With an ultralight product comes less durability, and the Fly Creek is quite delicate. It pitches with a single integrated hub pole and has top quality features such as partially solid nylon walls that block spindrift and help to insulate. This tent is quite small, but is a great choice for two people who like to snuggle, or a single hiker.
The lightest weight tent is also the least comfortable. The Fly Creek HV UL2 has a small, tapered interior with a single front door and vestibule. We acknowledge that Big Agnes is trying to address this problem by creating slightly more interior room in the latest iteration of the Fly Creek in their High Volume model.
Although one of the smallest tents in this review, we noticed the extra foot room in the new HV model of the Fly Creek which accommodates tall people better than the old version.
We do indeed notice slightly more room inside, the door is steeper and provides more head room at that end, and our feet no longer brush the top of the tent at the end. However, that is when just one person is sleeping in it.
The HV version's door side wall is steeper, allowing for more head room. It is still a tight squeeze for two people.
Big Agnes attempts to make the sidewalls of the tents less saggy by attaching them to the guy points of the outer fly, but we still find that the walls sag in a bit, and the floor is lifted off the ground when the tent is taut, making the interior smaller. If two people are sharing this tent they should be prepared to get cozy. The Fly Creek has a few small pockets that are adequate for stashing your things. The Big Agnes Copper Spur HV UL2 is a more comfortable, two-door tent that is a great lightweight choice for two people, along with the NEMO Dagger 2, Big Agnes Rattlesnake SL2 mtnGLO, The North Face Triarch 2, the NEMO Galaxi 2, and the ultimate contender for comfort, scoring the only 10 out of 10 in the review, the REI Half Dome 2 Plus. However, with comfort often times come weight; and in the case of the Half Dome 2 Plus, you'll have to carry 5 pounds and 7 ounces.
The Fly Creek HV UL2 is a great choice for one person who wants to spread out their stuff.
The Fly Creek HV UL2 does a good job at keeping you dry in heavy rains, although we noticed that the HV model has mesh all the way along the sides of the tent, and the bathtub floor only comes up a few inches from the ground. This could result in more splashback getting into your tent in heavy rains. The major problem with the design of this tent is the single hub. With the back pole just going straight into the ground, it is only reinforced by the staked out corners and guy lines.
It only has a single pole and is not entirely free-standing, but has two side doors instead of one front, which acts to guy out the sides better. Several testers experienced the Fly Creek fully collapsing in a cross wind because the back pole was not reinforced, and were disconcerted with how flimsy the guy line and their attachments seemed. We also had difficulty guying out the tent satisfactorily and experienced a lot of flapping because many of the guy points and stake loops share stakes. If you anticipate high winds, bring your ear plugs or choose another tent. We would recommend this tent for camping below tree line, or where you know you will not experience windy conditions. We found the Hilleberg Anjan 2 GT, Big Agnes Copper Spur, and Big Agnes Rattlesnake SL2 mtnGLO were the most weather resistant in the bunch.
The Fly Creek is a pretty stealthy color in the high alpine. We would not recommend taking this tent out in high winds. Seen here below Mount Brewer in the High Sierra.
Weight and Packed Size
We'll say it again — this tent is light. Weighing 2 pounds, 5.6 ounces, it is a pleasure to carry around. Its super-thin materials make it very packable and it fits into a tiny stuff sack, or you can just shove it into the extra space in your backpack. In fact, it was the lightest contender in our review and could also pack down the smallest. Following closely behind was the Tarptent Double Rainbow, which weighed 2 pounds, 15 ounces.
Ease of Set-Up
We find the Flycreek challenging to guy out so that the fly is completely taut, although we appreciate that all the guy line comes already attached.
The Fly Creek is not an entirely free-standing tent. It has a single hub pole design that creates the font entrance, the back ridge pole comes down in the middle, and the back corners need to be staked out. It is not as easy to set up as a traditional two-pole free-standing tent and it is difficult to get all sides of the tent completely taut with no sagging. The front door vestibule is particularly difficult to tension - we preferred the set up of the REI Half Dome 2 Plus, Eureka Midori 2, NEMO Dagger 2, Big Agnes Copper Spur, Big Agnes Rattlesnake SL2 mtnGLO, and MSR Hubba Hubba NX.
We find the Fly Creek somewhat finicky to set up, especially on hard surfaces like granite where you can't use stakes. It is difficult to completely tension the fly.
This is the least durable tent that we tested. It is made from high-quality materials that will stand the test of time, but they are paper thin and can easily make you feel like the Hulk when you accidentally tear them with your bare hands. With all ultralight products, being gentle with your gear is the price you pay for low weight. If you've got your sights sent on a durable tent that has a light weight, we'd recommend the Big Agnes Copper Spur, Sierra Designs Clip Flashlight 2, or the NEMO Dagger.
The Fly Creek UL 2 is a great choice as a light, roomy solo shelter, or a very cozy ultralight shelter for two for any backpacking adventure.
The Fly Creek HV costs a full $100 less than the roomier Editors' Choice winning Copper Spur HV. Although it may feel like a single-use product to some people, because of its high-quality construction and materials, this is a high-end product. We think the Fly Creek is good value for the price. If you want a stronger, roomier tent that is still on the lighter end of the spectrum, consider the Big Agnes Copper Spur HV UL2.
McKenzie Long sets up the Fly Creek HV UL2 in soft duff for the night.
The Fly Creek's main limitations are its delicate materials and its lack of strength in high winds. The ultra light 15 denier nylon needs to be treated like wrapping paper on Christmas Eve. It is very easily abraded so make sure your tent is properly staked down and won't roll around on the ground when left unattended.
The HV version of the Fly Creek has added head and foot room, but is very similar to the original model.
You can't get much lighter than the Fly Creek UL2 in a double-walled tent. If you are looking for something that is more durable and even lighter, check out our Ultralight Shelters Review.
Other Versions and Accessories
Big Agnes makes the Fly Creek HV UL in a one-, two- and three-person version. For an even lighter version of this tent check out the Big Agnes Fly Creek HV2 Platinum Review. Big Agnes makes the Platinum in one- and two-person versions.