The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of outdoor gear

The Best Insulated Jacket for Women Review

Layered appropriately  even jackets like the Patagonia Micro Puff can provide enough warmth for cold days. Pictured here is our main tester at Glacier Beach in Iceland.
By Amber King ⋅ Senior Review Editor
Saturday February 16, 2019
  • Share this article:

Seeking out the best women's insulated jacket for your next adventure? After scouring over 70 different options on the market, we settled on 15 of the top models. Seeking out extreme conditions, we truly tested the limits of each jacket. We hiked to the tops of the world's tallest sea cliffs, sailed in the North Sea, skinned up the steep mountains of the Colorado Rockies, and skied down the groomers of slopes of the Sierras. Each was exposed to cold, wet weather, and was soaked to the core in our objective shower tests. Evaluating each using six important metrics, we've identified key performance differences to help you find the best insulated jacket this season.


Top 13 Product Ratings

Displaying 1 - 5 of 13
≪ Previous | Compare | Next ≫
 
Awards Editors' Choice Award Top Pick Award  Best Buy Award  
Price $194.95 at Backcountry
Compare at 2 sellers
$171.73 at REI
Compare at 2 sellers
$99.96 at Backcountry
Compare at 2 sellers
$99.99 at Amazon$149.50 at Patagonia
Compare at 2 sellers
Overall Score Sort Icon
100
0
77
100
0
74
100
0
73
100
0
72
100
0
70
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros Warm, compressible, lightweight, weather resistantSuper warm, lots of comfort features, versatile fitBreathable, warm, great comfort features, mobile face fabric, great layering abilityWarm, lofty, inexpensive, cute and stylish, removable faux-furSuper mobile face fabric, wide range of thermoregulation, comfortable, cute colors and style
Cons Lacks comfort features, not breathableHeavy, compression isn't the best, sticky zipperNo cinch cord around hoodLacks water resistance, no pull tabs on zippersExpensive, not very wind resistant, non-adjustable hood, short torso
Bottom Line A compressible jacket that is warm and lightweight, perfect for any adventurer requiring a technical, high performing insulated jacket.Designed for standing around in the coldest of temperatures.Offering a unique balance of warmth and breathability, this jacket is highly versatile.An inexpensive and well-performing synthetic jacket perfect for winter weather.This mobile and breathable design offers a wide range of thermoregulation and comforts.
Rating Categories Rab Xenon X Hoodie - Women's Stance Ventrix Hoody Peak to Park Nano Air Hoody
Warmth (25%)
10
0
8
10
0
10
10
0
7
10
0
9
10
0
6
Weight & Compression (20%)
10
0
9
10
0
3
10
0
6
10
0
5
10
0
6
Weather Resistance (20%)
10
0
9
10
0
10
10
0
7
10
0
7
10
0
7
Comfort & Coziness (15%)
10
0
7
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
8
Breathability (15%)
10
0
5
10
0
5
10
0
9
10
0
6
10
0
9
Style & Fit (5%)
10
0
5
10
0
4
10
0
7
10
0
9
10
0
6
Specs Rab Xenon X Hoodie... Stance Ventrix Hoody Peak to Park Nano Air Hoody
Weight (ounces) 10.65 oz 25.95 oz 25.15 oz 25.15 oz 11.82 oz
Number of Pockets 3 (2 zippered hand, 1 zippered internal chest) Two zippered hand pockets, single zippered chest pocket and two internal drop pockets, internal mesh zip pocket 3 (2 zippered hand, 1 zippered chest) 3 (2 zippered hand, 1 zippered chest) 4 (2 zippered hand, 1 zippered internal chest, 1 zippered external chest)
Insulation 60g/m2 2oz PrimaLoft Gold Active ThermoLite (180gsm) 80g 100% polyester Ventrix stretch synthetic insulation Synthetic down 100% polyester 60g FullRange 100% polyester stretch insulation
Outer Fabric Pertex Quantum nylon Nylon plain-weave with DWR treatment (40d, 100% nylon) 92% nylon, 8% ripstop Storm-Lite DP II 100% Polyester 1.5oz 30D 100% nylon ripstop
Lining 100% nylon ripstop Polyester plain-weave (40d, 100% polyester) 92% nylon, 8% elastane Microtex Lite II Taffeta 100% Polyester 2oz 50D 100% nylon plain weave
Hood Option? Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Stuffs into itself? Yes No No No No
Cuff construction Elasticized cuffs Lightweight stretch Elasticized cuffs Stretch-knit Stretch-knit
Warranty Information Lifetime warranty with original proof of purchase - includes repairs Lifetime; will repair, replace, or refund, no questions asked Limited lifetime warranty; will repair or replace due to manufacturing defect (not regular wear and tear or misuse) Limited lifetime warranty Lifetime warranty - includes repairs to seams and zippers, as well as other manufacturer defects

