The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of gear

Best Life Jackets of 2020

The NRS Vapor is a simplified paddling vest that's comfortable and works well.
By Maggie Brandenburg ⋅ Senior Review Editor
Tuesday July 7, 2020
  • Share this article:
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more

Need a life jacket? We researched 40+ of the best vests and purchased 14 to test side-by-side for 2020. With hundreds of options to choose from and dozens of outdoor activities for you to enjoy, we chose a range of jackets, from value buys and perfect paddle partners to fisherman's friends and options for your dog or kids. We paddled, floated, and frolicked in the water in these jackets, testing every model's components and ability to move. No matter if you're a pontoon partier or a solo SUPer, we've found the perfect life vest for you.

Related: The Best PFD of 2020

1

Best All-Around Life Jacket


Stohlquist Fit


Editors' Choice Award

$24.99
(17% off)
at Amazon
See It

Intended Use: Recreational | Entry Style: 3 front clips
Universal sizing
Top more accommodating for larger chests and women
Larger armholes are comfortable
Good strap management
Top strap harder to pull tight
Lots of seams around edges

The Stohlquist Fit is a "universal sized" life vest that is surprisingly comfortable on the range of sizes it manages to accommodate. Both large and small testers of all genders find this vest easy to wear and adjust to the right size. A thinner top section of the front side also allows it to bend more easily than many others, which most women will greatly appreciate. Where several other, similar jackets are too close and uncomfortably tight around the neck and collar bones, the Fit is just right. Relatively large armholes keep it decently comfortable and may be enough for you to take this on a short paddling trip as well. Numerous loops all the way around the vest also help keep strap tails out of the way, making your day that much more enjoyable.

However, for thinner individuals, the top strap's first containment loop is a bit too close to the buckle, making it more challenging to tighten completely. And while the jacket is thin enough to be comfortable leaning back in your boat, it's a bit on the long side for scrunched up postures like kayaking. This vest does come with a manufacturer's warranty against any defects, which we appreciate, as it's lined by protruding seams on every edge. Though it's unlikely to blow your Aqua Socks off, this simple design is comfortable and easy enough to ensure you'll actually be able to wear it all day.

The Stohlquist Fit is one of few universally sized PFDs that actually manages to be comfortable for a wide range of sizes!
The Stohlquist Fit is one of few universally sized PFDs that actually manages to be comfortable for a wide range of sizes!

2

Best Paddle Jacket


Astral V-Eight


Editors' Choice Award

$119.90
at Amazon
See It

Intended Use: Paddling | Entry Style: Front zip & 1 outer clip
Excellent breathability
Good mobility
Great strap management
Useful pockets
Durable
Back may be wide for narrow shoulders
Pockets are cumbersome when stuffed
Front a bit bulky

The Astral V-Eight is a super-versatile vest with just about everything we want in a paddle jacket. A high foam location on the back leaves the majority of the panel to be open, airy mesh — any paddler's dream. The front clip is on top of the foam paneling, avoiding that uncomfortably tight feeling from so many other vests after hours of sitting in a cramped cockpit. Spacious pockets will help you keep necessities close at hand while a thinner top section is greatly appreciated by our lady testers. A front zipper and side adjustments create a more even overall feel we love, and velcro sections on the shoulder straps hold those up and out of your business.

While the high back paneling works with most small watercraft seats, it is a bit obnoxious if you spend a lot of time swimming in this vest. It can also be a touch wide for narrow-shouldered folks, though it doesn't interfere with "normal" paddling maneuvers. Though we appreciate the versatility of the expandable pockets on the V-Eight, stuffing them totally full can become an obstacle for your inner arms. The front is also a bit on the thick, inflexible side, but we found ourselves quickly forgetting that the longer we wore it. For a paddle jacket that's comfortable and versatile, this one is our favorite.

Read the full review: Astral V-Eight

We love the comfort and versatility of the Astral V-Eight for a day out paddling.
We love the comfort and versatility of the Astral V-Eight for a day out paddling.

3

A Simple, Comfortable Paddle Vest


NRS Vapor



$79.95
at REI
See It

Intended Use: Paddling | Entry Style: Side entry, 2 side clips
Flexible fit
Great arm mobility
Very durable
Slightly less expensive
A bit long
No pockets
Full coverage is less breathable

This uniformly constructed jacket is a comfortable and simple solution for a full day of paddling. An even distribution of foam all around eliminates the added front-bulk of so many other paddle jackets. The NRS Vapor is made from several panels integrated together inside, which enhances the flexibility of the finished product. Side adjustment helps this vest be comfortable and uniformly secure and not too tight in any one place. Exceptionally large armholes essentially eliminate underarm paddle rash, and the interior fabric helps wick sweat that you work up while powering your boat.

