While the women's Teva Terra-Float Churn It Up are comfortable enough for casual use, they don't stack up to other shoes we tested in terms of traction, sensitivity, and durability. They do alright on hard surfaces like a wet cement boat ramp and flat terrain, but our testers couldn't quite trust that we wouldn't slip off a raft or slide down a muddy trail. Their insoles drain quickly and the mesh uppers dry fairly fast in the sun, making them a great choice for casual hiking in wet conditions. The lacing system loosens throughout the day and doesn't allow for much adjustability. For a high-performing water shoe you can trust in scenarios where you really need your shoes to stick, we'd recommend looking elsewhere.
Teva Terra-Float Churn It Up - Women's Review
Compare prices at 2 resellers Pros: Comfortable, drain well, lightweight, decent traction on hard surfaces
Cons: Lack traction in mud and sand, slip off the heel with layers, low sensitivity, laces loosen throughout the day
Compare to Similar Products
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Terra-Float Churn It Up looks good walking around camp or on the town. Their mesh uppers dry quickly and the comfortable FloatLite midsole provides excellent support on longer side hikes. Yet they aren't quite specific enough for someone looking to get after it on the water.
The insole of the Terra-Float provides great arch support and cushioning. The laces adjust easily with single-pull elastic lace. However, the lace loosened slowly with extended use. They're comfortable with sockless feet, the mesh tongue and synthetic uppers providing an ideal design to prevent irritating seams.
We also found the elastic tightening mechanism to only cinch down on the top of the foot, leaving space enough in the heel for them to slide off when striding uphill. The synthetic material didn't pair well with warm layers; the heel slid off even more easily when we added neoprene socks or a drysuit. While the shoes drained well through the mesh and through holes in the insole, the mesh let in quite a bit of sand, which was difficult to remove.
The Terra-Float Churn It Up gave decent traction on hard surfaces like a cement boat ramp and dry rocks. However, its veritable lack of lugs made them unreliable for sand and mud.
We found ourselves in a treadmill situation ascending a muddy trail, our legs trembling from the effort of keeping our feet from sliding back. Forget going downhill in the mud. We similarly found them unable to dig in well to sand.
These shoes work great on casual walks or kicking it at camp, but lack the tread and durability to reach for them on more serious water adventures. They're relatively lightweight but are too high-volume for a kayak.
Their poor lacing system makes it difficult to wear these with neoprene socks or a drysuit, making them less than ideal on colder days. In a swim or even steep hike, they'd be likely to come off. But they're nice for walks and wearing around town due to their more street-style design.
Made almost entirely of mesh, the Terra-Float Churn It Up are more of a sunny-day shoe. They also stay on the foot better with bare feet.
In addition to making space around the heel when tightened, the shoes slip off the heel more easily when neoprene socks or a drysuit were added. The shoes drain quickly with its mesh exterior and holes through the insole. The uppers dry fast as well. They're a good pick for warmer, sunnier regions and warmer water.
While the insoles and tongue help up against sand and months of harsh treatment, the mesh showed significant signs of fraying. We doubt they'd hold up being stuffed under a raft thwart or into a kayak, the toe bumper not big enough to provide any sort of useful protection outside of stubbing your toe.
The hard lacing system coupled with nylon lace holes presents a potential issue, as hard pulls on the laces and extended use is likely to rip through the holes or break the lace itself.
The Terra-Float Churn It Up sacrifices sensitivity for a cushy footbed. It looks and functions more like a running shoe, with a substantial heel to toe drop, leaving much on the foot without direct contact with surfaces.
The stiffness and heel-to-toe drop of the shoe prevent it from wrapping flexibly around rocks and logs. While you're unlikely to feel nuances of unstable terrain, you'll have great support and cushion.
For a more versatile and sensitive shoe, you could find a more high-performing shoe at a lower price. Even for a shoe that you're looking to wear casually, we find the Terra-Float Churn It Up to be a bit above what we'd like to pay.
The Teva Terra-Float Churn It Up provides excellent cushion and great drainage. It functions decently as a casual shoe to wear around camp, but its poor adjustability and low sensitivity make it less than ideal for a water-specific shoe.
— Monica Nigon