OnGuard Bulldog DT Review
Cons: Lacks the security of better U-locks, clunky design, mount is not our favorite
Compare to Similar Products
OnGuard Bulldog DT
|Price||$45 List||$114.95 at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$74.99 at Competitive Cyclist|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$124.95 at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$115.00 at Amazon|
|Pros||Inexpensive U-lock, durable, good quality||Very secure, mounts to bike, convenient size for locking up||Wearable design, solid security, easy to use||Compact, extremely secure, heavy-duty||Large and strong U-lock, relatively lightweight, beefy mount|
|Cons||Lacks the security of better U-locks, clunky design, mount is not our favorite||Heavy, bulky to transport||Not lightweight, uncomfortable with some backpacks, pricey||Heavy, limited versatility, expensive||Not the highest security possible, expensive|
|Bottom Line||The price is nice here, but it's also once of the lower-security U-locks we have tested||This is the best lock for urban bike life||Wear this chain lock around your waist to bring solid security with you whenever you cycle||This lock is a petite beast||High price meets high quality|
|Rating Categories||OnGuard Bulldog DT||New York Standard U-Lock||Hiplok Original: Superbright||New York Fahgettaboudit U-Lo...||ABUS Granit X-Plus 540 U-Lock|
|Ease Of Transport (25%)|
|Ease Of Use (20%)|
|Specs||OnGuard Bulldog DT||New York Standard...||Hiplok Original:...||New York...||ABUS Granit X-Plus...|
|Measured weight (lbs)||3.0 lbs||4.5 lbs||4.3 lbs||4.7 lbs||3.3 lbs|
|Type of lock||U-Lock + cable||U-lock||Wearable chain||U-Lock||U-lock|
|Lock dimensions||U-lock: 6" x 11" (13mm thick U), Cable: 4' x 0.39"||4" x 8" (16 mm thick U)||33.5" circumference, 2" width||3.3” x 6.3” (18mm thick)||9" x 4.3" (13mm thick U)|
|# of keys included||5 keys||3 keys (one with HID light)||3 keys||3 keys (one with LED light)||2 keys (one with LED light)|
|Primary materials||Steel, braided steel cable||16mm Hardened Steel||8mm hardened steel chain, 600D polyester sleeve||18mm Hardened Steel||13mm hardened steel|
|Warranty/Manufacturer programs||$1,501 Theft Protection, Lifetime Warranty; Key Registration||$4,000 Theft Protection, Limited Lifetime Warranty, Key Safe Program||1-year manufacturer warranty||$5,000 Theft Protection, Limited Lifetime Warranty; Key Safe Program||None|
|Unique Features||Includes 4 foot cable, one key has micro-light||Keyhole cover, LED light on one key; dust cover over keyhole||Reflective sheath, curve key||Small and super burly, LED light on one key; dust cover over keyhole||Automatic keyhole cover, LED light on one key|
|Bolt Cutters, 36"||No||No||No||No||No|
|Number of cuts required to free lock||2 cuts||2 cuts||1 cut||2 cuts||2 cuts|
Our Analysis and Test Results
We didn't find much to get excited about in terms of security. Granted, it's a less expensive U-lock, but OnGuard gives the Bulldog DT a "70" or "high security" rating according to its own internal rating system. If they are referring only to the U part of the lock, we would tend to agree. However, our testers discovered that the shackle is this lock's vulnerable spot.
For thieves with hand tools, the Bulldog is burly: there's no getting through this lock with hammers, tin snips wire cutters or bolt cutters. Once you introduce power tools into the equation, it's over, as with all locks. What downgrades the score of this lock is how quickly we were able to cut through this lock in comparison to other, thicker U-locks we tested. The lock easily succumbed to an electric-powered angle grinder within mere seconds. The worse news? If thieves can cut through the shackle (which we accomplished much easier than we expected), that disables the metal plate that locks the U into the shackle-- so in one cut, it's possible to nab your bike. We generally recommend U-locks that require two cuts to the U portion, or at least a shackle that's more difficult to cut through.
Ease of Transport
If you're not exactly "handy", installing a bike mount could be something of an adventure. Perhaps having this in mind, the designers at OnGuard created a bike mount that is simultaneously robust and easy to install, even if you're not all that skilled at that sort of thing. The low-profile mount fits on most frames and keeps the lock in place even on some considerably rough roads. The mount is sturdy. However, many of our testers didn't love that it positions the 3-pound lock off-center on the bike. We prefer lock mounts that keep the lock streamlined with the bike frame. If you're toting the included cable around for additional security, it will need to be carried in a pack.
While the OnGuard Bulldog isn't the heaviest U-Lock in our lineup, we bet you'll notice the extra three pounds of weight on climbs no matter if the lock is mounted to your frame or is stuffed into your backpack. That's just part of being a U-lock, and actually, this one is lighter than several models. It's also a larger lock, so if you ride a smaller frame (read: 50cm or smaller) you might not be able to mount this lock directly to your frame. Larger sizes mean they can fit around more objects but also more of a bear to transport.
Ease of Use
Even though the locking mechanism is often noted for its security, our testers complimented the OnGuard Bulldog for how easy it was to use. There was no fighting or odd "grippiness" to this lock: every time we used it, it came apart and locked up smoothly.
We also appreciated the fact that this lock comes with five keys — one of which has a light on it. If you're a busy bike commuter, it stands to reason that you might misplace a key. Having four extras is wonderful insurance that you won't run out of them too quickly.
What is not easy to use is OnGuard's protection policy which claims that it will reimburse you up to $1501 if your bike is stolen using their lock. What they put in the fine print is that you have to register your lock and pay to register it in order to qualify. And if you happen to have your bike stolen and you want to collect on this policy, you must provide them with receipts for the lock, the bike, an evaluation of the value of the bike and then proof that the lock failed (most often: the broken lock itself.) As you can imagine, this isn't an easy thing to do. Because of this, we didn't add any extra points to this metric because we assume most riders will not be able to collect on this policy. Most theft insurance policies follow this scheme (OnGuard is not the only company to flash big dollar signs and then have tough stipulations). For this reason, we don't put much weight behind these theft protection policies.
Our testers were impressed with this U-Lock that enabled us to lock our commute bikes to pretty much any bike rack-- and to do so using the most secure method (locking the front and back tire next to the frame and to the bike rack). There were only a handful of situations where we encountered a bike rack or on the trailhead where, due to the constraints of simply being a U-Lock, we couldn't lock our bike securely. In conventional urban settings, this lock is adeptly versatile.
The 4-foot cable that is included with the U-Lock could make this lock a bit more versatile if you live and commute in a low-risk area. However, we always recommend locking both tires to the frame and bike rack. If you're looking for a lock in even a medium-risk area, the included cable isn't going to do much than to deter a snatch-and-grab opportunist. Note: The cable cannot be used on its own, and once the U-lock is defeated, the cable is also defeated.
When you're in the market for a bike lock, less isn't always more…especially when it comes to the price. Granted, we love a good bargain just like the next person, but if you need a U-lock to meet your security needs, we think there are better options out there. At its exact price point, it's actually the best U-lock we know. However, we would recommend that our biking friends spend only a bit more money to get a better lock.
If you've decided there's enough risk where you're riding to merit a U-lock, there are plenty of other options out there that don't cost a whole lot more, but that will offer you more security and peace of mind. The OnGuard Bulldog DT is ok, but its clunky design, off-center mount, and lower security (as far as U-locks are concerned) didn't fully impress us.
— Rebecca Eckland