If you've never once thought to yourself, "I could really use a pocket on this PFD," then this life jacket is right up your alley. It boasts a quality construction but not a single pocket or knife attachment anywhere. Depending on your stature, it may also be a bit longer in the torso than is ideal for kayaking. Additionally, it runs a bit large — folks on the lower end of the recommended chest size will have a harder time achieving a snug fit. And of course, the full coverage doesn't offer the same breathability as a vest with large mesh panels. Yet for a simple, comfortable, and effective paddle jacket, we're fans of this one.

Read the full review: NRS Vapor

Though it may not be covered in bells and whistles  the NRS Vapor is a comfortable paddle jacket that's easy to love.
Though it may not be covered in bells and whistles, the NRS Vapor is a comfortable paddle jacket that's easy to love.

4

Most Comfortable Fishing Vest


Astral Ronny


Top Pick Award

$99.95
at Amazon
See It

Intended Use: Fishing | Entry Style: Front zip
Comfortable fit
Good arm mobility
Back works with boat seats
Pockets are small
Closes with zipper only

The Astral Ronny is the most comfortable fishing vest we tested. Though the zipper-only front closure takes some extra and more frequent adjustment, once on and in place, it provides a comfortable and secure fit. The lack of buckles and clips, if you can get used to it, is exceptionally comfortable, eliminating the pressure points caused by individual straps. Narrow shoulder sections and large armholes help keep your arms free enough for fly fishing or paddling to your favorite fishing hole. The thinly padded back works well with boat seatbacks, and vented sections in numerous places provide breathability.

However, if you're the kind of fishing fanatic who loves to keep half a tackle box's worth of gear in your PFD pockets, the Ronny will likely not be enough. It's three pockets are rather small, and fairly specific. It only has one, very minimal general-use pocket. The largest one is designed to fit a radio, and the third is a pop-out drink holder. We also read numerous user complaints about the snap on the VHF radio pocket breaking after a season of use, and though this didn't happen to us, we read too many testimonies to ignore it completely. At the end of the day, unless you're in need of massive, versatile pockets, the comfort of the Ronny is sure to keep you happy even if the fish aren't biting.

We love the comfort and fit of the Astral Ronny. Though it has minimal pockets  it does have one just for holding your beverage!
We love the comfort and fit of the Astral Ronny. Though it has minimal pockets, it does have one just for holding your beverage!

5

Most Comfortable for Kiddos


O'Neill Child Reactor USGC



$59.95
(8% off)
at Amazon
See It

Intended Use: Children 30-50lb | Entry Style: Front zip, 2 clips, leg strap
Soft material on skin
Buckle covers help prevent rubbing
Very flexible foam
Not very adjustable
Less breathable

This child's vest feels like a dream against the skin. The O'Neill Child Reactor is made of soft, hydroprene material that, while a bit heavy, is exceptionally comfortable. The entire vest is flexible rather than stiff, with segmented foam panels inside that let your kid still be a kid. A front zipper helps to give even more security without compromising Junior's ability to scream about how much he loves this life jacket. The tops of the shoulders lack foam, making it easy to do whatever stroke (or best attempts) your child is comfortable with. A loop on top of the jacket also makes it easier to grab and hoist your child with one hand, if the need arises.

While the sides have expandable panels, they only expand so far, making this vest not a great fit for girthier children. Those panels also mean it's not as breathable as an open-sided design. The leg strap isn't as long as some of the others we tested, making it less conducive to kids who are sprouting straight up like beanstalks. The armholes could be larger — keep in mind that they might be a source of inner arm rash for some children. Though this vest may not fit larger kids, if it does fit, it's an exceptionally comfortable option to wear.

6

Best Flotation for Dogs


Ruffwear Float Coat



$79.95
at REI
See It

Intended Use: Dogs | Entry Style: Over-the-head, 2 bottom clips
Exceptional flotation
Secure fit
No loose ends
Coverage is less breathable
Stiff

The Ruffwear Float Coat is a full-coverage life vest for your dog. While every dog is a different shape and proportion, the Float Coat comes in six sizes so you can find the best fit. Foam paneling extends not just on Fido's back, but around the neck and under the chest as well. This extra security helps even the densest dogs float without compromising their leg range of motion for swimming. Cleverly concealed buckles keep straps and clips from pinching, and velcro bands secure loose ends. A sturdy handle on the back lets you help even the largest dogs out of the water more easily. Abrasion-resistant fabric and robust construction give this doggie life jacket an extra boost of durability.

For a dog who's timid around water or one who will swim for hours on end, the flotation and comfort of this vest are ideal. However, the extra coverage — and the thickness and stiffness of that coverage — make the Float Coat not particularly breathable. If your dog spends more time enjoying the water from inside the boat or on the shore, this added warmth might be too much for a hot summer's day. And if you're into pockets, the Float Coat has none. This doggy jacket is optimal for a dog who spends a lot of time in the water and could use the impressive flotation it provides.

