The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of outdoor gear

Fabric Scoop Race Shallow Review

There's nothing especially noteworthy about the Fabric Scoop Race Shallow, but it's well made and relatively comfortable for all types of mountain biking.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:  $105 List | $99.95 at REI
Compare prices at 2 resellers
Pros:  Good power transfer, clean look, quality construction
Cons:  No anatomical relief, only available in one width
Manufacturer:   Fabric
By Jeremy Benson ⋅ Senior Review Editor  ⋅  May 7, 2019
  • Share this article:
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more
79
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#7 of 13
  • Comfort - 30% 8
  • Performance - 20% 9
  • Durability - 20% 8
  • Weight - 20% 6
  • Versatility - 10% 9

Our Verdict

The Scoop Race Shallow is a quality mountain bike saddle from the cycling accessory manufacturer Fabric. Testers found it to be relatively comfortable, with an excellent shape and medium density padding, although the shell is quite stiff and uncompromising compared to some of the competition. On the bike, it allows for a very clean and powerful pedal stroke as well as great freedom of movement with a snag-free rounded tail shape. It also has an exceptionally clean look, with a seamless waterproof synthetic cover that is secured neatly under the shell. It appears to be very well made and we have no complaints about its durability. At 253g, it's far from the lightest saddle in the test, but we feel this a versatile model for riders who prefer a stiffer saddle.


Compare to Similar Products

 
Awards  Editors' Choice Award  Top Pick Award Top Pick Award 
Price $99.95 at REI
Compare at 2 sellers
$125 List$120 List$130 List$135 List
Check Price at Amazon
Overall Score Sort Icon
100
0
79
100
0
90
100
0
87
100
0
85
100
0
85
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros Good power transfer, clean look, quality constructionLightweight, unique suspended feel, comfortable, versatileComfortable, versatile, reasonably pricedLightweight, comfortable, short lengthLightweight, unique design, suspended feel
Cons No anatomical relief, only available in one widthNo tail protectionSlightly heavier than the competitionOnly available in wider widthsOnly available in narrow width
Bottom Line There's nothing especially noteworthy about the Fabric Scoop Race Shallow, but it's well made and relatively comfortable for all types of mountain biking.The Undercover Stratum is an excellent combination of comfort, performance, and versatility in a lightweight package and the new winner of our Editor's Choice Award.The Phenom Comp is is one of our highest rated models with comfort, performance, and versatility.The Koda Team was originally designed for women but this unisex saddle delivers incredible comfort in a lightweight package.Despite its unique design and appearance, the lightweight Spyder Outland saddle is a comfortable performer for people with narrower sit bones.
Rating Categories Fabric Scoop Race Shallow Tioga Undercover Stratum TI Specialized Phenom Comp WTB Koda Team Tioga Spyder Outland
Comfort (30%)
10
0
8
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
8
Performance (20%)
10
0
9
10
0
10
10
0
10
10
0
8
10
0
8
Durability (20%)
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
9
Weight (20%)
10
0
6
10
0
9
10
0
6
10
0
9
10
0
10
Versatility (10%)
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
10
10
0
8
10
0
7
Specs Fabric Scoop Race... Tioga Undercover... Specialized Phenom... WTB Koda Team Tioga Spyder Outland
Weight (grams) 253g 202g 243g 203g 202g/178g
Rail Material Titanium Titanium Cr-Mo Titanium Hollow Chromoly
Dimensions 282 mm x 142 mm 285 mm x 140 mm 265 mm x 143 mm 255 mm x 142 mm 285 mm x 125 mm
Target Use (mountain, road, etc.) Mountain, Road, Gravel Mountain, Cross-country, Gravel Mountain, Road Mountain, Cross-country Mountain
Seat Cover Material Synthetic Bio X-Pad ReActiv Synthetic Microfiber N/A
Shell Material Synthetic SpyderWeb Carbon reinforced, Adaptive Edge Flex-Tuned Duel Tech Carbonite
Anatomical Cut out or channel Anatomical Channel Channel/Anatomical Anatomical Anatomical
Available widths 142 mm 140 mm 143mm, 155mm 142mm, 150mm 125mm

