We haven't always been a fan of the "tape-style" harnesses. While they look sleek on and feel great when "hanging" around the crag, once you weight the rope they usually don't feel so comfortable when you're actually hanging in them. But Black Diamond found a way to make a thin, non-padded harness comfortable to hang in, and we love the Solution. It's lightweight and breathable, and you'll barely notice that it's on even when hang-dogging your project of giving your buddy an epic belay. If you're looking for a more all-around model, with a full-strength rear tag line loop and slots for ice clipper carabiners, then check out our Editors' Choice winner, the Camp Supernova. We also liked the Black Diamond Momentum, which has a bit more padding and retails for only $55. But for those dedicated bolt clippers or anyone who prefers a thinner style harness, you can get a comfortable one in the Solution.
Black Diamond Solution - Women's Review
Compare prices at 3 resellers Pros: Lightweight, breathable, comfortable, and highly mobile
Cons: Might not feel great if the leg loops don't fit you
Manufacturer: Black Diamond
Compare to Similar Products
Black Diamond Solution - Women's
|Price||$69.95 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$67.46 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$53.85 at Amazon|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$86.21 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$117.66 at Amazon|
Compare at 3 sellers
|Pros||Lightweight, breathable, comfortable, and highly mobile||Lightweight, comfortable, and versatile||Comfortable, easy to clip rigid gear loops, great value, adjustable leg loop system is light and easy||Padded waist belt is comfortable, made in the USA and customizable||Versatile, mobile, and compact|
|Cons||Might not feel great if the leg loops don't fit you||High-rise might not fit everyone, less durable than other harnesses||Waistbelt doesn't have the best ventilation||Heavy and a little buky||Thin leg loops dug into the back of our legs when hanging|
|Bottom Line||A lightweight and thin harness that is comfortable to hang in.||The best all-around harness in our test group - not specialized for any one thing but good at a lot of things.||One of the best and least expensive all-around harnesses in this review.||A comfortable traditional harness that gives you great all-day support.||Packs down small for lightweight adventures.|
|Rating Categories||Solution||CAMP Supernova||Momentum||Misty Mountain Silhouette||Arc'teryx AR-385a|
|Standing Comfort (20%)|
|Hanging Comfort (20%)|
|Specs||Solution||CAMP Supernova||Momentum||Misty Mountain...||Arc'teryx AR-385a|
|Designed for these Disciplines||Sport||Sport, Trad, Ice||Sport, Trad||Sport, Trad||Sport, Trad, Ice|
|Weight in ounces (size small)||12||12.8||11.8||15.4||13|
|Gear Loops||4 (rigid)||4 (rigid with flexible attachment points)||4 (rigid)||4 (rigid)||4 (rigid with flexible attachment points)|
|Haul Loop||Yes (not full strength)||Yes (2 clip in points)||Yes||Yes||Yes (not full strength)|
|Adjustable Legs?||No||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes (detacheable)|
|Ice Tool Holder Slot||No||Yes (2)||No||No||Yes (4)|
|Waistbelt Construction||Fusion Comfort Technology (3 strands of webbing)||3 mm EVA foam padding||Dual Core (2 thin bands of webbing with foam in between)||Cambered bi-layer waistbelt||Warp Strength Technology|
|Special Features||Leg loops have same wide construction as waistbelt||Leg loops detach at the legs and not the waist for less bulk in the back||trakFIT leg adjusters are low profile and lightweight||Upturned gear loops||Colored fibers inside high wear points to indicated when it's time to retire|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Solution received on of our highest scores for standing comfort. It's our favorite harness to wear around the crag. The thin waistbelt and leg loops help you stay cool all day long, and we didn't have any weird or annoying fit issues with it.
A lot of this metric comes down to how well the different geometries of a harness fit your particular body shape. Women's hips also vary a lot more than men's in their rise, so if you have a shorter rise or prefer to wear your harness over your hipbones as opposed to above them on your waist, you may not find this one so comfortable. Those ladies should check out the Petzl Selena, which is designed to ride a little lower. The Mad Rock Venus and Edelrid Jayne II also felt like they had a lower rise to us.
