Reviews You Can Rely On

The Original Muck Boot Company Arctic Ice Tall Review

An unbeatable option for everyday use in seriously cold and snowy places
The Original Muck Boot Company Arctic Ice Tall
Photo: The Original Muck Boot Company
Editors' Choice Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:  $195 List | $184.97 at Amazon
Pros:  Super traction, very convenient, fully waterproof to 16 inches
Cons:  Slightly sloppy fit, sorta heavy, fairly pricey
Manufacturer:   The Original Muck Boot Company
By Andy Wellman ⋅ Senior Review Editor  ⋅  Nov 4, 2020
  • Share this article:
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more
83
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#1 of 14
  • Warmth - 25% 7
  • Water Resistance - 25% 10
  • Fit and Comfort - 25% 7
  • Ease of Use - 15% 9
  • Traction - 10% 9

Our Verdict

It's hard to imagine a more effective winter snow boot than the Muck Arctic Ice Tall, which performs at the top of the list in many of our grading categories. It has the best traction and grip of any boot due to the combination of Vibram Arctic Grip rubber and super deep and aggressive lugs, providing the ideal option for deep snow, slippery ice, and nasty mud. Its tall shaft keeps the snow out of the boot, even when it gets deep, and the slip-on design is highly convenient. Last but not least, it offers the best waterproof protection of any boot in this review. These boots are ideal winter work boots, perfect for chores like shoveling, and work great for activities like ice fishing, although wouldn't be our first choice for going on long winter hikes or snowshoeing.

Compare to Similar Products

 
Awards Editors' Choice Award Top Pick Award Top Pick Award Best Buy Award Top Pick Award 
Price $195 List
$184.97 at Amazon
$199 ListCheck Price at REI
Compare at 3 sellers
Check Price at Backcountry
Compare at 2 sellers
$239.95 at REI
Compare at 3 sellers
Overall Score Sort Icon
83
81
78
73
71
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros Super traction, very convenient, fully waterproof to 16 inchesWarm, completely waterproof, comfortable, good traction, supportiveConvenient slip on design, waterproof to 11.5 inches, more affordable than competitors, customizable fitWarm, comfortable, affordable, great tractionVery comfortable, stylish, good for walking and standing om, convenient on and off
Cons Slightly sloppy fit, sorta heavy, fairly priceySizing runs a bit small, expensiveHandles let in water or debris, only come in single whole sizes, not as warm as some competitorsNot completely waterproof, more labor intensive to put on than othersNot super warm, relatively low maximum puddle depth, traction performs below most others
Bottom Line An unbeatable option for everyday use in seriously cold and snowy placesAn excellent and supportive combination of comfort, warmth, waterproofness, and tractionA very convenient and water proof winter boot that is great for chores and repeated daily useA casual boot for tromping around in the snow and rain at a budget friendly priceA stylish and comfortable boot that is a top choice for those who live in cities and don’t commonly need to work or hike in deep snow
Rating Categories The Original Muck B... Oboz Bridger 10" In... Bogs Bozeman Tall Kamik NationPlus Blundstone Thermal...
Warmth (25%)
7.0
10.0
7.0
9.0
6.0
Water Resistance (25%)
10.0
9.0
9.0
4.0
5.0
Fit And Comfort (25%)
7.0
6.0
6.0
9.0
10.0
Ease Of Use (15%)
9.0
6.0
10.0
6.0
9.0
Traction (10%)
9.0
9.0
8.0
9.0
5.0
Specs The Original Muck B... Oboz Bridger 10" In... Bogs Bozeman Tall Kamik NationPlus Blundstone Thermal...
Maximum Puddle Depth Before Major Leaking 16 in 8.5 in 11.5 in 4.5 in 3.25 in
Appropriate Activity Town, chores All activities, from chores to hiking Town, chores All activities, from chores to hiking Town, errands
Width Options Regular Regular Regular Regular and wide Regular
Fit Details Roomy Runs 1/2 size small True to size True to size True to size
Measured Shaft Height (from bottom of sole to top of shaft) 16 in 10 in 13 in 11 in 7 in
Weight (per pair, size 11) 5.4 lbs 3.6 lbs 4.4 lbs 3.6 lbs 2.9 lbs
Lining/Insulation 5 mm CR Flex-Foam Neoprene w/ Fleece Lining 400g 3M Thinsulate synthetic fibers 7mm Neo-Tech Neoprene Removable 200B 3M Thinsulate Full Thinsulate liner
Upper Material 5 mm CR Flex-Foam Neoprene Waterproof nubuck leather Rubber Waterproof suede and ballistic nylon Waterproof leather
Toe Box Spandura rubber Rubber Rubber Rubber Ergonomically engineered toe spring
Outsole Vibram Arctic Grip Winterized Rubber BioGrip SNOWTREAD Synthetic Rubber Dual density TPU
Company-claimed cold-weather rating Not listed Not listed -72 F -40 F Not listed
Animal products used? No Yes, leather No Yes Yes, leather
Sizes Available 7 - 15 8 - 14 7 - 14 7 - 14 7 - 12

