With a plethora of products to choose from Big Agnes, the Hazel SL 15 is this company's version of a down "Traditional Mummy" bag. It has a mid-range price, but it's materials and weight fall short of other competitors in this range. We think the Hazel is a comfortable product that will keep you warm down to around freezing temperatures. We appreciate that the Big Agnes trademark pad sleeve is removable.
Big Agnes Hazel SL 15 Review
Compare prices at 3 resellers Pros: Warm, comfortable, removable pad sleeve
Cons: Heavy, somewhat expensive
Manufacturer: Big Agnes
Compare to Similar Products
Big Agnes Hazel SL 15
|Price||$299.95 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$414.00 at Feathered Friends||$529.00 at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$329.95 at Amazon||$273.93 at Amazon|
Compare at 2 sellers
|Pros||Warm, comfortable, removable pad sleeve||High-quality down, warm, lightweight||High-quality down, warm and lofty, light, a top tier product||Comfortable, lightweight, excellent materials, not constricting||Lightweight, compressible, comfortable|
|Cons||Heavy, somewhat expensive||Sizing not for everyone, fabric is a bit noisy||Very expensive||Comforter sometimes does not stay tucked in||Expensive, not particularly warm|
|Bottom Line||Big Agnes' traditional shaped mummy bag will keep you warm and comfortable, but is a bit on the heavy side.||This high-end bag will keep you warm and comfortable from Spring to Fall in all conditions.||The Flame is a new, high-quality backpacking sleeping bag at a high price.||A great, high-quality choice at a relatively low price for those looking for a lightweight bag that doesn't sacrifice comfort.||This lightweight sleeping bag is a great choice for alpine climbing or fast and light adventures.|
|Rating Categories||Big Agnes Hazel SL 15||Egret UL 20||Sea to Summit Flame 15||Cloud 800||Rab Neutrino 400 - Women's|
|Packed Size (15%)|
|Specs||Big Agnes Hazel SL...||Egret UL 20||Sea to Summit...||Cloud 800||Rab Neutrino 400 -...|
|EN Comfort Rating (F)||15 (not EN rated)||20 (not EN rated)||15||26||21|
|Fill Type||DownTek™||Goose down||Duck Down||PFC-Free DriDown||Ethically sourced European Goose down|
|Total Weight (lb.)||2.61 lb
Pad Sleeve: 3oz
|1.72 lb||1.95 lb||1.7 lb||1.7 lb|
|Total Weight (oz)||42.75 oz||27.5 oz||31.2 oz||27.4 oz||27.2 oz|
|Women specific features||Exterior cinch system to minimize cold air pockets, women's specific fit||Extra fill in footbox and chest||Women's specific fit - more insulation in key areas||More insulation per square inch than men's version||Women's specific fit|
|Fill Weight (oz)||26oz||17.3 oz (medium)||22.9 oz||14.8 oz||14.1oz|
|Material||Nylon ripstop||Pertex Endurance UL||Ultralight 10D Nylon Shell||15d nylon risptop||Pertex Quantum|
|Sleeping Pad Sleeve||Yes||No||No||Yes||No|
|Shoulder Girth||58 in||54 in||60 in||59 in||60 in|
|Hip Girth||56 in||56 in||58 in||58 in||56 in|
|Foot Girth||38 in||38 in||40 in||39 in||38 in|
|Stuff Sack included?||Stuff sack and storage bag included||Stuff sack and storage bag included||Stuff sack and storage bag included||Stuff sack and storage bag included||Stuff sack and storage bag included|
Our Analysis and Test Results
This middle of the road mummy bag has low quality down fill power and is heftier than many of the other women's models we tested.
Big Agnes rates this bag to 15 degrees Fahrenheit. However, it is not EN tested. Although we don't necessarily think the EN rating is the be all and end all of measurements, we do not think this 15 degrees Fahrenheit temperature rating is accurate in comparison to bags that are EN rated to 15F. We would put the Hazel SL somewhere in the 25-degree range. The warmest bag we tested was the Feathered Friends Egret which is also not EN rated, but Feathered Friends puts it at 20 degrees, and our testers find that accurate, if not conservative. We'd take the Egret into colder temps than that but would not trust the Hazel in such temps.
We do like the insulated hood shape, and interior draft tube that prevents drafts coming down the front of the neck and the "petite" size fits our 5'5 tester like a glove with no room for extra cold air to hang around.
The Hazel SL weighed in at a hefty 2.61 pounds, almost a full pound heavier than our lightest bag, the Sierra Designs Women's Cloud 800. Most of the down bags in this review are lighter than the Hazel except for the NEMO Rave and the Kelty Cosmic. The bag feels heavy on top of us, and we can tell the difference in down quality between the Hazel and the Sea To Summit Flame 15 Women's that has 850 down and is way lighter and fluffier feeling.
The removable pad sleeve weighs an additional 3 ounces. We think the contributors to the high weight of this bag is all the additional features and a lot more fill weight is required with low quality 600 fill down than a higher fill power to achieve the same warmth.
This product is quite comfortable for a standard mummy shaped bag. We were surprised to see that our 5'5 tester fell at the upper limits of the "petite" size and was apprehensive that this bag would be too small. However, we were pleased that the sizing was right on and the bag fit our 5'5 tester perfectly. It has just enough room in the hips and shoulders without being too roomy.
Since this is a down sleeping bag, it does compress down relatively small in comparison to the synthetic products we tested. However, this isn't our most compressible product by a long shot. The Rab Neutrino 400 - Women's and the Cloud are much smaller and more compressible. The Hazel is even less compact when you factor in the huge pad sleeve to the equation.
Big Agnes is known for feature-laden bags. We're not impressed. In general, we believe that most features add to the weight of a bag and don't add much functionality; which is the case with the Hazel. We think that pad sleeves are the biggest culprit of weight adding and we're thankful that you can remove the included pad sleeve - although it is challenging to do so and to put it back together.
The Hazel also has an "exterior cinch system" that's meant to help with sizing your bag. We think it just compresses the down to make the bag less warm although it's meant to shrink the size of the bag, so there is less air inside to keep warm, but by compressing the loft of the bag, it makes it less warm overall.
We do like the Hazel's small stash pocket for evening needs like headlamps and earplugs.
This bag could be good for short backpacking trips or car camping. If you are afraid you'll roll off your sleeping pad in the night this is one of the lighter bags that include a pad sleeve (although we prefer the super light integrated ones on the Sierra Designs Backcountry Bed).
We were disappointed to see that the Hazel rings in at $300. We do not think this is a good value for such a heavy bag with 600 fill down and would recommend something like the REI Joule or the Cloud that are around the same price point and are warmer and lighter.
The Big Agnes Hazel SL 15 is a relatively warm and comfortable product. However, if this bag had a lower price tag we would be more inclined to recommend it, but it is heavy for a backpacking sleeping bag, and we don't think the included features do much to increase its functionality. There are many other high-quality bags in this review that we would reach for before the Hazel at a similar price point, or we'd pay much less for similar quality products from other manufacturers.
— Jessica Haist