The Ruffwear Float Coat provides buoyancy on top AND underneath your dog  for extra security.
The Ruffwear Float Coat provides buoyancy on top AND underneath your dog, for extra security.

7

Best for SUP


NRS Zephyr


Top Pick Award

$100 List
List Price
See It

Intended Use: Paddling | Entry Style: Waist belt, inflatable
Comfortable belt
Easy to use and repack
Bonus pocket
Bulkier than some inflatables
A bit stiff

If you're a confident swimmer, but still need something to wear on your paddleboard to keep you legal and safe, the NRS Zephyr is ideal. This inflatable belt features a wide strap with soft padding behind the main pack. The pull tab is off-center, to help it not get caught between your legs. It inflates quickly when triggered and is easily rearmed with a common, relatively inexpensive 16g CO2 canister. While not all inflatable manufacturers carefully consider the comfort and fit of the bloated bladder, the Zephyr has a long neck strap that's easy to don and adjust to your height even as you flounder in the water.

Though this belt pack is a bit beefier and stiffer than some competitors, the comforting hip protection panel and clever strap management have us quickly forgetting we're wearing it. The tiny pocket isn't the most useful but will fit a (waterproof) car key and a tube of SPF lip balm. It's also recommended to be refilled with a whole kit that includes a little green plastic tab, indicating through the window that it's ready for use. Unfortunately, that tab is flung into the water when inflated, contributing trash to the ecosystem. Fortunately, you can rearm it with just a new cylinder, but the red "not ready" status on the front may have you second-guessing if you remembered to do so. All of this aside, anytime we want to do some serene SUPing, the Zephyr is still our top choice to wear.

Read the full review: NRS Zephyr

It's important to remember that inflatable flotation devices, like the NRS Zephyr, are intended only for very confident swimmers. Though it may be tempting to wear this minimal belt on a hot day, if you aren't a strong swimmer, this type of device is not enough to keep you safe.

Keeping your torso totally free while you SUP is easy with the NRS Zephyr.
Keeping your torso totally free while you SUP is easy with the NRS Zephyr.

8

Most Comfortable for Dogs


NRS CFD



$45 List
List Price
See It

Intended Use: Dogs | Entry Style: 1 neck and 2 bottom clips
Breathable design
Wide, comfortable straps
Large pockets
Less secure fit
Less flotation

With all the foam flotation panels concentrated on your dog's back, the NRS CFD (Canine Flotation Device) leaves the sides and chest open. This extra breathability is excellent for hot days, especially if your dog isn't getting into the water so much to cool off. The straps wrapping under Lucky's chest and stomach are wide and soft, and buckle on the foam backing, ensuring that no clip tugs on your dog's fur. Such an open design on the bottom is also much more comfortable for dogs to sit and lie down happily compared to a full-coverage doggie vest. The CFD also has a single, large zippered pocket that's great for stashing waterproof items like poop bags or a leash.

However, this flotation concentration on just your dog's back does put a large damper on the vest's overall effectiveness. With straps so close together, it's difficult to get a very secure fit, leaving the back end of the jacket rather loose. If your dog loves to swim, is tackling big waves or swiftly moving water, the small amount of flotation provided by this loose-fitting back panel isn't going to be much help. However, if your dog enjoys hanging out on the boat all day or lounging on the beach, with occasional forays into the water, the extra comfort and breathability of this vest are sure to be appreciated in the hot sun.

9

Great Value for a Kids Jacket


Stearns Child Hydroprene


Best Buy Award

$35.05
(12% off)
at Amazon
See It

Intended Use: Children 30-50lb | Entry Style: Front zip, 2 clips, leg strap
Softer material
Zippered front
Inexpensive
Leg strap off to the side
Not much room to grow

The Stearns Child Hydroprene is a solidly comfortable jacket that's less expensive than most similar models. Made of hydroprene material, this vest is comfortable against the skin without requiring a swim shirt. The front zipper helps create a more evenly snug fit, rather than squeezing your child's chest between narrow straps. Paneled sides stop the security straps from rubbing against your child's skin while they play the day away in the water. And though it's not the most comfortable child's vest we tested, compared to other hydroprene models, it's extremely affordable.

That being said, some of the details of this vest are less impressive. The leg strap is oddly quite far off to one side of the jacket, rather than centered as we want it to be. It's also not as flexible and not quite as soft as other hydroprene models we tested. And while we think the zippered center does a great job achieving a more even, comfortable fit, this lack of expansion — along with a slightly shorter leg strap — makes it less adaptable to children with greater circumferences or taller torsos. Despite these small shortcomings on some of its details, we think the Stearns is a great value for what you get.

