Watershed Colorado Duffel Review
Compare to Similar Products
Watershed Colorado Duffel
|Price||$219 List||$160 List||$29.89 at Amazon||$25 List|
$18.00 at REI
$12.99 at Amazon
|Pros||100% watertight, high-quality construction, easy to pack||Completely watertight, durable, packed with features||Easy to pack, translucent material, welded seams||Lightweight, rectangular shape, simplicity is a feature||Three bag set, weather-resistant, small handy sizes, simple design, inexpensive|
|Cons||Expensive, large||Not very streamlined (lots of straps), takes a moment to open and close||Not 100% watertight under pressure, can tear on sharp objects||Not abrasion resistant, must be part of a system||Durability concerns, 10L bag is very narrow|
|Bottom Line||Be prepared for even the wettest adventures with this versatile and impenetrable product||Packed full of useful features, this deck bag is well suited to the touring kayaker that likes to have their essentials at hand||Easy to compress and simple to close, this is a great choice for your day trip essentials and more||For backpackers and day hikers, this model is a packing cube dry bag hybrid||These bags offer reasonable weather resistance at a great price but are not the most durable option|
|Rating Categories||Watershed Colorado...||Watershed Aleutian...||SealLine Discovery...||Osprey Ultralight D...||Outdoor Products 3-...|
|Ease of Use (25%)|
|Quality of Construction (15%)|
|Specs||Watershed Colorado...||Watershed Aleutian...||SealLine Discovery...||Osprey Ultralight D...||Outdoor Products 3-...|
|Weight||54.0 oz||23.0 oz||6.8 oz||2.0 oz||0.7 oz (2L), 1.0 oz (4L), 1.3oz (10L)|
|Tested Size (liters)||75L||11.5L||10L||20L||2L, 4L, 10L|
|Closure Type||ZipDry||ZipDry||Dual strip roll-top||Roll-top||Roll-top|
|Attachment Points||6 plastic D-rings, 2 handles, 1 removable shoulder strap||6 plus mesh and bungee cord||1 plastic D-ring||1 fabric loop||0|
|Style||Duffel||Deck bag||Dual-strip fold down w/ purge valve||Roll-top||Roll-top, 3-pack|
|Material||Polyurethane-coated nylon||Polyurethane-coated nylon||PVC free 12 oz polyurethane film body; 300D 18oz polyurethane-coated polyester bottom||40D ripstop nylon||Polyurethane coated ripstop 60% cotton, 40% rayon|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Colorado Duffel is 14 inches tall, 32.5 inches wide, and 13.5 inches deep with a 28-inch opening. It's wider than tall dimensions and huge mouth make packing this bag an easy task. It is made out of polyurethane-coated nylon and closes with a ZipDry seal, which strongly resembles a giant Ziploc bag. Both durable and watertight, this model is ideal for the avid water person.
This model is exceptionally waterproof and takes home an elusive perfect score for keeping water completely out throughout our several months of rigorous testing. A garden hose and thundering rainstorm have absolutely no effect on this protective bag. It's even capable of spending a prolonged time being held entirely underwater without letting any moisture in or any air out. Testers pushed this bag beyond almost all others, trusting it enough to carry our camera equipment even when we knew the bag was likely to get dunked in the water.
The ZipDry seal top, along with the classic roll-top design, provide an impenetrable barrier when closed properly. Rolling the lip and fastening it down with the provided buckles guarantees that nothing can tug at the seal while the product is in use. The thick, polyurethane-coated exterior and fully impenetrable seams ensure that whatever you put inside will stay dry.
The Colorado Duffel is less bulky and more flexible than other models with this level of waterproofness. Generally, you see a reduction in waterproofness with an increase in malleability, but that is certainly not a trade-off made by this bag. The Colorado is easy to stuff into or onto your craft and it provides unmatched protection against the water.
Ease of Use
This metric is all about packing, unpacking, and transporting your gear. Once again, the Colorado Duffel performed well in this category. The huge opening at the top of the bag combined with the duffel shape make it super easy to pack. It's also wider than it is tall, which is preferable to a deep narrow bag for both packing and retrieving the contents without a lot of fishing.
Carrying this product is akin to any other regular duffel bag. The carrying straps secure with a comfortable neoprene grip that spares waterlogged fingers from the abrasiveness of the nylon webbing. It's incredibly simple to move this duffel from point A to point B and huck it up into your boat. That said, if you are looking for something to carry over longer distances, some other models feature removable backpack straps that make them much more comfortable to lug around.
It is worth taking a bit of extra time to ensure you fully seal this bag. In addition, don't expect to be able to open it in a rush. Although this closure system is reliable when used correctly, if the seal isn't given basic care (like a dab of 303 Rubber Seal Protectant), it can become challenging and time-consuming to close the bag.
Quality of Construction
This model takes home yet another notable score in this metric, outshining almost all the competitors. The polyurethane-coated nylon, thick single-ply webbing, and hefty plastic D-rings are a well-built combination that results in a rugged dry bag well suited for even the most formidable adventures. Throughout all of our testing, this model never showed the slightest sign of wear and sustained no scratches, let alone tears. It is not a rare sight to see 10-year-old Watershed duffel bags still in frequent use.
Watershed makes five other models with almost identical construction to the Colorado Duffel but in various sizes ranging from 19.5 liters to 111 liters. Whether you are tight on space or need to forgo packing light, you can find the perfect size to fit your needs.
One of our favorite things about this product is the ziplock style closure. It's simple to seal, and — unless you have the right technique — difficult to open. Press the seal together with your fingers, roll the top down a few times and buckle it into place. Between the thick, beefy seal and the buckles, you can rest assured it's not about to pop open at random while careening through a rapid. To break the seal, simply grab the pull tabs on each side and curve the lip into an S shape. Pull the tabs in opposite directions, and viola, it comes right open. This does take some practicing to get used to, but once you've figured it out, it's quick and painless.
Attaching this model to your craft of choice is just as simple. Six total Duraflex D-rings provide sturdy lash points; one small one on each end, and two large ones on each side. That's some of the most attachment points of any dry bag we tested. Many competitors provide just two attachment points, so we appreciate the extra security of this one. Its long and low shape also add to its ease of being securely attached to the inside of your watercraft, helping you to charge rapids without worrying about losing your gear.The ziplock style closure is easy to securely seal and opens with a twist and pull.
One of the few downsides to this product is the lack of a built-in organization system for small items. One big cavern with no internal pockets or compartments makes it easy to lose things like sunscreen and car keys inside the bag. It's helpful to have your own organizational system using smaller sacks inside this behemoth bag.
If you plan to carry fragile equipment, a Watershed offers a selection of liners that can be purchased separately. These insert fits snugly inside the Duffel and provide added protection for your gear.
This model is one of the more expensive bags we tested, but for the seasoned water-person, it's well worth the investment. Its exceptional durability promises to keep your gear dry for many adventures to come, and its outstanding waterproofness protects your most valuable electronics from even the largest deluges of water.
The Colorado Watershed Duffel is the avid water person's bag of choice. Convenience, comfort, versatility, and durability rarely come in such a neat little package. This product not only boasts all of these qualities but also delivers on its promise to provide an impenetrable barrier between your precious gear and the water.
Ad-free. Influence-free. Powered by Testing.
GearLab is founded on the principle of honest, objective, reviews. Our experts test thousands of products each year using thoughtful test plans that bring out key performance differences between competing products. And, to assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. No cherry-picked units sent by manufacturers. No sponsored content. No ads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing and comparison.Learn More