Best Overall Synthetic Jacket


Rab Xenon X Hoodie - Women's


Editors' Choice Award

$194.95
(17% off)
at Backcountry
See It

77
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Warmth - 25% 8
  • Weight & Compression - 20% 9
  • Weather Resistance - 20% 9
  • Comfort & Coziness - 15% 7
  • Breathability - 15% 5
  • Style & Fit - 5% 5
Weight: Mid-weight (10.65 oz) | Insulation: 60g/m^2 PrimaLoft Gold Active
Compressible with its stow-away system
Outstanding weather protection
Versatile
Relatively inexpensive
Boxy fit
Not very breathable

Dominating the Editors' Choice podium, this amazingly protective and compressible jacket is an amazingly versatile. The warmth to compression ratio is stellar, packing into the smallest spaces of your backpack and keeping you warm when the weather deteriorates. The fabrics are slippery and smooth with ample room, offering great layering capabilities. What we love the most is the loftiness of the coat…making it feel like you're wrapped in a warm sleeping bag all day long. This is our favorite coat because it simply performs in all conditions throughout all seasons.

It's hard to find caveats with this coat…that's why it's our favorite after all. But, if we had to really scrutinize, the boxy fit isn't the most flattering. Also, the Pertex Quantum shell doesn't offer much breathability through the fabric or ventiing capabilities. Despite these minor imperfections, it's highly versatile functioning in all four seasons either as a wear-alone jacket or additional warmth layer.

Read review: Rab Xenon X

Best Bang for the Buck


Columbia Peak to Park - Women's


Best Buy Award

$99.99
at Amazon
See It

72
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Warmth - 25% 9
  • Weight & Compression - 20% 5
  • Weather Resistance - 20% 7
  • Comfort & Coziness - 15% 8
  • Breathability - 15% 6
  • Style & Fit - 5% 9
Warm and protective
Versatile style
Great value
Durability is questionable

This jacket is perfect for wear from the ski slopes to the chalet. The StormLight shell is fairly weather-proof warding off strong winds and a light rain. The insulation is lofty and cozy…making it perfect for wear on days that dip below freezing. The removable hood is huge and insulated, with a removable faux-fur liner allowing for those who love it to keep it on, and for those that hate it to take it off. Since the hood can be removed, it can easily be worn underneath a more protective shell if you plan on crushing it in super wet conditions.

While performance is great all-around, the price does reflect the quality of craftsmanship. The stitching isn't very tight, noting many flyaways, and some of the material actually ripped during our testing period. This makes the durability of this jacket questionable…however, we didn't notice any performance deteriorate after washing it a couple of times, or when getting it wet. While we love this coat (and it's low price), you do get what you pay for. If you're a recreational outdoors person looking for a nice and stylish (and high value) insulated winter jacket that doesn't require the best performance on the market, this is our top recommendation.

Read review: Columbia Peak to Park

Top Pick for Warmth


Black Diamond Stance - Women's


Top Pick Award

$171.73
(25% off)
at REI
See It

74
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Warmth - 25% 10
  • Weight & Compression - 20% 3
  • Weather Resistance - 20% 10
  • Comfort & Coziness - 15% 9
  • Breathability - 15% 5
  • Style & Fit - 5% 4
Weight: Heavy-weight (1lb 9.95 oz) | Insulation: ThermoLite® (180 gsm)
Very warm
Lofty and comfortable
Great Features
Not super compressible
Sticky zipper

This is the warmest insulated jacket that we've tested thus far. This parka is incredibly lofty and cozy, providing all-day comfort for wear on the coldest days of winter. The continuous shell fabric provides fantastical weather resistant from rain, snow, sleet, and wind. Also, the many features of this jacket make it perfect for hanging out all day in cold weather.

