The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of gear

Columbia Whirlibird IV Interchange - Women's Review

A decent deal for two jackets that can be worn in three combinations, the Whirlibird is a great intro ski jacket.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:  $199 List | $138.93 at REI
Compare prices at 3 resellers
Pros:  Inexpensive, three jackets in one, warm, comfortable
Cons:  Not very stylish, hood not helmet compatible, two layers don't work well when zipped together
Manufacturer:   Columbia
By Betsy Welch ⋅ Review Editor  ⋅  Dec 13, 2019
  • Share this article:
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more
64
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#11 of 12
  • Weather Resistance - 20% 8
  • Comfort and Fit - 20% 6
  • Warmth - 20% 8
  • Ventilation - 20% 5
  • Style - 10% 5
  • Features - 10% 5

Our Verdict

The Columbia Whirlibird IV Interchange is a decent jacket at a low price point. This is the sixth iteration of the Whirlibird that we've tested, and Columbia continues to make improvements to its form and function. We like how the layers perform individually but found that they don't work in combination quite as well we would hope. Columbia has upped the Whirlibird's game by including pockets in the inner jacket layer as well as the shell, but it still lacks the ski functionality of the other jackets we've tested. It did keep us protected from the elements in all but the most torrential of storms, and is warm and toasty with the insulating layer. If you're not after a very ski-specific jacket and want something that provides reasonable value at a low price point, this is the jacket for you.


Compare to Similar Products

 
Awards  Editors' Choice Award Editors' Choice Award  Best Buy Award 
Price $138.93 at REI
Compare at 3 sellers
$799.00 at REI
Compare at 3 sellers
$598.95 at Backcountry
Compare at 2 sellers
$399.00 at Backcountry
Compare at 2 sellers
$207.93 at REI
Compare at 3 sellers
Overall Score Sort Icon
100
0
64
100
0
82
100
0
79
100
0
77
100
0
76
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros Inexpensive, three jackets in one, warm, comfortableTop quality, good looking, warm, comfortable, useful featuresBreathes well, stylish, well-constructedSolid construction, highly functional, ski specific, breathes wellInexpensive, warm, stylish
Cons Not very stylish, hood not helmet compatible, two layers don't work well when zipped togetherExpensive, not very breathableOff-set pocket placement, proprietary powder skirtOn the heavy side, not remarkably flatteringFits a bit snug around the hips, non-removable powder skirt
Bottom Line A decent deal for two jackets that can be worn in three combinations, the Whirlibird is a great intro ski jacket.Warm, cozy, good looking, and comfortable, the Primo Puff is a great jacket for resort skiing that comes at a high cost.The North Face hit it out of the park with this stylish, breathable hard shell that can work hard and play hard.The Powder Bowl offers great protection from the elements in a simple yet well-constructed design.This resort ripper will help you shred the slopes with style and ease, at a great price!
Rating Categories Whirlibird IV Interchange Primo Puff A-CAD FUTURELIGHT Powder Bowl Jacket Armada Stadium
Weather Resistance (20%)
10
0
8
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
8
Comfort And Fit (20%)
10
0
6
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
8
Warmth (20%)
10
0
8
10
0
9
10
0
4
10
0
4
10
0
8
Ventilation (20%)
10
0
5
10
0
6
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
6
Style (10%)
10
0
5
10
0
8
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
8
Features (10%)
10
0
5
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
9
10
0
8
Specs Whirlibird IV... Primo Puff A-CAD FUTURELIGHT Powder Bowl Jacket Armada Stadium
Insulation Thermarator 65g PlumaFill None None 80g Polyfill in body, 60g in sleeves
Waterproofing Omni-Tech Gore-Tex 2L Futurelight 3L Gore-Tex 2L DWR
Weight (in pounds) 2.4 lbs 2.0 lbs 1.5 lbs 1.7 lbs 1.9 lbs
# of Pockets Shell: 5, Liner: 3 2 hand, 1 chest, 1 internal 2 zippered chest, 1 zippered phone, 1 zippered wrist, [internal] 2 goggle 2 zippered hand, 1 zippered chest, 1 arm, [internal] 1 zippered, 1 drop 2 hand, 2 chest, 1 sleeve, 1 indernal drop-in
Main Fabric Legacy Dobby 72% Nylon/ 28% Polyester. 100% recycled polyester plain-weave GORE-TEX fabric with stretch 75D x 56D recycled polyester, brushed tricot backer, DWR coating 150D 100% recycled polyester GORE-TEXT with DWR coating 100% Nylon (solid prints); 100% Polyester (prints)
Unique Features 3-in-1, internal goggle pocket hood has laminated visor; watertight zippers; RECCO reflector off-set pockets accommodate backpack;YKK AquaGuard zippers; pass-through pocket; jacket-to-pant integration Watertight, coated zippers, adjustable powder skirt, RECCO reflector Internal goggle pocket, wrist gaiters
Hood Option? Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Pit Zips? Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Cuff construction Velcro Velcro Velcro Velcro Velcro with wrist gaiters
Ski features Powder skirt, pass and goggle pocket Powder skirt, helmet compatible hood Powder skirt, thumb loops, goggle pocket, pass pocket Powder skirt, pass pocket Powder skirt, pass and goggle pocket, jacket/pant interface

Our Analysis and Test Results

We love the three different options of the 3-in-1 model and found that the Columbia Whirlibird IV Interchange actually functioned better as two separate jackets rather than one. The jacket covers other necessary requirements, like zippered hand and chest pockets, but misses the mark on a non-removable powder skirt, non-helmet compatible hood, and clunky design. Fortunately, it's adequately weatherproof and impressively warm.

