Our team of testers struggled to find something they didn't like about the REI Co-op Camp Dreamer XL. We wrongly assumed that since this pad was less expensive than previous award winners, there would be some serious design flaw, like it would be a pain to inflate or at least smell weird. This is fortunately not the case, and the competitively priced Dreamer XL has an easy inflation system, is as comfortable as our beds at home, and even has a convenient carrying/storage bag. The price and quality combo would earn it our Best Buy award, except that it's our favorite mat, period, making it our new Editors' Choice. The only thing that will limit your enjoyment of this mat is the size of your tent, as it's only available in a massive 78" x 32".
REI Co-op Camp Dreamer XL Review
Cons: Too big for some single person tents
Manufacturer: REI Co-op
Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
Our Analysis and Test Results
The REI Dreamer XL is built to compete directly with top end mats like the Exped MegaMat 10 and the Sea to Summit Comfort Deluxe. It gets you four inches off the cold ground just like the MegaMat with a foam inflation pump that works better than the MegaMat. Its carrying sack makes it easy to tote around, but it isn't as packable as the Thermarest Dreamtime with it's built-in carrying straps.
Performance Comparison
Comfort
REI seems to taken many of our favorite features from other mattresses and combined them into a better and less expensive (crazy, we know!) camping mat. The polyester top is soft, silent, and not even the slightest bit sticky against your bare skin.
Like your mattress firm? You can pump this mat up to nearly bursting with the large foam pump pillow and not lose any air due to the one-way reversible Hi-flow TPR valve. For a plusher sleeping experience, you can press on the valve to fine tune the mat to your preferred level of softness. The foam pump doubles as a pillow, and while car camping you're probably just going to carry along your pillow of choice from home, the pump/pillow is actually pretty comfortable, and you can adjust the firmness the same way you would the mat. You can also squeeze all the air out of the pillow for more compact storage. When we first laid eyes on the Camp Dreamer with thought the visible air chambers would feel lumpy. After testing, we can assure you that you won't notice the chambers no matter how much you over or underinflate the mat.
Ease of Use
Our lead tester has used a plethora of camping mats, and truth be told, there are more exciting things to test than an inflatable pad. When we unpacked the Dreamer XL, and he saw the tightly packed pump/pillow, he elicited a taciturn "whoa cool" under his breath.
Not only does the pump actually make a comfortable pillow, but it also inflates the mat easily, drawing air in through a one-way valve and pushing it through another one-way valve into the mat while you pump it with your hands or feet. This mat takes less time and pumping than the Exped MegaMat 10 and the Nemo Nomad
To deflate the mat and the pump, you push the valve in and flip it around so you can squeeze all the air out without any getting back in. The valve feels flimsy and while we are concerned that it may not stay locked in place and could flip around on its own after a lot of use, but we didn't experience this at all during our testing period.
Warmth
With an R-value of 5.5, you'll have plenty of insulation between you and the cold ground for most car camping style adventures in the lower 48. The R-value rating is exponential, so this Mat is 5.5 times as insulative as a pad with an R-value of 1, which we would comfortably use all summer long. Also, remember that while the mat will keep a nice layer of warm air trapped under you, it won't make you feel any hotter on warm nights than a pad with a lesser R-value.
Versatility
This puppy is one of the biggest single person mats we've ever seen, and it's going to take up quite a bit of precious real estate in your tent. It may not even fit in the back of your truck. Though all that room to roll may offer unparalleled comfort, it makes this pad less versatile.
The Nemo Nomad Insulated is a better option for folks on the move who are sleeping in places where space is at a premium. It packs away much smaller, and you can actually fit in a suitcase. If your backcountry mission is mule assisted, we wouldn't hesitate to load one of these suckers up and have the most comfortable nights imaginable.
Packed Size
A set of these mats for the family will take up a ton of space in the car, and currently, XL is the only available size. With pillow/pump this pad packs away to 11 x 30" if you take the time to squeeze out as much air as you can. Otherwise, it's even bulkier when packed away.
The carrying sack is generously sized and stretchy, so if you're in a hurry or just feeling lazy, it's not difficult to fit the pad inside even if there's still a little air in the mat. REI also includes a pair of helpful compression straps, but they aren't attached to the pad like the ones on the Thermarest Dreamtime, so they're easy to lose. Considering the vast sleeping space provided by this pad, we think it packs away to a respectably compact package, and it doesn't take up more space than the Exped Megamat 10.
Best Applications
The Dreamer XL (and the Exped Megamat 10 and the Sea to Summit Comfort Deluxe) provide a level of comfort that rivals and sometimes exceeds that of our own beds. For car campers and travelers with enough room in their vehicle, there is no better option for a good night's sleep. One of our testers used a mat for two weeks on wildfire assignment and slept like a baby every night despite high temperatures, bugs, and the constant whirring of generators. We will hands down never go car camping again without this mat. Weight is no concern when you're walking from your car to your tent site or sometimes simply putting the mat down next to your car. With the Dreamer XL, we got great sleep away from home so we could play hard the next day.
Value
$169 minus the member dividend gets you the pad, the pump, and the carrying sack. A great deal. Our current Best Buy Award Winner is the Alps Mountaineering Outback $200 (usually on sale for cheaper), and we like the inflation system on the Dreamer better. The Outback does have an extra two inches of length, but you won't need them unless you're over 6'6.
Conclusion
REI knocks it out of the park with the Dreamer XL, earning it our Editors' Choice Award, snagging it from the equally comfy but more expensive Exped Megamat 10. Putting these mats side by side, they feel very similar, but the Dreamer is a touch bigger and costs $200 less. Insane!
— Matt Bento