Our major caveat with this jacket is its sticky zipper and lack of compression. Being a heavy-weight jacket it's not as light as other contenders, but it definitely doesn't feel heavy on. The style isn't anything to write home about, but it's cute enough to wear out on an informal night in town. Overall, this is the warmest insulated contender and a perfect option as a winter jacket.

Read review: Black Diamond Stance - Women's

Top Pick for Breathability


Outdoor Research Ascendant Hoody - Women's


Top Pick Award

$99.95
(60% off)
at Backcountry
See It

69
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Warmth - 25% 4
  • Weight & Compression - 20% 7
  • Weather Resistance - 20% 6
  • Comfort & Coziness - 15% 9
  • Breathability - 15% 10
  • Style & Fit - 5% 8
Weight: Mid-weight (11.74 oz) | Insulation: 100% Polyester PolarTec Alpha Direct
Extremely Breathable
Durable and weather-resistant
Fleece-lined interior liner wicks away moisture
Not super warm

This soft-shell like jacket offers an extremely breathable design that is effective at protecting from a stabbing wind and light rain. The interior is lined with a plush fleece that, when worn on the skin, wicks away moisture. The mobile face fabric is flexible, moving with your body while you move. It's perfect to wear on its own with a t-shirt, stacked with layers underneath, or even worn underneath a shell. It's versatile in its function and a go-to if you're looking for a protective shell that will off-load heat while you break a sweat in winter.

Superlative breathability comes with the trade-off of warmth. As one of thinnest insulated jackets out there, it's not suitable for wear on its own in super cold weather. It must be layered with an insulative layer or even shell in order to perform. The only time it would be suitable is if you're planning on pounding out the miles on foot, intending to break a sweat the whole time. So…if you're in need of a jacket that will offer impeccable breathability in cold weather, this is our Top Choice. It's also great for hiking, backcountry skiing, climbing and more! Just make sure to add a base layer on cooler days or a shell when the weather starts to turn.

Read review: Outdoor Research Ascendant Hoody

Top Pick for Lightweight Adventures


Patagonia Micro Puff Hoody - Women's


69
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Warmth - 25% 6
  • Weight & Compression - 20% 10
  • Weather Resistance - 20% 6
  • Comfort & Coziness - 15% 5
  • Breathability - 15% 7
  • Style & Fit - 5% 7
Weight: Mid-weight (8.07 oz)| Insulation: 65g PlumaFill 100% polyester
Extremely lightweight and compressible
Great warmth: weight
Great as an additional layer or wear-alone option
Expensive
Not very durable

The Patagonia Micro Puff Hoody is an uber-lightweight and compressible insulated jacket that can fit into the smallest backpacks out there. For its lightweight construct, it's surprisingly warm with only 65-grams of PlumaFill insulation. We took it hiking in the cold and wet climates of Iceland and the Faroe Islands and it performed perfectly as our go-to warmth piece. It's also perfect to layer underneath a shell with warmth to weight ratio and stand-out breathability.

While this jacket is cute and super lightweight, the fabric does tear easily. We observed some holes in the material after coming up against some sharp branches. That said, the insulation stays in place and the fabric is easy to repair. Overall, a great Top Pick with many fantastic performance properties.

Read review: Patagonia Micro Puff Hoody - Women's

Top Pick for Weather Protection


Patagonia Micro Puff Storm - Women's


Top Pick Award

$249.97
(50% off)
at Backcountry
See It

67
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Warmth - 25% 7
  • Weight & Compression - 20% 5
  • Weather Resistance - 20% 10
  • Comfort & Coziness - 15% 7
  • Breathability - 15% 4
  • Style & Fit - 5% 5
Weight: Mid-weight | Insulation: 65g PlumaFill 100% polyester
Weatherproof shell
Lofty insulative liner
Easy layering
Durable and lightweight
Expensive
Lacks breathability
Not super compressible

This unique jacket offers a real weatherproof shell with a built-in liner that offers weather protection, warmth, and awesome features. It's built as a belay parka meant to perform in cold to warm weather, offering great protection from snow, sleet, and other forms of precipitation. The built-in insulation is warm enough for temperatures that hover above freezing and the jacket is large enough to accomodate a secondary jacket or other bulky layers. Its pockets are massive and large enough to stash a water bottle or small lunch, with a built-in mesh pocket that doubles as a stuff sack.

