The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of outdoor gear

Tubbs Mountaineer - Women's Review

This well-rounded snowshoe is a pleasure to use and has all the features needed for a day out in some serious snow.
Editors' Choice Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:  $270 List | $269.95 at REI
Compare prices at 2 resellers
Pros:  Excellent flotation, great traction, easy to use bindings, comfortable, pleasant to walk in no matter the terrain
Cons:  On the heavy side, don't pack down as flat as other models, pricey
Manufacturer:   Tubbs
By Penney Garrett ⋅ Senior Review Editor  ⋅  Oct 22, 2019
  • Share this article:
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more
90
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#1 of 10
  • Flotation - 30% 9
  • Traction - 25% 9
  • Stride Ergonomics - 15% 9
  • Ease of Use - 10% 9
  • Binding Security - 10% 9
  • Binding Comfort - 10% 9

Our Verdict

The Tubbs Mountaineer is a joy to wear. It performed excellently across all of our test metrics, securing its place as our Editors' Choice winner. From its fantastic flotation and bomber traction to its comfortable and easy to use bindings, this snowshoe has it all. It's on the heavier side, and the bindings don't compress down as flat for transport as other designs, but all was forgiven as soon as we were floating happily on deep snow drifts and hiking up icy slopes. For a fantastic all-around technical shoe, this is an excellent choice.

While we love the Mountaineer for almost everything, we still think the MSR Lightning Ascent is a better purchase for highly advanced objectives. Their bindings are more versatile, their traction a bit grippier, and they are a full pound lighter. And if you need to cut the price tag in half, be sure to read about the MSR Evo, our Best Buy for Versatility.

Product Updated

Tubbs has some new binding technology for this snowshoe. Find out more below.

October 2019


Compare to Similar Products

 
Awards Editors' Choice Award Top Pick Award    
Price $269.95 at REI
Compare at 2 sellers
$299.95 at Amazon
Compare at 2 sellers
$143.45 at Amazon
Compare at 2 sellers
$149.93 at REI$151.54 at Amazon
Overall Score Sort Icon
100
0
90
100
0
85
100
0
83
100
0
79
100
0
77
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros Excellent flotation, great traction, easy to use bindings, comfortable, pleasant to walk in no matter the terrainSuperior traction, heel lifts for steep terrain, easy to use, men's and women's versions, add-on flotation tail compatibleGood traction and flotation, excellent binding system, heel lift, affordableGreat traction, Boa binding system, comfortable binding, easy walking, quietExcellent traction, comfortable bindings, fantastic stride ergonomics
Cons On the heavy side, don't pack down as flat as other models, priceyExpensive, binding straps flop around, bindings take longer to get intoA bit heavy, tail flips up a lot of snow, toe shape feels a little wideBoa system is more finicky and less repairable than a strap system, on the heavier sideBinding system potentially isn't secure, doesn't float well unless you're very light
Bottom Line This well-rounded snowshoe is a pleasure to use and has all the features needed for a day out in some serious snow.This is a serious snowshoe for people that want superior traction and versatility while out in steep and variable backcountry terrain.This is a well-rounded and solidly performing snowshoe fit for all kinds of terrain and objectives.This is a well-performing snowshoe with great traction suitable for many different kinds of terrain and snow.This is a comfortable snowshoe with fantastic traction and great stride ergonomics for women.
Rating Categories Tubbs Mountaineer - Women's Lightning Ascent Atlas Elektra Montane Louis Blizzard II Tubbs Flex RDG - Women's
Flotation (30%)
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
6
Traction (25%)
10
0
9
10
0
10
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
9
Stride Ergonomics (15%)
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
9
Ease Of Use (10%)
10
0
9
10
0
7
10
0
9
10
0
7
10
0
8
Binding Security (10%)
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
9
10
0
7
10
0
7
Binding Comfort (10%)
10
0
9
10
0
7
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
8
Specs Tubbs Mountaineer... Lightning Ascent Atlas Elektra... Louis Blizzard II Tubbs Flex RDG -...
Uses Mountain terrain Mountain and technical terrain Mountain and technical terrain Day hiking, variable rolling terrain Day hiking, mountain terrain
Optimum weight loads (per size) 21": 80-150 lbs, 25": 120-200 lbs, 30": 170-250lbs 22": 180 lbs, 25":120-210 lbs 23": 80-160 lbs, 27": 120-200+ lbs 22": 80-160 lbs, 25": 100-200 lbs 80-150 lbs
Weight (per pair) 21": 4.3 lbs, 25": 4.8 lbs, 30": 4.9 lbs 22": 3.56 lbs, 25": 3.75 lbs 23": 4.26 lbs, 27": 4.36 lbs 22": 4.2 lbs, 25": 4.4 lbs 3.5 lbs
Binding mount Full Full Fixed Full Full
Binding system ActivFit binding PosiLock AT bindings Wrapp Swift binding Boa binding CustomWrap binding featuring the Boa Closure System
Crampon Anaconda toe & Python heel crampons Powder-coated steel Torsion2 crampons All-trac toe crampon Traxion HCS front crampon & V-rail crampon Traction rails and carbon steel toe crampon
Frame material Aluminum 7000-series aluminum Aluminum V-frame 6061-T6 Aluminum ErgoStream Plastic frame and decking with steel traction rails
Deck material SoftTec decking Urethane-impregnated nylon Nytex decking EDGE molded polymer Plastic advanced Torsion Deck
Surface area (per size) 136 in² for 21", 178 in² for 25", and 234 in² for 30" 160 in² for 25" 145 in² for 23" and 176 in² for 27" 189 in² 151 in²
Dimensions 8 x 21"/25"/30" 7.25 x 22"/25" 8.5 x 23"/27" 8 x 22"/25" 8 x 22"
Flotation tails sold separately? No Yes No No No
Load with tails (per size) N/A Up to 240 lbs for 22", 270 lbs for 25" N/A N/A N/A
Men's and Women's versions? Yes Yes No, women's specific Yes Yes
Sizes Available 21", 25", 30" 22" and 25" 23" and 27" 22" and 25" 22"
Size Tested 25" 22" and 25" 27" 25" 22"

