Hands-on Gear Review

Marmot Spire - Women's Review

Price:  $400 List | $179.98 at Backcountry
Compare prices at 3 resellers
Pros:  Durable, weather proof material
Cons:  Stiff, limited mobility, low versatility
Bottom line:  This is a stiff model that is less comfortable for climbing but very thick and durable.
Editors' Rating:   
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Weight (oz):  14.50
Category:  Heavy weight, Regular fit
Length of back, from base of neck to bottom (inches):  25
Manufacturer:   Marmot

Our Verdict

The Marmot Spire is a very durable and weatherproof jacket. It is also cumbersome and stiff. For this reason, it was not our favorite hardshell for all mountain use. It is reasonable for in bounds skiing or snowshoeing in bad weather; however, it is very thick, making it less suitable for high output aerobic activities or lightweight mountaineering.



RELATED REVIEW: The Best Hardshell Jackets for Women


Our Analysis and Test Results

Review by:
Lyra Pierotti

Last Updated:
Monday
February 26, 2018

Share:

The Marmot Spire is a durable, weatherproof shell best suited to skiing in bounds due to its heavy weight and limited ranges of motion.

Performance Comparison


Ice climbing in the Spire seemed like a logical choice  but the fabric proved too stiff for technical climbing movement.
Ice climbing in the Spire seemed like a logical choice, but the fabric proved too stiff for technical climbing movement.

Weather Protection


The Spire is a very rugged and weatherproof shell jacket. It is thick and well featured to keep snow and precipitation outside. The hood is highly adjustable with a broad brim that keeps precip off your face. The waist hem has a drawcord to seal out cold drafts. And there is a removable powder skirt to keep you dry even when you take a tumble in deep powder. This was one of the strongest categories for the Spire, but it had some competition. We also really liked the burly Arc'teryx Alpha SV, if you can stomach the price or the excellent Norrona Trollveggen.

The many faces of the Spire.
The many faces of the Spire.

Mobility


This jacket feels very stiff and heavy. It was not our favorite for ice climbing, and it felt too cumbersome for climbing movement. But it is decent for skiing in bounds in heavy snowfall and is where it excels the most. We were frustrated by how restrictive it felt to move around in this jacket. We much preferred the supple and soft OR Clairvoyant or the impeccably designed Arc'teryx Beta SL.

Stiffer fabric and a storm flap instead of waterproof zippers all conspire to make this jacket feel heavier and stiffer.
Stiffer fabric and a storm flap instead of waterproof zippers all conspire to make this jacket feel heavier and stiffer.

Breathability


This jacket is very heavy and best suited to colder or less aerobic activities. It has very small pit zips with one zipper, so you don't have a lot of options for venting if you get warm. For a much lighter jacket that offers excellent breathability, check out our favorite, the Arc'teryx Beta SL. Or if you want a good all-around model that features pit zips and highly breathable eVent 3 layer fabric, check out the REI Stormrealm.

The pit zips have storm flaps instead of waterproof zippers  which adds weight and stiffness to the jacket.
The pit zips have storm flaps instead of waterproof zippers, which adds weight and stiffness to the jacket.

Weight


At 14.5 ounces for a small jacket, this was the heaviest in the review, and by far the heaviest among the technical outdoor style jackets. The next closest, at 13 ounces, is more of a lifestyle hardshell jacket. For the burliest and best severe weather jacket, 4.5 ounces lighter, check out the Arc'teryx Alpha SV. The Alpha shows just what you can get in a severe weather jacket for much less of a weight penalty. Or, if you're looking in the opposite direction, check out what you can get with the featherweight Arc'teryx Beta SL.

Features


The Spire seems best suited for inbounds skiing and snowboarding. It has a shorter torso length which is less ideal for climbing, as it won't seat as well under a harness. It does have a powder skirt, however, and a burly hood for when it's dumping snow. The pit zips are pretty small to be very effective, and only have one zipper, so they only unzip in one direction. The cuffs are simple and adjustable with velcro.

The bottom hem adjustments are at the center zipper instead of the sides which we thought made them more difficult and awkward to operate.
The bottom hem adjustments are at the center zipper instead of the sides which we thought made them more difficult and awkward to operate.

We did really like the high front pockets at a funky and useful angle and loved the sizeable inner chest pocket. The lower left sleeve also has a handy little pocket, suitable for electronic ski lift passes. For a jacket that is also well featured for in-bounds skiing, you might also like the Patagonia Triolet. Otherwise, for an excellent all-around competitor for mountain use, the Norrona Trollveggen had a great blend of features, as well as strong performances in the other metrics.

The powder skirt is great for in bounds skiers  and we love internal zippered chest pockets.
The powder skirt is great for in bounds skiers, and we love internal zippered chest pockets.

Durability


The Spire shines in the durability metric. It is made of 3-layer GORE-TEX, 4.9 oz/yd polyester. It is thick, stiff, and proved relatively indestructible in our field tests. Durability was this jacket's strongest metric. There were a few contenders, but only one that beat it: the Arc'teryx Alpha SV. If you don't want to fork out the cash for that one, you'll likely appreciate the Arc'teryx Beta AR or the Norrona Trollveggen.

Versatility


This jacket is best for in bounds skiing. It is not very breathable, has poor venting, and feels thick and stiff. However, it has excellent ski area specific features, so if that's what you're looking for, this might be a great fit. This was not the Spire's best category. For our most versatile models, we like the Norrona Trollveggen or the Arc'teryx Beta AR.

The removable powder skirt helps keep fresh snow out of the jacket  even when it's deep  or you face plant in it.
The removable powder skirt helps keep fresh snow out of the jacket, even when it's deep, or you face plant in it.

Best Applications


This is a great jacket for inbounds skiing and riding. The features, like a powder skirt and small zippered sleeve pocket hint at this utility. It is marketed as a high altitude shell jacket, but if we're going on an expedition, we would much prefer a lighter weight jacket with the same weather protection, such as the Arc'teryx Alpha SV or even the Norrona Trollveggen.

Value


This jacket is not the most expensive shell out there, but it also has limited utility. This makes it a poor value unless it is the perfect fit for your uses.

Conclusion


Testing the Spire on a beautiful winter day.
Testing the Spire on a beautiful winter day.

The Marmot Spire is limited in scope for technical activities, but extremely storm proof and durable and hiking or in-bounds skiing. If it fits you well and meets your needs, likely as a ski resort hardshell (probably not as a high altitude or expedition shell), then you might really dig it.

Lyra Pierotti

You Might Also Like

OutdoorGearLab Member Reviews


Most recent review: February 26, 2018
Summary of All Ratings

OutdoorGearLab Editors' Rating:  
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 (3.0)
Average Customer Rating:  
 (0.0)
Rating Distribution
1 Total Ratings
5 star: 0%  (0)
4 star: 0%  (0)
3 star: 100%  (1)
2 star: 0%  (0)
1 star: 0%  (0)


Have you used this product?
Don't hold back. Share your viewpoint by posting a review with your thoughts...