Hands-on Gear Review

Black Diamond Trail Trekking Poles Review

Black Diamond Trail Compact
By: Chris McNamara ⋅ Founder and Editor-in-Chief  ⋅  Apr 4, 2012
Price:  $100 List  |  $87.71 at Amazon - 12% Off
Pros:  Compact, light, good value, extra foam grip below main handle, durable locking mechanism
Cons:  Not very long, no longer the most compact or light poles
Manufacturer:   Black Diamond

Our Verdict

The Black Diamond Trail Trekking Poles is our current top pick for a lightweight value trekking pole because it is so compact, light, and a great value. You can save $10 by going with the Black Diamond Trail Back which, if you are taller, is nice because the Trail Back is 6 inches longer. However, the Trail Back is heavier, does not collapse as small, and does not have the extended foam below the main handle. If you want a shock absorber, there is the Black Diamond Trail Pro Shock.

If you want the ultimate light and compact pole, check out the Black Diamond Distance Carbon Z which about half the weight and compacts much smaller. The Ultra Distance is $50 more expensive and does not adjust.


Our Analysis and Test Results

Share:

Likes


This is one of the most compact trekking poles out there. It folds down to a small 23 inches and is a great value. This is one of the few trekking poles that fits in a carry on bag (most airlines limit the bag to 22 inches long so these poles fit if packed diagonally). Most other compact trekking poles are 25-26 inches at their smallest which is harder to pack in your luggage and a little more bulky when attached to the back of a backpack. This is one of the few trekking poles we would recommend for scrambling or easy rock climbing because it is so compact.

We really like the Black Diamond locking mechanism. It is simple and durable. In our experience, the typical "twist tightening" on other poles (like Leki) breaks down a little too fast. As the poles get older, it takes more finesse to tighten them and eventually the tightening mechanism starts to fail. In our experience with the Black Diamond tightening system, this is way less likely to happen.

The wrist attachment is very soft and one of the most comfortable we tested. It has a wide piece of webbing lined with soft and breathable material. We also really like how the foam grip has an extra four inches below the main handle. This comes in handy on occasional steep terrain where you can "choke up" on the pole without having to take the time to shorten or lengthen it.

Dislikes


The trade off for these poles being so compact is that they are not very long. If you are over six feet tall, or like really long poles for the downhills, you may be disappointed in these. At their longest, they are not that long. I am 5' 10" and feel I don't need them any longer… but just barely.

While the locking system is our favorite, it is a little clunky looking. There is something nice and streamlined about the twist lock poles like most of the Leki brand poles. That said, we gladly trade the speed and durability of Black Diamond poles for the look and design of the Leki.

There is no anti-shock device in these poles. We don't really care, but many people may want that feature. The problem with anti-shock devices is they generally make the poles longer and heavier. To get the poles back to the weight of a non-anti shock pole, you can buy a carbon fiber version but then the costs really start adding up. For example, the Black Diamond Alpine Carbon Cork pole is only an ounce lighter and not as compact for nearly double the price ($140)

Stories


After getting a severe leg bruise, I had to hike to the top of El Capitan. Luckily, as we were driving into Yosemite Valley, the Yosemite Mountain Shop was open. I asked for their cheapest poles and they gave me the Trail Trekking Poles. They literally saved my legs that day. I was able to put a lot of weight on my arms on the hike up. Then, when we rappelled the face of El Capitan to rig ropes for filming Steve Wampler's climb, these poles fit easily off to the side of my harness without getting caught in the ropes (the extra shortness was key). When we got to the base of El Capitan, I extended the poles again and used them to walk down to the car. I liked them so much I took them on my next El Capitan climb - something I had never done before. Because they are so compact, I could clip them under the haul bag with out them getting too tangled. When it came time for the East Ledges descent, out came the poles and saved my knees again!

Best Application


These are ideal for trail walking and traveling. Because they are so compact, they are also great for sierra climbs and scrambles.

Value


These are among the least expensive poles out there. The Black Diamond Trail Back is $10 less expensive but it is not as light, compact nor does it have the awesome extra foam below the handle.

Other Versions


The Black Diamond Trail Back trekking pole.
Black Diamond Trail Back
  • Cost- $80.00
  • Weight per pair- 1lb 2oz
  • Usable Length- 26-55 inches
  • Collapsed Length- 25 inches
  • 3 section poles
  • Best Buy award

The Black Diamond Trail Ergo Cork Trekking Pole
Black Diamond Trail Ergo Cork
  • Cost- $120.00
  • Weight per pair- 1lb 2oz
  • Collapsed Length- 29 inches
  • 3 section poles
  • Top Picks for general trekking, because it has one of the nicest overall grips in our review

Black Diamond Distance FL Z-Series Trekking pole
Black Diamond Distance FL
  • Cost- $130.00
  • Weight per pair- 15.5oz
  • Usable Length- 37-43 inches, 41-49 inches and 47-55 inches
  • Collapsed Length- 13.4 inches, 14.6 inches and 15.7 inches

Chris McNamara

You Might Also Like

OutdoorGearLab Member Reviews


Most recent review: April 4, 2012
Summary of All Ratings

OutdoorGearLab Editors' Rating:  
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 (4.0)
Average Customer Rating:  
 (0.0)
Rating Distribution
1 Total Ratings
5 star: 0%  (0)
4 star: 100%  (1)
3 star: 0%  (0)
2 star: 0%  (0)
1 star: 0%  (0)


Have you used this product?
Don't hold back. Share your viewpoint by posting a review with your thoughts...