Our Analysis and Test Results

Mountaineer Updates


Tubbs revamped the Mountaineer since our test period. Most notably, the newest version of this snowshoe features the ActiveFit 2.0 binding, which has a TPU cinch strap designed for easy entry and support while hiking, and has a pull-strap which releases the binding when you're ready to step out. The photo comparison below depicts the latest version and the version we tested, respectively.


We're linking to the updated Mountaineer above, but be aware that as we've yet to test it, the review below still only tells our account of the previous version.

Hands-On Review of the Mountaineer


For top-notch performance and supreme comfort in a snowshoe, our current favorite is the Mountaineer. Everything about this snowshoe feels friendly and smooth whether out on groomed beginner trails or advanced icy hills.

The Mountaineer aced every one of our testing metrics with ease.
The Mountaineer aced every one of our testing metrics with ease.

Flotation


The Mountaineer is the best floating snowshoe in our review. The generous surface area makes staying atop deep snow drifts easy and comfortable. The Mountaineer also comes in three sizes, making it easy to find the perfect not-too-big, not-too-small size for your height, weight, and pack load. We tested the 25" length, but for larger bodies and heavier loads Tubbs also makes this shoe in an impressive 30" version. There is a 21" model for those that are smaller and lighter. Most models don't offer this many size options, save for those that can be kitted out with supplemental flotation tails.


It was immediately clear that this snowshoe floats excellently. We have a lot of impressive shoes in this review that also performed well, but the Mountaineer stood out as being a notch above the rest. It strikes that perfect balance between weight and surface area. The Lightning Ascent is a full pound lighter, but the narrow design shaves off a bit of surface area, so it's not quite as floaty. The Louis Garneau Blizzard II has the largest surface area of all our tested models, but something about the shape is slightly less buoyant.

We achieved great flotation in the Mountaineer  the best in our entire test suite.
We achieved great flotation in the Mountaineer, the best in our entire test suite.

Traction


Our testers felt confident and secure on all types of snow and terrain with the Mountaineer. This shoe offers a carbon steel toe crampon with eight multidirectional teeth for constant contact as well as an aggressive heel crampon for assistance on downhills. There is also a 19° heel lift for help with steep ascents.


It's a well-conceived system that functions just as needed without feeling like overkill on flat, packed out beginner trails. The only model with noticeably better traction is the Lightning Ascent with its toothed outer perimeter instead of smooth tubes.

Well-designed crampons make for solid and secure outings no matter the terrain.
Well-designed crampons make for solid and secure outings no matter the terrain.

Stride Ergonomics


For such a technical shoe, we were highly impressed by how easy and natural the Mountaineer feels when walking.


