Ratings Overview - Winter Boots for Women

Total 8 products tested
Compare Products Side-by-Side
Compare Gear Review Summary Retail Price Overall Rating Category Ratings
Compare
up to 5
Products sorted by Overall Rating score List Price Score 0-100 Warmth Weather Protection Comfort and Coziness Traction Style Ease of On and Off
The North Face Shellista Mid II

 The North Face Shellista II Mid
The North Face Shellista II took home the Editors' Choice award for its wonderful balance of style and performance. While this boot didn't excel at any one metric, it performed well across all of...  read more >
$140

Editors' Choice Award
100
0
79
Warmth - 7 of 10
7
Weather Protection - 7 of 10
7
Comfort and Coziness - 9 of 10
9
Traction - 8 of 10
8
Style - 9 of 10
9
Ease of On and Off - 8 of 10
8
Sorel Joan of Arctic

 Sorel Joan of Arctic
If you endure long winters, regularly slog through the snow, or just want a winter boot that is going to keep your feet warm and dry without making you look like you completely gave up on fashion...  read more >
$180

Top Pick Award
100
0
77
Warmth - 9 of 10
9
Weather Protection - 9 of 10
9
Comfort and Coziness - 6 of 10
6
Traction - 6 of 10
6
Style - 8 of 10
8
Ease of On and Off - 7 of 10
7
Vasque Pow Pow III UltraDry

 Vasque Pow Pow III UltraDry
The Vasque Pow Pow III UltraDry is an excellent choice for the frequent winter hiker. It offers great protection from cold, wet elements, and its combination of ankle support and warmth made it a...  read more >
$150

Top Pick Award
100
0
76
Warmth - 9 of 10
9
Weather Protection - 9 of 10
9
Comfort and Coziness - 8 of 10
8
Traction - 9 of 10
9
Style - 3 of 10
3
Ease of On and Off - 3 of 10
3
Kamik Momentum

 Kamik Momentum
The Kamik Momentum shines with great all-around performance for a low sticker price. That's why we couldn't help but give it our Best Buy award! Ideal for casual around-town errands and outdoor...  read more >
$90

Best Buy Award
100
0
75
Warmth - 8 of 10
8
Weather Protection - 7 of 10
7
Comfort and Coziness - 7 of 10
7
Traction - 8 of 10
8
Style - 6 of 10
6
Ease of On and Off - 9 of 10
9
Sorel Tofino II

 Sorel Tofino II
The Sorel Tofino II is a high-performing boot that earned good scores across all our metrics, but lost its podium as Editors' Choice to The North Face Shellista Mid this year. Although it doesn't...  read more >
$170

100
0
71
Warmth - 6 of 10
6
Weather Protection - 8 of 10
8
Comfort and Coziness - 6 of 10
6
Traction - 7 of 10
7
Style - 9 of 10
9
Ease of On and Off - 8 of 10
8
UGG Adirondack II

 UGG Adirondack II
An extremely comfortable and cozy winter boot, the UGG Adirondack II stands out for its unique features and sheepskin liner. This boot offers stellar all-around performance: it's cute enough to wear...  read more >
$225

100
0
64
Warmth - 6 of 10
6
Weather Protection - 5 of 10
5
Comfort and Coziness - 9 of 10
9
Traction - 6 of 10
6
Style - 6 of 10
6
Ease of On and Off - 6 of 10
6
Northside Kathmandu Waterproof

 Northside Kathmandu
The Northside Kathmandu winter boot features a faux-fur collar and full-suede exterior. We instantly fell in love with its design and fantastic level of comfort and coziness, but were let down when...  read more >
$90

100
0
57
Warmth - 6 of 10
6
Weather Protection - 4 of 10
4
Comfort and Coziness - 8 of 10
8
Traction - 4 of 10
4
Style - 7 of 10
7
Ease of On and Off - 5 of 10
5
Columbia Minx Mid II Omni-Heat

 Columbia Minx Mid II Omni-Heat
The Columbia Minx Mid II Omni-Heat boot stands out for its super lightweight design and one-pull lacing system. We love its super soft and silky inner liner that doesn't pull out when taking it on...  read more >
$120

100
0
55
Warmth - 4 of 10
4
Weather Protection - 4 of 10
4
Comfort and Coziness - 6 of 10
6
Traction - 7 of 10
7
Style - 7 of 10
7
Ease of On and Off - 7 of 10
7
Compare
up to 5
Products sorted by Overall Rating score List Price Score 0-100 Warmth Weather Protection Comfort and Coziness Traction Style Ease of On and Off
Compare Products Side-by-Side
Total 8 tested