Columbia Rebel Roamer Review
Compare prices at 2 resellers Pros: Best pant among $50 and under options, above average durability, excellent storm worthiness
Cons: No pockets, breathability, ventilation, not easy to put on without removing footwear
Compare to Similar Products
Columbia Rebel Roamer
|Price||$49.99 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$149.95 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$89.73 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$49.95 at Amazon|
Compare at 2 sellers
Check Price at REI
|Pros||Best pant among $50 and under options, above average durability, excellent storm worthiness||Mega stretchy fabric, best breathability in the review, built in belt is the bomb||By far the lightest and most compact pant in our review, great mobility, elastic waist band is extremely comfortable and functional||Compact, light, affordable||Inexpensive, lightweight, excellent packed size, reasonably weather-resistant, baggy cut makes it easy to wear over other layers, low profile waistband doesn't pinch under a backpack|
|Cons||No pockets, breathability, ventilation, not easy to put on without removing footwear||Not quite as abrasion resistant as other models, so-so weather-resistance||Less durable than most, hard to pull on over boots||Thin fabric prone to tearing, limited breathability||Not especially breathable, clammy with moderate aerobic activity, no front hand pockets, below average articulation|
|Bottom Line||A killer pant for the price, offering better than expected feel and weather resistance, but does not offer much in the way of features||A fantastic all-around pant with rad stretchy fabric, which offers exceptional freedom of movement and the best breathability||Hard to beat for any trip where weight and packed space are at a premium - as long as there isn't too much off-trail travel, where their lower than average durability could be an issue||Budget, lightweight pants totally suitable for occasional use||Perfect for those who want to bring a pair of rain pants but aren't likely to use them very often|
|Rating Categories||Columbia Rebel Roamer||Stretch Ozonic Pants||Outdoor Research He...||Marmot PreCip Pant||Co-op Essential|
|Water Resistance (25%)|
|Comfort And Mobility (18%)|
|Breathability & Venting (18%)|
|Packed Size (12%)|
|Specs||Columbia Rebel Roamer||Stretch Ozonic Pants||Outdoor Research He...||Marmot PreCip Pant||Co-op Essential|
|Measured Weight||12.5 oz / 354g||10 oz / 283g||6.5 oz / 184g||8 oz / 225g||9.5 oz / 271g|
|Waterproof Fabric Material||Omni-Tech Waterproof/Breathable||2.5 Layer Dry Q Active Stretch||2.5 Layer Pertex Shield+||Nano Pro||2.5-layer REI Proprietary waterproof breathable fabric|
|Face Fabric and Layer Construction||70D 100% Nylon||40D Dry Q Active Stretch||30D 100 Nylon Ripstop w/ Pertex Shield+ Waterproof Breathable Insert||NanoPro100% Nylon Ripstop 2.2 oz/ yd||40-denier nylon ripstop|
|Pockets||0 pockets||1 pocket||1 pocket||3 pockets||1 pocket|
|Side Zips Length?||None||Full Length Side Zips||1/4 Length Ankle Zips||1/4 Length||1/4 Length Ankle Zips|
|Put on Over Hiking or Mountaineering Boots||No||Yes||No||Yes||No|
|Inseam Length, Size Medium||30 or 32 in||30, 32, 34 in||31 in||32 in||31.5 inches|
|Stows Into Pocket?||No||Yes||Yes||No||Yes|
|Waist band Style||Elastic + Shock Cord||Nylon Belt + Elastic Band||Elastic + Shock Cord||Elastic + shock cord||Elastic + Shock Cord|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Columbia is simply put; the best performing rain pant for the least money This very functional rain pant retails for $50 but can often be found for less. This pant does give up a little when it comes to breathability, features, and tear-resistance but it doesn't give up much when comes it comes to storm worthiness compared to other even much more expensive models. Best of all for hikers and backpackers the Rebel Roamer is lighter and more compact than many of the models in their review.
The Rebel Roamer provided exceptional weather resistance and kept our testers dry in our side-by-side garden hose and shower tests, as well as in real-world use on soggy day hikes and backpacking trips. The DWR held up far better than we expected and is comparable to several more expensive pants in our fleet.
Compared to other $50 and under contenders, the Rebel Roamer is incredible. It offers some of the best weather resistance of any rain pant in its price range, with no other pant coming close in price. Compared to other options in our review, we found that the Rebel Roamer was comparable in performance to the Marmot PreCip Full Zip Pant ($100) and The North Face Venture Half Zip ($80), though it didn't have as many features.
