Hands-on Gear Review

CiloGear 30L WorkSack Review

CiloGear 30L WorkSack.  Shown here in the standard fabrics.
Price:  $189 List
Pros:  Perfect balance of low weight and durability, excellent features, super comfy for climbing, 4 fabric options
Cons:  Could be too small for multi-day trips (unless you go ultralight)
Editors' Rating:   
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Capacity (liters):  30
Capacity (cubic inches):  1830
Total Weight (grams):  Standard Fabrics - 590g (stripped) / 980g (max). Woven / Non-Woven Dyneema - 505g (stripped) / 940g (max). Non-Woven Dyneema - 480g (stripped) / 870g (max).
Manufacturer:   CiloGear

Our Verdict

The CiloGear 30L WorkSack has been refined over time until… perfection? The pack's capacity is best for day trips and car-to-car alpine climbing, but can also work for 1-3 night climbs if you're traveling ultralight. Due to its durability (across all 4 fabric options) the pack also performs very well for rock climbs of all types. This is the most comfortable pack (for technical climbing) we've ever tested. If you're looking for a do-everything small capacity alpine pack, look no further.

However, all Cilo packs are made to order in Portland, Oregon, often involving a delay in delivery. Cilo Gear packs are not widely available at major online retailers, so if you can't get to one of their retailers and need something soon, consider the Black Diamond Speed 50.

If you want one all-purpose pack that's also large enough for multi-day winter climbs consider the CiloGear 30:30.

If we were to choose two packs for climbing primarily in North America we'd get the Cilo 30L WorkSack and a Hyperlite Mountain Gear 3400 Ice Pack, the latter of which is more comfortable for hiking and lighter than the CiloGear 45L WorkSack.

Check out the complete Mountaineering and Alpine Climbing Backpack Review to see how the 30L WorkSack compares to the competition.



RELATED REVIEW: The 8 Best Mountaineering Backpacks

Our Analysis and Test Results

Review by:
Chris Simrell

Last Updated:
Thursday
August 29, 2013

Share:

First, a note about pronunciation


Cilo is pronounced "chee-low", not "see-low" or "silo".

Max Neale down climbing on the Evolution Traverse with the CiloGear 30L W/NWD pack.
Max Neale down climbing on the Evolution Traverse with the CiloGear 30L W/NWD pack.

Like all CiloGear WorkSacks, the 30L is offered in multiple fabric options. There are four to choose from:

Standard - This is the cheapest option and was updated in the winter of 2012-2013 to be significantly more durable than the previous version.
Max weight - 980g / 34.6oz
Minimum weight - 590g / 20.8oz

Price - $189

Guide Service - Standard fabrics plus extra durability for $20 more.
Max weight - 990g / 34.9oz
Minimum weight - 590g / 20.8oz

Price - $199

Woven and Non-Woven Dyneema (W/NWD) - Our favorite fabric option, extremely durable and lightweight, likely the best pack fabric in the world.
Max weight - 940g / 33oz
Minimum weight - 505g / 18oz

Price - $500

CiloGear 30L WorkSacks in four different materials  left to right: standard  GuideService  W/NWD  and NWD.
CiloGear 30L WorkSacks in four different materials, left to right: standard, GuideService, W/NWD, and NWD.

Performance Comparison


CiloGear 30L WNW on the Cilley-Barber  Mt. Katahdin  Maine.
CiloGear 30L WNW on the Cilley-Barber, Mt. Katahdin, Maine.

Weight


Weight is a variable thing for CiloGear WorkSacks. Because you can remove almost every part of any CiloGear pack the total weight of your pack will depend on which features you take along on a particular trip, and what version (fabric option) you choose to purchase. Take a look at the side-by-side comparison table in our Mountaineering and Alpine Climbing Backpack Review to get the full weight specs on all the different fabric options.

The standard 30L WorkSack has a total weight of 980g (34.6oz), and a stripped weight (no lid, no hip belt, no bivy pad, no side straps) of 590g (20.8oz). This gives the pack a weight to volume ratio of 0.6 — 1.1 oz/L (depending on how stripped down your pack happens to be). Overall the 30L WorkSack hits a sweet spot in terms of weight for this capacity of pack by balancing weight concerns, with durability. The Speed 30 for example is significantly heavier, while the Mountain Hardwear SummitRocket 30 is far lighter, but not nearly as durable, comfortable, or versatile. The 30L Guide Service version is slightly heavier than the regular version, and the W/NWD is slightly lighter. The NWD version is the lightest overall.

99% of the time our testers use the 30L without the lid. Add a silnylon or cuben fiber pack liner (or a contractor style trash bag) to keep contents waterproof, if needed.