Performance Comparison


The Whirlibird IV got the job done  but we found it lacking in a few categories.
The Whirlibird IV got the job done, but we found it lacking in a few categories.

Weather Resistance


The Whirlibird proved relatively water-resistant during our test. It uses OmniTech waterproof shell materials, and we were impressed with the bombproof seam sealing. This jacket had velcro attachments on the flap covering the main zipper, which was a feature that came in handy when the weather was windy and wet. Unfortunately, the hood is small and ill-fitting, which meant that we had a hard time zipping the jacket up enough to protect our chin and face.

Comfort and Fit


The Whirlibird is pretty comfortable and allows for good mobility while carving turns on the ski hill. Although Columbia's sizing is usually more relaxed, this year our smaller testers fit the size medium better, and it felt snug on our normal size medium folks. Consider sizing up if you like the extra room (or like to stuff your pockets full of snacks!) The 3-in-1 nature of the jacket tends to feel bulky while skiing, but is quite comfortable with less exertion.

The small fit our tester more snugly that she liked.
It was hard to get the jacket to zip up fully and use the hood over our helmet at the same time.

Style


This jacket doesn't win rave reviews in the style department. It's fairly basic both in design and options. We did appreciate that the inner insulated layer was basic black in the version we tested; however, the inner lining of the insulated layer was a crazy disco-patterned silver. Not quite the style we're looking for in a ski jacket, but slightly forgivable since it was located inside the jacket.

The Whirlibird IV wasn't wasn't the most stylish of the bunch.
The Whirlibird IV wasn't wasn't the most stylish of the bunch.

Warmth


The Whirlibird has a removable interior synthetic jacket that uses Columbia's unique Omni-Heat reflective technology to keep you warm. We were skeptical at first because it looks like a flashy gimmick — but it seems to work. We stayed very warm in this jacket.


The inner jacket is made from synthetic insulation and is lined with tiny aluminum dots that are designed to reflect your body heat back in towards you, similar in function to a foil space blanket. Heat loss through radiation is not the significant method of heat loss when skiing — convection through wind and conduction through sitting on a chilly chairlift are the most likely ways to lose heat. That being said, we are not sure if it was those reflective dots that kept us warm, or if it was the combination of the thick synthetic insulation and the wind-resistant outer shell, but either way, we stayed toasty.

The Whirlibird has decent ski performance and is comfortable out there on the slopes.
The Whirlibird has decent ski performance and is comfortable out there on the slopes.

Ventilation


The Whirlibird is somewhat breathable, although we still worked up a sweat occasionally in it. One point of frustration with this jacket is that it has pit-zips for ventilation, but you cannot vent the interior jacket. We do like that you can always remove the inner insulating layer on warmer days.

The Whirlibird's pit zips helped more if we were only wearing the outer hard shell.
The Whirlibird's pit zips helped more if we were only wearing the outer hard shell.

The Omni-Heat system's tiny dots are supposed to allow moisture to move out between them for breathability (so it is more breathable than an actual space blanket!). We are not sure if the silver dots facilitated moisture transfer or not, but the synthetic material seemed to wick moisture away sufficiently.

The fun  flashy inside of the insulated layer of the Whirlibird IV.
The fun, flashy inside of the insulated layer of the Whirlibird IV.

Ski Features


The Whirlibird has some decent ski features, but they get lost in the 3-in-1 construction. The non-removable powder skirt on the outer shell is covered up by the insulated layer. There is only one interior zip pocket on the inner layer, but there is not a goggle pocket in the interior jacket. Columbia has moved the Whirlibird's goggle pocket to the interior of the shell, which doesn't make sense if you're wearing both layers.

We liked the velcro flap that protected the main zipper.
We liked the velcro flap that protected the main zipper.

We think that its layers work well separately. The shell is a fantastic wind and water-resistant layer to wear on a warm day, and the interior layer is a warm and cute jacket to wear around town for apr├Ęs-ski activities, but together they make the jacket less functional. When the internal layer is zipped in, it makes the powder skirt impossible to use. We think that Columbia probably had to sacrifice some ski-specific features given the inherent heft and bulkiness of the 3-in-1 design.

The jacket performs well as two separate pieces.
The jacket performs well as two separate pieces.

Value


The Whirlibird is a good value for a warm and basic ski jacket. It's not great for someone looking for something super ski-specific, however, because it can't be everything to everyone. We do think it's a great value if considered as two separate jackets.

Conclusion


For an inexpensive ski jacket, the Columbia Whirlibird IV Interchange will keep you warm and dry in a simple and straightforward package. We felt that its two layers work better individually than they do together, and that the jacket felt clunky when both were worn together. Nevertheless, for the price, this jacket performs well and is a great entry point for someone just starting out who's not quite sure what's most important to them in a ski jacket.


Betsy Welch