Performance Comparison
The Wagontop 6.
Photo: Lyra Pierotti
Comfort
This contender is among the more comfortable tents in our review. It is tall and boxy, giving you lots of space to stand up, walk around, hang out, etc. The generous vestibule creates even more usable space, and the back awning design (similar to the REI Kingdom 6) provides ease of access via a "back door" if needed — and if the weather doesn't demand that you enter and exit via the vestibule.
Great, big windows in the Wagontop 6.
Photo: Lyra Pierotti
With lots of space for air to flow (several windows and ventilation high on the tent) and a light color scheme, this is an excellent tent for full sun and warm weather. We loved this tent for our beach hangout time, with an important pro tip for setup (see below). The windows also gave us a great view out the side of the tent for the times we wanted to get out of the sun and hang out inside.
The two-room design is very similar to the REI Kingdom 6, and arguably even more comfortable to hang out in. However, with this comfort comes significant costs to wind resistance and ease of setup.
The spacious vestibule and numerous door configurations of the Wagontop 6.
Photo: Lyra Pierotti
Weather Resistance
If anything goes sideways on your camping trip in the Wagontop 6, so will your tent. Literally. The tent is so tall and boxy that it kept blowing sideways in light, variable winds on the beach, even with two people standing inside as we tried to anchor it down (pro tip: use fabric tent anchors designed for snow and sand, they increase your anchor's surface area).
The tall, broad side and tent/vestibule gaps on the Nemo Wagontop 6 make this tent much weaker in stormy weather.
Photo: Lyra Pierotti
Once set up and anchored, we were not pleased with the amount or the design of guy lines. They are attached too low on the tent to adequately counter its tendency to behave like a large rectangular sail in the wind, and there are only four guy lines for such a giant sail of a tent (in addition to the two vestibule stake loops).
The tent does not have a full fly to cover the tent. It has a generous vestibule which acts as a sort of half, built-in fly, and an awning in the back (similar to the REI Kingdom 6). But in the rain, waterproofness relies on closing the windows. To close the windows, a flap of tent fabric, sewn to the base of the window on the inside of the tent, can be unrolled and fixed to the top of the window with Velcro and two corner loop closures: Not the most inspiring weatherproofing system. There are also gaps between the fly/vestibule and the inner tent that raise questions about workmanship (see below) in addition to concerns with weather resistance.
Complicated pole design makes the Wagontop 6 one of the more challenging tents in this review to set up.
Photo: Lyra Pierotti
Ease of Setup
The asymmetrical poles proved quite challenging to keep track of and orient correctly. This is certainly a tent to practice setting up at home with your setup team. The pole design was one of the more wonky designs we encountered in this review. Perhaps the livability makes up for it; it does stand tall and create a lot of useable tent space.
Among the finer setup details, we noticed that the poles of this tent were much harder to expand. We are accustomed to guiding tent poles as the shock cord gently snaps them into place, but these poles were the weakest in our review and required our testers to push them into place several times.
Erecting the Wagontop 6, thinking "Whoa, this camping tent is bigger than some apartments I've lived in!"
Photo: Lyra Pierotti
Getting even more nit-picky, the bundles of T-shaped poles also made for a massive handful of poles that was not easy to handle while setting up or breaking down.
Workmanship
This tent is not our first pick to weather any sort of storm. We found gaps between the vestibule/fly and tent body that created edges for the wind to catch (even blowing the tent sideways in one test), and spaces for rain to sneak through.
The excellent carrying bag for the Nemo Wagontop 6: the compression straps allow you to reduce bulk before zipping so you don't strain the zipper forcing it closed.
Photo: Lyra Pierotti
Packed Size
The Wagontop is on the larger side of the tents in this review. As such it is also bulkier when packed up. However, its carrying/storage bag is very well designed. Compression straps and buckles allow you to stuff and cinch the bulky tent, and then zip the bag shut without straining the zipper. This means you don't have to diligently fold the tent (stuffing is a feature our reviewer's love). Other bags in the review, such as the Coleman Carlsbad Fast Pitch 6 strained their zippers when trying to stuff the tent back into the bag instead of folding, rolling, and neatly sliding it back into the bag.
Camping tents all packed up for side-by-side comparison. The Optic 6 is dead center.
Photo: Lyra Pierotti
Value
This tent is on the upper end of the price range in this review. For a tent that has odd edges and gaps between the fly and the tent, and acts like a sail in the wind, this tent is probably not worth the price for most users.
Conclusion
The Wagontop 6 is a tall, roomy, and fun tent with enough design flaws to make questionable whether it is worth the high price. It performs poorly in the wind and is not the best in the rain because of the partial fly and gaps between the tent and body. Smaller Nemo tents seem to be more worthwhile, but this one is not a winner.