Comfort and Mobility
These pants are pretty darn comfortable; the waistband has a low profile, allowing a backpack's waist belt to be worn over the top, with minimal pinching. The Rebel Roamer's shock cord and cinching toggle did not interfere or bother us while hiking or wearing a pack; it functioned as intended and did a fine job of preventing our pants from inching down.
The internal fabric was comfortable against our bare skin and the wider than average cut (and overall design) gave the Rebel Roamer slightly above average mobility. Our testers thought this pant crushed most others in its $50 price range. It's worth mentioning that the Roamer is a little baggier than average, though most of our testers didn't find the issue to be significant.
Breathability & Ventilation
Overall, these pants lacked breathability and were likely the least breathable contender that we tested. They did not feature any ventilation options. When we tested ventilation, the Rebel Roamer performed the poorest, even with the other models having their vents completely zipped closed.
However, for a just-in-case type pant, or for someone saving their pennies, they will work fine. In fact, we wore them on three resort ski days, where their minimal breathability didn't prove to be a big issue. If you have the extra dollars to spend, we would recommend upgrading to the Marmot PreCip Full Zip or the REI Talusphere, as both of these contenders scored highly and were in the $100-$110 price range.
There aren't a lot of "extra" features on the Rebel Roamer - this pant is as basic as it gets. There are no pockets or side zippers (not even short ankle length zippers). The only true extra feature is the Velcro pant tighteners/closures on the lower cuffs of the pant, which help seal out snow or other debris. Despite this relatively basic feature, our testers found it performed surprisingly well during snow based adventures.
This competitor offers a surprisingly decent packed size, especially considering its durability and price point. Overall, they are smaller than average and are more compact than many of the more expensive (though more featured) options.
Our testing indicated that the Rebel Roamer pants are more packable than the Marmot PreCip Full Zip and The North Face Venture Half Zip and offer a comparable packed sized to the Marmot Minimalist Pant.
The Rebel Roamer clocks in at a respectable 12.5 ounces (on the OutdoorGearLab scale). This puts the pant on the slightly lighter than average end of the spectrum, as it weighed less than several of the more expensive models. It achieves this low weight, despite a relatively heavy construction style by not offering many features (like pockets) or zippers of any kind.
Despite its price, the Rebel Roamer is lighter than pants like the REI Talusphere Full Zip (19.5 oz), the Marmot PreCip Pants (14 oz), and The North Face Venture Half Zip (13 oz).
Despite weighing in on the lighter side, this contender is durable; in fact, they are one of the more abrasion resistant pants in this review. We think these pants are more durable than the Mountain Hardwear Stretch Ozonic or the Marmot PreCip Pants, but not quite as durable as the Marmot Minimalist Pants. We would easily ski in these pants and use them on trips with off-trail travel, earning a 7 out of 10.
Ease of Use
The Rebel Roamer is the most basic pant in this review. It doesn't have any side zippers (even 1/4 length ankle zippers), though we found it wasn't difficult to pull the pants over lower profile shoes like trail runners or light hiking shoes; this is due to the Roamer's looser fit and slick internal fabric. When pulling over medium to large volume footwear, like more traditional hiking boots, we had to remove our boots in order to put these pants on and visa-versa.
Despite the Columbia Roamer's reasonable price, it performs surprisingly well when worn during a wide range of activities. It is light and packable enough for backpacking and hiking, though it doesn't offer any side ventilation and does not feature exception breathability; however, as a true rain pant, it is decent. This pant is durable enough for downhill skiing or snowboarding and its boot cuff is wide enough to fit over higher volume boots (though you will likely have to take your boots off). The Velcro tab at the bottom allows for the Roamer to perform well when worn on snow-based adventures.
At $50, the Rebel Roamer is the best pair of rain pants that you can buy in the price range. It is basic and does not feature any pockets or side zippers, but it does an excellent job of keeping the wearer dry. It is durable, lightweight, and versatile, ranging from backpacking to downhill skiing. While it is not the most breathable pant, we still think it's the best pant in its price range.
A spin on the old mantra of: "There are better pants, and there are cheaper pants, but there are no better, cheaper pants" stands. If you are willing to spend a little more, you can buy a slightly lighter pant that will breathe better and will have more features (like pockets). If you like these pants but wish they had a few more features, we'd recommend giving The North Face Venture Half Zip ($80) a look, as they are similar in versatility and durability, with the Venture offering a few more features, like half-length side zips and pockets and better breathability. If you're on a budget or just don't want to spend a bunch of money on rain pants that you might not use very often, then these versatile bad boys blow the $50-and-under competition out of the water. You can certainly buy nicer rain pants, but with all things considered regarding weight, compressed size, and weather resistance, these pants are a fantastic value.
— Ian Nicholson