Reviews You Can Rely On

Muck Boot Arctic Ice Tall AGAT - Women's Review

This highly durable boot is completely waterproof and great at insulating, though it's a bit too bulky to wear on low-snow days or during high-output activities
Muck Boot Arctic Ice Tall AGAT - Women's
Photo: The Original Muck Boot Company
Top Pick Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:  $190 List | $199.95 at Amazon
Pros:  Full coverage protection, highly durable, reliable traction
Cons:  Pricey, very heavy, retains moisture, difficult to drive in
Manufacturer:   The Original Muck Boot Company
By Liz Chamberlain ⋅ Review Editor  ⋅  Dec 6, 2021
  • Share this article:
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more
84
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#1 of 13
  • Warmth - 25% 8
  • Weather Protection - 25% 9
  • Comfort and Fit - 20% 7
  • Durability - 15% 9
  • Traction - 15% 9

Our Verdict

The impenetrable Muck Boot Arctic Ice Tall Arctic Grip is built for working and playing hard. Reaching an impressive 16-inches in height, the boot's rubber and neoprene construction provide ample warmth and protection from high snowdrifts and sloppy snow conditions. This boot is a favorite to use for winter chores like chopping firewood, blowing snow, and shoveling because of its durable, protective design. It is completely waterproof and provides the best coverage in our lineup. The burly underfoot traction is also impressively sticky, performing well on ice and snow. Unfortunately, it is quite bulky and heavy, but we feel the weight is worth it for those seeking a hearty workhorse that'll get you through outdoor workdays and winter storms.

Compare to Similar Products

 
Awards Top Pick Award Editors' Choice Award Best Buy Award Top Pick Award Top Pick Award 
Price $190 List
$199.95 at Amazon
$250 List
$249.95 at Amazon
Check Price at REI
Compare at 2 sellers
$179.30 at Amazon
Compare at 2 sellers
Check Price at REI
Compare at 3 sellers
Overall Score Sort Icon
84
83
81
77
75
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros Full coverage protection, highly durable, reliable tractionCozy wool lining, very warm, highly waterproof, versatile constructionGood value, ultra warm, great traction, highly waterproofProtective, durable, very warm, breathable, excellent traction, high valueLightweight, super soft interior, durable leather exterior
Cons Pricey, very heavy, retains moisture, difficult to drive inExpensive, slightly bulkyOnly ankle-high coverage, hiking-specific style, narrow fitLess stylish, somewhat heavy, stiff collarUnimpressive outsole traction
Bottom Line This highly durable boot is completely waterproof and great at insulating, though it's a bit too bulky to wear on low-snow days or during high-output activitiesThis boot is the epitome of comfort and warmth wrapped in a versatile, high-performing, waterproof packageThis well-priced boot hits all the marks with a winter-friendly design that maintains great traction, weatherproofing, and warmthGreat for winter hiking on slippery trails thanks to incredible traction, support, and weatherproofingOne of the most comfortable choices in our lineup, with a soft, heat-retentive interior and durable, waterproof exterior
Rating Categories Muck Boot Arctic Ic... UGG Adirondack III Merrell Thermo Chil... Keen Revel IV Polar... The North Face Shel...
Warmth (25%)
8.0
9.0
8.0
8.0
8.0
Weather Protection (25%)
9.0
8.0
7.0
7.0
7.0
Comfort And Fit (20%)
7.0
9.0
9.0
7.0
8.0
Durability (15%)
9.0
8.0
8.0
8.0
7.0
Traction (15%)
9.0
7.0
9.0
9.0
7.0
Specs Muck Boot Arctic Ic... UGG Adirondack III Merrell Thermo Chil... Keen Revel IV Polar... The North Face Shel...
Maximum Puddle Depth Before Major Leaking 16" 9" 6" 7" 7"
Measured Shaft Height (from bottom of sole to top of shaft) 16" 8" rolled / 10" extended 6" 7" 10"
Measured Weight (per pair, size 7) 4.59 lbs 2.36 lbs 1.79 lbs 2.41 lbs 2.25 lbs
Type of Boot Winter workwear All-around winter Winter hiking Winter hiking All-around winter
Fit Details Runs big True to size True to size True to size, wide True to size
Lining/Insulation Fleece UGGpure wool M Select Warm (200g) 200 grams KEEN.WARM Recycled PET Heatseeker Eco Pro (200g)
Removable Liner? No No No No No
Footbed bioDEWIX EVA Kinetic Fit BASE EVA OrthoLite
Upper Material Rubber Waterproof suede and leather Waterproof PU-coated leather and mesh Mesh and Leather Full-grain leather and ballistic nylon
Toe Box Rubber Rubber Rubber Leather Rubber
Outsole Vibram Arctic Grip A.T. Molded White Spider Rubber M Select GRIP KEEN.Polar Traction Surface Control rubber
Company Claimed Cold Weather Rating Not stated -32°C/-25°F Not stated -32°C/-25°F Not stated
Temp Change in Ice Bath -9.5 F -7.2 F -5.2 F -3.8 F -6.5 F
Animal Products? No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Sizes Available 5 - 11 5 - 12 5 - 11 5 - 12 5 - 11

