Mystery Ranch Skyline 17 Review
Cons: Heavy, no key clip, not tapered
Manufacturer: Mystery Ranch
Compare to Similar Products
Mystery Ranch Skyline 17
$119.00 at Amazon
$108.95 at Backcountry
|$82.46 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
$62.32 at Amazon
|$44.96 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|Pros||Durable, functional, versatile||Simple, great zippered pocket, streamlined||Durable, comfortable, simple||Light, great features, roomy||Simple, sturdy, light|
|Cons||Heavy, no key clip, not tapered||Limited attachment points, easy to drop stuff||Heavy, few hydration features||Fragile, not super versatile||No emergency whistle, draw cord and cord lock blend into pack|
|Bottom Line||Though it's heavy, this pack makes up for it with durability and great climbing features||Though there are no extra features, this bag ticks all the boxes for multi-pitch climbing||This comfortable and utilitarian pack is light on features but heavy on durability||This small and light climbing pack is well optimized for alpine action||This is a great pack for multi-pitch rock climbs at a very fair price|
|Rating Categories||Mystery Ranch Skyli...||The North Face Rout...||Black Diamond Creek 20||Black Diamond Blitz 20||Black Diamond Rock...|
|Climbing Utility (25%)|
|Specs||Mystery Ranch Skyli...||The North Face Rout...||Black Diamond Creek 20||Black Diamond Blitz 20||Black Diamond Rock...|
|Measured Weight||1.4 lbs||1.1 lbs||1.7 lbs||0.9 lbs||0.9 lbs|
|Fabric Type||1000D cordura nylon||420D nylon||1200D polyester with TPU coating||Dynex (210D + PE 200D)||840D nylon|
|Accessory Pockets?||One internal zip, one external zip||One external zip||One internal zip||One external zip, one internal zip||One external zip, one internal zip|
|Outside Carry Options?||Top strap, side straps, ice axe attachments||Daisy chains||Top strap, two daisy chains||Top strap, ice axe attachments||Top strap doubles as rope strap|
|Hip Belt?||Yes, removable||Yes, removable||Yes, removable||Yes, removable||Yes, removable|
|Hydration System Compatible?||Yes||Yes||No||Yes||Yes|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Mystery Ranch Skyline 17 is a relatively new pack from a venerable American pack company. Though they're not known for being ultralight, Mystery Ranch products do have a reputation for durability and functionality, and the Skyline lives up to that reputation.
When it comes to comfort, one of the things we like about the Skyline 17 is the relatively short back length. No climber wants interference at either the top (helmet) or bottom (chalk bag) of a climbing pack. A shorter pack can fit a taller climber, but not the other way around. The back length was great for our 5'11" lead tester, but it also worked for shorter folks. Additionally, the padding on the back of the pack gave good protection for those times when we crammed a rack in there. However, we wish that the pack had some top-to-bottom taper, which helps you forget the rack is in there while climbing and that the padded part of the shoulder straps was longer.
The Skyline 17 has many of the features we like in a climbing pack, and they're done well. A whistle is integrated into the sternum strap buckle, and the hip belt attaches to the pack with a simple girth hitch and is easily removable. There are a pair of grab loops on top of the pack that can be easily rigged for hauling. If you do need to haul, the top strap, side compression straps, and the ice axe attachments are all removable. Though removing the ice axe attachments is not intuitive, our testers love that these things are removable without using scissors.
The hydration system carry is decent, but if your reservoir doesn't have a clip or hook built into the top, you'll need to rig something up. Hanging a reservoir in the pack also blocks access to the internal mesh pocket. We missed a key clip on this bag as well.
The Skyline 17 is about as durable as a pack can be without being a haul bag. Much of that is due to the materials. The pack body is made of 1000 denier Cordura, and the zippers are a reliable #10 YKK. The only way we could see this pack being more durable would be by adding a flap of fabric over the zipper for protection.
While the overall style and look of the Skyline didn't knock our socks off, we do find it to be fairly versatile. We don't measure volume ourselves in this review, but our testers felt like this pack was a bit bigger than the stated size. Small and medium-sized laptops can fit inside. So could the ingredients for a few meals from the grocery store.
The ice axe attachment points expand this pack's options into snowy/icy realms, though the size might be a limiting factor on colder days. The detachable top and side straps make securing a rope to the outside quite easy, and the daisy chains on the front expand the attachment options.
This is among the heavier packs in our review (see below), so it is not a first choice for stuffing into a larger pack for an extended backcountry mission.
This is not an ultralight climbing pack, and we were fine with that — it could never be ultralight with materials this beefy. This bag weighs 1.4 pounds (about 640 grams). Removing the top and side straps and the ice axe attachments can shave off a few ounces, but ultimately the Skyline prioritizes durability over weight.
This is not one of the cheaper packs in our test. However, it is built to last, and we think that in the hands of a climber who will be using it regularly, it is a good value.
The Mystery Ranch Skyline 17 does most of the things we want a small climbing pack to do, and it does those things reasonably well. It's comfortable for climbers of many sizes and shapes, quite functional, and can be used for other stuff. It's on the heavy side, but that's the cost of a pack this durable.
— Ian McEleney
Ad-free. Influence-free. Powered by Testing.
GearLab is founded on the principle of honest, objective, reviews. Our experts test thousands of products each year using thoughtful test plans that bring out key performance differences between competing products. And, to assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. No cherry-picked units sent by manufacturers. No sponsored content. No ads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing and comparison.Learn More