While this coat is quite protective, it's not as warm as we'd expect. The 65-grams of PlumaFill insulation is nice and lofty, but because it is sewn into the liner, it's not as fitted, making it less warm than other competitors. In addition, the shell can't be separated from the inner jacket and vice versa. The price tag is also quite high. While you do get a shell and an insulative layer in one jacket, it's functionally best for those seeking a warm and protective jacket that can't be taken apart. Some people prefer this, while others prefer to buy them separately to make it more versatile. Ideal for wet climates or areas that experience inclement weather. Overall, this Top Pick will keep you protected in the worst conditions that father winter has to offer.

Read review: Patagonia Micro Puff Storm - Women's


Analysis and Test Results


Synthetic jackets offer the unique property of keeping you warm…even if it gets wet. It's a perfect piece to don if you're seeking a ultra versatile jacket that will keep you warm despite the weather conditions. As gear testers, we took each of the 15 contenders all over the world to truly see how the performance of each compares. Centralized in SouthWest Colorado, we wore them regularly from the desert landscapes to the tops of the Rocky Mountains. We also tested them in different locations around the world including the cold North of Canada and the remote Islands territories of Northern Europe.

Hanging out on the towering seacliffs of the remote Faroe Islands...a perfect place to don the Patagonia Micro Puff.
Hanging out on the towering seacliffs of the remote Faroe Islands...a perfect place to don the Patagonia Micro Puff.

The most important metrics we determined to rate performance includes; relative warmth, compression & weight, weather resistance, comfort, breathability, and style & fit. Through our testing period, we scored each of the products for each of the categories. While some did well across all metrics, others have a specific function for unique climates, uses, and conditions. The award winners highlight the creme of the crop and our top recommendations.

Value


At OutdoorGearLab, our Best Buy winner is often an indicator of the product that not only offers high value but provides a steal of a deal. The most expensive products are not always the best performers and sometimes those that offer a great deal, offer great performance. For example; the Rab Xenon X is our Editor's Choice winner and offers the best balance of all metrics considered. Its price point is about average and less than other contenders (like the Arc'teryx Atom LT) that didn't score as high. Our Best Buy award winner offers the highest in value. Great performance at a reasonable price. This year, the Columbia Peak to Park takes home this award, offering amazing protection and warmth at a great price.

Look for deals on last season's colors. Typically these products feature the same performance at a greatly reduced price.


Warmth


When evaluating warmth, we took each jacket out into cold, blustery weather that dipped down into the negative double digits. We walked around, hiked, ran, and just stood around wearing similar layers under each coat to determine relative warmth differences. We also looked at warmth features to include cinching hoods, weather resistant shells, and the relative length of the torso and arms. Finally, we note the relative amounts of insulation. All these factors are important when considering the overall warmth of an insulated jacket.


The warmest jackets in this review is the Black Diamond Stance, featuring 180gsm of ThermoLite insulation. It features a longer torso and arm length to help cover all the essential parts. Also, both are highly weather resistant. The Black Diamond simple beats out the competition because of its loftier insulation and continuous face fabric that offers a little more in the way of insulation.

In our testing, we layered using a single merino wool midweight base layer to truly determine the differences relative warmth.

We are surprised that the Rab Xenon X provides enough warmth to keep anybody warm in super cold weather. While the jacket is on the thinner side, the lofty 60 g/m2 PrimaLoft Gold Active provides generous warmth while the Pertex Quantum Nylon shell locks in heat. When taking a short walk in double negative digits in humid weather, we found that we were cold at first pretty cold, but with a short walk and a cinched down the hem, heat locked in and stayed for a short period. As a result, we'd recommend this jacket for colder weather when using an appropriate layering system, but not on its own.

