My first reaction to these gloves was that they looked funny. But after belaying with them, I came to like the rubber on the palms. It gives great control both with the rope and with handling biners and belay devices. That said, once you start thinking about paying $30 for climbing gloves, these have stiff competition. It all comes down to how much you like the feel of the rubber on the palm and like the fact this can also be used as a mountain bike glove.
Mad Rock Belay Glove Review
Cons: Interesting look, overkill knuckle protection, hard to find
Manufacturer: Mad Rock
Our Analysis and Test Results
The thin layer of rubber on the palms gives these great grip on the rope, belay device and carabiners. You have confidence you are not going to drop things. You don't have to grip the rope as hard when paying out slack, which gives a nice feel to it. There are big protectors for the knuckles that are nice if you are jumaring. These also work well as mountain bike gloves in cold conditions. They do not breathe well enough for really warm conditions.
The plastic on the knuckles seems a little overkill. It would be better if the gloves didn't have it and were therefore a little lighter and more streamlined. The knuckles on belay gloves don't wear out that fast; it is almost always the finger tips that go long before anything else.
These are ideal for belaying, whether on a multi-pitch route or at the crags. I would also use them for cleaning on big walls because of the rubber on the palms that makes it less likely you will drop stuff. I would not use these for heavy rappelling situations because they are too thin. They also double as mountain bike gloves in cooler conditions (they don't vent well enough for really hot conditions).
At $30 these are toward the higher end of the price scale. They are for people that like the feeling of the rubber on the palm and are willing to pay a little extra for it.
— Chris McNamara