The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of gear

Brooks LSD Pullover Review

This pullover is a functional running jacket with some good extra features
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:  $85 List | $66.19 at Amazon
Compare prices at 2 resellers
Pros:  Lightweight, smooth fabric, good portability
Cons:  Abrasive seams, pullover design can be frustrating
Manufacturer:   Brooks
By Brian Martin ⋅ Review Editor  ⋅  Feb 26, 2020
  • Share this article:
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more
61
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#9 of 10
  • Breathability - 30% 6
  • Weather Resistance - 20% 5
  • Comfort and Mobility - 20% 5
  • Portability - 15% 8
  • Features - 15% 7

Our Verdict

If waking up, strapping on your shoes, and getting out for a pre-coffee run is part of your morning routine, the Brooks LSD Pullover could be a functional addition to your closet. The LSD is fantastically bland and won't give you the look of someone trying too hard — its beauty lies in its functionality. The pullover design isn't necessarily as versatile as other trail running oriented jackets, but it fits right in an urban environment. The kangaroo pouch offers temporary hand warmth while waiting for the crosswalk light, and the functional stuff pouch offers just enough versatility to take the LSD on a hike with the family.

Updated Colors
The colorway we tested this year is already on the way out, but there's a fresh batch out in stores now (one of the new options is shown above). Despite the update in hues, none of the tech specs have changed.

Compare to Similar Products

Our Analysis and Test Results

While there are some downsides to using a pullover, the lightweight simplicity of the LSD is appreciated on short morning jogs around the park when layering or delayering isn't really necessary.

Performance Comparison


For a nippy jog around the park  the LSD performs quite well. If you're heading out into the mountains and want the LSD to keep up  you may want to dig into this review further.
For a nippy jog around the park, the LSD performs quite well. If you're heading out into the mountains and want the LSD to keep up, you may want to dig into this review further.

Breathability


The LSD achieves its breathability through a large mesh panel obscured by the same common fabric that comprises the rest of the jacket. For maximum breathability, opening the half zip chest zipper really does allow for ample airflow. The large flap on the back was a bit frustrating during times of high wind, however. The design helps scoop air in when moving, but it also catches wind and flaps like a goose trying to protect its goslings.

Large back vents  similar to a flyfishing shirt  actually do let quite a lot of air move through the jacket. Our only frustration with this design was when high winds would kick up and cause some serious flapping.
Large back vents, similar to a flyfishing shirt, actually do let quite a lot of air move through the jacket. Our only frustration with this design was when high winds would kick up and cause some serious flapping.

Weather Resistance


The LSD is certainly not the most weather-resistant jacket we tested, but it's also not made or intended to be a highly weather-shielding layer. The fabric is ultra-light and lacks even a Durable Water Repellant (DWR) treatment coating as other basic running layers have. That said, it does well keeping the bite out of wind and chill during morning jogs with the flapping back panel being more of a frustration than a vulnerability to weather.

If your shoulder mobility is as poor as our main tester  you may opt to weather the exposed windy ridge section of your run without struggling your way into this jacket. If the material had a little bit of stretch this process would be waaaay easier.
If your shoulder mobility is as poor as our main tester, you may opt to weather the exposed windy ridge section of your run without struggling your way into this jacket. If the material had a little bit of stretch this process would be waaaay easier.

Comfort and Mobility


Overall, the LSD provides ample material for a full range of movement without restriction. While some jackets shave grams by snugging up the jacket sizes, Brooks allows enough material to keep a loose and comfortable fit. As you might expect from such an affordable jacket, seams are sewn with large chunky patterns that become a bit abrasive after a long day out. While the seams aren't affixed with high quality, invisible tape, they are decently comfortable and aren't that noticeable unless you put on a snug running hydration pack or are out on the trails for hours.

Short sleeve lengths can be frustrating especially if you intend to use your jacket for anything besides running with your arms pasted to your sides.
Short sleeve lengths can be frustrating especially if you intend to use your jacket for anything besides running with your arms pasted to your sides.

Portability


Some of the common frustrations with running jacket portability (like a stuff pouch that is the wrong size or no storage system at all) have been solved cleverly by Brooks. The LSD provides a lightweight package that is easy to pack and deploy. There's an elastic armband for convenient carrying, which seems like a good idea in theory, but strapping it around the bicep and running isn't very comfortable. The one-size-fits-all strap was far too tight on our main gear tester and too loose on others — and it's not adjustable.

This 4.7oz package is tidy and easy to use. Honestly  this jacket could be even lighter if the useless elastic armband were removed. It was too tight for many of our testers and not adjustable.
This 4.7oz package is tidy and easy to use. Honestly, this jacket could be even lighter if the useless elastic armband were removed. It was too tight for many of our testers and not adjustable.

Features


360-degree reflective markings on both arms seem to offer light reflection as well as portray an element of movement. Jackets with only a reflective chest logo often don't give drivers any sense of how far away a subject is, while reflective armbands offer significantly more movement and depth. The other noteworthy feature is the recently mentioned elastic armband on the stuff sack that could be useful for some users.

Brooks definitely knows the value of 360 degree visibility. While the daytime color scheme isn't the greatest  there are ample reflectors on all sides.
Brooks definitely knows the value of 360 degree visibility. While the daytime color scheme isn't the greatest, there are ample reflectors on all sides.

Value


The LSD is one of the most affordable jackets in our test. The portability, nighttime visibility, and breathability are all on point, making it a decent option for urban running. While this jacket is a good value, other options offer better overall performance and versatility.

If you manage to hit an artery  the LDS's elastic band might double as a tourniquet. It definitely cut off circulation during our testing...
If you manage to hit an artery, the LDS's elastic band might double as a tourniquet. It definitely cut off circulation during our testing...

Conclusion


The Brooks LSD has been slowly evolving over the years and continues to knock on the door of the elite running jacket club. With a bit more development, comfortable body mapping technology, and improved weather resistance, this could be a real contender. As it is now, the LSD offers great packability and decent performance for the reasonable price tag but isn't our favorite.

Brian Martin