Our Analysis and Test Results

The Muck Boot Company Arctic Ice Tall is a slip-on boot with a very tall shaft that envelopes the ankle and lower leg most of the way up the calf. It features Vibram's Arctic Grip wet ice technology on the outsole, which is amazing for those who have to walk daily on ice. The upper is made of neoprene, lined with fleece for comfort, and coated in rubber on the outside to provide a more waterproof boot, to a higher height, than any other we've tested. The convenience, waterproofness, and traction really propelled it to the top of our overall rankings, and unless you specifically want a winter hiking boot, this is the first one we would recommend.

The Arctic Ice Tall is the burliest winter boot made by the Original Muck Boot Company and is also one of the most expensive. There are options to lessen the price a bit, or if you prefer something slightly different. For instance, the Arctic Ice Mid is the same boot but with a shorter shaft height, for those who don't often wade in super deep snow. The Arctic Pro is a more heavily insulated model, which doesn't have the Vibram Arctic Grip outsole. Or there is the Arctic Sport Tall, which adds an EVA midsole and interior foam cushioning for a better grip on the foot if you intend to do a fair bit of hiking or walking in your Muck boots.

Performance Comparison


The Arctic Ice Tall are among the best boots you can buy, due in...
The Arctic Ice Tall are among the best boots you can buy, due in large part to the fact that they are completely waterproof and have the best traction of all that we've tested. They are also quite warm and very convenient, and thus make for absolutely ideal work boots or for frequent outdoor chores.
Photo: Andy Wellman

Warmth


These boots feature 5mm thick neoprene insulation lined with comfortable soft fleecy material. We conducted a couple of different warmth tests, besides wearing them in the snow and cold while conducting chores in temperatures down to around 10F, and found them to be pretty darn warm. In general, though, we have found that neoprene insulated boots tend to be very waterproof, but not as warm as competing boots that are insulated with 400g of Thinsulate.


When standing in about 5 inches of a freezing, running stream for 10 minutes, our toes did not get cold at all while wearing these boots. In fact, the only coldness we felt was if our feet rested tightly against the edges of the boots for too long. In our cold slush ice bucket test, we noticed that the inside of the boots without a foot inside of them actually did lose a lot of heat over the course of our 12 minutes test, dropping from 66.3 degrees down to 38.3 degrees by the end. While this test was unfortunately not very scientific, it did show that these boots allow more heat transfer than some others and rely on the warmth of a foot on the inside to stay warm. And, not surprisingly, we found them to be much warmer when moving around a lot rather than sitting still for long periods. We also like how the cuff at the top of the shaft is a bit tighter than Bogs boots, so less warm air leaks out. Overall, The Arctic Ice Tall are warm enough for most winter activities, especially when you are staying active.

Tromping through snow, standing in slush puddles, nothing could make...
Tromping through snow, standing in slush puddles, nothing could make our feet cold while wearing these boots, at least in the 10F temperatures where we live.
Photo: Andy Wellman

Water Resistance


This is the tallest boot in our testing, with the highest shaft height of 16 inches, as well as the highest potential water entry point, which is also at the top of the shaft — 16 inches high.


The outside of this boot is covered in a single coating of rubber with absolutely no seams where water might have the opportunity to leak in. This rubber extends most of the way up the shaft, and, above that, the neoprene is covered with Spandura, which is also waterproof. Unless you manage to poke a hole or create a tear in the sides of your boots, these are as waterproof as they come, and your feet will be staying dry.

These are the most waterproof boots we've tested, with a 16 inch...
These are the most waterproof boots we've tested, with a 16 inch stack height before water can leak into them, and a completely seamless rubber seal all the way around the neoprene inner booty.