Our Analysis and Test Results

The Arctic Ice Tall AG is impressively protective and waterproof. It is the tallest boot in our lineup, combining all the capabilities of a rain boot with the warmth of winterized footwear. It stands out as the most protective and driest option in our lineup, with the drawback of also being the heaviest. The price tag is high, but the functionality and versatility of this boot are unmatched by cheaper options. If you need durable construction that'll last throughout the years, be sure to look into this beast of a boot.

Performance Comparison


We took to romping around in frosty puddles to test the...
We took to romping around in frosty puddles to test the waterproofness of each boot.
Photo: Liz Chamberlain


Warmth


The Arctic Ice Tall stands out as one of the warmest in our review. The Muck Boot Company constructed the ultimate storm boot with fleece-lined and water-resistant insulation backed by 5mm of neoprene. The boot is designed to keep you warm in arctic-like temperatures — hence the name. We found that even with just a thin wool sock, it kept us warm when temperatures dipped well into the negatives.


The hefty rubber outsole measures nearly 2 inches at the heel and 1 inch beneath the toe, minimizing your foot's exposure to cold conditions. If you work as a lift operator or are planning an ice fishing trip --activities that require more standing around than moving-- these boots will keep your feet well insulated from the elements.

We liked tucking our pants into this tall boot to keep our lower...
We liked tucking our pants into this tall boot to keep our lower legs dry when working by the lake.
Photo: Rachel Dobronyi

We measured the boot's internal temperature change in an ice bucket test and found the temperature dropped 9.5 degrees Fahrenheit. This rating fell in the middle of the pack, meaning it wasn't the best or the worst in regards to heat retention. Despite the average results, we felt the overall coverage of the boot contributed to the Arctic Ice Tall keeping our feet warm over a long period in the outdoors.

These boots aren't the most stylish, but they are awesome for winter...
These boots aren't the most stylish, but they are awesome for winter chores like this.
Photo: Amber King

Weather Protection


Hands down, these are the most protective winter boots in our review. Built like a rain boot, the Arctic Ice Tall provides 16 inches of coverage from the sole. The boot's collar came up to roughly 2 inches below our main tester's knee. There is no fur or other fancy features on this boot, just straight business. The calf circumference measures 15 inches around, meaning lots of extra space to stuff leggings, Carhartts, or winter pants. The upper is quite stiff, so if you're not interested in the stuff-in method, you may prefer a lower boot that allows you to stretch winter pants over.


This boot feels like the snowplow of footwear. Burly materials and a thick construction repel water and snow no matter what winter activity you get into. We reached for this boot during both big rain days and larger snow dumps. When we couldn't get our truck up the driveway because the snow was too deep, these boots were our first choice to pair with the snowblower and get to work.

We grabbed the Arctic Ice when there was super deep snow to trudge...
We grabbed the Arctic Ice when there was super deep snow to trudge through. It is truly the perfect shoveling boot.
Photo: Liz Chamberlain

The boot's shaft is constructed of a double-down 5mm neoprene and rubber construction. This boot offered some of the best protection during our water tests, staying dry on the inside even when marching for two minutes in a river. If you live in an area that gets lots of snow or you want a boot that'll protect you as you tromp through wet fields or rivers, this is a great option.