The ThermoBall Hoody is super cute hosting numerous baffles loaded with ThermoBall insulation.
The ThermoBall Hoody is super cute hosting numerous baffles loaded with ThermoBall insulation.

The warmth performance of this jacket is comparable to the Black Diamond First Light Hoody. The Black Diamond instead features a more breathable shell designed for warmth during aerobic activities like Nordic or backcountry skiing. Other thinner jackets that scored lower in this review had a breathable face fabric and less insulation.

The Rab Xenon X  our Editors' Choice winner provides the most facial coverage of all jackets tested. This adds to its warmth rating.
The Rab Xenon X, our Editors' Choice winner provides the most facial coverage of all jackets tested. This adds to its warmth rating.

Some jackets function best as a stand-alone piece that does better in the warmer seasons, or as an additional layer for skiing or hanging out around town in frigid conditions. For example; the Patagonia Micro Puff provided relatively more warmth and insulation than the Patagonia Nano Puff, which is surprising given its lighter nature. Both are great examples of jackets that have a slippery face fabric and easily fits underneath a shell or a heavier model in colder conditions. The North Face Thermoball Hoody also falls into this category, providing more warmth than the Micro Puff. Many of our testers liked using this piece for colder days in the winter and as a hiking option in the Fall.

Testing in the double negatives proves to be cold but awakening. Here we wear the OR Women's Ascendent with many layers in our testing process.
Testing in the double negatives proves to be cold but awakening. Here we wear the OR Women's Ascendent with many layers in our testing process.

The super breathable Outdoor Research Ascendant Hoody provides the least amount of warmth. As an exceptional layer or stand-alone jacket in the warmer seasons, this is not a cold weather jacket due to its super breathable nature. That said, we love wearing it during warmer winter runs or alpine tours in the backcountry, earning a Top Pick for just this function.

Weight & Compression


We love jackets that compress into the bottom of a backpack or clip to something. Also, a lightweight jacket makes it more versatile for a variety of purposes. As a result, we regard compression and weight as one of the most important metrics. To test each comparatively, we noted stow-away systems, relative weight, and compressed each until they couldn't compress anymore. Jackets scoring the highest in this category feature a formal stow-away system, compress to about the size of a salami sandwich, and are so light we hardly notice it on.


The most compressible and lightweight jackets out there feature a baffled design with pods that are stuffed full of insulation. The air among the insulation is what gives it overall loft and warmth. These contenders scored higher in this metric. In comparison, mobile face fabric jackets offered a little less compression, but in some cases are still relatively lightweight. Let's explore each option comparatively.

Here we scope out Crestone Peak  a Fourteener located in Colorado. We strap the Patagonia Micro Puff to our running pack (it also fits inside) for when temperatures plunge at higher altitude.
Here we scope out Crestone Peak, a Fourteener located in Colorado. We strap the Patagonia Micro Puff to our running pack (it also fits inside) for when temperatures plunge at higher altitude.

If you're looking for the lightest and most compressible layer, the Patagonia Micro Puff is the best option out there! As our Top Pick, it weighs only 8.07 oz, making it the lightest jacket tested. It works great as a mid-layer in the winter or as a stand-alone piece during the winter months. It packs down the smallest and fits into the smallest cracks and crevices of any backpack. We stuffed it into the confines of a tiny running pack. Additionally, it stows away into its left pocket and features a carabiner loop. Overall, it has the best weight to compression ratio, earning a perfect score in this category and earning a Top Pick for lightweight adventures


We fastpack over 100 miles with only the Patagonia Micro Puff as our warm layer piece in the remote corners of the world. The Hornstrandir Reserve is renowned for its cold and wet weather  in addition to its gnarly trails. On this fast packing mission  light and fast is the way to go. The Micro Puff was our Top Pick for this trip because of its unique design.
We fastpack over 100 miles with only the Patagonia Micro Puff as our warm layer piece in the remote corners of the world. The Hornstrandir Reserve is renowned for its cold and wet weather, in addition to its gnarly trails. On this fast packing mission, light and fast is the way to go. The Micro Puff was our Top Pick for this trip because of its unique design.