The Stearn's Child Hydroprene is a great value for a comfortable kids jacket  though the leg strap is farther to one side than we'd prefer.
The Stearn's Child Hydroprene is a great value for a comfortable kids jacket, though the leg strap is farther to one side than we'd prefer.

10

Great Organization for Fishing


NRS Chinook



$139.95
at REI
See It

Intended Use: Fishing | Entry Style: Front zip & 1 inner clip
Vented back panel
Large, versatile pockets
Good strap management
Velcro strips on shoulders may catch shirt
Back panel fit is difficult

This fairly comfortable life jacket is breathable and pleasant to wear, with large pockets to keep your tackle close. An openly-designed back panel concentrates the inner foam at the top of your back, letting your sweaty lower back be enclosed by just mesh. It also works well for nearly any low seatback in a fishing kayak. Velcro tabs on the shoulders keep your strap tails in check, and an extra clip at the bottom of the vest makes it easy to unzip the front and relax as you take a break for lunch. Flip-top pockets are decently sized and versatile enough for you to implement your personal organizational style, while a VHF radio attachment and rod holder keep your hands free to paddle.

Though we like the extra utility of the bottom clip on the inside of this vest, it digs into the stomach a bit while paddling. The upper foam section of the back panel also can be challenging to get to lay flat against your back, floating up when you're in the water and bobbing awkwardly behind you even when you're not. And though we appreciate the extra breathability from the half mesh back panel, the tightened adjustment straps dig into the body unpleasantly. We also had some issues with the velcro strap management strips on the shoulders snagging shirt shoulders while casting, pilling the fabric. That said, the NRS Chinook is still an overall solid choice for kayaking fisherfolk who dig extra breathability and appreciate larger pockets.

11

Comfortable Recreational Coverage


O'Neill Superlite USCG



$37.24
(7% off)
at Amazon
See It

Intended Use: Recreational | Entry Style: 4 front clips
Comfortable fit and adjustability
More pleasant fabric feel
Very flexible
Smaller armholes
Coverage can feel excessive on some

The O'Neill Superlite is solidly comfortable to wear all day long — as long as you don't need an extreme range of motion (like for paddling). The entire thing is made of thinner, flexible foam covered in pleasant ripstop nylon that's easy to wear right against your skin. Four very wide buckles gathered around the waist make it easy to wear tightly without restricting the lungs. It comes in six sizes and a women's specific version, letting you purchase exactly the one you need and not worry about those loosey-goosey tails flopping about.

But if you're hoping to do a little paddling in your life jacket, this one isn't the best option. It has much smaller armholes and extensive coverage that isn't conducive to sweating in a cramped kayak. However, if you're on the hunt for a seriously comfortable vest to wear all day on the pontoon party boat, then the O'Neill is a superb choice.

12

Best Bang for your Buck


Stearns Adult Classic


Best Buy Award

$26.09
at Amazon
See It

Intended Use: Recreational | Entry Style: 3 front clips
Universally sized
Reasonable arm mobility
Inexpensive
A bit stiff
On the larger side
Durability concerns

The Stearns Adult Classic is an impressively inexpensive vest that just works. Its universal sizing make it a great choice for a back-up jacket when your friends or family want to join you on the water. It's a solid performer with armholes large enough to be comfortable and mobile for all the normal movements you'd do hanging out on your boat. While many other cheap contenders tend to be too close and tight on the neck, this one maintains an appropriate distance.

This vest is a bit stiffer across the chest than others, which can make it more challenging, especially for women, to comfortably wear all day. Also, if you're not careful, the straps may slip off the back of the foam, but can easily be readjusted to avoid that discomfort. This isn't a knockout when it comes to durability, but it's not terrible either. And for the price, it's less devastating when you do need to replace it. If you're looking to stick to a budget or want to have an extra life jacket around for company, this is a solid choice.

The Stearn's Adult Classic is a solid universal vest that's inexpensive  making it a great back-up option to keep around for when friends come calling.
The Stearn's Adult Classic is a solid universal vest that's inexpensive, making it a great back-up option to keep around for when friends come calling.

13

Room to Grow for Little Ones


MTI Adventurewear Child Livery



$39.95
at Amazon
See It

Intended Use: Children 30-50lb | Entry Style: 3 front clips, leg strap
Longer leg strap
Fits wider children
More breathable
Less comfortable feel
Construction isn't impressive

Though it's certainly less elegant than some of its competitors, the MTI Child Livery isn't without its merits. Open sides aid in breathability on a hot day and long straps help accommodate children of all proportions. A longer leg strap makes this model a better fit for taller children as well, and a handle on top makes it easier to lift your child to safety if needed. Alternating buckle colors help ensure you're clipping everything in the right place — even if your child doesn't want to sit still while you do it.