Our Analysis and Test Results

Fabric makes a broad range of saddles and accessories for all types of cycling and has quickly grown their market share over the past several years. The Scoop Race Shallow is a moderately priced all around version in their popular line of Scoop saddles. It features their "shallow" profile that is designed for a more neutral riding position that most people have on a mountain bike. It's got an agreeable shape with a firm shell and moderate padding that allows for a powerful pedal stroke. There's nothing especially noteworthy about the Scoop Race Shallow, but it's relatively comfortable with a clean look, quality construction, and solid all-around performance.

Performance Comparison


The Scoop Race Shallow scored relatively well across the board but was bested by several other competitors which offer a higher degree of comfort, lighter weight, or both.

Testing the Scoop Race Shallow on a lovely spring day.
Testing the Scoop Race Shallow on a lovely spring day.

Comfort


The Scoop Race Shallow is a relatively comfortable saddle, and it scored among the top performers in this metric. It couldn't quite match the superior comfort offered by our highest rated saddles like the Specialized Phenom Comp, Tioga Undercover Stratum, or the WTB Koda Team, but it's not far off the mark either.

Its got a relatively basic but quite agreeable shape that provides a relatively high level of comfort.
Its got a relatively basic but quite agreeable shape that provides a relatively high level of comfort.

Its comfort is primarily due to its shape, with an agreeable 140mm width, rounded side to side profile, and slightly scooped tip to tail profile. This shape supports the rider's weight comfortably on the sit bones while allowing for an unencumbered pedal stroke. It also has medium density padding beneath the waterproof synthetic cover that provides a little bit of cushion. Underneath that padding, however, is a stiff nylon shell that is relatively unforgiving compared to a saddle like the Tioga Undercover Stratum that has a more flexible shell design. When compared to another model with a very stiff shell, the SDG Circuit Mtn Ti, the Scoop is far more comfortable due to its more rounded side to side profile and somewhat softer padding.

It's got a relatively round side to side profile compared to some of the other saddles in this review.
It's got a relatively round side to side profile compared to some of the other saddles in this review.

The Scoop Race Shallow doesn't have any anatomical relief which detracts slightly from its comfort score. There is a depression that runs from the tail of the saddle forward about a third of the way, but it's a little too far back to provide any relief for the perineal area. Saddles like the SQlab 611 Ergowave Active and the Specialized Phenom Comp have significantly better anatomical pressure relief and score higher for comfort as a result.

The shape of the Scoop Race Shallow makes it a relatively comfortable place to rest your hindquarters  but there is little in the way of anatomical pressure relief compared to many other saddles in this review.
The shape of the Scoop Race Shallow makes it a relatively comfortable place to rest your hindquarters, but there is little in the way of anatomical pressure relief compared to many other saddles in this review.

Performance


From a performance standpoint, there's little not to like about the Scoop Race Shallow. There's nothing especially noteworthy about it, it's no-frills, but it gets the job done well. It has a nice teardrop shape with a rounded side to side profile and a stiff shell that makes for an unrestricted and powerful pedal stroke. It feels quite similar to the Specialized Phenom Comp and the Tioga Undercover Stratum in that regard, although the latter is more forgiving overall.

Pedaling performance is one of the Scoop Race Shallows strong suits. Its shape and stiff shell allow for excellent power transfer.
Pedaling performance is one of the Scoop Race Shallows strong suits. Its shape and stiff shell allow for excellent power transfer.

The shape of the Scoop Race Shallow allows for great freedom of movement. It's easy to move side to side and fore and aft with a rounded tail shape that isn't prone to snagging on shorts or other articles of clothing. The nose of the saddle is also right around average in width and length making it good for getting your weight forward on especially steep sections of climbing.

The scoop has a nice shape that makes it easy to move around with a snag-free rounded tail shape.
The scoop has a nice shape that makes it easy to move around with a snag-free rounded tail shape.

