more efficient with fuel and simmers better.
Soto Windmaster Review
Cons: Not the most fuel efficient
Compare to Similar Products
|Price||$64.95 at Amazon||$69.95 at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$144.95 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$67.25 at Amazon||$44.95 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|Pros||Light, works in the wind, great piezo lighter||Works in the wind, great for simmering, best of the best||Light, fairly fuel efficient, piezoelectric lighter, can simmer||Easy to use, inexpensive, fuel efficient||Simple, light, inexpensive, strong hardcase|
|Cons||Not the most fuel efficient||Unreliable piezo igniter||Not windproof||Heavy, bulky||Unstable, no piezo|
|Bottom Line||This lightweight stove is easy to use and will boil water when it's breezy.||This simmering champ can also perform in the wind.||This light, relatively fuel efficient and convenient stove is our Top Pick For Integrated Canister Stoves.||This big stove does everything an integrated canister stove is supposed to do, and does it well.||This small, light, easy to use stove can actually simmer and is perfect for backpacking.|
|Rating Categories||Soto Windmaster||MSR PocketRocket Deluxe||JetBoil MiniMo||Camp Chef Stryker Multi-Fuel||MSR PocketRocket 2|
|Fuel Efficiency (25%)|
|Simmering Ability (25%)|
|Time To Boil (10%)|
|Ease Of Use (15%)|
|Specs||Soto Windmaster||MSR PocketRocket...||JetBoil MiniMo||Camp Chef Stryker...||MSR PocketRocket 2|
|Boil Time (1 liter)||4:10 min:sec||3:22 min:sec||4:06 min:sec||5:11 min:sec||4:41 min:sec|
|Trail Weight||3.0 oz||3.0 oz||12.2 oz||18.5 oz||2.6 oz|
|Packed Weight||3.5 oz||3.5 oz||15.2 oz||27.2 oz||3.7 oz|
|Wind Boil Time (1 L, 8-10mph)||8:43 min:sec||7:18 min:sec||04:56 min:sec||6:48 min:sec||30 min|
|Category||Small Canister||Small Canister||Integrated Canister||Integrated Canister||Small Canister|
|Dimensions (inches)||4.7 x 3.9 x 3.6 in||3.3 x 2.2 x 1.8 in||5 x 6 in||4.25 x 8 in||3.5 x 2 in|
|Fuel Type||Isobutane||Isobutane||Isobutane||Isobutane, propane||Isobutane|
|Additional items included||Stuff sack, pot support||Stuff sack||1L pot, canister stand, plastic cup, stuff sack for burner||1.5L pot, 2 canister stands, stuff sack, propane adapter||Plastic case|
Our Analysis and Test Results
Soto is not yet as widely known as some of the other brands in this test. However, the Windmaster has been around for a few years and is distinguishing itself as a very high performing small canister stove. Part of its appeal is its performance in the wind. It must be getting noticed because the burner head of the just-released MSR PocketRocket Deluxe looks almost the same…
The Windmaster is nothing special when it comes to fuel efficiency. It burned 0.5 ounces of fuel bringing one liter of water to boil in calm conditions. In our 8 - 10mph wind test this stove used 0.8 ounces of fuel to boil one liter of water. The most fuel-efficient stove in our test is the Camp Chef Stryker 200; it used 0.3 ounces with no wind and an impressive 0.4 in front of the fan.
Most of the small canister stoves in our review fall in the 2 - 3-ounce range for weight. The Windmaster is no different, weighing in at 3 ounces (85 grams) for the burner and 4Flex pot support. The included stuff sack adds another 0.5 ounces. It weighs the same as the PocketRocket Deluxe.
Simmering is something that anyone who's cooking more than a freeze-dried meal needs. Small canister stoves are generally pretty good at simmering, and so is the Windmaster. Our testers found it could be turned down quite low. So low that it is easily blown out by any disturbance in the ambient air! We would have liked a little more resistance when turning the control valve — a detail that gave the Deluxe an edge. That stove and the Primus Classic Trail were the best simmerers in our review.
Ease Of Use
The Soto Windmaster is easy to use. Our testers don't like keeping track of parts and prefer stoves that require as little assembly as possible, so we don't like having to put on and remove the 4Flex pot support. Nevertheless, the pot support is big and sturdy and easily handled cookware larger than 1 liter.
The piezoelectric igniter on the Windmaster works every time. We took several trips with this as our only stove and never took a lighter out of our backpack. We wish the piezo on the PocketRocket Deluxe were this good. Our Top Pick Integrated Canister Stove, the Jetboil MiniMo is tied with the Stryker for easiest to use.
The Windmaster has respectable boil times. With no wind, it boiled a liter of water in 4 minutes and 10 seconds. In front of the fan blowing 8 - 10 mph it was still able to boil a liter of water, albeit in 8 minutes and 43 seconds, which is impressive. For the first time in our testing, this year we have two small canister stoves that can bring a liter of water to a rolling boil in the wind, this stove and the PocketRocket Deluxe.
The Windmaster is a good stove for all sorts of backpacking trips. Its low weight and reasonable packed size make it a good choice for lightweight trips. Conversely, the big and supportive 4Flex pot supports give it some versatility for group trips or hikers who use a variety of cookware.
Though it is one of the more expensive small canister stoves in our test (at $65), we think the high performance of the Windmaster makes it a good value. However, we like the PocketRocket Deluxe a bit more, and it's only $5 more.
We like the Soto Windmaster. The solid piezo igniter and pot supports make it easy to use. We wish all the piezoelectric igniters in our test were this reliable. The gourmet cooks amongst us also appreciated the ability to simmer with this unit. However, it was this stove's performance in the wind that impressed us the most. The Windmaster was the first small canister stove we used that could boil water in front of our test fan. Then the PocketRocket Deluxe came along (with a very similar looking burner head) and edged this stove out in a few key areas.
— Ian McEleney