Asolo Outlaw GV - Women's Review
Cons: Not a lot of cushioning, poor traction
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Asolo Outlaw GV has a suede upper, molded EVA midsole, Gore-Tex liner, and Vibram sole. Just a note here that we ordered this shoe in a US size 10 women's, which turned out to be significantly larger than the standard size 10 shoe, and in fact it was labeled a 42.5 European size (most size 10s that we tried were a 41 to 42). We returned the larger shoe and tested a 9.5 instead which was a much better fit.
This pair was the least comfortable shoe in our review. There is very little cushioning underfoot in either the heel or the forefoot, which meant that we felt every sharp rock and hard surface underneath us. In addition, the insole was very slippery, and our feet were constantly moving around in them while walking. It was really the strangest sensation, which eventually led to hot spots forming from the friction. The insole itself was thin and flimsy, and provided no additional cushioning. While you the insole is easily replaced with an aftermarket one, since we already paid a significant amount for these shoes we don't really want to have to add anything else to them. If you want to feel like you are hiking on clouds, then consider our Top Pick for Comfort, the Hoka One One Tor Summit WP - Women's, with a super thick sole that provides ample cushioning.
We weren't that impressed with the support of these shoes either. While the firm sole provided adequate support over rough terrain, there is very little arch support in the shoe and we also experienced some heel lift. If you have very flat feet this shoe might suit you, but if you have a regular and particularly a high arch this shoe literally falls a little flat.
The traction on the Asolo Outlaw GV also left something to be desired. While they use a Vibram sole, the lugs are stiff, small, and closely spaced, which when combined together resulted in poor performance on slippery sandstone slabs. If you like to scramble when hiking and need your hiking shoes to stick like a gecko, check out the Merrell Moab 2 Ventilators.
There's no question that this is a waterproof shoe. The Outlaw let no water in during our ten minute bucket test, and the suede upper beads water off like no other. It didn't even appear to saturate at all even after being submerged for 10 minutes, which means it would take a lot of moisture before the Gore-tex liner would even need to come into play. So why did it receive only a 7 out of 10? Because the lowest point of the shoe (at the ankle opening) is only 3.5 inches above ground, and some other models, like the Oboz Sawtooth Low BDry and the Hoka One One Tor Summit WP came up to 4 inches. It might not seem like much, but that extra half an inch could be the reason why a small splash when crossing a stream soaks your sock or not.
We gave this shoe a fairly high score for durability. The whole unit is well-made and we had no wear issues during our testing period, and we found few durability complaints when scouring other on-line user reviews. We do worry about the durability of the tread though, because it is not as thick as some other models.
This shoe is a good option to wear in rainy climates, as the suede upper sheds water like a champ. But the lower cut ankle creates more chances for water to enter when crossing streams and splashing through muddy pools, so keep that in mind.
This shoe retails for $175, which is considerably more than some of the other pairs in this review, like the $100 Merrell Moab 2 Ventilator and the $115 Keen Voyageur - Women's. Some of this expense is no doubt related to the suede upper and Gore-Tex lining, but it's still a considerable amount to pair as far as we are concerned. Our Editors' Choice winner, the Oboz Sawtooth Low BDry, retails for only $140 and was a higher performing model.
There are some great things to like about the Asolo Outlaw GV, including the seriously waterproof upper and fairly lightweight design. However, there just was not enough comfort and support underfoot for us, and the slippery insole caused us to feel some hot spots after only a few miles.
— Cam McKenzie Ring