The tough part of OutdoorGearLab reviews is that we choose only the best to test and then critique them obsessively picking them apart from every possible angle. Sometimes this can make a product that performs well seem like it's bottom-of-the-barrel in comparison to the best of the best. This is the REI Co-op Merino Top. A fantastic top that performs well, is comfortable, breathes and does a good job wicking sweat away from your skin. It is the lowest scoring merino wool layer. That means it is a great all-around top but didn't stand out in any specific category in comparison to the other tops. Overall this is a layer that gets the job done, and you'll be happy with, but if you want a base layer that performs extraordinarily in a specific category, we've got those too. Similar weight to the Icebreaker 200 Oasis, this top is slightly less durable and took a bit longer to dry than the Icebreaker. For $80 though, it's tough to find a solid merino wool top that's less expensive than this REI model.
REI Co-op Merino Midweight Review
Cons: Not durable, loose fit thru torso, loses shape after consistent washing/drying
Manufacturer: REI Co-op
Compare to Similar Products
REI Co-op Merino Midweight
|Price||$79.50 at REI||$65.93 at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$85 List||$55.00 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$64.98 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|Pros||Super comfortable, odor resistant, breathable, fun colors, wicks well||Excellent temperature regulation, cozy comfy feel, very warm, breathable, doesn’t hold odor.||Lightweight, breathable, fast to dry, great fit||Ultra-lightweight, extremely breathable, quick to dry, soft, doubles as sun shirt, affordable||Comfortable, nice fit, breathable, versatile, quick to dry, odor resistant|
|Cons||Not durable, loose fit thru torso, loses shape after consistent washing/drying||Expensive, not the most durable, heavy when wet||Not super warm, low durability||Not very warm, not super durable||Expensive, lack of durability, heavy when wet|
|Bottom Line||A super comfortable 100% merino wool midweight base layer that is warm enough for winter ventures but light enough to carry you through Spring and Fall outings.||Our Editors’ Choice scores high across every metric making its way into our hearts as a favorite, keeping us warm, dry, and comfortable in any situation.||Our Top Pick for breathability, this layer excels at wicking sweat and keeping you dry during high output activities. With an excellent fit and lightweight, comfortable material, this is a favorite among testers.||An ultra-lightweight base layer top that is built for movement and high heart rate activities in anything from cool to hot conditions, a perfect all-around layer for the milder seasons at a great price.||Although not an award winner, this 100% merino wool top does a great job balancing warmth with breathability to bring you a solid, year-round workhorse.|
|Rating Categories||REI Co-op Merino Midweight||SmartWool Merino 250 Crew||Rab Merino+ 120 Crew||Capilene Lightweight Crew||Icebreaker 200 Oasis|
|Comfort And Fit (20%)|
|Drying Speed (15%)|
|Layering Ability (10%)|
|Specs||REI Co-op Merino...||SmartWool Merino...||Rab Merino+ 120 Crew||Capilene...||Icebreaker 200 Oasis|
|Material||100% merino wool||100% merino wool||Merino wool and polyester blend with 37.5™ Technology||100% recycled polyester double knit with Polygiene®||100% merino wool|
|Weight (size M)||8.5 oz||9.2 oz||5.1 oz||3.6 oz||7.7 oz|
|Types available||crew, 1/4 zip||crew, 1/4 zip, hoody, pullover||crew, 1/4 zip||crew, 1/4 zip, t-shirt||crew, short sleeve, half zip|
|Fabric Weight||200 g/m²||250 g/m²||120 g/m²||Unspecified||200 g/m²|
|Air Dry Test (minutes)||45||50||25||25||35|
|Fit||Slim fit||Slim fit||Slim fit||Slim fit||Slim fit|
|Stitching||Flat seams||Flatlock seams||Flatlock seams||Flatlock seams||Flatlock seams|
|Shoulder top seams?||No||No||No||No||No|
|Drop tail hem?||Yes||No||Yes||Yes||Yes|
Our Analysis and Test Results
REI's merino wool base layer enters the field as a contender as a comfortable and versatile midweight base layer to keep you warm and dry through the ski, hiking, and fishing seasons. A soft and cozy feel against the skin with a good fit, sensible design, and fun color combos allow this REI base layer to enter the big leagues. Although this layer isn't an all-star yet it has least entered the ring.