One of the things that helped make this harness more comfortable was the tapered leg loops. Leg loops construction must be a finicky business — too wide and bulky as it passes between your thighs and you'll feel like there's too much material bunching up in there. That was the case with the Arc'teryx FL-355. The Solution has one of the widest leg loops in this review, but it tapers down so that there isn't too much going on between your legs.
We didn't think that the Solution would be so comfortable to hang in because at first glance there is minimal padding and our experience with thin harnesses hasn't always been great. But the triple-strand load distribution disperses your weight over the entirety of the waistbelt and leg loops, and we felt great hanging in this one even on an extended belay or hang dog session.
Here again is where the Solution's leg loops are superior to other models. Some, like the Black Diamond Technician, don't have enough coverage, so that we felt the adjustable webbing digging into the sides of our thighs and cutting off circulation. The Solution's loops extend far enough around the front to mitigate this issue. The waistband was also surprisingly comfortable for being so thin, though we still prefer more padding when doing longer routes with hanging belays. The Black Diamond Momentum was slightly more comfortable in this regard, and the Misty Mountain Silhouette is also an excellent choice for long trad routes.
We rated each harness on their discipline-specific features. When evaluating an all-around harness we wanted to be sure we really could use it for multiple disciplines, and with a sport-specific harness, we wanted it to have everything we needed to help us send our proj and nothing that we didn't. When compared to other sport-specific harness like the Mammut Zephir or the Petzl Selena, the Solution had much better features.
We think the molded gear loops that Black Diamond uses on most of their harnesses are some of the best in the business. They are encased in plastic molding so that they are rigid for easy racking, and they extend about an inch away so that they stay racked neatly together. Our only quibble with this style is that it's not comfortable to throw your pack on over this harness when moving from one spot to another. It's not that big a deal to take your harness off either, but for anything more than a 5-minute hike, you'll be more comfortable without it on.
We like these gear loops better than the Petzl Selena's, which lay flat, and the Mammut Zephir's, which has a long, angled plastic gear loop on each side. The idea for that design is that it keeps all of your draws at the front of the gear loop for easy access, but when the angle steepens they all go shooting the back of your harness and out of reach.
The Solution scored at the top of the pack for mobility. This harness offers unparalleled ease of movement.
The elastic on the legs have a lot of stretch to them, so you can heel hook, high step, or contort yourself in any which way without any interference from the harness.
As a dedicated sport model, this isn't the most versatile harness. It's comfortable enough to take on a longer route, but it lacks a few key features that you would want in an all-around model.
There is a 0 kN tab sewn on the back of the harness for a tagline, potentially, though it does seem a little flimsy to us. The Black Diamond Technician has a p-cord style 5th gear loop in the rear which is more user-friendly for carrying extra gear like a rappel device or anchor system. There's no option for ice tools carabiners, and the non-adjustable leg loops will limit your ability to wear this in colder weather over heavier pants.
The Solution is also not very adjustable. The fixed leg loops do have a good amount of stretch to them from the elastic, but if the proportions don't quite fit you, then you won't find this model as comfortable.
Black Diamond does seem to have sized their leg loops a little more generously than the Arc'teryx FL-355. Those leg loops felt tight on us (while the waistbelt fit fine), as opposed to the Solution that fit us in both the legs and waist. If you do need more adjustability in the legs, look to the Camp Supernova, our Editors' Choice winner, which has adjustable leg loops.
The Solution is our favorite harness for the sport crag, and for that, we've given it our Top Pick for Sport Climbing award.
This harness retails for only $70, which seems like a real bargain to us, particularly considering that the Arc'teryx FL-355 costs $145, more than twice as much!
The Black Diamond Solution is our number one choice for most sport climbing applications. The lightweight and breathable waistbelt won't weigh you down, and it's comfortable enough for prolonged hanging or working belays. If you haven't liked some of the thinner style harnesses from other manufacturers in the past, check this one out and you might be pleasantly surprised.
— Cam McKenzie Ring