Compared to the soft, pliable hydroprene contenders, the more traditional-feeling fabric on this vest just doesn't quite live up. The back panel is also a bit disproportionately wide for some children, hitting uncomfortably against their arms. The open sides, while breathable, provide an opportunity for the straps to rub directly on your kid's skin if they're not wearing a swim shirt. And though this is one of the lightest child vests we tested, its sloppy seams and thin materials don't give us a ton of confidence in its durability. But if your child is taller, thicker, or growing quickly, the added adjustability of the Livery may be exactly what you need.

14

Unique Work Stations for Fishing


Stohlquist Fisherman



$129.95
at REI
See It

Intended Use: Fishing | Entry Style: Front zip
Fold-out work stations
Tall back for boating
Pockets are bulky even when empty
Shoulders are less comfortable

The Stohlquist Fisherman is an alright jacket with unique pockets that fold out into flat work stations. These pockets have several straps and tabs inside to keep extra flies and jigs, as well as swap them out as needed. The main draw to this vest is these very unique pockets, but they kind of take over the aesthetic of the whole jacket. It also features a half-mesh back for easy use in small watercraft seats and added breathability.

The shoulder straps are a bit wide for narrow users and far too scratchy to enjoy wearing over bare skin. The unique pockets are also quite protruding, no matter if they're stuffed to the brim or completely empty. They easily get in the way of intense paddling, making this vest, not our favorite for fishing from a kayak. However, if the idea of having a small workspace attached to your body everywhere you go appeals to you, for sure give this jacket a look.

For a dog who doesn't need much help in the water  the NRS CFD provides a little extra flotation on top  without restricting movement or breathability.
For a dog who doesn't need much help in the water, the NRS CFD provides a little extra flotation on top, without restricting movement or breathability.

Why You Should Trust Us


This review is headed by life-long water-lover Maggie Brandenburg and includes a wide swath of her friends and family, and even her dog, to help test and provide feedback on this army of life jackets. Maggie has been paddling for 25+ years, from the completion of an ACA canoe touring program in high school to working as a whitewater rafting and kayaking guide for 4 years and an ocean kayak guide for another year. She's guided thousands of water lovers on hundreds of adventures over the last 15 years. Ever a staple on her adventures, Maggie's 11-year-old dog, Madeline, helps test gear too, from inflatable kayaks to dog beds to this current selection of dog life vests.

To test these flotation devices, we wore them for hours on end, paddling across lakes and taking dips in ponds. For weeks, we evaluated each model on fit, comfort, and mobility. We checked out pockets and special features to assess versatility. We snapped snaps, clipped clips, and zipped zippers, all the while examining durability. We wore each model next to the water, in boats, in swimming pools, and in the blazing sun. By comparing every jacket side-by-side, we teased apart the best and worst parts of each to present to you our findings and help you find the best fit for your body and your preferred water activity.

This inflatable is one of the simplest and easiest to rearm for next time and pack away.

Analysis and Test Results


We evaluated every vest's performance in four different metrics to get an overall picture of how each measures up. We tested their comfort by wearing them with and without a shirt, in a boat, and under the hot sun. We evaluated their fit and tested adjustment points, comparing them to who they say they fit. We paid particular attention to how different shapes of adult, child, or dog fit into each vest. We judged each jacket's mobility in the water and out, examining armholes, movement, and adaptability while trying to swim, paddle, fish, and enjoy life on and in the water. To assess versatility, we considered the activities each is made and advertised for and which ones they're actually good at. Can you wear a fishing vest paddling; would you want to? We looked at every feature each model has, used them, and evaluated how helpful they are. We also scrutinized each PFD's durability, considering their construction and materials, putting them through the wringer in scummy ponds and on abrasive sand, and scouring the internet for other user complaints. The combination of all four of these metrics provides a thorough, honest picture of each vest's strengths and weaknesses.

Who Needs a Life Vest?


Wearing a life vest isn't just a smart idea, in the US it's legally required for there to be a properly fitting, US Coast Guard approved flotation device for every single person on a recreational boat. And though (if you're above a certain age) you don't technically have to wear said vest to comply with the law, according to the US Coast Guard and the American Boating Association, more than 2/3 of boating fatalities and over 90% of drownings happen when the victim isn't wearing a life jacket. That's right: if you're thinking that having your PFD just an arms reach away is enough to keep you safe, the stats show that in over half of all drowning cases, the victim had access to a life vest on board, but chose not to wear one. Every dangerous activity has it's life-saving safety equipment — from football helmets to car seatbelts — so why wouldn't you wear one?

