The Edelrid Fraggle II has a simple design that allows kids up to 88 lbs (40kg) to easily slip it on and get it adjusted. The unique design only requires two slide block buckles, which are easy for kids to tighten themselves. The webbing across the back allows for good mobility for the upper body, and the tie in points are high enough to keep kids from becoming inverted in a fall. However, it's not the most comfortable harness of those tested. Specifically, the rigid leg loops caused pressure points and rubbing between the legs.
Edelrid Fraggle II Review
Compare prices at 2 resellers Pros: Easy on/off, quick adjustment
Cons: Limited adjustability, not the most comfortable
Compare to Similar Products
Edelrid Fraggle II
|Price||$59.85 at Amazon|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$59.95 at Amazon||$41.21 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$49.95 at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$49.95 at Amazon|
|Pros||Easy on/off, quick adjustment||Fully featured, comfortable, secure fit||Dual adjust waist belt, large gear loops, kids can adjust easily, comfortable||Dual waist belt buckles, largest gear loops, high quality||Easy to adjust, simple yet functional design, comfortable to hang in|
|Cons||Limited adjustability, not the most comfortable||Narrower size range, not the best for larger kids||Not the lightest||Heaviest||Small gear loops|
|Bottom Line||A good beginner harness with a simple design that allows kids to get in and out of easily.||This harness seems to have it all, comfort, security, and a plethora of features that can facilitate all types of climbing.||This is a comfortable sit harness capable of any type of climbing.||A fantastic option for almost any kid looking for a comfortable, and fully capable harness.||This simple harness is both comfortable and easy for kids to get on and adjust.|
|Rating Categories||Edelrid Fraggle II||Petzl Ouistiti||Mammut Ophir - Kid's||Petzl Macchu||Edelrid Finn|
|Hanging Comfort (40%)|
|Standing Comfort And Mobility (20%)|
|Specs||Edelrid Fraggle II||Petzl Ouistiti||Mammut Ophir - Kid's||Petzl Macchu||Edelrid Finn|
|Designed for these disciplines||Top Rope||Top Rope||All Around / Sport||All Around / Sport||All Around / Sport|
|Weight (size medium) (ounces)||12.3||15.4||10.6||12||10.1|
|Waist Belt Construction||Full Body||Full body||Sit||Sit||Sit|
|Waist Size Ranges (inches)||17.5 - 21.5||23 - 28 in||20 - 26.7 in||21 - 25 in||15.5 - 24 in|
Our Analysis and Test Results
No other full body harness in our test is as easy for kids to get on and adjust. It may not be the best for long periods of hanging, but for lowering off top ropes, it does its job adequately.
In theory, the rigid padded panels should do a good job of spreading the forces, making for a comfortable place to hang, but we were left wishing the (non-adjustable) leg loops did a little bit better job supporting the climber's weight. While we wouldn't say it's uncomfortable, others in the test offered more comfort. The tie in points, while higher than that of a sit harness, do a good job of keeping kids upright without being so high that the knot is at face level when lowering.
Standing Comfort and Mobility
For times when the kids aren't hanging, the same rigid "Jointed Padding" panels feel intrusive and caused issues with rubbing and pinching between the legs. The places the straps overlap (back and hips), added noticeable pressure points as well, and the overall stiffness of the panels made the kid testers want to remove the harness when not climbing, which fortunately is easy and fast. However, the way in which the webbing crosses in the back does a great job of making sure that mobility isn't sacrificed and kids can climb freely.
Getting a good fit with this harness is a breeze, as the open front design makes it easy to step into it and adjust quickly. The shoulder straps and harness are secure, and a front buckle also keeps the tie in points together. We found ourselves wishing the tie in loops were slightly larger and easier to get the rope into. Our ropes ranged from 9.8mm to 10mm, and they were still on the tight side to thread.
The sliding auto-locking buckles are smooth to operate, and since there are only two buckles, were super easy for kids to adjust themselves. There is an added attachment/tie in point on the back of the harness for added security on steep terrain or for skiing which could come in handy to some.
There are two areas in which we rate versatility. Size range: will it work for a wide range of kids, which is handy for sharing between friends, siblings or campers, etc. The other is for climbers who are looking to advance in climbing and determining whether the harness will limit the climber to specific styles etc. This harness lacks both. Size range is so limited that Edelrid had to offer two sizes. One for the youngest of kids (XXS) and one for older kids up to 40kg (88 lbs) kids. There are other comfortable options available that offer a wider adjustment range for the same price, allowing parents to buy a single full body harness and use it for the duration of time the child needs a full body style harness.
This is a great weekend warrior harness or for kids who occasionally go to the gym with the family. It's a super simple design that almost any kid can throw on, adjust, and go. It's fairly comfortable to use for a limited period of time, but not the first choice for long term comfort.
The $60 price tag is a decent price for any full body harness; however, for the same price, you could buy a Black Diamond Momentum Full Body and have a similarly designed harness that offers more comfort. The "jointed padding" design uses padded sleeves that the straps go through to pad the back and shoulders. While this may make perfect sense, it ends up having a slightly less polished appearance. The size range doesn't extend as much as other full body harnesses, requiring them to offer it in two sizes to cover the size range.
We love how easy it is to get on and adjusted quickly and how the front buckle holds everything together (including the shoulder straps) until the kids are ready to tie in. The two buckle tightening system is easy and saves having to fiddle much with the harness. The major drawback of this harness is the fact that the padding is stiff and is relatively uncomfortable for both hanging in and for approaching the wall or playing at the base. The Black Diamond Momentum Full Body has a similar easy to use design but offers more comfort for both hanging and wearing around between climbs.
— Adam Paashaus