MSR Whisperlite Review
Cons: Heavy, difficult to simmer, more complicated than a canister stove
Compare to Similar Products
|Price||$100 List||Check Price at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|Check Price at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$16.95 at Amazon||$23.99 at Amazon|
Compare at 2 sellers
|Pros||Small, durable, inexpensive, versatile, easy to repair||Lightweight, works in the wind, great piezo lighter, very stable for small canister stove||Works in the wind, great for simmering, best of the best||Tiny, light, cheap||Good at simmering, simple operation|
|Cons||Heavy, difficult to simmer, more complicated than a canister stove||Not the most fuel efficient, pot supports pack up separately from stove||Unreliable piezo igniter||Small burner head, poor wind performance||No piezoelectric igniter, slow to boil|
|Bottom Line||This legendary liquid fuel stove is the choice of expeditions and institutions||Our favorite small canister stove, providing the best performance for most backpackers||This simmering champ can also perform in the wind||A shockingly small and lightweight inexpensive model||This standard small canister stove is good for simmering but bulky in your pack|
|Rating Categories||MSR Whisperlite||Soto Windmaster||MSR PocketRocket De...||BRS-3000T||Primus Essential Trail|
|Fuel Efficiency (25%)|
|Simmering Ability (20%)|
|Ease Of Use (20%)|
|Boil Time (10%)|
|Specs||MSR Whisperlite||Soto Windmaster||MSR PocketRocket De...||BRS-3000T||Primus Essential Trail|
|Category||Liquid Fuel||Small Canister||Small Canister||Small Canister||Small Canister|
|Trail Weight||11.5 oz||3.0 oz||3.0 oz||0.9 oz||3.9 oz|
|Wind Boil Time (1 L, 2-4mph)||8:09 min:sec||7:24 min:sec||7:20 min:sec||15 min||15 min|
|Boil Time (1 liter)||7:54 min:sec||4:42 min:sec||3:39 min:sec||4:43 min:sec||6:00 min:sec|
|Packed Weight||15.2 oz||3.5 oz||3.5 oz||1 oz||3.9 oz|
|Dimensions (inches)||4 x 4 x 4 in||4.7 x 3.9 x 3.6 in||3.3 x 2.2 x 1.8 in||1.97 x 1.2 x 1.3 in||4.3 x 2.4 in|
|Fuel Type||White Gas||Isobutane||Isobutane||Isobutane||Isobutane|
|Additional items included||Windscreen, heat reflector, small-parts kit, and stuff sack||Stuff sack, pot support||Stuff sack||Stuff sack||None|
Our Analysis and Test Results
Backpackers and mountaineers have depended on the original Whisperlite stove for all of their cooking and snow melting needs for decades. While it is still a great stove, indeed, the best liquid fuel stove in our review, newer stove technology has more to offer modern backpackers. That said, for expeditions and varsity level snow melting, this is still the stove of choice.
As with all liquid fuel stoves, some knowledge and skill are required to be able to light this stove properly. You must prime the stove first, which involves burning a bit of liquid gas to heat up the fuel line so that the white gas turns to a vapor. This allows the stove to burn a hot blue flame. This priming process uses up a tiny bit of extra fuel (if done correctly). We found the Whisperlite to be more fuel-efficient than most other liquid fuel stoves. MSR says that 20 ounces of white gas burned at max flame will burn for 1 hour and 50 minutes — that's a lot of Ramen noodles!
Getting the included windscreen wrapped tightly around the pot is important for the operation of any liquid fuel stove. Not only will this more effectively screen the stove from the wind, but it also boosts fuel efficiency in calm conditions.
The trail weight of the Whisperlite is 11.5 ounces. Though it is the lightest of the liquid fuel stoves, it's heavier than all of the canister stoves in our review.
Although the Whisperlite is not known for its excellent simmer control, we have experimented with cooking all kinds of things on this stove. Because it has been around for so long, people have developed lots of different tricks to cook more intricate meals. Most of these tricks begin with depressurizing the fuel bottle: prime, light, turn off, release fuel pressure, pump three times, and light again.
One system that works very well for baking things like pizzas and brownies on a Whisperlite is what we like to call the "tower of power". This involves depressurizing the fuel bottle and using the windscreen to create a tower around the burner to place the pot or pan on — thus removing the pan from the direct, intense heat of the burner. With some monitoring, this produces great baking results in the backcountry.
Backpackers who want to introduce some finer cuisine to their wilderness experience without having to become a stove whisperer should look into one of the small canister options, though be aware that these generally don't work well with big pots and pans.
Ease Of Use
All liquid fuel stoves require more set up and care when operating than any canister stove, but the Whisperlite is the most straightforward of the bunch. Readers new to cooking their own meals in the backcountry should be aware that any liquid fuel stove presents much more open flame during normal operation than a canister gas stove. While using a canister gas stove in a tent or vestibule is definitely frowned upon by stove manufacturers (and tent manufacturers), using a liquid fuel stove in a tent or vestibule is much more of a risk.
The Whisperlite is very easy to troubleshoot, clean, and repair in the field. Those of us who have used this stove for a long time can take it apart, clean it, and put it back together with our eyes closed. This stove is a great choice for any extended backpacking trip, especially when cooking for large groups. Many outdoor schools, including Outward Bound and NOLS, use it for all of their expeditions. It has a wide and stable base for larger pots and group cooking. We have noticed that the legs tend to warp over time, especially if it is jammed into a pack haphazardly. This can create a less stable platform that may wobble slightly if not set up carefully. Almost any liquid fuel stove will be more stable than a canister stove, and this one has average stability for its sector.
In our tests, the Whisperlite brought 1 liter of water to a rolling boil in 7 minutes and 54 seconds. This is the middle of the pack compared to the other liquid fuel stoves. It took about 1 minute and 30 seconds to prime; this was not included in the boil time.
In our 2 - 4 mph wind test of the stoves, all of them boiled a little more slowly, though the Whisperlite only took 14 seconds longer to bring 1 liter of water to a rolling boil.
The Whisperlite presents excellent value and is the simplest, lightest, and smallest stove in the liquid gas stove category. It is very easily repairable, and, with a little practice, you can cook a variety of items on it, making it fairly versatile. It lasts a very long time and is also the least expensive liquid fuel stove in this review.
If your backcountry travel involves large groups on extended trips or melted snow as your only source of liquid for more than a few days, then this is the stove for you. It is versatile, inexpensive, and relatively lightweight and simple. For shorter trips, groups less than four, or any time when weight and space are at a premium, a canister stove is probably a better call. However, while it requires more learning and maintenance than a canister stove, in certain environments, the MSR Whisperlite is hard to beat.
— Ian McEleney & Jessica Haist