This top offers a pretty standard warmth rating when stood against other merino tops of comparable weight. Warm enough to keep you comfortable through resort season, hiking thru the snow and fall leaves, and backpacking in the crisp temps of early spring. It does well as a stand-alone layer, wind doesn't cut through it like more breathable options, and ups the toasty factor when layered.
This top scored average in almost every category, including breathability. That means it is efficient and better than the majority of base layers out there but not the most breathable top available. This is going to do a great job breathing in almost every situation you put it in except the most extreme demanding examples of extreme cold mixed with high-intensity output.
For the everyday user and outdoor enthusiast, it breathes well, wicks sweat and dries fairly quickly but is not at the top of its class.
Comfort and Fit
The merino wool is soft next to skin, and the itch is minimal and reduces with washings but still tended to be a little itchier than other merino layers. The printed tag sits smoothly against your neck. This layer sits baggy through the torso. Excess fabric under the arms and loose hem that feels a bit sloppy. It fits more like a long sleeve cotton t-shirt. This top lacks the thoughtful design and purposeful fit of layers like the Rab Merino+ 120 Crew or the Arc'teryx Phase AR.
We might consider sizing down for a traditional, snug base layer fit. Offset shoulder seams are great for carrying a backpack. Slightly longer drop-tail hem helps keep it from coming untucked or staying under a backpack hip belt. The drop-tail hem is also key when rolling over onto your side in your sleeping bag and exposing the small of your back to the cold. Minor underarm gusset reduces pull on your shoulders when lifting arms above your head but isn't as good as other brands' gusseted underarms. Tapered sleeves hug arms well and are snug against the wrist. Looks good enough that it can be comfortably worn as a stand-alone layer around town.
Overall, the fit is ok. The body is loose and a bit awkwardly baggy while the arms are tight and tapered making it an odd combo. It shrunk and changed shape after washing and drying.
This top came in the bottom half of the bunch in the dry speed test. It was the second slowest merino layer to dry next to the thicker SmartWool Merino 250 and took 10 minutes longer than the similar weight Icebreaker 200 Oasis Crew.
Merino layers are known for being heavy when wet and slow to dry, although all the merino layers dried faster than two synthetic tops that we tested from Arc'teryx and The North Face.
Merino is more durable than it used to be but still not a quality that it's known for. In our abrasion test, we wore a hole through the fabric. There were only two other tops that sported a hole from our abrasion test, the Patagonia Capilene Air and The North Face Warm Crew.
This top was one of the only layers to shrink/change shape noticeably after washing and drying. Not the most durable but not the least, again this top finds itself falling in the middle of the pack.
This layer has the smoothest feeling face fabric of all the merino tops we tested which helps with layering. The smoothness allows it to not stick when putting a tighter fleece mid layer over top of it although the bagginess through the torso makes it feel a bit bulky and bunched up under a tight mid-layer. The looser fit and baggy hem allow it to fit naturally over a t-shirt but the tight sleeves don't work over another long sleeve.
This top does great for any outdoor venture in mild to cold temperatures. Resort skiing, hiking, fishing, or hiking. It doesn't perform at the highest standards but is adequate across the board.
At $79 it is the cheapest 100% merino wool layer but is also the lowest scoring merino wool layer so we'd say the value is appropriate to the performance of the top.
Not a home run hitter in any category but a consistent performer for the price point. It is soft, comfortable, warm, breathable, versatile, and looks good around town or apres ski. All in all, it doesn't receive our highest marks but does get an accepting head nod, letting it know that it's doing a good job and has the potential to become something great someday. It's good, but not great like most breakfast diners.
— Roland Mott