The Rab Xenon X is another option that features a high compression to weight ratio. This Editors' Choice award winner compresses just as small as the Patagonia Micro Puff and stows away nicely into its pocket. The most significant difference between the two is that the Rab is a little heavier (10.65 oz) than the Patagonia Micro Puff. The North Face Thermoball is also a lightweight option that does well in this category but scores a smidgen lower because of its higher weight (11.46 oz). All jacket options are great stand-alone layers in the warmer seasons and fantastic mid-layers in the cold of winter.

Jackets that feature a stow-away system include the following:
  • Patagonia Micro Puff
  • Rab Xenon X
  • Patagonia Nano Puff Hoody
  • The North Face Thermoball Hoody
  • Black Diamond First Light Hoody
  • Patagonia Micro Puff Storm
All the rest do not pack into their pocket, but most are relatively compressible.

A look at all the jackets with a stow-away system. Some systems don't compress the jacket to their maximal compressibility. Here  the Patagonia Micro Puff (far left) is the most compressible jacket tested.
A look at all the jackets with a stow-away system. Some systems don't compress the jacket to their maximal compressibility. Here, the Patagonia Micro Puff (far left) is the most compressible jacket tested.

The Arc'teryx Atom LT Hoody is one of the jackets that did well in this category despite it not having its stow-away system or baffled design. The contender is thinner than most with a softer face fabric that doesn't make noise. While it doesn't compress down into its pocket, it still stows away nicely into the hood of the coat. Also, it only weighs 11.18 oz, a little lighter than the North Face Thermoball, and a little heavier than the Rab Xenon X.

All the jackets that do not compress wrap easily into their hoods  but don't have their own stow away systems.
All the jackets that do not compress wrap easily into their hoods, but don't have their own stow away systems.

Weather Resistance


To assess weather resistance, we simply went outside when mother nature offered soul-crushing weather to truly test performance. This includes conditions offering howling winds, snow, sleet, rain, and more. When bad weather wasn't an option, we stood in the shower to determine how each piece performed during a simulated heavy rainfall and light sprinkle. In the end, we determined that the designs offering the best weather resistance typically are continuous fabric designs with many layers. Lightweight options that offer a heavier shell also did well in this category.


Water Resistance
An insulated jacket does not serve as a substitute for a rain jacket or a hardshell, but many of the products that we reviewed are treated with a DWR (Durable Water Repellent) finish. Thanks to the differences in fabric and stitching, each repelled water a little differently.

Simulating a heavy downpour in our shower at home  we figured that the Black Diamond Belay Stance offers some of the best water protection.
Simulating a heavy downpour in our shower at home, we figured that the Black Diamond Belay Stance offers some of the best water protection.

Which jacket offers the best weather resistance? A new contender this season is the Patagonia Micro Puff Storm that offers a unique design. With H2No shell and built-in insulation, this is the most protective and lightweight insulated jacket tested thus far in our review. No other jacket can be deemed as "weather-proof" to the extent of the Micro Puff Storm. As a result, it earns a Top Pick, standing up in the worst weather out there. If you're seeking an insulative jacket that will keep you protected from the elements in say wet climates or inclement weather, this is our top recommendation.

Snowy days at the Ouray Ice Park is a perfect place for the Patagonia Storm coat  winning our Top Pick for Weather Resistance.
Snowy days at the Ouray Ice Park is a perfect place for the Patagonia Storm coat, winning our Top Pick for Weather Resistance.

The Black Diamond Stance Parka is also super weather resistant, but it's not as lightweight or weatherproof as the Micro Puff Storm. It features a thick construct with lofty insulation and a 40-denier 100% continuous nylon shell. While it's not waterproof the insulation retains warmth when wet and the many layers do a great job keeping the nasty stuff on the outside of the jacket. The continuous face fabric also does a great job cutting the wind and protecting from the elements.

The Patagonia Micro Puff stacks nicely under a lightweight shell when bad weather comes in. Here we climb into the clouds on Crestone Peak in Colorado.
The Patagonia Micro Puff stacks nicely under a lightweight shell when bad weather comes in. Here we climb into the clouds on Crestone Peak in Colorado.