Above all else, the number one question you should ask yourself when considering purchasing a PFD is, "will I actually wear this?" After all, if you aren't comfortable in your vest, you aren't likely to be wearing it when you find yourself in a life or death situation. As the US Coast Guard bluntly states, "the best life jacket is the one you will wear."

To make sure your jacket is as comfortable and safe as possible, be certain to check the sizing before you pull out your credit card. Just like buying a new shirt, sizes across different styles and manufacturers are close but not the same. And unlike a shirt, wearing a life vest that's too small or large for you could leave you lethally exposed. Most PFD sizes are listed as an inch measurement, taken around the largest part of your chest. This is true for adult jackets and dog vests, but for children (or anyone under 90lb), sizing depends entirely on weight. Buying a life vest also isn't the time to aspirationally purchase a size smaller — this equipment is meant to save your life, but can't do so if it doesn't fit.

Finding the right size and fit of a life jacket is critical to being comfortable wearing it all day.
Finding the right size and fit of a life jacket is critical to being comfortable wearing it all day.

What Kind of Activities Make You Excited?


To figure out what kind of life jacket you should get, think about what you're planning to do on the water. Are you a deep-sea fisherman heading out to snag your catch of the day? Are you a solitude seeker, taking your paddleboard out on the lake for some peace and quiet? Did your friends just buy a powerboat, and you're planning an all-day Labor Day celebration? There are many specific designs of PFDs to choose from, and quite a few that are versatile enough to be used for several different activities. Keep your personal aspirations in mind as you read further to select your ideal flotation device.

Are you ready to hit the water? Having the right PFD can make all the difference.
Are you ready to hit the water? Having the right PFD can make all the difference.

Adjusting Your Vest


Once you've selected your jacket, make sure you're wearing it properly. An unzipped, loosely fitted jacket can easily come off your body as your boat tips over, you fall overboard, or even just in the current of the water while swimming. You'll need to adjust your vest every time you put it on — or put it on your child or canine companion. The basics of which are boiled down to a singular idea: If you can yank the jacket up over your head, it's not tight enough. This applies to yourself, your friends, your dog, and your children. The specifics of adjusting will depend on the vest you're wearing, but if you give it a serious tug and it slides upwards, it's not adjusted properly.

Boating and General On-Water Recreation


Hitching a ride on a party barge or taking the speedboat out for a Sunday spin? If relaxing is your gig, you're likely on the lookout for a general recreation vest. These vests tend to be simple, with very few frills — and often less expensive too. Some things to keep in mind while considering different models are the neck and arm areas and the bottom strap. Many vests have narrow necks and small armholes, both of which reduce breathability and are significantly less comfortable to wear. Similarly, if the bottom strap of the jacket is too close to the bottom of the foam panels, it's more likely to slip off and rub directly against your skin — ouch.

In addition to the numerous jackets listed here, we also tested two other generic life vests, the MTI Adventurewear Livery Sport and the Onyx Adult General Purpose. While each of these jackets may seem on par with the competition, we found both of them to be significantly less comfortable and comparatively unpleasant to wear. The MTI Livery Sport is shockingly short, uncomfortably stiff, and not particularly breathable. The Onyx General Purpose rides far too close to the neck to be comfortable, and the bottom strap continually slides off the back of the jacket while you wear it. We can honestly say we're disappointed in the performances of these two vests.

We tested several models for general use. The Stohlquist Fit is thin and flexible with easily adjustable straps and universal sizing. It's comfortable to wear and actually does a solid job accommodating the wide range of sizes its "universal" designation claims to. The Stearns Adult Classic isn't quite as impressively accommodating but is still reasonably comfortable and adjustable — and less expensive, making this universal vest a great value. The O'Neill Superlite is very comfortable. It's exceptionally thin and flexible, with four wide buckles located lower on the torso, giving a much more even, relaxed fit. However, it also is less breathable and has smaller arm openings, restricting easy movement. It comes in specific sizes, which makes it even more comfortable to wear if it's your personal vest, but is less ideal as a guest PFD or highly-adjustable back-up option.

General purpose recreational vests lack many of the frills that more specific jackets have  but are also simple  easy to use  and often much cheaper.
General purpose recreational vests lack many of the frills that more specific jackets have, but are also simple, easy to use, and often much cheaper.

Paddling Jackets


If you're ready to head out on the water under your own power, having full range of motion of your arms and increased breathability while you stroke and feather are two of the most important factors. Paddle jackets often have narrower shoulder sections, integrated mesh panels, and some of the largest arm openings. Many also concentrate all the foam flotation on the back to the top of the vest to completely avoid interfering with the low seatback of most paddle-powered boats. They may also have varying pockets for specific purposes — from keeping a granola bar close at hand to warming your hands from the cold whitewater or even keeping your emergency knife easily accessible.