CiloGear WorkSack in the North Cascades  Washington.
CiloGear WorkSack in the North Cascades, Washington.

If you want to fit several days of gear and food inside a 30L pack you'll need to go ultralight. Start by getting an ultralight sleeping bag and an ultralight shelter.

Durability


Will Dean following mixed terrain on the N. Face of Mt. Snoqualmie with the Cilogear WorkSack.
Will Dean following mixed terrain on the N. Face of Mt. Snoqualmie with the Cilogear WorkSack.
CiloGear substantially improved the overall durability of the 30L WorkSack when they updated the design and fabrics in the winter of 2012-2013. We found that the primary complaint with the old version was a lack of durability on the side panels, particularly if you were packing skis on the side or doing a lot of climbing on rough rock. The new version has fixed this by beefing up the durability on the bottom — now VX42 (420d Cordura laminated with dacron X-Pac) — and by putting VX21 (210d Cordura laminated with Dacron X-Pac) on the bottom sides and front crampon panel. The upper side panels and lid remain 210 Cordura with dyneema ripstop. By using more abrasion resistant fabrics on the high wear areas and keeping the fabrics lighter on the non-wear areas, CiloGear has struck a good balance between long-term durability and weight. Overall the 30L WorkSack remains a very lightweight pack considering that it's built to take abrasion, carry ice tools and crampons, and last you for years.

If long-term durability is a major concern, consider the W/NWD version. Though extraordinary expensive the W/NWD packs from CiloGear are ultra-strong, built-to-last in the truest way, AND lightweight. The fabric is non-woven dyneema on the inside and woven dyneema on the outside. Yes, dyneema is the same material your superlight, super strong climbing slings are made of (some people call it spectra). Both the tear strength and abrasion resistance of W/NWD are very very very good. We've tried to beat the crap out of our 30L W/NWD, but even after two years it shows less wear than many alpine packs do after 3 months. Specifically, we've used that pack for: Evolution Traverse in the high Sierra, Regular NW Face of Half Dome, Grand Teton, alpine climbing in the Canadian Rockies, ice climbing in the Adirondacks, backpacking in Glacier National Park, backpacking the Lost Coast Trail (CA), backpacking in the North Cascades, climbing the Southern and Northern Picket range in the North Cascades, the Cilley-Barber on Mt. Katahdin (ME), two months of traveling and sport climbing in Turkey (where one tester deliberately and consistently dragged it on sharp limestone), and countless other rock, ice, skiing, hiking, and city day trips. The W/NWD is dirty, but in excellent condition. We are confident that it is the best pack fabric in the world and we highly recommend it if you have the cash to push the performance envelope.

The CiloGear 30L W/NW Dyneema WorkSack on the RNWF of Half Dome.
The CiloGear 30L W/NW Dyneema WorkSack on the RNWF of Half Dome.

Comfort


Generally speaking the 30L WorkSack is fairly comfortable. Our main finding concerning comfort was that if you're planning a one-night trip — and bringing the 30L — you tend to stuff it to the gills a bit. With only a folded foam bivy pad for a frame the pack tends to "round out" a bit in the back. While not particularly uncomfortable, when loaded up full the pack can tend to feel a bit cylindrical against the back. One solution is to take less gear. Or alternatively, take the CiloGear 30:30, which at about 40L is more appropriate for a 2 night trip. One feature we really like is the internal compression strap. This allows you to cinch the load in your pack in against your back by tightening an internal strap that connects the front and back of the pack, bring the load closer to your body and allowing it to ride better on the hips and not throw you off balance.

Compared to other packs of its size the 30L WorkSack is actually rather nice to hike with. It has a padded waist belt for example, something not found on the SummitRocket 30. We found the comfort of the pack to be similar to the Black Diamond Speed 30. Overall the 30L WorkSack was our favorite pack to climb with.

Will Dean belaying on NY Gully  NW Face Snoqualmie Mountain  Cascades  Washington.
Will Dean belaying on NY Gully, NW Face Snoqualmie Mountain, Cascades, Washington.

Versatility


Like all CiloGear packs we found the 30L WorkSack to be a very versatile pack. All the straps are removable, and perhaps more importantly, their location is customizable with CiloGear's unique strap system. You can rid yourself up to carry skis, or a sleeping pad, crampons, or remove it all for a sleek exterior. The lid, internal bivy pad frame, and hip belt are also removable. The ability to securely carry ice tools and crampons, have excellent abrasion resistance, all while remaining a lightweight pack overall makes the 30L WorkSack our go-to small alpine bag.

