We've tested a ton of packs over the course of decades here at OutdoorGearLab. They get steadily better, at better and better prices. While little is currently notable about the REI Co-op Trail 25, we have the long view. We are happy to report that it is the culmination of many years of development, drawing from across the entire business. The design and shape are that of what would have been, 15 years ago, one of the more sophisticated packs on the market. It faces some tough competition from similarly cheap packs like our Best Buy REI Co-op Flash 22, which takes the cake for value due to its similar features and volume but far lighter weight. However, for the upgrades available in, say, the Editors' Choice Osprey Talon 22, you will pay two to three times more. We recommend the Trail 25 for those who value durability and versatility in their daypack.
REI Co-op Trail 25 Review
Cons: No padded waist belt, heavy for the volume and features
Compare to Similar Products
Our Analysis and Test Results
All iterations of the REI Trail 25 have pleased us. The latest version makes minor tweaks but maintains the value, quality, and usability we like. The Trail 25 scores higher than many packs that cost a lot more.
A daypack's comfort is, primarily, a function of the load. Some carry just a water bottle and windbreaker in their day pack. For that, the most basic construction is appropriate. Others, though, are carrying cold weather clothing, some technical equipment, 12-hours worth of food and water, and associated emergency supplies. That weight adds up to a heavy load that taxes a body.
Comfort under the heaviest loads requires more support than the Trail 25 provides. The thin waist belt and soft back panel simply won't support beefy loads as well as more sophisticated designs. That said, many on our test team have carried expedition loads in packs that aren't much different, in terms of comfort, than the REI Trail 25. This isn't the most comfortable pack, but it will do the job.
However, for the hip belt on this pack to do any good at hauling a load, it will need to fit you, and the back length on this pack is not adjustable. The soft back panel pads and webbing waist belt design of the REI Trail 25 is essentially the same as the suspension system of the Osprey Daylite, the Deuter Speed Lite 20, and the Arc Teryx Brize 25. This configuration does the job. Of course, the more rigid, structured, and contoured back panels of the Editors' Choice Osprey Talon 22 will be more supportive and vent perspiration better.
Weight to Volume Ratio
The Trail 25 weighs 31 ounces and can carry up to 26 L, for a weight to volume ratio of 1.2 oz/L. The pack is made of relatively thick fabrics, with more than average zippers and pockets, as well as some heavy metal buckles. Balancing these weightier attributes is the fact that the pack has a simple, low key suspension system and isn't super large. Its compression straps tighten down the load well around the entire pack and make it very stable.
This weight threshold marks a line between packs that have padded waist belts and those that do not. This pack and those lighter have webbing waist belts, while those that are heavier have padded waist belts. There are exceptions, in that there are heavier packs with webbing waist belts. There are no packs lighter than the Trail 25 that have padded waist belts. The pack that is currently the heaviest in our test is nearly twice the weight of the Trail 25. This is the Editor's Choice REI Co-op Traverse 35 at 54 ounces. The lightest pack in our test, the Top Pick REI Co-op Flash 18, is less than half the weight of the Trail 25 at 9 ounces. The Top Pick Osprey Daylite Plus is similar in weight.
Cycling, rock climbing, and commuting/traveling are all best done with packs that are less rigid. With that in mind, we dig the versatility of the Trail 25. Its soft frame moves with the body and stuffs into small spaces like under a bus seat.
For multi-sport and all-around use, we'd put the Trail 25 in the same, upper category with other products that are made with thick fabric, no rigid frame, and relatively simple construction. That short list includes the Arc Teryx Brize, and the Editors' Choice Osprey Talon 22.
Ease of Use
Nothing about the Trail 25 stands out, in terms of ease of use. It is simple and clean, with zippers and straps that work as intended. It isn't particularly convenient nor is it particularly cumbersome to use. It is just a basic backpack. We liked how easily the zippers operated compared to other panel-loaders like the Osprey Stratos 34. The metal pole holders are somewhat awkward and didn't work on some poles. Given how much weight they add, they seem out of place. We liked the mesh water bottle pockets (2 on one side, 1 on the other) for quickly storing trash we found on the trail (that are accessible without taking the pack off) or a water bottle.
We wouldn't say that it's the easiest to use, but it is good enough. Like the Osprey Talon 22 and the Gregory Zulu 30, no straps cover any important zippers. The top and bottom straps are nice for carrying things like waders for fishing, or a wet layer after a short rainstorm. In short, the Trail 25 is simple and its function only enhances the product.
The thick ripstop nylon used on the Trail 25 is fairly typical pack cloth. Our experience with this pack, as well as with other packs with fabric like this, suggests that it will last years and years. Depending on your usage patterns, it is possible that the zippers will begin to fail before the fabric does. And this takes thousands of cycles to do. Style, hobbies, and lifestyle moves will come and go well before this pack wears out on you.
The fabric of the pack is the primary determinant of its durability. We awarded our Best Buy award to the REI Co-op Flash 22. The Flash pack is comfortable, very light, and straightforward, at a great price. However, the Flash pack is made of thin, flimsy fabric. Its fabric may wear out faster than the Trail 25, but its top-loading design makes it resistant to things like sand, which can destroy zippers.
In our rain testing, the Trail 25 let in water about as fast as the Osprey Talon 22, which is to say it lets in a lot of water, fast. The raincover works well, but if you have anything strapped to the outside that prevents use of the raincover, the lack of zipper flaps will let water into the main compartment fast.
We recommend this backpack to anyone seeking an all-around daypack at a reasonable price. It does all you'll need for three season day hiking and is just right for travel, commuting, and light-duty technical outdoor travel.
This is a cheap, durable, and adequately functional pack. It is a tough competitor for Best Buy with the REI Co-op Flash 22. If you're on a budget, we'd recommend this pack if you think you'll want a daypack for both commuting and hiking. If you're shopping for the best value for mainly outdoor pursuits and travel, but occasional commuting, our Best Buy REI Co-op Flash 22 fits the bill.
Widely available at a reasonable price, the Trail 25 is a basic, no-frills day pack for many users. The construction is simple but handy. The soft-backed design is versatile, but not as supportive as a more rigid design would be. If you want a pack for work and play that you can abuse without worry, this is a great pack.
— Dan Scott