The North Face Phantom 38 Review
Our Analysis and Test Results
With high scores in our weight-to-volume comparisons, comfort, and adaptability metrics, The North Face Phantom 38 proves itself as a versatile mountain pack.
The North Face Phantom 38 has one of the lowest scores in this metric due to its relatively low volume and its relatively heavy weight. Though listed as a 38-liter pack, the Phantom has a measured volume of 42 liters. The eight-liter lid can be removed, making the pack's stripped volume 34 liters.
Total Volume = 42 L
Main Bag = 34 L
Pockets = na L
Lid = 8 L
This pack weighs 35.8 ounces total, and 28.6 ounces stripped. This is comparable to the Hyperlite Southwest, but the Hyperlite has a much larger capacity. The Phantom's performance in this metric leaves a lot to be desired; however, the pack remains a favorite pick for the mountains, where features, comfort, and durability are equally as important.
Total weight with all modular components = 2 lb 3.7oz
Pack stripped of components = 1 lb 12.5oz
Lid = 7.2oz
Load Carrying Comfort
For what looks like a simple pack, the Phantom 38 provides an impressive level of comfort, despite its slimmed-down appearance and basic feature set. The shoulder straps are fairly thin, both width-wise and padding-wise, but they provide enough support to endure heavy loads. The waist belt is the key to the Phantom's high scores in this metric; the belt is also fairly minimal, but it is shaped in a way that contours to the hips and provides support without any additional bulk.
Other packs, like the Mountainsmith Scream, provide padding and support in the waist belt but also add bulk and extra weight. The Phantom's hip belt is comfortable but sleek. In comparison to The North Face Hydra 38, the Phantom is much sleeker and more comfortable in terms of both the hip belt and the frame.
For those looking for a simple pack for overnight missions into the mountains, the Phantom 38 has everything needed for a lightweight trip. Though it is small and lightweight, the pack manages heavy loads with ease, making it a good option for these kinds of outings.
Its feature set is designed with alpine climbing in mind. The pack has ice axe loops that are easy to use and adjust, reinforced ski loops, and a removable lid. The side straps, also used for an A-frame ski set up, are highly adjustable and allow for the pack to compress down if interior space is not in use.
The major downside to the pack is the roll-top closure. Without the lid, the roll-top closure is meant to seal the inside of the pack from the elements. We found the buckle and strap are placed in such a way that it wasn't able to compress the top enough to create a tight seal. This is a small issue, but in comparison to other packs, like the ULA CDT, it was a bit of a disappointment.
The major features that make the Phantom 38 a highly adaptable pack are its large removable lid and its removable hip belt. Both of these features, when integrated into the pack, are designed well enough to be useful. But, they are also designed to be easy to remove, and the pack still performs well without them.
This is important because in some cases, removable features can complicate a pack and detract from the overall effectiveness of the design. In the case of the Phantom, though, the pack works great with and without the lid and the hip belt. The North Face Hydra 38, for comparison, is not at all designed to be modified and thus receives a lower score in this rating metric.
Made from 210-denier high-tenacity nylon and 840-denier IronLite nylon, the Phantom 38 is a seriously durable pack. We carried climbing gear and camping equipment in this pack for three straight months and saw no signs of wear. The Phantom held up to the wear and tear that comes with scrambling in the mountains and approaching climbs.
We were pleasantly surprised with this pack's ability to combine durability with a fairly lightweight design and a comfortable frame. Compared to both the L.I.M. Strive and The North Face Hydra, the Phantom is a more comfortable and durable pack.
As our Top Pick winner for Alpine Climbing and Mountaineering, the Phantom 38 is, you guessed it, ideal in the mountains! This durable, comfortable pack fits close to the body, making it maneuverable and easy to wear in climbing and scrambling terrain. The waist belt is supportive and comfortable, which are features that are key for heavy loads required for alpine missions. Though its volume is relatively small, the Phantom can easily carry overnight gear, a rope, and personal climbing gear. The removable lid allows for even more flexibility. If you are looking for a versatile, sleek pack that can accompany you on mountain missions this summer, the Phantom is our go-to.
Sold online for $170, the Phantom 38 is a reasonably priced option compared to the other highly specific, technical packs in this review. Though it is not made of the lightest, most high-tech materials or made for eight-week thru-hikes, the Phantom is simple, sleek, and perfect for the mountains. Many of its competitors in this review would become shredded after a few days scrambling in the alpine and cannot carry skis or ice axes, whereas the Phantom is designed for these types of outings.
The North Face Phantom 38 is the pack we take on trips above treeline. Its simple design has the right combination of features to keep us organized, and the waist belt and shoulder straps are ergonomic and padded enough to withstand carrying heavy loads for long periods of time. With its removable lid and adjustable side straps, the Phantom can be used for overnight missions, or as a day pack if need be. The hip belt and sleek profile made us feel comfortable scrambling with this pack on, which is key for quick trips into the alpine. The durable nylon holds up to three months of continual use, without as much as a significant scratch. We are incredibly impressed with the performance of this award winner and its reasonable price tag is the icing on the cake - and yet another reason to make the Phantom an award winner.
Ad-free. Influence-free. Powered by Testing.
GearLab is founded on the principle of honest, objective, reviews. Our experts test thousands of products each year using thoughtful test plans that bring out key performance differences between competing products. And, to assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. No cherry-picked units sent by manufacturers. No sponsored content. No ads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing and comparison.Learn More