The Mountaineer was a favorite for many testers in this area. It provides bomber traction without feeling too sticky on packed snow. The shape is very conducive to a woman's stride, the smooth frame glides easily over all types of snow, and the bindings move gracefully. All in all, a great experience!

Walking felt easy and natural in the Mountaineer.
Walking felt easy and natural in the Mountaineer.

Ease of Use


Once again, the Mountaineer impressed. From the intuitive bindings to walking and climbing on all terrain types, this is a snowshoe that aims to please.


The ActiveFit binding on this model is a favorite of our testers. Toe placement and heel centering are obvious and intuitive when you step into the binding. And two webbing loops allow you to tighten it across the top of the foot symmetrically. The back heel strap ratchets down quickly and securely, and loosening the whole system is as simple as pulling up on the obvious handle that sits across your toes.

It's super easy to make minute adjustments at any point, even with larger gloves or cold fingers. The single pull loop system on models like the Gold 13 or Elektra Montane is easier, but only marginally so. Combine all of this with the fact that the Mountaineer feels natural to walk in and floats like a dream, and you have an excellent snowshoe.

Pull each of the two tabs to tighten evenly and then up on the obvious handle to loosen quickly - this is a great binding system that's very easy to use.
Pull each of the two tabs to tighten evenly and then up on the obvious handle to loosen quickly - this is a great binding system that's very easy to use.

Binding Security


The binding system on this shoe is snug, secure, intuitive, and well-designed. From the moment we pulled these on until we took them off hours later, everything stayed in place and inspired confidence.


The benefit of a binding system with webbing like the Mountaineer is that you can make a field repair if needed and still get back to your car or campsite. Boa systems like the one on the Blizzard II can be fast and convenient, but a repair on the fly would be really difficult, if not impossible. We find the simple strap system on the MSR Lightning Ascent and Evo to be even more conducive to emergency repairs, but the Mountaineer isn't too far behind.

Everything about this system felt snug and secure. Zero complaints.
Everything about this system felt snug and secure. Zero complaints.

Binding Comfort


This binding system is padded and cozy in all the right places. It tightens evenly and can accommodate the smallest adjustments, making it highly comfortable and easy to use.


Once again, while we appreciate the simple and very versatile bindings on the MSR models in our review, those strap systems are easy to overtighten and create pinch points. Additionally, it's harder to get complete uniformity between the two feet. The Mountaineer, on the other hand, hugs your boots evenly with uniform tension.

The Mountaineer is comfortable no matter where we walk  hike  or climb.
The Mountaineer is comfortable no matter where we walk, hike, or climb.

Best Applications


A better question than, "what is the Mountaineer good for?" is what isn't it good for? This is a very well-rounded and well-executed snowshoe, appropriate for practically any kind of outing from easy groomed beginner trails to steep icy mountain ascents.

The Lightning is a smarter choice for exposed and technical pursuits because it's a much lighter shoe, packs down flatter, has optional flotation tails, and offers slightly burlier traction. But if your plans aren't specific to anything quite so technically minded, save some cash and get the Mountaineer. It floats with ease, has comfortable and smart bindings, and feels surprisingly natural to walk in.

The Mountaineer is our favorite snowshoe to wear for the most activities.
The Mountaineer is our favorite snowshoe to wear for the most activities.

Value


This snowshoe will set you back $270 and is the second most expensive model in our review after the Lightning Ascent. Do we think it's worth the price tag? If you are a serious snowshoer with technical aspirations, then yes. If you are just a sometimes snowshoer who doesn't much care for climbing steep hills, then probably not.

One of our Best Buy options, the Elektra Rendezvous or MSR Evo, is undoubtedly a smarter choice. Or consider something more mid-range like the $200 Atlas Elektra Montane, which still offers features like a heel lift. But if you daydream about floating on deep powder up steep snowy mountain faces, then the Mountaineer is well worth the damage it will do to your wallet.

Conclusion


We found the Mountaineer to offer the most consistent performance and to be the most crowd-pleasing snowshoe in our review. While the Lightning might be better for the most advanced terrain, and several other options are more appropriate for the casual user on a budget, this one was our favorite for the broadest range of uses. If you want to be comfortable and ready for almost anything, this is a great choice.

Comfortable  secure  and floatacious (that's a word  right?) - this describes the Mountaineer in a nutshell. Or a hardshell.
Comfortable, secure, and floatacious (that's a word, right?) - this describes the Mountaineer in a nutshell. Or a hardshell.


Penney Garrett