Feathered Friends Flicker 40 UL Review
Cons: Not as warm as others (in the version we tested), neck draw cords loosen over time
Manufacturer: Feathered Friends
Compare to Similar Products
Feathered Friends Flicker 40 UL
|Price||$364.00 at Feathered Friends||$300 List||$410.00 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$379 List||$329.00 at Feathered Friends|
|Pros||Highest scoring ultralight sleeping bag, best features, and most versatile||Very affordable, highly customizable, versatile, lots of features||Warmth-to-weight ratio, excellent fabric, best bag with a hood, versatile||Warm for an ultralight bag, simple and versatile design, box baffle construction, waterproof stuff sack||Super simple and light, highest quality down, spacious and comfortable|
|Cons||Not as warm as others (in the version we tested), neck draw cords loosen over time||Long wait for product to be custom made and shipped, foot box draw cord still leaves a little hole, lots of buttons and straps||Tight fit, shallow hood, expensive||A little constricting, small foot box, not the best neck draw cord design||No zipper, hard to tell the difference between variable fill zones, must be paired with warm jacket, feet can get hot in warmer weather, not as versatile as other ultralight bags|
|Bottom Line||The best performing set of features that allow for the most versatile usage||The warmest quilt in our review also comes at a reasonable price||A very warm and lightweight full mummy with a full zip||With an enclosed foot box and ¾ length zipper, this warm hoodless mummy can also be used quilt style||The only mummy bag that uses more down fill in the foot box and less around the torso, to take advantage of the clothing you have with you|
|Rating Categories||Flicker 40 UL||Revelation 20||Summerlite||ZPacks Classic||Feathered Friends Vireo UL|
|Specs||Flicker 40 UL||Revelation 20||Summerlite||ZPacks Classic||Feathered Friends...|
|Style||Center zip mummy bag or unzipper to be quilt||Quilt||Hooded mummy||Hoodless mummy||Hoodless, zipperless mummy|
|Manufacturer Stated Temperature Rating||40F||20F||32F||20F||25F lower half, 45F upper half|
|Measured weight, bag only (ounces)||19.1 oz||20.9 oz||19 oz||20.3 oz||16.4 oz|
|Claimed weight from manufacturer (ounces)||20 oz||20.19 oz||19 oz||19.8 oz||16.7 oz|
|Stuff Sack Weight (ounces)||0.8 oz||0.6 oz||1 oz||0.9 oz||0.8 oz|
|Stuffed Size||7" x 10"||7" x 12"||6" x 12"||6" x 12"||7" x 10"|
|Fill Weight||8.4 oz||13 oz||10 oz||13.1 oz||9.4 oz|
|Fill Power||950+ goose down||850 Downtek||850+ goose down||900 fill||950+ goose down|
|Construction||Continuous baffles||U shaped baffled quilt||Continuous baffle||Vertical upper baffles and horizontal lower baffles, box baffle construction||No hood, no zipper and a variable fill|
|Shell Material||Pertex Endurance UL||10D nylon fabric||100% nylon ripstop||.70 oz/sqyd (23.7 g/m2) Ventum Ripstop Nylon w/ DWR||Pertex Endurance UL|
|Shoulder Girth (inches)||62"||55"||59"||61"||64"|
|Hip Girth (inches)||48"||55"||51"||61"||48"|
|Foot Girth (inches)||39"||55"||38"||35"||38"|
|Zipper Length||Full length center zip||1/3 length at bottom||Full length||3/4 length||No zipper|
|Sizes||Regular, long, and wide||Short/regular, regular/regular, regular/wide/ long/wide||5'6", 6', and 6'6"||Slim, standard, and broad (girth) short, medium, long, x-long and xx-long (length)||62", 68", and 74"|
|Temp Options (degrees Fahrenheit)||20, 30, 40F||10, 20, 30, 40F||32F||10, 20, 30, 40F||25, 45F|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Flicker 40 UL ended up as the top selection in this year's review because it simply did everything slightly better than the competition. The Flicker 40 is our highest rated bag because we liked that it opened up fully into a blanket for the warmest nights, or for two people. And unlike the other quilts, we were able to fully zip ourselves up and cinch the drawcords at the head and feet to be fully enclosed when we got chilled. No matter how warm the temperature rating or how much high quality down was used, we could never get the other quilts to be draft-free on chilly nights.
Not only were we thrilled with the versatility and design of this bag's unique features, but we enjoyed the attention to detail on other aspects of the Flicker 40 UL as well. The Pertex Endurance UL shell fabric is lightweight and naturally water-resistant, meaning there is no coating to wear off, and it offers great first-line protection against condensation inside a tent. The 950+ fill down lofts up nicely and is supremely lightweight. Attention to design detail, such as adding more durable fabric to the zipper baffle that cannot catch in the zipper, and including a neck collar to help seal in the warmth, further endeared this bag to our hearts. It is worth noting that while we tested a 40F version of this bag, it is also available in 20F and 30F versions, and for sleeping in the mountains in the spring and fall, we would probably order a warmer version in the future. It also comes in wide and long versions.
