Casio GW9400-1 Review
Cons: Very bulky, lots of buttons, busy display, not intuitive
Compare to Similar Products
|Price||$253.72 at Amazon||$296.00 at Amazon||$169.19 at Amazon||$65 List|
Check Price at Amazon
|$209.59 at Amazon|
|Pros||Durable, long battery life||Long battery life, durable aluminum finish, great fit, precise, easy-to-use interface||Solar powered, clearly labeled buttons, fairly easy-to-use interface||Inexpensive, simple, accurate, light, functional||Stylish, comfortable fit, records many activities|
|Cons||Very bulky, lots of buttons, busy display, not intuitive||Altitude and barometric graphs are sub-par, no GPS, lag on button presses||Feels big on your wrist, busy display and bezel, rigid wristband||Lacks features, lacks comfort, no compass, ugly, poor display||Short battery life, inaccurate altimeter and GPS, touch screen difficult to use|
|Bottom Line||A classic ABC watch with impressive battery life||Great for those looking for a classic altimeter watch at an affordable price||A simple altimeter watch with decent features, but plenty of room to improve its aesthetic qualities||This is an inexpensive altimeter watch that is accurate enough for curious backcountry travelers||This is a stylish watch best suited to road runs and gym workouts|
|Rating Categories||Casio GW9400-1||Suunto Core Alu||Casio Pathfinder PA...||Casio SGW300HB||Polar Ignite Fitness|
|Altimeter Accuracy (30%)|
|Battery Life (20%)|
|User Experience (20%)|
|Comfort And Fit (15%)|
|Specs||Casio GW9400-1||Suunto Core Alu||Casio Pathfinder PA...||Casio SGW300HB||Polar Ignite Fitness|
|Dimensions (Inches)||None provided||1.93 x 1.93 x 0.57”||2.26 x 2.00 x .60||1.97 x 1.97 x .55”||1.69 x 1.69 x .33"|
|Type of Battery||Solar rechargable battery||Watch battery||Solar, rechargeable battery||Watch battery||Rechargeable lithium ion battery|
|Battery Life (w/o GPS)||7 months (w/o further exposure to light)||12 months||Continuous||3 years||5 days|
|Battery Life w/ GPS on||No GPS||No GPS||No GPS||No GPS||17 hrs|
|Altitude Range||-700 to 10,000 m (-2,300 to 32,800 ft)||-500 - 9000 m||-2,300 - 32,800ft (-700m - 10,000m)||-2,300 - 32,800ft (-700m - 10,000m)||None provided|
|Altitidue differential?||Yes||Yes||Yes||No||None provided|
|Elevation interval||1m/3tf||1m/3ft||20ft||5m/20ft||None provided|
|Barometer||Yes, barometric graph||Yes||Yes||Yes, no graph||For tracking altitude, no viewable graph|
|Barometric Recording Interval & Time (for the graph)||Every 2 hours default (or every 5 seconds in barometer mode)||Every 30 minutes, 24 hours||Default every 2 hours (with baro activated, every 5 seconds for 5 minutes, then every 5 minutes), 24 hours||None||None provided|
|Barometric Pressure Range||260 - 1,110 hPa (7.65 - 32.45 inHg)||920 - 1,080 hPa (27.13 - 31.85 inHg)||260 to 1,100 hPa (7.65 to 32.45 inHg)||260 - 1,100 hPa (7.65 - 32.45 inHg)||None provided|
|Storm Alert Alarm?||No||Yes||No||No||No|
|Time Features||Digital, stopwatch, timer, world clock||Digital, dual world times, stopwatch, countdown timer||Digital, world time (31 time zones, 48 cities), stopwatch, timer||Digital, world time (31 time zones), stopwatch,||Digital, stopwatch, timer,|
|Time Alarm||Yes, 5 daily alarms||Yes||5 daily alarms||5 daily alarms||Yes, one daily alarm|
|Temperature Resistance Range||14 to 140 F (-10 to 60 C)||-20° C to +60° C (-4F - 140F)||-10 to 60 C (14 to 140 F)||Low: -10C/14F||14 - 122 F (-10 to 50 C)|
|Water Resistance||Yes, 200 meters||Yes, 100 meters||Yes, 100 meters||Yes, 100 meters||Yes, 30 meters|
|Types of bands and material||Silicone||Silicone||Plastic, cloth, metal||Plastic, cloth, metal||Silicone|
|GPS, GLONASS, both?||No GPS||No GPS||No GPS||No GPS||Both|
|Apps||no||n/a||n/a||n/a||Yes, Polar Flow|
|Charging Type||solar||Battery||Solar charged battery||Battery||specialized cord|
|Warranty||Limited Warranty Period (1 year)||Limited Warranty Period (2 years)||Limited Warranty Period (1 year)||Limited Warranty Period (1 year)||Limited Warranty Period (2 years)|
|Other Cool Features||sunrise/sunset||sunrise/sunset||sunrise/sunset||None|
Our Analysis and Test Results
This watch is a winner when it comes to battery life and has some good basic features, but it's uncomfortable and visually overwhelming.
