, or you don't want to carry other layers around town with you. Often, the more weather-resistant a fleece jacket is, the less it breathes. The thicker and heavier models, like The North Face Denali 2 were better at blocking the wind than others, and the "Hardface Technology" on the Arc'teryx Fortrez Hoody also helped block the wind. Our Top Pick For Weather Resistance is the Patagonia R1 Techface Hoody. This thin fleece is wind resistant, has an effective water-resistant DWR treatment, and even a brimmed hood like you would find on a rain jacket. Keep in mind that DWR treatments don't work as well when your jacket gets dirty, and even the Techface will "wet-out" in heavy rain.

This jacket was the second most weather resistant model behind The North Face Denali 2. Light precip beaded up and rolled off the "hardface" exterior of this fleece.
This jacket was the second most weather resistant model behind The North Face Denali 2. Light precip beaded up and rolled off the "hardface" exterior of this fleece.

Pair a breathable fleece like the Patagonia R1 Hoody with a dedicated wind layer, and you have the ultimate alpine setup. You can check out our Wind Breaker Jacket Review for more information on that type of layer.

As far as protection from precip goes, The North Face Denali 2 is by far the most water resistant fleece in the lineup. Not only is this fleece thick, it has a Durable Water Repellent (DWR) treatment, causing light rain to bead off this fleece like water off a duck's back. However, in a massive rainstorm, even the Denali 2 will eventually soak through. The Arc'teryx Fortrez also offers a little defense regarding weather resistance. Though not as thick as the Denali, this fleece could resist light rain for more than a few minutes. The breathable Patagonia R1 and the Marmot Preonsoaked up rain like a sponge, so you'll want to keep a waterproof layer handy when cruising around in the mountains with these jackets. You can also find a great option over in our Rain Jacket Review if this is what you're after.

Nylon patches over the chest  shoulders  and elbows of The North Face Denali make it even more durable and weather resistant.
Nylon patches over the chest, shoulders, and elbows of The North Face Denali make it even more durable and weather resistant.

Weight


Weight is something to consider if you are hiking long distances, or heading for a "fast and light" mission in the alpine. While a few ounces here or there might not seem like much, when you shave ounces off of all of your gear, those weight savings start to add up. The breathable Outdoor Research Deviator is one of the lightest fleece we tested, weighing in at a featherweight 9.65 ounces. The North Face Summit L2 Proprius Hoody, the Patagonia R1 Hoody, the Arc'teryx Adahy, and the Arcteryx Konseal are also respectably lightweight models, all weighing under 13 ounces.


On the heavier side, TNF Denali 2 weighs almost 25 ounces, twice as much as the lighter models, making it too heavy and bulky to throw in your pack when heading for a long hike; ditto for the supremely comfortable Campshire Hoodie. If you just need a layer for car camping though, and weight is not an issue, you'll appreciate having a warm layer like the Denali 2, the Norse Peak (16 oz), or the Synchilla Snap T when hanging around the campfire at night.

Style is totally subjective. Would you show up to a tinder date looking like this?
Style is totally subjective. Would you show up to a tinder date looking like this?

Style


As much as we obsess over the performance details of our gear, we still know it's important to look good! We did our best to balance our general impressions of each fleece with feedback from our brutally honest friends and family to assess each jacket for style points. What works the best in the mountains doesn't always look the best for a night on the town. Our top scorers in style are the Patagonia Better Sweater and The North Face Campshire Hoody. The Better Sweater combines a sleek fleece knit weave for style with breathable side panels, so you're not totally out of luck on a strenuous hike. The Patagonia Crosstrek Hoody also gets excellent style points by maintaining some urban styling while being more breathable than the Better Sweater. The Patagonia Synchilla Snap T is available in many patterns and colors with new styles coming out seemingly every season.


The North Face Denali also scored well in the style metric. Though not a favorite of our testers, its classic look is loved by many, and these jackets continue to sell like hotcakes year after year. The R1's tight hem (though very functional for layering) lost it some style points because it looks weird over a pair of jeans. The Outdoor Research Deviator Hoody was also dubbed a date night no-no due to its techy look and its scuba-like hood. Remember, style is subjective, and if a jacket fits you better than it did our testers, feel free to throw our fashion advice out the window.

This jacket looks way more at home in the boulders than around town.
This jacket looks way more at home in the boulders than around town.

Conclusion


Our lead tester takes the CoEfficient out for a spin at the local crag. It kept him quite comfortable in the shade.
Our lead tester takes the CoEfficient out for a spin at the local crag. It kept him quite comfortable in the shade.

The plethora of jackets on the "fleece" market can make your head spin, and without the actual jacket in hand, making a decision while shopping online can seem overwhelming. In general, we buy these jackets for their primary function - warmth. However, as technology grows, and designs improve, the added features modeled in most fleeces today can be what seal the deal. Like almost all gear, it depends on how and where you're planning on using it. We hope our review of these products will positively assist you in your search for your new fleece. If you need further help, be sure to check out the tips we provide in our Buying Advice article.


Matt Bento