Feathered Friends bags are not sold by major commercial or online retailers.Find it online at: FeatheredFriends.com
The Flicker 40 UL uses 8.4 ounces of the highest quality 950+ fill goose down to give it loft and warmth. The down is sewn into place using horizontal box baffles, which means there is no point at which the interior and exterior fabric of this bag meet, creating down "dead spots" or points where there is no insulation. It has a number of features that contribute to the overall warmth effect, such as the aforementioned full-length center zipper, lined the entire way by a reinforced draft tube, and a down-filled neck collar that has two buttons to hold it closed at the top of the zipper. The effect of all these features is that it is a reasonably warm bag, good to around 40F, but not as warm overall as the warmest bags in our testing, as evidenced by the chart below:
We tested this bag numerous nights at temperatures well above its 40F limit and found it to be very comfortable. We also used it two nights at, or even slightly below, its 40F limit, and while it did not keep us piping hot at those temperatures, we were still reasonably comfortable, and not suffering like we were when we tested other quilts to their lower-end limits. However, it is worth pointing out that at its best, this is still a 40-degree bag without a hood, and so it was not as warm as the warmest hooded mummy bags. We think this bag performs very admirably for a 40F bag, but would not hesitate to order either the 30F or 20F versions in the future for added comfort during chilly spring and fall trips into the mountains, and would recommend you do so as well if you want a truly three-season bag.
Our size regular Flicker 40 UL weighed in at 19.1 ounces, slightly lighter than the 20 ounces advertised on Feathered Friends' website. While not included in our measurements, the included stuff sack weighed 0.8 ounces.
At 1 lb. 3.1 oz, this is indeed a very light sleeping bag and packs down small enough to easily carry with you during virtually any ultralight endurance activity. That said, it is not as light or as small as other 40°F bags we tested. The Flicker weighs virtually the same as other similarly designed quilts we tested, like the Enlightened Equipment Revelation 20, and ended up with a higher overall score. In our opinion, despite not being the lightest out there, this is still a very light bag, and we would even happily add the four ounces of weight to buy ourselves another 10 degrees of warmth with the Flicker 30 UL.
According to Feathered Friends, our regular sized Flicker 40 UL is 6'6" long in blanket mode, and 6'0" long when the end is cinched. This should make it plenty long to suit a six-foot-tall person, and in our experience, this was true. With our feet comfortably in the bottom of the bag and the end cinched, the neck collar and baffle easily came over our shoulders and sat snuggly around our neck. We also found that when fully zipped up, enclosing one in mummy mode, the bag was spacious and comfortable throughout, without the claustrophobic constriction inherent in some mummy bag designs. We found that the Flite 15d ripstop nylon inner material was plenty comfortable against our skin, although it wasn't our number one liner material.
While certainly among the more comfortable bags in this review, we couldn't rate it as high as some of the other bags we tested. While comparatively it wasn't the absolute best, we genuinely can't complain about how comfortable this bag is.
We define versatility as the ability for a sleeping bag to be effectively and comfortably used in the most possible different situations, and there is no doubt that this is where the Flicker 40 UL truly shines. While we have already talked at length about how much we love the fact that this bag can be either a fully opened blanket or an enclosed mummy, no other bag in this test can say the same. It easily received the highest score in this metric:
One of the design premises of many of the quilts we tested is that laying on top of down insulation compresses it, rendering it ineffective. Quilts use this reasoning to simply not include a bottom side and instead are designed to wrap around a sleeping pad. Our hard-earned experience with regards to these designs is that logic aside, quilt designs that could be made fully enclosed were noticeably warmer than their non-enclosed counterparts, regardless of temperature rating. Simply put, air manages to leak in and out of a person's warmth envelope if not fully enclosed.
Yet again, the Flicker 40 UL received the highest score for features, a perfect 10. When considering features, we assessed how useful the features were to the design of the bag, and also how well they worked. Besides the full-length zipper, we loved how well the foot box drawcord worked on this bag. With one pull, this bag goes from a fully flat blanket to have a completely enclosed foot box. Unlike similar designs, there is not even the smallest hole left in the bottom of the bag for air to escape, and we found the drawcord easily stayed tight through many nights of usage.
The quilt most similar in design to the Flicker 40 UL is the Revelation 20. As our Best Bang for the Buck Award winner, it is a very worthy alternative for those wanting a more budget-conscious choice, but we found that the drawcords on its foot enclosure, as well as around the neck, were simply too light and didn't snug up as well as those on this bag. The little quarter zipper and buckle combination of closing the bag was also not up to the standard of the high-quality zipper found on the Flicker 40 UL, and so it wasn't rated as highly.
The retail price plants it squarely in the middle of all of the ultralight bags we tested when considering the price. Since we called it the best overall ultralight sleeping bag, and think it is very versatile for different seasons, temperatures, climates, and uses, we think this presents a fantastic value. While we didn't rate for durability, we can also say we feel the workmanship displayed on this bag is top-notch. Highly recommended.
The Feathered Friends Flicker 40 UL sleeping bag is our best overall ultralight sleeping bag winner because it scored higher than the competition. Of particular note is how versatile it is, and how well its particular design features help it score above the rest. It shines as both a down blanket and hoodless mummy, and is plenty light and warm to be considered an ultralight enthusiast's dream piece of gear.
— Andy Wellman