The MTI Solaris offers below-average comfort and durability that failed to impress our testers. It does have tons of great storage pockets and extra features we enjoy, though. With a fairly low half-back and a bulky design, this jacket isn't the best option for paddlers. One of the few we tested without ripstop material and sporting some sloppy seams and fraying straps, we aren't impressed by this life jacket's durability. However, it does have some excellent organizational pockets and features and might be better suited to a laid back day of fishing than a hard afternoon of paddling.
MTI Solaris Review
Cons: A bit bulky, half back a little low, not the most durable
Compare to Similar Products
|Price||$78.37 at Amazon||$89.89 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$104.89 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$92.38 at Amazon|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$74.73 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|Pros||Good pocket organization, reflective strips, comes with a whistle||Tapered front, comfortable, breathable, good strap management, large pockets||Very adjustable, great fit, secure and comfortable, good sizing options, moves well, flattering||Excellent paddling mobility, breathable and open design, comfortable fabric, works for short torsos||Comfortable fabric, moves with you, durable, secure fit|
|Cons||A bit bulky, half back a little low, not the most durable||Back panel high for swimming, runs large, pockets may be in the way while paddling||Full coverage can be hot, runs a bit large||Bulky, unbending and flat, rough straps, key loop catches in pocket zipper||No ventilation, sizing a bit generic for a really good fit, pushes breasts into armpits|
|Bottom Line||Not our favorite, but filled with useful features.||A versatile paddling jacket with good ventilation and big pockets.||A highly adaptable, super comfortable women's PFD with great sizing options.||Providing out-of-the-way, low profile protection that doesn't cut down on your mobility.||A comfortable, full-coverage option for female paddlers.|
|Rating Categories||MTI Solaris||Astral V-Eight||Astral Layla||NRS Ninja||NRS Siren|
|Specs||MTI Solaris||Astral V-Eight||Astral Layla||NRS Ninja||NRS Siren|
|Intended Use||Kayaking||Recreational, fishing, touring||Whitewater, sea paddling, touring, SUP||Paddling (low profile)||Paddling, whitewater|
|Entry Style||Front, 2 center clips||Front, center zip and bottom clip||Pull over; side entry, off-center 3/4 zip and bottom clip||Pull over; side entry, 2 side clips||Pull over; side entry, 2 side clips|
|Sizes Available||XS/S (30-36")
|Size We Tested||M/L (36-46")||S/M (31-37")||S/M (31-37")||S/M (33-40")||XS/S (30-42")|
|Measured Weight (ounces)||20 oz||20 oz||26 oz||28 oz||29 oz|
|Foam Type||EPE/PE foam||PE foam & EVA foam||Kapok fiber front, PVC-free PE foam back||PVC-free, PE foam||PVC-free, ultrasoft foam|
|Main Material||300D polyester shell, 200D polyester liner||200 x 400D ripstop nylon||200 x 400D ripstop nylon shell, 200D nylon liner||200D urethane-coated ripstop nylon||200D ripstop nylon shell, smooth 210D nylon liner|
|Rated Buoyancy||16.6 - 19 lb||16 lb||16.3 lb||16.5 lb||16.5 lb|
|USCG classification||Type III||Type III||Type III||Type III||Type III|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Solaris is a unisex life vest that comes in three sizes. It's a half-back Type III vest made of a 300D polyester shell with a 200D polyester liner.
While we initially liked the lack of zipper on this front-clip vest, we soon realized that the placement of the clips and straps are a little too low to easily get a comfortable, secure fit. And though the top is slightly tapered, it's too high to be of much help for women. The entire front of the vest is also rather stiff and unbending, making it difficult to pull snug around your torso without it getting in the way of a near-body paddle stroke. The half-back works well with low touring seats and is thin enough that leaning back on a full seat isn't too terrible. However, if you're a shorter person or have a slightly taller seat back in your boat, the lower coverage may be in conflict with your comfort. The bottom strap is also located under the front panels, which makes it cut uncomfortably into your stomach when you sit.
If you can stand having the bottom strap cinched down securely, the Solaris stays in place as you plunge into the water. Based on the discomfort we felt while wearing this tightly and sitting for long periods of time, we doubt many will be inclined to suffer through this feeling. With the bottom strap less than snug, the Solaris does ride up in the water, as you'd expect from a loose vest. Our 5'4" main tester found herself unable to get a proper fit in the Solaris because it's too tall for her torso, meaning it rides up every time she gets in the water. This added area of padding without ventilation can also make the Solaris a bit warm to paddle in on a hot day. While the arm areas are wide enough for a decent paddle stroke, the bulkiness of the bottom of the MTI combined with its proclivity for riding up in the water makes it hard to swim in it without hitting the sides.
Assuming the back works with the seat height in your preferred craft, the Solaris is decent as a paddle jacket. It's also full of useful features that our organizational nerds were big fans of. This vest has multiple pockets on each side, that open out to the sides for sticking your hands and on the front into large cargo pockets. One is a velcroed flip-top while the other zips open. Numerous bungee loops provide attachment points for smaller items and the shoulder containment loops are also reflective. The Solaris even comes with a tethered emergency whistle right on the front of the jacket, giving you extra peace of mind if you do fall off the pontoon or powerboat. It also weighs just 20 ounces, about average among vests we tested.
Though the 300D polyester shell is thicker than many other PFDs we tested, its 200D polyester liner is about average and neither are ripstop, which can be a longevity issue, especially if you're rough on your gear. It's filled with EPE/PE foam, which is fairly standard among models in our review. We also noticed some sloppy seams and ends sticking out and starting to unravel after a few months of testing. The ends of some of the straps are also a little too easy to fray for our liking. MTI does offer a lifetime limited manufacturers warranty to the original owner and recommends that if the jacket is faded it should be replaced.
Retailing for a below-average price among contenders we tested, the low-scoring Solaris isn't even the cheapest PFD in this review. Unless you're really gaga for the features and pockets it has, we're just not convinced this price is worth what you get.
The MTI Solaris, unfortunately, didn't score very well in our testing and is our team's least favorite life jacket of the bunch we tested. It's not a terrible choice and has a lot of pockets for organizing whatever you may need on the water, but we think there are many better options available.
— Maggie Brandenburg