Durability


Based on our experience testing the Scoop Race Shallow we feel confident saying that it is a highly durable product. It has a very clean seamless design with a one-piece waterproof synthetic cover that is tucked into the shell underneath. The shell is a single solid piece as well with the sturdy Ti rails pressure fit into it. The rails are straight as the day we got the saddle, and we didn't experience any noises emanating from them while riding. Our one gripe with the Scoop is that it lacks any reinforcement around the damage-prone tail. One of our testers has put a season's worth of miles and abuse on a Scoop saddle that he won at a race, and he claims that it looks and performs as good as the day he put it on his bike.

Other than the lack of tail reinforcement everything about the Scoop appears to be high quality and plenty durable.
Other than the lack of tail reinforcement everything about the Scoop appears to be high quality and plenty durable.

Versatility


As mountain bike saddles are concerned, the Scoop Race Shallow is about as versatile as they come. It is suitable for all types of riding, from XC to gravity oriented riding, with a nice shape that allows for great snag-free freedom of movement and a clean and powerful pedal stroke. This saddle isn't specific to mountain biking either. This is a great all-around option that is equally at home on the road or adventure bike too. Riders who like a pressure relief cutout or channel will be better off looking elsewhere, as this saddle has a relatively stiff shell and no real anatomical relief in its design.

Weight


At 253g, the Scoop Race Shallow won't win any awards for being lightweight, but it falls into a relatively standard weight range for saddles in this review. This weight is reasonable, and if you need a lighter version, there are more expensive and lighter weight Scoop options available. If lightweight is what you seek, then we suggest our Editor's Choice Award winner, the Tioga Undercover Stratum, the WTB Koda Team, or the Tioga Spyder Outland, all of which weigh just over 200g.

It's not the lightest saddle in the test  but 253g isn't all that heavy either.
It's not the lightest saddle in the test, but 253g isn't all that heavy either.

Best Applications


The Scoop Race Shallow is a great option for all types of mountain biking and even road and gravel riding. It's best suited to the rider who needs a 140mm width and likes a somewhat stiff and uncompromising saddle with a very slightly scooped tip to tail profile and a rounded side to side profile.

We liked it on the mountain bike  but it looks just as good on any bike in your quiver.
We liked it on the mountain bike, but it looks just as good on any bike in your quiver.

Value


At a retail price of $105, the Scoop Race Shallow falls toward the lower end of the price spectrum of the saddles in this review. Many of the other models in this test are offered at or near this price point, and you can expect to pay at least $100 for a quality mountain bike saddle. There are less expensive options out there, like our Best Buy Award winner, the WTB Volt Race, which weighs less and has a higher overall performance score. That said, the Scoop is a very well made and durable saddle, and a quality option that will likely please a broad range of riders.

Conclusion


The Scoop Race Shallow is a high quality and durable option that is ideal for the rider seeking a no-frills saddle with great pedaling performance. It has an excellent shape that allows for great freedom of movement and a clean and powerful pedal stroke. While we do think this a versatile and solid option for most riders, it was bested in this test by lighter saddles that offer a higher level of comfort.

The Scoop Race Shallow offers a solid and somewhat uncompromising all-around performance in a quality package with a super clean look and design.
The Scoop Race Shallow offers a solid and somewhat uncompromising all-around performance in a quality package with a super clean look and design.

Other Versions


Fabric makes a full line of saddles, accessories, tools, and pumps. They make saddles for all types of cycling from road racing to mountain biking and everything in between. Each model is available in numerous versions that vary primarily in the rail material, weight, and price. The Scoop Shallow is offered in 6 different versions including the Race version reviewed here. It is also offered in Sport ($42) with steel rails, Elite ($80) with cro-mo rails, Pro ($180) with carbon rails, Pro Team ($180) with carbon rails and large logo, and the Ultimate ($285) that comes with carbon rails and a carbon shell.

Fabric also makes the Scoop Flat which is designed for a more aggressive forward body position, as well as the Scoop Radius models that are intended for riders who prefer a more upright position.


Jeremy Benson