The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of outdoor gear

Patagonia Rain Shadow Review

Patagonia Rain Shadow Jacket
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:  $189 List
Pros:  Stylish, lightweight, great waterproofing
Cons:  Zippers/pit-zips are sticky, doesn’t pack inside itself, hood cinches are tough to use, not very breathable
Manufacturer:   Patagonia
By Robert Beno and McKenzie Long  ⋅  Nov 30, 2013
  • Share this article:

The Skinny

New Version
Patagonia no longer makes the version of Rain Shadow that we reviewed here, but they now offer the Stretch Rainshadow for $199. We have not tested that version of the jacket, so the following review only pertains to the non-stretch model.

The Patagonia Rain Shadow is an attractive option for someone who needs a rain shell that looks good, is relatively lightweight, and isn't overrun with extraneous features. It is on the expensive side, so we would generally recommend the Patagonia Torrentshell over the Rain Shadow. It is slightly heavier but almost the same jacket for $60 less. Or go really cheap and get the Marmot PreCip, our Best Buy winner which is $80 less.

The Rain Shadow is Patagonia's slightly more high-tech, lightweight offering in the shell category (their less expensive jacket is the Patagonia Torrentshell). The Rain Shadow is the most attractive jacket that we tested and we loved the fit and cut of the coat. It is also fairly comfortable and layered well over other clothing.


Our Analysis and Test Results

A fairly lightweight rain shell made from Patagonia's 2.5 layer H2No fabric, this is a decent jacket for everyday outdoor use.

Performance Comparison


Dagan Heavrin in the San Juan Islands with Patagonia Rain Shadow.
Dagan Heavrin in the San Juan Islands with Patagonia Rain Shadow.

Water Resistance


We found the Rain Shadow to be completely waterproof. We tested the jacket in everything from Bay Area misty fog, to warmer Southern California downpours, to Truckee autumn almost-frozen miserableness and the jacket kept all moisture at bay. We stayed dry on rainy days around town and after a 1 hour run in a steady downpour the only moisture inside the jacket was self-made perspiration. We never felt any seepage or leakage, even at potential problem areas such as the zippers and along the seams. The best thing about the zippers on this jacket is that they have a coating that actually keeps all the water out. Simply put, Patagonia's 2.5 layer H2No fabric does the trick.

Breathability


The rain shadow breathes OK, but as with any rain shells, it does tend to get a bit stuffy. In high intensity activities we got wet on the inside, so if you're a sweaty person…well…you get the picture. The pit-zips help keep the jacket circulating air and prevent a complete soaking from the inside, but it was not as ventilated as the Marmot Aegis or the Marmot PreCip, which have pit-zips and large mesh pockets that can be left open to help with breathability. The Rain Shadow's pockets are not mesh and do not double as vents.

Features


We like the design of the hood on the Rain Shadow, and the way that it fit the head. Fitting a helmet in there would be a super tight squeeze, and would likely alter the effectiveness of the hood. While we liked the design of the hood itself, the hood tightening system left something to be desired. The loose ends of the elastic tightening cord inside the hood are located inside the collar. This means that to tighten the hood up you have to unzip the collar. Kind of a pain if you are putting the hood on in the rain and have to let some water in/heat out to tighten up the hood.

The cinches for the waist are right in front and straightforward, making it super easy to tighten up the bottom of the jacket. The cuffs tighten with simple Velcro and do a good job of sealing up tight.

One of the coolest features on the jacket is also one of the biggest problems with it: the zippers. The waterproof coating on the zippers makes them look cool and eliminates extra fabric on the coat, but also makes the zippers really hard to operate, particularly on the pit-zips. We found the pit-zips almost impossible to operate with one hand… so basically impossible to use. We did notice that the zippers started to loosen up after a lot of use, so maybe they will break in well.

In an effort to craft a lightweight rain jacket, Patagonia eliminated the need for more than two pockets on the Rain Shadow. The pockets themselves are pretty cool (they're made of the same waterproof material as the jacket, so whatever is in the pocket doesn't get wet from your condensation).

Weight & Bulk


The jacket is one of the lighter ones that we tested. At about 11.4 ounces it would be a good choice if you need a light rain shell. In an effort to make a lightweight jacket, Patagonia also eliminated the ability for the Rain Shadow to pack inside one of its own pockets. We find this strange as it is one of the only rain jackets we tested that doesn't pack up small inside its own pocket, and for a lightweight jacket, that would be a very useful feature.

Conclusion


If looking for a lightweight shell, this is a decent choice, but it is not the lightest or most minimal piece out there. For an outstanding minimal shell, we recommend the Montane Minimus Jacket or the Outdoor Research Helium 2 - Men's.


Robert Beno and McKenzie Long