The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of outdoor gear

Mountain Laurel Designs TrailStar Review

The Trailstar pitched close to the ground with five points tied out.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:  $230 List
Pros:  Tremendous coverage and strength for its weight, multiple pitching configurations, simple and reliable.
Cons:  Large footprint requires large campsites, door needs to be repositioned when wind changes direction, hard to enter and exit.
Manufacturer:   Mountain Laurel Designs
By Chris McNamara and Max Neale  ⋅  Apr 13, 2015
  • Share this article:
63
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Livability - 15% 7
  • Ease of Set-up - 5% 5
  • Weather Resistance - 30% 8
  • Durability - 10% 8
  • Adaptability - 10% 3
  • Weight - 30% 5

The Skinny

The Mountain Laurel Designs TrailStar cuts through high winds likes a fighter jet. The Trailstar's large footprint, however, requires relatively large sites that, depending where you are, can take longer to find. The shelter's low angle walls are not suitable for serious snow loading. And, because the tarp performs poorly in cuben fiber, the silnylon version (that we tested) is relatively heavy compared to other types of floorless shelters.

Some people love the Trailstar, but over the years our testers have developed a strong preference for flat tarps or pyramids. If you want a spacious tarp that can handle epic weather we suggest getting a pyramid tarp, specifically the Mountain Laurel Designs SuperMid.

Like many of the ultralight shelters we tested the TrailStar is not widely available on at major online retailers. The Black Diamond Beta Light however, is available at many online retailers, often on sale.


Our Analysis and Test Results

You can buy the TrailStar at www.mountainlaureldesigns.com.

Performance Comparison



Livability


The Trailstar can be pitched in many different configurations that offer varying degrees of comfort. The most common configuration (both for our testers and, an image search reveals, by the masses) is pitching it with a taller trekking pole in the middle and a medium length pole at the entrance. As long as you keep the angles right the Trailstar is a highly customizable. With long lines it can be pitched several feet off the ground or buttoned down tight against the ground. When pitched with 6-8" between the bottom wall and the ground the shelter provides two people with lots of space to lay down and to store gear. Head room is less plentiful in another configuration. When the Trailstar is locked to the ground it's admittedly difficult to enter and exit.

Mountain Laurel Designs Trailstar pitched in storm mode close to the ground.
Mountain Laurel Designs Trailstar pitched in storm mode close to the ground.

Weather Resistance


Wind glides over the Trailstar as fast and as fluidly as an Olympic speed skater. It's difficult to estimate just how sturdy the shelter is in very high winds — it depends largely on stake and soil type and other campsite characteristics — but we believe that it's capable of protecting you in every condition found by backpackers. Pitching it around 120cm height works well for most conditions and dropping the center pole to around 100cm allows you to lock the edges close to the ground. The Trailstar's longer walls, when compared to most A-frame and falt tarps, reduce the amount of force applied to each tieout, which is critical because it can be difficult to truly lock the edges of many tarps to the ground. The Trailstar feels very safe and secure in high winds.

The low flat design is much less capable of handling snowloading, however, when compared to mids. A few inches of snow in the shoulder season is no problem, but we don't believe the Trailstar is suitable for winter nights that bring 6+ inches of snow. Mids with four steep walls do much better with snow loading.

The Trailstar is cut from high quality 30 denier silnylon and constructed with an attention to detail that few other silnylon shelters can match. Unlike most self-supporting double wall tents found in our backpacking tent review this is a shelter that's competent on extended trips to the planet's most remote areas. When sleeping in the Trailstar during a serious storm far from the nearest trailhead one feels comfortable and secure and confident that the shelter will not break.

The Trailstar pitched close to the ground with five points tied out.
The Trailstar pitched close to the ground with five points tied out.

Weight and Packed Size


Our silnyon Trailstar weighed 18 oz. before we seam sealed it and attached a generous amount of guyline. Afterwards it weighed 22.1 oz. You can save some additional weight by purchasing lighter guyline that doesn't absorb as much water.

Adaptability


The Trailstar is adapatable in that it can be pitched in a variety of ways. Unfortunately, each configuration is relatively similar and takes up a large area. In our rating we score the Trailstar higher than pyramid tarps and considerably lower than A-frame and flat tarps. The Trailstar is rather poor at adapting to sites that require a suboptimal pitch.

Limitations


The Trailstar is limited by its large footprint. While testing the shelter in the High Sierra we were unable to camp in sites that accommodate pyramid tarps and many self-supporting tents. When walking through rocky terrain it can often take much longer to find a suitable campsite; if pitched close to the ground the long, low walls may touch rocks close to the perimeter, which, when combined with wind, may abrade the silnylon. Pitching requires a relatively large flat area free of obstacles, perhaps 12 ft. by 12 ft. in area. Therefore, it's important to consider if the terrain will accommodate the Trailstar. In most places, and certainly in many established campsites in forested areas, the shelter goes up without a problem. Some long distance hikers and those that travel off trail in may find a shelter with a smaller footprint to be better for their needs. The magnitude of this drawback will largely depend on the terrain that you plan to travel through and, if venturing through rocky or densely forested areas, your ability to identify potential campsites in advance.

When the wind changed direction at night we had get out and reposition the door so that it didn't catch as much wind. This can be annoying, as it requires repositioning multiple tieouts, but choosing good campsites can largely mitigate the problem.

Both for first time users and experienced users the Trailstar is more difficult to pitch than many other shelters tested here. It's not terribly difficult, but it does take longer and requires more finagling than pyramids and the A-frame tarps we've tested.

The Trailstar walks the line between being a tarp and a mid, but we don't believe that it matches the performance of mids in winter weather. This is a do-it-all 3three-season shelter, not a four-season shelter capable of significant snow loading.

Best Application


We believe the Trailstar is best suited to camping in exposed areas with high winds that have large campsites.

Value


$230 for a top-of-the-line bombproof shelter! This is an excellent value.

How to Get It


The Trailstar is not sold by major commercial or online retailers. Get it online at

www.mountainlaureldesigns.com

It's important to note that Mountain Laurel Designs has a heinously long wait time and that their website is very difficult to use and is rarely updated. Through purchasing at least five products we've found that it usually takes 4 to 10 weeks to get something from their online checkout to our doorstep. Mountain Laurel Designs builds excellent products, and offers custom options on everything they make, but you must plan ahead.

Check out this fun setup video.


Chris McNamara and Max Neale