This watch takes altitude readings based on barometric pressure, which works because generally air pressure decreases as you go higher. However, the drawback of this method is that barometric pressure can change with weather, meaning that if a storm rolls in, your altimeter may give you an inaccurate reading. The user manual even recommends calibrating your altimeter based on a known elevation as frequently as possible to help account for this.
We found that the altimeter was decently accurate- not great, not terrible. When calibrated at a trailhead right before a hike, it would do pretty well. One evening after being calibrated in Bishop before driving up to Mammoth, its reading was 320' off compared to an elevation sign, which seemed like a significant amount for an hour after calibration.
Battery life is where the Casio watches excel. Relying on a long-lasting rechargeable solar battery means that if you're embarking on a multi-month long trek, you'll never need to worry about access to electricity in order to keep this watch working. Its specs claim it can go as long as 7 months before needing any exposure to sunlight to charge it, and while we weren't able to spend a winter in the Arctic to verify this, we believe it. Throughout testing, which involved both weeks of use as well as weeks in a desk drawer, it stayed at the medium or high battery levels. You won't ever need to go out of your way to charge this watch, since general exposure to sunlight while on your wrist should be enough to keep it fully functioning.
In spite of its fairly conservative number of features, this is one watch that you'll definitely need to sit down and read the manual for. Similar to the Suunto Core and Ambit models, it has five buttons (not including a separate backlight button), but we found the GW9400 much more complicated to learn. Each button has multiple labels and functions that can be hard to distinguish because of how they're etched into the black casing. Even setting the time and location required a deep dive into the user manual. The watch face packs a lot into a fairly small screen, and we didn't like how cluttered it felt.
The backlight was bright enough, but it only stayed on for one second at a time with no option to hold it in and keep it on, which could prove frustrating if trying to change or view a setting during the night. Frustration was the general mood when using this watch- a lot of the actual functionality is just more complicated than it needs to be.
Watches don't get bulkier than this one. It's a behemoth on your arm, and for our small-wristed reviewers, it was impossible to get a comfortable fit. Measuring the watch face down the length of your arm, the diameter is 52 mm, but measuring the face from one side of your arm to the other, the diameter is 65 mm. This is due to the straps being inflexible where they join the main watch body, so on a smaller arm, there's a lot of extra space where it can't be tightened down.
The screen itself is 30 mm in diameter, with the part of the screen that's actually showing data measuring closer to 25 mm. This feels a bit disappointing when you consider how much real estate the watch is taking up on your arm. The buttons were responsive, and we didn't have any issues using them with gloves on, but it'd be hard to fit this watch under close-fitting layers.
Although it has the features you expect in a basic ABC watch, it felt like learning to use them was more complicated than necessary.
Altimeter and Barometer
The altimeter and barometer use a sensor on the left side of the watch, with the altimeter measuring a range of -2,300' to 32,800'. The barometer screen also shows the temperature and a barometric pressure graph of the previous 42 hours from the automatic readings the watch takes every two hours.
Compass readings are accessed using the same sensor button that gives you altimeter and barometer readings. It can be calibrated, and we found its accuracy on par with the other ABC watches tested. The manual recommends bringing a compass to double-check readings in high-consequence situations.
Heavy backcountry sleeper? Good news- you can set five daily alarms on this model so that you never miss your predawn wake-up call! (This can be a surprisingly rare feature in altimeter watches.) Other than that, the basic timekeeping features include a stopwatch, timer, world clock, and sunrise/sunset data for your programmed location.
The number of customers looking for this specific watch is bound to be small. There are multiple other watches at the same price point that offer either more features, better style, or both. If all you're needing is a basic altimeter watch, and you still want the look and durability of a Casio, we recommend the Casio SGW-300H for about one-fifth the price of this model.
The Casio GW9400 is a basic ABC watch with a steep learning curve. Its battery life is impressive, its aesthetics are not, and unless you're going on the longest and most rugged adventures, it's probably not the watch you're looking for.
— Paige Klugherz