The Rab Xenon X is another contender that offers a similar level of performance with its Pertex Quantum face fabric that repels water and wind. This is an excellent option for anybody looking for a great midweight jacket that offers a wind-shell as a face fabric…a unique design for an insulation jacket.

Of the quilted competitors, the The North Face ThermoBall offers the best weather resistance. It's baffled design allows some airflow but it does not make it impervious to a sharp wind. Though it does a better job than both the thinner Patagonia Micro Puff and Patagonia Nano Puff because of its tighter stitching patterns. Also, the fabric, when put into the shower test, absorbed little to no water, and repelled water effectively…making it much more weather resistant than most.

When it's close to freezing  a windy and shaded belay is not ideal. Luckily Alison could layer her Patagonia Nano over a soft shell to both lock in heat and cut the wind. This layer doesn't hack it on this exposed  frigid belay.
When it's close to freezing, a windy and shaded belay is not ideal. Luckily Alison could layer her Patagonia Nano over a soft shell to both lock in heat and cut the wind. This layer doesn't hack it on this exposed, frigid belay.

Finally, it's important to note the more breathable products scored lower in this metric. For example, the North Face Ventrix isn't as wind-resistant as jackets built with a continuous face fabric. Though, its base layers are a little thicker than the OR Ascendent Hoody making it more wind resistant for blustery days. The Arc'teryx Atom LT Hoody has breathable, stretchy panels under the arms to allow more airflow, equating to less wind resistance. Of these three, the North Face Ventrix provides the best weather resistance because its inner and outer layers are stacked together to hold their insulation in place, providing a double layer of protection, in comparison to the single layer found in the other jackets.

Comfort & Coziness


Looking to burrow down while the comforts of your coat surround your torso and face? In this metric, we look at the comfort and cozy features of each jacket. Think fur-lined collars, fleece-lined interiors, helmet compatibility and more! Contenders that scored the highest in this metric have the best features tested. These insulated synthetic jackets are ones that our testers didn't want to take off!


Our testers fell in love with the super cozy OR Women's Ascendant for its amazing furry liner and soft-shell fabric. Both are soft to the touch, and moves with your body, whether you're climbing or hiking. While this fleece liner is a little sticky and not super easy to layer with bulky or fleecy layers, it is a cozy and great wear all day option.

Steph sports the uber-breathable OR Women's Ascendant Hoody that is perfectly cozy for morning coffee before climbing in Indian Creek.
Steph sports the uber-breathable OR Women's Ascendant Hoody that is perfectly cozy for morning coffee before climbing in Indian Creek.

All of the coats tested showed some affinity for helmet compatibility. Some, however, provided more room between the collar and body of the jacket. Some jackets like the Patagonia Nano Air, and Arc'teryx models feature a garaged zipper, keeping metal of the face in frosty conditions. Take a look at the picture below to compare the helmet compatibility of each jacket tested.

The garaged zipper and softer face fabric of the Nano Air are both great comfort features.
The garaged zipper and softer face fabric of the Nano Air are both great comfort features.

All jackets had some features of coziness and comfort. Loftiness was a significant consideration here. In this realm, the loftiest jackets are the Black Diamond Stance and the Rab Xenon X. Wearing it feels like slipping into a cozy and warm sleeping bag.

The ultra-lofty nature of the Rab Xenon X is super cozy and comfortable - especially on cold days.
The ultra-lofty nature of the Rab Xenon X is super cozy and comfortable - especially on cold days.

Breathability


Breathability is an important metric to consider so we can discuss if a jacket has the affinity to be used for exercise throughout the seasons. The more breathable options we tested typically have softer face fabrics or "breathable panels" that allow ample airflow in high sweat areas like under the arms or the back. A more breathable jacket is better for aerobic activities like hiking or running in cold weather, but sacrifice warmth and weather resistance as a trade-off.


Of all the jackets tested though, the Outdoor Research Ascendent is by far the best at wicking and breathing. The fleece liner wicks away moisture while the insulation is quite porous allowing one to easily off-load heat. This jacket surpasses other option because of this construction, making it our top go-to for super sweaty endeavors like winter running or cross-country skiing.