Features


The 30L WorkSack has all the features needed in a small alpine pack, none you don't, and you can remove features when they aren't needed. The ice tool attachment system (the same system found on all CiloGear packs) is our favorite out of all the packs we used. It is extremely simple to use, and extremely secure. Picks are slotted into a fabric slit with the tool neck clipped into place, and the tool shaft secured with a short piece of shock cord and a cord lock. For crampons, you can rig up a length of shock cord to the front of the pack, zigzagging the cord across the front panel, and securing it with a cord lock and overhand knot. We found this to be the most effective crampon attachment method for this pack. Alternatively, you can use two of the straps provided with the pack or strap them to the top of the pack under the lid, on top of the lid, or use the included straps

While the lid has a pocket, the inside of the pack also contains a medium sized hanging pocket. This is big enough for the little things — headlamp, sunscreen, cell phone etc. and it flips up to give access to the bivy pad slot.

The hipbelt is reasonably comfortable and built very tough. (The buckle is unnecessarily gigantic for a 30L pack.) For climbing some of out testers prefer to use the grey strap set as a hipbelt because it's 4+ oz. lighter and performs nearly as well-- it prevents the pack from sliding around and throwing you off balance-- as the larger belt. The large hipbelt can take some weight off your shoulders, but, because this is a climbing pack, the hipbelt is no where near as effective at putting weight on your hips as a backpacking pack, which typically rides much lower. Though this may

The pack is available in one size. Taller folks may want to request the longer shoulder straps. Additionally, CiloGear offers women specific hip belts.

Watch the videos below to see how CiloGear features work.

Best Applications


Car-to-car alpine excursions and one to three night climbs with a light kit.

Value


The standard 30L WorkSack is an excellent deal at $182. The $500 W/NWD version provides unmatched performance and durability; if you don't lose it first, you can give it to your kid. We don't believe the NWD version is a good value.

CiloGear WorkSack alpine rock climbing.
CiloGear WorkSack alpine rock climbing.

Other Versions and Accessories


CiloGear 45L WorkSack
CiloGear 45L WorkSack.  Shown in the standard fabric option.
  • Cost - $259 - $700
  • Capacity - 45-75 L
  • Weight - Standard fabrics stripped - 27.9oz
  • Weight - Standard fabrics max - 63.5oz
  • A good choice if you're looking to do primarily multiday alpine climbing trips

CiloGear 30:30 WorkSack
CiloGear 30:30 Guide Service WorkSack
  • Cost - $219
  • Capacity - 40 L
  • Weight - Standard fabrics stripped - 23.9oz
  • Weight - Standard fabrics max - 43.4oz
  • Extremely versatile, go-to alpine pack

Skiers- check out the removable shovel pocket and ski strap set.

How To Get It


If no retailers in your area carry CiloGear packs they can be ordered from http://www.cilogear.com/packs.html Be aware that there may be delays; CiloGear is a small company and orders can be backlogged.

Videos



Chris Simrell

You Might Also Like

OutdoorGearLab Member Reviews


Most recent review: November 13, 2014
Summary of All Ratings

OutdoorGearLab Editors' Rating:  
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 (5.0)
Average Customer Rating:  
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 (5.0)

100% of 2 reviewers recommend it
 
Rating Distribution
4 Total Ratings
5 star: 100%  (4)
4 star: 0%  (0)
3 star: 0%  (0)
2 star: 0%  (0)
1 star: 0%  (0)
Climber

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
   Nov 13, 2014 - 07:40am
JimH · Climber · Denver CO

My wife has the base fabric model, and I just got the Cadillac W/NW Dyneema. Completely second the OGL review - this is pretty much perfection. The Dyneema fabric is sturdier than I imagined - tough, light, but bulletproof. The adaptibility is super - the strap system is brilliant - easy to pare it down to a perfect sack with as few contraptions as you want - or rig it for tools, crampons, compression, etc. we use them for everything from 14ers to cragging. I waited about six weeks on production, they kept me informed, and shipping was very fast. Worth every penny.



Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this product to a friend.

Climber

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
   Sep 17, 2013 - 07:19pm
robduncan · Climber · slc, ut

Best skiing/ alpine climbing backpack out there. I think this thing is just about as good as they could get. Use it and believe it!

Extremely versatile and can be configured in as many ways as you can come up with! Easily can be strapped onto other Cilo Packs to piggy-back big loads to base camps, etc.

I have used the straight up Nylon (cheapest model) and it's been tough and held up to use and abuse.

In spite of the simplicity- I think this is the best carrying backpack I have ever used.



Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this product to a friend.


Have you used this product?
Don't hold back. Share your viewpoint by posting a review with your thoughts...