The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of gear

Five Ten Guide Tennie - Women's Review

A decent all-around shoe that feels clunky compared to its competition; our female testers feel that this shoe is in need of an update
Five Ten Guide Tennie - Women's
Photo: Five Ten
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:  $120 List | $77.73 at REI
Compare prices at 3 resellers
Pros:  Supportive, relatively inexpensive
Cons:  Uncomfortable, heavy
Manufacturer:   Five Ten
By Lauren DeLaunay ⋅ Senior Review Editor  ⋅  May 19, 2020
  • Share this article:
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more
56
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#8 of 9
  • Climbing Ability - 35% 6
  • Hiking Comfort - 25% 5
  • Support - 20% 6
  • Weight & Packability - 20% 5

Our Verdict

Our favorite approach shoes are ones that have high marks in every category because when the going gets tough, we want a shoe that can handle everything. Unfortunately, the Five Ten Guide Tennie has fallen behind the curve, and despite its above-average support score, it's performance is average in just about every other way. This shoe has been a classic among approach shoes for years, but our lady testers aren't incredibly impressed.

Compare to Similar Products

 
Awards  Editors' Choice Award Top Pick Award   
Price $77.73 at REI
Compare at 3 sellers
$130.00 at Backcountry
Compare at 2 sellers
$140.00 at Backcountry
Compare at 3 sellers
$76.83 at REI
Compare at 3 sellers
$129.95 at Backcountry
Compare at 2 sellers
Overall Score Sort Icon
56
74
68
67
66
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros Supportive, relatively inexpensiveLightweight, great climbing ability, comfortableSupportive, comfortable, durableLightweight, good technical climbing abilityBreathable, lightweight, climbs well
Cons Uncomfortable, heavyNot as durable as someHeavier, more expensiveStiff for long hikes, expensiveLess comfortable for long hikes
Bottom Line Without a great climbing or hiking ability, this shoe falls behind its competitorsThanks to its lightweight design, comfortable build, and top-notch climbing ability, this shoe is an all-around winnerThis is a supportive, durable shoe that's made for big missions in the mountainsThis shoe excels in weight and climbing ability but lags behind in hiking comfortGreat breathability and climbing ability at a low weight and decent price
Rating Categories Guide Tennie La Sportiva TX2 - Women's La Sportiva TX4 - Women's Konseal FL Scarpa Air Crux - Women's
Climbing Ability (35%)
6
8
7
8
7
Hiking Comfort (25%)
5
7
7
5
6
Support (20%)
6
6
7
6
6
Weight & Packability (20%)
5
8
6
7
7
Specs Guide Tennie La Sportiva TX2 -... La Sportiva TX4 -... Konseal FL Scarpa Air Crux -...
Weight per Pair (in oz) 23.6 oz 16.8 oz 21.0 oz 19.8 oz 19.1 oz
Sole Rubber Stealth C4 dotted rubber Vibram MegaGrip Vibram MegaGrip Vibram MegaGrip Vibram Vertical Approach, Megagrip
Width Options Regular Regular Regular Regular Regular
Upper Suede and synthetic Polyester mesh Leather Single-layer ripstop mesh knit polyester mesh
Midsole Compression-molded EVA Traverse Lite Traverse Injection MIMIlex Injected EVA 2D EVA-MP
Sizes Available 5 - 11 US 36 - 43 EU 36-43 EU 5 - 10 US 36-42 EU

Our Analysis and Test Results

The Guide Tennie failed to win an award because of its heavy, less comfortable design. When evaluated side-by-side with some other support-based products, we couldn't help but notice its shortcomings in comfort and climbing ability.

Performance Comparison


Exploring Bishop with the new Guide Tennies.
Exploring Bishop with the new Guide Tennies.
Photo: Lauren DeLaunay

Climbing Ability


To judge a shoe's climbing ability, we took it all over California's most famous climbing areas. From boulders to big walls to sport climbing meccas, we edged, smeared, and jammed our way to success. The Guide Tennie has decent climbing ability and we appreciated its durable sticky rubber for long alpine missions and scrambling. In the end, however, it fell behind some of the slimmer models in this review.

The Guide Tennie has a much more traditional shape and design, built for long approaches and burly missions with required fourth- and fifth-class sections. The Tennie strikes a great balance between support and climbing ability, but we had a hard time trusting its edge after experiencing the great toes of some other products in this review.

Smearing is a breeze with the Guide Tennie.
Smearing is a breeze with the Guide Tennie.
Photo: Lauren DeLaunay

This shoe handled solidly on slabs due to its wrap-around rand, but its toe was too wide to jam into any small cracks. It might make for a decent off-width shoe, but hand cracks were improbable. The Tennie earned a slightly below-average score for fifth-class climbing ability.

Hiking Comfort


Looking at materials, lacing and midsole structure, the Guide Tennie was slightly less comfortable than we had hoped. The toe box was narrow and uncomfortable, and the heel sat too low.

We did like the soft materials and stiff sole of the Tennie, but after hiking down into the Owens River Gorge, our toes were killing us, and the shoe lacked significantly in breathability. We were also annoyed that the heel of this shoe was lower than the heels of other products we tested. Ultimately, we couldn't pick the Tennie over its competitors.

Checking out the leather upper and wrap-around rand of the Guide...
Checking out the leather upper and wrap-around rand of the Guide Tennie.
Photo: Lauren DeLaunay

The lacing system of the Tennie was similar to that of its competitors, but the laces on some of our favorite products reached slightly further down the foot, making for a more versatile fit.

Support


Earning a high score in this category, the Guide Tennie shows us one area where it shines. Decent arch support and a stable build make for decent long-distance approaches.

The second-highest scorer for support, the Tennie has a nice arch and stiff sole. We were impressed with how secure our feet felt in these shoes, and their solid build was great for tough hikes on sharp talus. We felt very stable in these shoes whether on rock, steep snow, or loose scree.

We were less than impressed hiking in the Tennie.
We were less than impressed hiking in the Tennie.
Photo: Lauren DeLaunay

Weight and Packability


At OutdoorGearLab we generally prefer our gear to be as light as we can get away with. And while we realize that weight usually comes at the cost of other important factors like support and durability, we were very impressed when we put the Guide Tennie on the scale. At the slightly above-average weight of 11.8 ounces, this shoe still lighter than the heaviest shoes we tested.

The Guide Tennie is just barely light enough to put on your harness for multi-pitch adventures. We expected it to be heavier than it was, so we were actually pleasantly surprised. Still, this shoe is a bit much for clipping to your harness.

Value


The Guide Tennie is priced ok. We'd be keener to recommend this shoe if it was just a little cheaper because of its relatively low overall score. For just a few more bucks, there are some great products with higher all-around scores.

Conclusion


A hiking-focused approach shoe, the Guide Tennie strives to be an all-arounder but ultimately falls short. With an old-school design, the Tennie's decent scores and average price make it difficult for us to recommend it when compared to its many stellar competitors.

The Guide Tennie is more a hiking shoe than a climbing shoe.
The Guide Tennie is more a hiking shoe than a climbing shoe.
Photo: Lauren DeLaunay

Lauren DeLaunay