Smartwool PhD Run Ultra Light Micro Review
Compare prices at 3 resellers Pros: Lightweight, comfortable, both womens' and mens specific fit avaliable, highly breathable.
Cons: Not durable, slips down on the run, foot slippage, expensive.
Compare to Similar Products
Smartwool PhD Run Ultra Light Micro
|Price||$16.95 at Backcountry|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$15.00 at Amazon||$15.00 at Amazon|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$12.71 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$15.00 at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|Pros||Lightweight, comfortable, both womens' and mens specific fit avaliable, highly breathable||Protective medium cushioning, protective length, durable fibers, strong at wicking, quick to dry||Super comfortable padding, toe spread, blister prevention, excellent moisture management, protective||Super comfortable, fits great, durable, good padding||Deliciously comfortable, well-cushioned, affordable|
|Cons||Not durable, slips down on the run, foot slippage, expensive||Medium cushioning isn't ideal for super hot weather||Some may not love the toe sock design, cooler than merino wool when wet||Slips easily||Poor breathability|
|Bottom Line||An ultralight running sock with good breathability but poor durability||An excellent all-around awesome contender that's built for long days on the trail or road||If you love to spread your toe, this toe-sock is our favorite for its excellent cushioning, comfort, and moisture management||A top choice when it comes to balancing comfort and durability||An all-around performer at a great price|
|Rating Categories||PhD Run Ultra Light Micro||Blister Resister Quarter||Trail Midweight Mini-Crew||Coolmax Vertex Ultra-Light||Balega Silver No Show|
|Wicking & Breathability (25%)|
|Slip Prevention (15%)|
|Specs||PhD Run Ultra...||Blister Resister...||Trail Midweight...||Coolmax Vertex...||Balega Silver No...|
|Material||48% merino wool, 48% nylon, 4% elastane||32% Drynamix polyester, 32% polyamide, 30% mohair, 4% microfiber, 2% elastane||39% COOLMAX polyester, 58% Nylon, 3% Lycra||52% Coolmax Polyester, 44% Nylon, 4% Lycra Spandex||75% Drynamix Polyester, 23% Nylon, 2% Elastane|
|Warranty||100% Satisfaction Guarantee (witihin two years)||One year warranty||One year warranty||Unconditional lifetime guarantee||One year warranty|
|Ankle Cut||Micro||Quarter Length||Quarter Length||No Show||No Show Tab|
Our Analysis and Test Results
A lightweight merino-wool synthetic sock that is totally barebones. While we wanted to love the Smartwool PhD Micro Elite it simply does not measure up to other running socks out there. It's nice and breathable but lacks functionality while running with questionable durability.
The Smartwool PhD Micro Elite is a lightweight no-frills option that lacks any major cushioning. It's best for those that don't need plush materials or extra protection underfoot. Constructed of an even amount of Nylon to Merino Wool, it is comfortable to wear on the trail. When feeling the fabric with your fingers, it's a little scratchier than most. However, on the roads and trails, it feels good to wear. We do enjoy the little bit of cushioning at the tips of the toes that adds a little protection.
In general, the fit feels a little bit small out of the package, but once you get the right size, it does okay. The collar has a thin elastic band, that we wish, was a little beefier. The tab on the back protects the Achilles heel, but is a little shallow and didn't cover up all the way against some shoes that have a higher collar. During a few runs, we had to keep stopping to pull this sock up as it slid down the shoe. This would easily be fixed by designing the sock with a longer Achilles section in the back and a more elastic band.
As we mentioned before, there is no additional cushioning in either the toes, forefoot, or heel. The elastic band around the arch of the foot keeps the sock in place, but doesn't offer a huge amount of compression, as we experienced with the Feetures Merino 10, a Top Pick for Comfort. Overall, the fit is okay, but some of our testers experienced it sliding down the foot when charging hard on flats.
Wicking & Breathability
It's thinner construction offers great moisture management. The sock is thinnest under the arch and throughout the top of the foot, offering great ventilation. While the stitching is tight, the threads are able to effectively wick away moisture from the foot. This is a great option for running in the Summer, Fall, and Spring.
Like most thinner socks, the Smartwool PhD Micro doesn't do much to prevent slippage. The merino wool-nylon fabric is slick and smooth and doesn't really stick well to the insole of a shoe. Since toe bump (on the downhill) can become an issue with these slippery contenders, we'd recommend a tighter fitting shoe if this is a concern. That said, there were no blister issues as a result of this slippage.
While the Ph.D. material used in Smartwool's sock is pretty durable in comparison to the rest of their fabrics, this still showed quite a bit of wear and tear after just the first use. The fabric pilled after the first wash (even with the correct washing directions). While this isn't a huge concern as it doesn't affect performance drastically, potential holes are.
After 30 miles, we note an area where the big toe touches the top of the fabric. Here, we noticed the beginnings of a small hole. Under the sock, in high use areas, we note compression of the already thin material and stitching seriously wearing down. Also, after washing, it did shrink. Overall, we aren't super impressed with the durability and think there are more durable products out there to be considered with similar make-up.
While Smartwool has many great products, we aren't impressed by the performance and value of this particular product. There are higher-value options, with better construction and warranties.
Smartwool has amazing products that are typically comfortable and great for all-around use. To be honest, we aren't especially impressed with the Smartwool PhD Micro Elite. While it is fairly comfortable for a lightweight sock, the fit is on the smaller side, it rides down on the run, and durability is questionable. If you're a hardcore Smartwool fan and have tried these socks, and they work, we are more then happy for you! However, we also believe there are better running sock options out there for the price.
— Amber King