These neoprene boots kept us completely dry.
These neoprene boots kept us completely dry.
Photo: Rachel Dobronyi

Comfort and Fit


The trade-off with this high-performing boot is in this category. Don't get us wrong, the Arctic Ice Tall isn't uncomfortable, but it is bulky, heavy, and hard to use for long periods without minor discomfort. Since the heel and outsole are so thick, it can feel like you're dragging an extra weight beneath your feet. As a result, if worn for a long period, it can cause some fatigue in the ankles, knees, or quads. For this reason, we would not recommend the Arctic Ice for recreational hiking or activities that require a flexible and lightweight construction. That said, if you get used to it, this renowned work boot can be worn throughout the day in poor weather.


The interior of the Arctic Ice is comfortable with a soft liner that makes it easy to slip in and out of. There are no fuzzy or furry components in this boot. Fortunately, the absence of fur does not equate to an absence of warmth. The fleece lining feels softer than felt and equally as warm. The fit is on the larger side compared to other boots we've tested, often requiring a thicker pair of socks — though we wouldn't necessarily suggest sizing up or down. At well over 2 pounds per boot, the weight is definitley also something to keep in mind.

While not the most plush boot, the Arctic Ice is still pretty cozy...
While not the most plush boot, the Arctic Ice is still pretty cozy and perfect for tasks like this one.
Photo: Amber King

An interesting observation to mention is how difficult it is to drive in this boot. It got caught under the pedals when driving a manual transmission truck. Even in an automatic vehicle, the sole is so thick it felt like driving in a ski boot. You have to lift your entire leg to transfer from one pedal to another.

Durability


One of the main reasons we recommend the Arctic Ice Tall to be used as a work boot is its durability. Neoprene is highly resistant to abrasions and is known to have a long lifespan, even in wet climates.


Neoprene and rubber are generally quite flexible and resistant to fading and deterioration from exposure to sun, wind, rain, and more. The outsole of this boot is so thick that it can naturally withstand heavy use under extreme conditions with no problems.

The Arctic Ice Tall dried super quickly after stomping around in...
The Arctic Ice Tall dried super quickly after stomping around in snow, mud, and puddles. Water is no match for rubber and neoprene.
Photo: Liz Chamberlain

Traction


If you plan on encountering icy terrain or slippery surfaces, you'll appreciate the aggressive traction of the Arctic Ice Tall. The lugs are thick and deep with an evenly dispersed pattern. Speckled lugs in the center channel have a slightly softer rubber compound which provides greater grip beneath the heel and the ball of the foot. This boot earns top marks in this category because it bites down on icy and hard-packed trails like a pro.


The Arctic Ice Tall has one of the best traction capabilities across various surfaces. This boot out-performed the soft and fluffy snow boots while boasting a comparable grip to the hiking boots. Several of the boots in our lineup use the Vibram Arctic Grip rubber compound, which is best for wet and icy conditions, though we feel the deep lug pattern on the Arctic Ice is the best.

The Vibram Arctic Grip rubber on the Arctic Ice Tall proved to be...
The Vibram Arctic Grip rubber on the Arctic Ice Tall proved to be unstoppable.
Photo: Liz Chamberlain

Value


If you're searching for a winter boot that is a protective warrior, you'll consider the investment of the Arctic Ice Tall worth it. While the price tag is high, you will undoubtedly get your money's worth thanks to the high quality and versatile design. The materials and craftsmanship are solid and should last you through many winter seasons. If you're traveling or working on cold or icy surfaces, the value is enhanced even further, and we think it's worth the price for its function.

Conclusion


This winter beast is built to withstand severe weather without blinking an eye. The tall neoprene and rubber construction looks more like a rainboot than a traditional winter boot, but don't be fooled. The Muck Boot Arctic Ice Tall AGAT is warm, completely waterproof, and super easy to kick on and off. It is a lot heavier and bulkier than most, but if you're seeking a boot that's durable and will work alongside you during the winter months, this protective winner is our best recommendation.

Puddle jump tests were a part of the testing process that helped us...
Puddle jump tests were a part of the testing process that helped us determine the level of the boots waterproofness. This particular boot very easily rose to the top.
Photo: Liz Chamberlain

Liz Chamberlain

Ad-free. Influence-free. Powered by Testing.

GearLab is founded on the principle of honest, objective, reviews. Our experts test thousands of products each year using thoughtful test plans that bring out key performance differences between competing products. And, to assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. No cherry-picked units sent by manufacturers. No sponsored content. No ads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing and comparison.

Learn More