- Ease of rigging
- Ease of change-over to Rappel
- Size, weight, bulk, sexiness
- Ease of rope feed
- Overall Bomberness (a technical term)= how quickly the device engaged, if it ever failed…etc…
In the end, each device worked well for a self belay, but there can be only one Solo TR king.
To test, we used the rigging system described in our SuperTopo article How To Set Up A Self Belay for a Solo Toprope, with 3 different devices on miles of varying vertical terrain ranging from low angle 5.7 to overhanging 5.11+. We scrutinized each product and compiled a review based on the information we were able to gather.
We tested three different devices head-to-head: Petzl Micro Traxion, the tried and true Petzl Mini Traxion, and the Wild Country Ropeman 3 ascender.
While each of the devices that we tested worked as a self-belay for solo top-roping, we found the Micro Traxion to be the most well suited to the task due to it's light weight, small size, smooth feed, and ease of change over from climbing to rappelling. The only caveat here is that the Micro Traxion is also the most expensive.
A close second is the classic Mini Traxion. Favored for its originality, treasured for its solid performance, revered for its cash savings over the Micro Traxion. The Mini Traxion was not quite as smooth on the rope feed, and the clamp is a bit more difficult to lock in the open position, but the $10 worth of extra beer you can buy is probably worth those minor inconveniences.
Wild Country's Ropeman 3 is a solid little device. However, it has been recalled so we can no longer recommend it.
NOTE: the term "progress capture pulley" is clunky but the best we could think of. Many people often refer to all devices as "Mini traxions" or "Mini traxioning" because the Petzl Mini Traxion is the device that started the rapid growth of toprope self belaying.