While we've done an even more in-depth analysis of paddle jackets, we tested a few here that stand out from the crowd. The Astral V-Eight is an exceptionally comfortable, breathable, versatile, and durable vest. With mesh paneling in all the right places, useful pockets, and a fit that works well when crunched into a kayak cockpit, there's a lot we love about this well-thought-out jacket.

The NRS Vapor is a simplified paddle vest that offers comfort and security without all the bells and whistles. It has even padding all over and perfectly placed adjustment straps that help you quickly forget you're even wearing a life vest. With no extra pockets or attachments, you can stay sleek and mobile in this uncomplicated vest. If you're a confident swimmer looking for a flotation device for your SUP, we recommend the NRS Zephyr. This inflatable waist belt is exceptionally comfortable, liberating to wear, and our choice for SUP-ing. And when you do need to pull the tab and use the bladder, a long adjustable neck strap makes it easier to put on, even mid-panic.

Comfortable as a belt and adjustable once inflated  the NRS Zephyr is our favorite inflatable PFD.
Comfortable as a belt and adjustable once inflated, the NRS Zephyr is our favorite inflatable PFD.

Fishing Vests


The one thing that all fishing vests have in common is pockets. Some have a few modest pockets for small items, while others seem to be nothing but pockets. Whatever your pocket preference, it's still most important to have a comfortable jacket that you'll actually want to put on.

We tested three fishing jackets with very different pockets and quite a range of comfort too. The Astral Ronny is the most comfortable of the bunch, with a zipper that creates an even, snug fit, and clever mesh panels integrated throughout to increase breathability. However, it also has the smallest, most specific pockets of the models we tested. One pocket is designed for a VHF radio, one is specifically a cup holder, and just one small pocket remains for general use.

The Astral Ronny is the most comfortable fishing jacket we tested.
The Astral Ronny is the most comfortable fishing jacket we tested.

The NRS Chinook has the adjustment straps running straight across the back, making it significantly less comfortable. It does have a cleverly hidden inner clip that will keep the vest attached even when unzipped — though this also slightly detracts from overall comfort, as the plastic clip digs into the belly. The Chinook's pockets are decently sized and fairly versatile, allowing you to keep far more things on your person than the Ronny. The Stohlquist Fisherman is the least comfortable fishing model of the three. It's exceptionally bulky in front, with hardened pockets sticking out that make it even more so. The shoulder straps are particularly scratchy. Yet it has some of the most unique pockets we've seen, that fold out at 90-degree angles to create mini workstations, right on your abdomen. For fly fishers or folks constantly changing out gear on their fishing lines, this built-in workspace could be a dream come true.

Though a bit protrusive  the Stohlquist Fisherman's mobile workstation pockets may be exactly what you're looking for.
Though a bit protrusive, the Stohlquist Fisherman's mobile workstation pockets may be exactly what you're looking for.

Child Life Jackets


When it comes to finding the right jacket for your kids, the rules of sizing are slightly different. Rather than measuring your child's chest circumference, vests are sized by weight. This is incredibly important to get right, as the various sizes offer different buoyancy ratings. If you're putting a 53lb child in a jacket designed for kids 30-50lb, they're not going to float very well. The lighter jacket doesn't offer the same flotation power as one made for 50+lb kids. Yet, as any parent knows, just because two children each weigh 40lb doesn't mean they're the same height or girth. This adds an extra layer of difficulty in finding the right kids' vest, as some are less accommodating for taller or thicker children.

Additionally, younger children tend to be differently proportioned to most adults. With narrow shoulders, thin chests, and a center of gravity that's usually somewhere behind their belly buttons, it can be difficult to secure a life jacket onto a child. The normal rule of yanking it upwards to see if it comes off almost always results in exactly that outcome, simply because of the shape of young children compared to adults. This is why a life jacket with a leg strap is so important for kids. That extra strap makes sure the jacket can't come sliding up over their ears and off their heads. At the same time, it necessarily straps under a fairly sensitive area of the body, creating a delicate balance between being snug enough to stay put without being so snug it causes discomfort or a rash.

Using the top handle to hoist your child out of the water only works if the life jacket is properly fitted.
Using the top handle to hoist your child out of the water only works if the life jacket is properly fitted.

We tested three children's PFDs, all with leg straps. The O'Neill Child Reactor is the most comfortable option of those three. It's made of soft hydroprene with pliable paneling for easy movement. A zipper and two straps help give it even security, making it more comfortable. However, it's also a full jacket, with stretchy but closed sides, which is less ideal for thicker kids. It also doesn't have as long of a leg strap as some others, which rules out very tall children as well. The Stearns Child Hydroprene is very similar in its construction and size limitations. It's not quite as soft and flexible as the O'Neill, but is still impressively comfortable. Combined with a much lower price than most similarly-composed models, the Stearns is a great value for kids. The MTI Child Livery doesn't have the same silky hydroprene material, but it does have open sides and longer straps, making it much easier to fit on taller and wider children that are still within the weight limit.

