Midland GXT1000VP4 Two Way Review
Compare prices at 2 resellers Pros: Good range
Cons: Large, expensive, poor battery life
Compare to Similar Products
Midland GXT1000VP4 Two Way
|Price||$69.99 at Amazon|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$189.96 at Amazon||$70 List||$70 List||$29.95 at REI|
|Pros||Good range||Easy to use, great range, great battery life, good weather resistance||Small size, solid range, water resistant||Excellent range, has an extraordinary amount of features/settings, good battery life||Inexpensive, small and light, water resistant, has privacy codes|
|Cons||Large, expensive, poor battery life||Large and heavy, very expensive||More expensive, poor battery life, questionable quality control||Difficult to set up and learn to use, has the capability to get you in trouble with the FCC||Poor range, inaccurate battery indicator|
|Bottom Line||With poor battery life and decent range, this radio's positives don't make up for its size and price||Aside from its larger size, this radio performed with excellence all around, especially in ease of use||Battery life and the price are the two weakest points of the X-Talker 36 that otherwise has solid range, small size, and water resistance||Licensed ham radio operators will appreciate the amazing range and tons of features||While it has poor range, this inexpensive radio is our top recommendation in its price range|
|Rating Categories||Midland GXT1000VP4 Two Way||BC Link 2.0||Midland X-Talker 36||BaoFeng BF-F8HP||Midland X-Talker T10|
|Range And Clarity (30%)|
|Ease Of Use (25%)|
|Weather Resistance And Durability (15%)|
|Battery Life (15%)|
|Weight And Size (15%)|
|Specs||Midland GXT1000VP4...||BC Link 2.0||Midland X-Talker 36||BaoFeng BF-F8HP||Midland X-Talker T10|
|Measured Weight (Single Radio, with Batteries)||7.4 oz||11.0 oz||5.0 oz||7.8 oz||3.9 oz|
|Battery Capacity||700 mAh||2,300 mAh||700mAh||2,000 mAh||1,000 mAh|
|Battery Type||NiMH, Alkaline AA||Lithium Ion||NiHM, Alkaline AAA||Lithium Ion||AAA|
|Rechargeable?||Yes, also can use normal AA batteries||Yes||Yes, or normal AAA||Yes||No|
|Charge Via USB?||No||Yes||Yes||No||n/a|
|Battery Life Test Results (hr:min)||9:00||22:45||11:40||17:40||21:20|
|Frequency Range||462.55 to 467.71 MHz||462.55 to 467.71 MHz||462.5625 to 467.7125 MHz||65-108MHz (FM Receive only) 136-174MHz and 400-520MHz (TX/RX)||462.55 to 467.71 MHz|
|Dimensions (in) Body Only||2.4 x 1.2 x 4.9"||3.9 x 2.4 x 2" Body;
3.15 x 2.2 x 1" Mic
|1.30 x 2.20 x 6.10"||2 x 1.2 x 3.7"||2 x 1 x 3.5"|
|Privacy Codes?||Yes, 104 available||Yes||121 available||Yes||Yes, 38 available|
|NOAA Weather Alerts?||Yes||Yes||Yes||No||Yes|
|Clips to Pack?||Yes||Yes||Yes||No (mounts sold separately)||Yes|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Midland GXT's range is its strong suit, while its short battery life left us wishing for more. Its large screen and more user-friendly control layout were necessary to efficiently navigate the larger number of functions this radio offers. The added capability of this radio struggles to compensate for its larger size (7.4 ounces and 8 inches tall) and price tag.
Range and Clarity
The GXT reached the middle of the pack with a range of 2.8 miles in our unobstructed straight line range test. This was a small increase over cheaper and smaller options. It performed relatively even better in the hill test and the poor weather test, but it still was not quite in the top echelon of radios with good range.
Ease of Use
This radio ended up being quite average in its ease of use. We really like that it has a volume/power knob for easy and quick adjustments. It also has five larger buttons on the front to navigate the menu. We like the menu navigation more than on some other more basic radios, but we found that the additional options in the menu in comparison to simpler radios made for a similar amount of confusion. As with most others, all of the functions are not immediately easy to adjust, but a few minutes with the directions sorted us out.
We found the buttons just big enough to operate with gloved hands, and the volume knob makes gloved life much easier. The belt clip has a nice spring, but still not secure enough for such a large radio in rough terrain. The display has a nice backlight that lights up when you press buttons, making night operation a bit easier. When changing the batteries, we found the rubber seal around the battery door to easily jump out and potentially get lost. The key lock worked most of the time, but did once become unlocked and start changing settings in our pack.
Weather Resistance and Durability
Midland says that this radio is resistant to splashing water from any direction. While we found that splashing water does not seem to get inside of the radio, it did often muffle the microphone to the point that it was hard to hear what the person with the wet radio was saying. We also found that in dirty conditions, any metallics in the dirt would stick to the speaker magnet and leave unsightly dirt in the small slots of the speaker cover.
This radio has a tendency to show wear faster than others we tested. The plastic casing seemed softer and less durable than others, and it has more scratches as a result. It comes with a one year warranty, but that does not include damage due to water.
The rechargeable battery pack (that can also be replaced with 5 AA batteries) lasted only 9 hours in our battery test, which was less than half the life of many other options. It also had a misleading battery indicator that jumped from full to totally drained in a matter of minutes. We did like that the radio has the versatility to be charged or just to put batteries in, but that is its best attribute in this category.
Weight and Size
At 7.4 ounces with battery pack, this radio is one the heavier end of the spectrum. It is about 8 inches tall including the antenna, which also makes it one of the largest. It felt bulky in a jacket pocket, so we preferred to use the supplied belt clip or keep it in our backpack when it was not in use much.
This radio has a middle of the road price and a lower than average overall score. If having good battery life and small size are not a top priority for you, you can get good range and more functions for a decent price with this radio.
This is a pretty mid-pack radio on a lot of fronts. It boasts pretty good range and plenty of features, but it is a bit more spendy and larger than some pretty comparable ones. We liked that it is water resistant, but we were disappointed to have the sound muffled so much by the water.
— Gray Grandy