Fit and Comfort


The fit of these boots is very spacious and wide, with lots of area in the forefoot to wriggle the toes around and no constrictions to cut off blood flow. The fit in the heel is also fairly wide, and one might even call these a little bit sloppy, which is why we don't recommend them as our top choice for long hikes (they are also heavy). Like Bogs, they only come in single whole sizes. Our main tester wears a size 11, and a size 11 boot fit well and comfortably, although the fit was a bit more precise with thick and bulky wool socks than thin ones. If you commonly wear a half size, we would probably recommend opting to size down rather than size up.


If we have one complaint, it comes from the cuff at the top of the shaft. As a tall boot, this cuff is above the midway point on the calf, and it has an elastic band that closely wraps the shin and calf, which keeps cold air out and warm air in. However, it also rubs this area a bit in a way that we found mildly annoying. The wide-open top of the shaft found on Bogs is a bit more comfortable in this area.

These are very comfortable boots that fit well. Although we wouldn't...
These are very comfortable boots that fit well. Although we wouldn't recommend them for really long winter hikes, they are awesome for winter time dog walks in the snow and ice, and are comfortable and spacious for all day wearing if you commonly work outside.

Ease of Use


These are slip-on boots, meaning there are no laces or other tightening features that need to be done up; you simply slide your foot in and out to put them on and take them off. Slip-ons are the most convenient style to take on and off many times per day and our favorite choice for winter chores for that reason.


As slip-on's go, we found these to be slightly more effort than Bogs. They don't have the convenient handles at the top of the shaft, so you have to grip tightly to the neoprene itself to pull them on. The tall shaft and tighter cuff at the top also mean it takes slightly more effort to pull them on. Emphasis on slightly, as these are still super easy to slide on in a hurry and race out the door.

As slip-on boots, these are quick and easy to get on the feet...
As slip-on boots, these are quick and easy to get on the feet, although without handles, one must grab the neoprene top to pull them on. A bigger issue is the tall stack is relatively tight and so there is often a fair bit of lower pant leg adjustment needed in the form of stuffing and straightening.
Photo: Andy Wellman

Traction


There is no doubt these boots have the best traction of any that we have tested. Not only do they have large, deep lugs that are well spaced out for maximum stick in soft snow, but they also feature the super cool Vibram Arctic Grip rubber compounds on the sole.


The Arctic Grip pods are placed in the middle of all of the largest lugs and grip well to slippery wet ice, making it easy to walk — no careful shuffle approach needed. For those who live and work near icy surfaces — for instance, frozen winter roads in the northeast or northwest — having this technology on your shoes is a total game-changer.

The outsole lugs on this boot are huge and aggressive, offering...
The outsole lugs on this boot are huge and aggressive, offering great traction on soft snow. The Vibram Arctic Grip rubber compound also grips ice like a miracle, making these the best choice for traction that we've found.
Photo: Andy Wellman

Value


As The Muck Boot Company's most advanced winter boot, it shouldn't be surprising that the price tag for these is up there with the other most expensive boots in our review. However, the performance is also at the top of the chart, literally, and while we haven't had the chance to wear them out completely, online reviews suggest they last for a long time for most folks. Despite the price, we think they present excellent value for those who live in the snow and deal with it on a daily basis. For those looking to save a little bit of money, the other variations on Muck's winter boots all cost a little bit less.

Muck boots are great for doing outside chores in the snow, slush...
Muck boots are great for doing outside chores in the snow, slush, and mud, like chopping up firewood for the dark winter to come. These present awesome value, and are our favorite winter work boots.

Conclusion


The Muck Arctic Ice Tall has the best traction on slippery surfaces, especially ice, of any boot we have tested. It is also very convenient to take on and off, quite warm, and totally waterproof. We think it's the best winter boot you can buy for daily use, although it wouldn't be our top choice for winter hiking or snowshoeing.

Shoveling during the first winter storm of the season, getting solid...
Shoveling during the first winter storm of the season, getting solid grip on the slippery paving stones, and enjoying the crisp silence of the cold white snow.
Photo: Andy Wellman

Andy Wellman

Ad-free. Influence-free. Powered by Testing.

GearLab is founded on the principle of honest, objective, reviews. Our experts test thousands of products each year using thoughtful test plans that bring out key performance differences between competing products. And, to assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. No cherry-picked units sent by manufacturers. No sponsored content. No ads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing and comparison.

Learn More