You can practically see how soft a hydroprene jacket  like the Stearns Child Hydroprene  is.
You can practically see how soft a hydroprene jacket, like the Stearns Child Hydroprene, is.

Dog Life Jackets


To choose the right life vest for your dog, you should start by knowing your dog — what are his abilities and interests? Does your dog love to swim? Does he revel in leaping off the end of a dock or spending hours retrieving a floating toy? Is your dog an experienced swimmer, comfortable around water? Or perhaps is your dog not at all interested in getting in the water but likes to join your paddleboard/kayak/boating adventures? If any of that sounds like your dog, it's best to prioritize the comfort and breathability of Fido's jacket. A confident swimmer likely doesn't need as much flotation but will appreciate a more comfortable design to paddle around in. A non-swimmer will similarly welcome added comfort and breathability as he/she lounges on a warm boat deck or in the front of your hot kayak. The NRS CFD is just such a jacket. It concentrates all foam on the dog's back, with wide straps holding the jacket around the body and neck. It's more open design is less secure but allows greater breathability and extra comfort for avid swimmers and nappers alike.

The NRS CFD is quite breathable and comfortable - and has one large pocket to keep your dog's belongings close at hand.
The NRS CFD is quite breathable and comfortable - and has one large pocket to keep your dog's belongings close at hand.

Or perhaps your dog is nervous around water, not wanting to go in deeper than his chest. Maybe your dog is enthusiastic about water but inexperienced. Or perhaps your dog loves water but isn't particularly buoyant — pugs, for example, are well-known for having a hard time staying afloat. Maybe your dog is an excellent, experienced swimmer, but is SO enthusiastic that he will chase the ball into the waves all day, to the point of exhaustion. Or perhaps you plan on taking your dog through some big waves or rough waters, like on a whitewater or ocean expedition. If any of that sounds like your dog, a jacket with extra flotation is a great choice. It can add confidence for a dog who's nervous (or an owner who's nervous!) and extra safety for dogs who refuse to give up swimming or have a harder time keeping their noses above the water. The Ruffwear Float Coat is our choice for flotation. Buoyant foam wraps underneath the torso and around the neck, keeping your dog afloat no matter how long they want to swim.

The Ruffwear Float Coat provides extra flotation underneath your dog - ideal for dogs who are nervous in the water or will swim until they're exhausted.
The Ruffwear Float Coat provides extra flotation underneath your dog - ideal for dogs who are nervous in the water or will swim until they're exhausted.

Every dog is a different size and shape, which can make it challenging to know if you've got the right fit. No matter what jacket you ultimately decide to use, there are a few tips and tricks to ensure your dog's safety in the water. First, make sure it's tight enough. Most doggie life vests have a top handle to grab — be sure the vest is tight enough that you can lift your dog with it. And just like you would for a human vest, yank the top forward toward your dog's head to make sure it won't slip off in the water.

Check and Recheck
Unlike your friend or your child, your dog can't tell you when their life jacket is too tight or too loose, or when they're getting too hot. Any time your dog is in a life vest, constantly check how tight it is and carefully monitor your dog's heat levels while wearing these thick garments.

Next, make sure it's loose enough. This can sound contradictory to the first point, but if the jacket is too tight, your dog won't be able to breathe, may overheat, or could even develop painful hot spots — and they can't tell you about any of it. Check around the ribs — you should still be able to fit several fingers under the straps when your dog is breathing in. Ask yourself how you would feel with that level of tightness. Especially look both behind and in front of Fido's front legs, to check for potential rubbing spots. Before getting out on the water, recheck all of this with your dog standing, sitting, and lying down — and continue rechecking periodically throughout your adventure, especially when Lucky gets in and out of the water. The goal is to find the range in between being too loose and too tight. At the end of the day, constant rechecking is critical.

Keep your dog safe around the water with the right life jacket for his abilities.
Keep your dog safe around the water with the right life jacket for his abilities.

Conclusion


While a life jacket isn't on just about anyone's list of Top Ten Favorite Clothing Items to Wear, it is an absolutely essential piece of gear for any day out on the water. Finding a PFD that's comfortable and lets you do what you want while wearing it will go a long way toward your enjoyment of safe boating and floating fun. No matter what your aquatic adventures look like, we hope this article helps you figure out which life vest is the best choice for you and your loved ones.

Enjoy the water safely and confidently in whatever life jacket you decide to wear.
Enjoy the water safely and confidently in whatever life jacket you decide to wear.

Maggie Brandenburg