If you appreciate a comfortable ride, the Brooks Caldera 3 is a wonderful choice. From the mountains to the roads in and around the San Juans, we tackled over 60 miles of trail. After exhaustive testing, we've learned this shoe performs best on less technical trails and offers fantastic road running capabilities. While the new outsole is stickier in wet conditions than the Caldera 2, it is not aggressive enough to provide trustworthy footing on super steep or slippery surfaces. The fit is neutral with a wider toe box that offers a versatile fit for both narrow and wider footed runners. The ultra-comfortable ride will keep you chugging for miles; it's an excellent option for short or long distances, including marathons.
Brooks Caldera 3 - Women's Review
Cons: Expensive, slips and slides on loose and slippery surfaces
Manufacturer: Brooks Running
Compare to Similar Products
Brooks Caldera 3 - Women's
|Price||$139.89 at Amazon||$139.76 at Amazon||$120.00 at REI||$129.95 at Backcountry|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$89.73 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|Pros||Super comfortable, responsive, versatile fit, durable construction, great for cross-over terrain||Superb traction, amazing durability, wide-toe box, zero-drop design, great sensitivity, highly protective outsole and upper||Comfortable, versatile fit, great responsiveness, fantastic value, durable||Excellent traction, great balance of foot protection and sensitivity, specific fit, durable outsole||Great price, flexible, comfortable, responsive, one-pull lacing system|
|Cons||Expensive, slips and slides on loose and slippery surfaces||Laces come undone easily, lacks a women’s specific fit, upper takes time to break-in||Doesn't shed mud well, some midsole compaction over time||Higher heel is less stable, lugs wear down on pavement||No aggressive outsole, lug durability is questionable|
|Bottom Line||A super comfortable shoe that offers exceptional performance on non-technical surfaces.||This Editors' Choice winner crushes every metric with its innovative and super durable design.||A superior performer that offers exceptional value on all types of terrain.||An aggressive trail shoe that is built for the steepest and most technical trails out there.||A well fitted and comfortable shoe that is best for non-technical surfaces.|
|Rating Categories||Brooks Caldera 3 - Women's||Inov-8 TerraUltra G260||Peregrine ISO||Speedcross 5||Sense Ride 2|
|Foot Protection (20%)|
|Comfort And Fit (15%)|
|Specs||Brooks Caldera 3 -...||Inov-8 TerraUltra...||Peregrine ISO||Speedcross 5||Sense Ride 2|
|Measured Weight||9.1 oz||8.75 oz||9.8 oz||10.7 oz||8.6 oz|
|Ideal Terrain||Non-technical trails, cross-over||All terrain||All terrain||Soft surfaces, technical terrain||Non-technical trails, cross-over terrain|
|Width Options||Regular||Regular||Regular and Wide||Regular and Wide||Regular|
|Heel-to-Toe Drop||4 mm||0 mm||4 mm||10 mm||8 mm|
|Stack Height from toe to heel (mm)||24/28||9/9||18.5/22.5||10/20||27/19|
|Upper||Mesh||Kevlar Mesh||IsoFit||Nylon mesh, sythetic overlays||3D Mesh|
|Midsole||BioMoGo DNA||EXTERFLOW||PWRFOAM||Injected EVA||Vibe|
|Outsole||Carbon/blown rubber||Graphene Grip||PWRTRAC||Contragrip||ContraGrip|
|Rock Plate?||None||Yes||None||Yes||None, profeel film|
|Sizes Available||5 - 12||4 - 15||5 - 12||5 - 12||7 - 10|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Brooks Caldera 3 is an all-around average yet super comfortable trail running shoe. The cushioning is firm yet springy and responsive for longer runs on less technical terrain or even roads. This is an excellent option for the budding trail runner or for those who stick to less technical terrain.
This shoe offers an average level of foot protection, utilizing 24 mm of cushioning in the forefoot with 28 mm in the heel. The cushioning itself is responsive and springy without any "mush" factor; it does feel like running on air. The Caldera protects from underfoot hazards, but some of the sharper rocks and sticks can still be felt underfoot with a direct impact.
The toe cap is pretty tough and not super flexible, offering a great level of protection from stubs. The overlay is fairly breathable, doing a decent job keeping out trail debris.
The level of protection is adequate, but not as protective as harder trail shoe options like the Scarpa Spin Ultra, which integrates a rock plate in addition to its cushioning for added protection.
The Caldera offers decent sensitivity; you can feel underfoot hazards while still being protected. Given the level of cushioning, it's not the most sensitive shoe out there, making it a good option for longer distances, as well as short trail adventures.
The outsole in this new iteration is loaded with a new rubber composite that is meant to be stickier than the previous version. During testing, we were traversing over rocky and wet terrain and were able to stick to wet surfaces.
The outsole itself isn't super aggressive and doesn't do incredibly well while climbing up or down steep hills as it slips out on rubble and rocks. Over mud and debris, this material gets gunked up on the outsole and can cause less traction with muddy surfaces. As a result, it's not meant for super-technical terrain; instead, we'd recommend it for hard-packed single track trails or even dirt roads. The lug didn't wear down much after 60 miles of testing on both road and trail, making it a great cross-over option.
Stability is average, with the outsole and midsole encapsulating trail hazards and pushing off them. The sole offers lateral flexibility, which absorbs some of this impact, allowing you to correct your body position. While it's not the most stable shoe out there, its performance is adequate and will keep you safe on most terrain.
Comfort & Fit
We adore the comfort elements of this shoe. The cushioning is super responsive and springy with sleek and well-constructed materials. On the run, it provides a smooth and even ride, and keeps you going strong for long distances.
The fit is regular and is ideal both wide and narrow fit. The lacing system is unique as well, detaching from the tongue and wrapping the foot for a precise fit. This precision ensures there isn't any toe bump on the downhill (your front toe doesn't bump against the front) and keeps the heel in place. There is also a touch of arch support, which adds to the fit. The 4 mm drop is low profile and a good option for both forefoot and heel strikers.
It weighs in at 9.1 oz, which is lighter than most technical trail shoes. This lightness makes it a great option for longer trail races over less technical terrain.
While it can certainly take you on technical trails, its outsole and design are better suited for less technical terrain like hard-packed single track or dirt roads (or pavement). We'd say you can wear it around town, but the pattern is 'unique' to a special taste. We'd love to see a less patterned option for style's sake.
Eeek! At $140, this shoe is expensive. If comfort is a priority, and you've had good experience with the Brooks brand, we recommend you try it. After wearing for over 60 miles, we haven't noted any serious signs of wear and tear, which bodes well for this contender.
The Brooks Caldera 3 is super comfortable trail runner that's average across the board. Its plush, responsive cushioning offers an exceptional ride, but it isn't the most protective or rugged option out there. The outsole is sticky but limited to performing on less technical surfaces, making it a great option for those just learning the art of trail running or appreciate sticking to the hills and the roads.
— Amber King