Leatherman Surge Review
Cons: Heavy and large; limited portability. Proprietary bit driver.
Compare to Similar Products
|Price||$129.95 at Amazon||$170 List||$79.95 at Amazon||$99.95 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$139.95 at Amazon|
|Pros||Large, excellent construction, full-size functions, customizable||Sophisticated, comprehensive||Compact, light, with multiple carry options, smart, effective tools||Comprehensive, well-made, aftermarket accessories and carry options||Easy tool and plier deployment, Leatherman pedigree|
|Cons||Heavy and large; limited portability. Proprietary bit driver||Heavy, expensive||Few features||Proprietary bit driver, no pocket clip included||No bit driver, magnets pick up metal grit|
|Bottom Line||This tool pulls no punches: it optimizes for function at the cost of portability||The sky-high standard by which other multi tools are compared||Clever and clean, with only a few tools, all of which are executed well for everyday carry||All you should need, with proven pedigree, at a forgiving price||Typical feature set packaged in a fundamentally different hinged package|
|Rating Categories||Leatherman Surge||Leatherman Charge+ TTi||Leatherman Skeletool CX||Leatherman Wave+||Leatherman Free P4|
|Construction Quality (25%)|
|Specs||Leatherman Surge||Leatherman Charge+...||Leatherman...||Leatherman Wave+||Leatherman Free P4|
|Number of Functions||19 + bits||19 + bits||5 + bits||18 + bits||21|
|Weight (ounces)||12.2 oz. 14.3 oz with case||8.8 oz||5.0 oz||8.5 oz. 9.5 oz with case||8.8 oz|
|Locking Tools?||All but pliers||All but pliers||All but pliers||All but pliers||All but pliers|
|Pliers Type||Needlenose, regular, wire cutters, hard-wire cutters, crimper||Needlenose with wire cutters, crimper||Needlenose with 2 wire cutters||Needlenose, regular, wire cutters, hard-wire cutters, crimper||Needlenose, regular|
|Tools Accessible Without Deploying Pliers||Blades, saw, file||Blades, saw, file||Blade||Blades, saw, file||All|
|Blades and Type||1 straight, 1 serrated||1 serrated gut hook type, 1 straight drop point||1 straight drop point||1 straight, 1 serrated||1 straight 1 serated|
|Number of screwdrivers||4 included, more available aftermarket for proprietary driver||1 integrated. Many bits included, with more available aftermarket for proprietary driver||4 included, more available aftermarket for proprietary driver||5 included/integrated. More available aftermarket for proprietary driver||1|
|File?||Yes, wood/metal and a diamond-coated file||Yes, wood/metal and a diamond-coated file||No||Yes, wood/metal and a diamond-coated file||Yes|
|Saw?||Yes||Metal and wood||No||Yes||Wood|
|Openers||Can and bottle||Can and bottle||Bottle||Can and bottle||Bottle and can|
|Other important Features||Ruler, awl, wire stripper||Ruler, cutting hook, wire stripper||None||Ruler||One-handed blades. Replacable wire-cutters|
|Other carry options||Pocket clip, key ring||Carabiner style clip, pocket clip||Pocket , pocket clip|
|Closed dimensions (Length by thickness, in inches)||4.5 x 0.8||4 x 0.8||4.3 x 0.6||4 x 0.7||4.2 x 0.7|
|Open Length (Pliers) (inches)||7.1in||6.2 in||6.2 in||6.3 in||6.5 in|
|Open Overall Length (Primary blade deployed) (inches)||7.6 in||7 in||6.8 in||6.9 in||4.25 in|
|Length of Primary Blade Effective Edge (inches)||3.1 in||2.8 in||2.6 in||2.8in||2.8 in|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Surge is Leatherman's largest multi-tool. It is indeed giant. It weighs over 3/4 pound and has a main blade that is nearly as long as that on your typical full-size pocket knife. The pliers are super robust and sturdy. The scissors are larger even than those on a full-size swiss army knife. With this large size utility increases but portability decreases. The result is a product that really only works for tool-box, vehicle, or belt carry. One can get an aftermarket pocket clip for this tool, but it will quickly wear out your pants if it doesn't pull them down first.
The variety of functions on the Surge is pretty standard for high-end multi-tools. With all the bulk, you had better hope the Surge would be comprehensive. You won't be disappointed. Of the tools included in multi-tools, the Surge basically has it all. Of course, we have our gripes and wishes. First, and this echos for nearly all Leatherman brand tools, we wish that the bit driver used standard 1/4" drive bits without an adapter. Given the layout of nearly every Leatherman tool, we don't see a good reason why they use the thinned-down proprietary bit format they use. Sale of accessories stands out as a possible reason. The Surge could be rearranged to fit a full-size 1/4" bit driver in there with minimal "cost" to the bulk or selection of other tools.
We expect excellent construction quality in Leatherman brand tools. The Surge is exactly what we would expect. Further, because of its large size and flouting of weight limits, the materials and tools are thick and stiff. Surge pivots and springs are as tight as those on the Editors' Choice but the steel is even thicker and more robust.
For routine and novel use the large size of the Surge is largely welcome. Larger tools, up to a point, are easier to use. In the case of the Surge, it only tips into the "too large" category in terms of the pliers-closed handle size. For extended whittling or other knife work, especially in small hands, the large profile of the mostly-closed tool is strenuous and slightly insecure. Otherwise, the large pliers and scissors are very nice to use. The scissors aren't as tight and clean to cut with as others, but they are large.
The flip side of large, easy to use tools is portability. It is basically too large and too heavy for daily carry. Only those that can and will wear a belt sheath will find the Surge to live handily on their person. Otherwise, it pretty much has to live in a toolbox or glove compartment or luggage for extended use. Of course, for short periods wearing it loose or pocket clipped (with the aftermarket Leatherman pocket clip) will work too.
For the quality and function, you will pay. The Surge is in the same price range as the Editors' Choice Charge TTI, but doesn't include the fancier materials and extra bits of the award winner. You pay for the size and mass and strength of the Surge.
The Leatherman Surge has a narrow appeal but fills an important niche. It is heavy and large but very functional. "Portable tools" exist along a spectrum, with portability on one end and "tool-ability" at the other end. The Surge is nearly a full-function tool that is sort of portable.
— Jediah Porter