The Atom LT is super breathable and a perfect option for morning runs due to its breathable face fabric and paneling under the armpits.
The Atom LT is super breathable and a perfect option for morning runs due to its breathable face fabric and paneling under the armpits.

If you seek a breathable jacket that offers a little more warmth, the North Face Ventrix Hoody scores well across the board, being more versatile over a broader range of seasons. The materials are a little bit thicker (and thus not as breathable), but it's more protective from wind and rain, making it a great mid layer or stand-alone jacket. The Arc'teryx Atom LT offers a similar level of breathability with a less fitted construction and less warmth.

Steph hikes up to the crag in the super breathable OR Ascendant Hoody  that earns a perfect ten score in this metric.
Steph hikes up to the crag in the super breathable OR Ascendant Hoody, that earns a perfect ten score in this metric.

The Atom LT is a great option as a mid-layer in the winter or as a wear-alone option while climbing or hiking in the shoulder seasons. Both offer breathability right through the face of the fabric, with the Atom LT sporting nifty vents along the armpits and sides of the jacket, with thinner materials.

The Nano Air kept us warm during ice climbing days and dry on long winter runs. It is the highest quality mobile fabric design in our testing pool.
The Nano Air kept us warm during ice climbing days and dry on long winter runs. It is the highest quality mobile fabric design in our testing pool.

Style & Fit


As in many of the women's clothing reviews that we do here at OutdoorGearLab, style is a component of this review. We recognize that many women are looking for jackets that have a flattering and feminine fit that will accommodate the length of their torso and arms. When considering style, we look at the cut, baffle shapes, fun features (like fur!), stitching patterns, and fabric type. We also note the length of the arms and torso to help our longer-limbed ladies find a jacket that will actually fit them! We then compare and contrast each model to give you a tangible style and fit rating. Those with more stylish features and fit both short and long-limbed testers than those that did not have these features.


Fit

Many of the jackets provided different fits based on the body types testing them. In this metric, we used some different women to gain an opinion on each piece. Of all jackets tested, some of the most versatile pieces include the Rab Xenon X, OR Ascendent Hoody, Patagonia Micro Puff Strom, and The North Face Thermoball Hoody. All of these options feature a longer torso and arms that fit our short and tall testers.

A look at the comparative lengths of some of the insulated jacket tested. Some fit those with a short torso while others feature longer arms and body.
A look at the comparative lengths of some of the insulated jacket tested. Some fit those with a short torso while others feature longer arms and body.

Style

The Arc'teryx jackets offer a level of craftsmanship and style that is unrivaled by any other model. Getting many compliments on the street, the Arc'teryx Atom LT features a continuous nylon face fabric and breathable arm panels that transition with different shapes of its primary color. This in addition to its flattering feminine cut had many of our testers eliciting "oooohs and awwws" whenever we pulled it out. It features the best colors of any jackets that most of our testers loved!

The Atom LT is a super cute jacket  perfect for wear around town or while hiking in the wilderness.
The Atom LT is a super cute jacket, perfect for wear around town or while hiking in the wilderness.

More technical pieces like the Patagonia Nano Air, OR Refuge, and OR Ascendent frequently elicited reactions like, "Oooooooh! It's so cute." Many of our testers like the soft face fabric feel (others didn't) offered by the Patagonia Nano Air and the OR Refuge. The OR Ascendant also has a soft face fabric but doesn't have any side baffling, and has a basic design (thus scoring a little lower). Both have fabrics that stretch to accommodate all shapes and sizes. The OR Ascendant has a longer torso and arms than the Patagonia Nano Air, fitting a wide range of body types. We really liked the OR Refuge because while the fabrics aren't super tight, they have a nice hourglass shape and flattering stitching (and color) patterns.

Luna takes the North Face Ventrix out for a spin while crushing rock in Boulder Canyon.
Luna takes the North Face Ventrix out for a spin while crushing rock in Boulder Canyon.

Conclusion


Choosing an insulated jacket can seem tough with so many options. Though, by acknowledging what you are looking for in an insulated jacket is the first step to determine which one is best for you. We hope that this review will help you find your next perfect insulated jacket for all the adventures you will embark upon in the future.


Amber King