Marmot has long had our respect for holding down the market on their PreCip, a remarkably affordable rain shell that performs well in a variety of environments. The Eclipse, however, is not up to this thematic standard. The outer material is nice and durable, but the inner material feels clammy and does not breathe as well as we would like for a jacket that costs $250. The features make it look like it would be adequate for mountain use but ultimately are abbreviated in ways that end up being frustrating, such as the pit zips with a single, one-way zipper so you can't adjust how big and where exactly you ventilate. This jacket has potential, but we don't think it should be more than double the price of the PreCip in its current state.
Marmot Eclipse - Women's Review
Cons: Less comfortable, less breathable, not ideal for mountain use
Compare to Similar Products
Marmot Eclipse - Women's
|Price||$159.21 at Amazon||$198.83 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$550.00 at Backcountry||$249.00 at REI||$209.95 at Amazon|
Compare at 3 sellers
|Pros||Durable exterior, functional for a variety of activities||Highly versatile, breathable, lightweight||Lightweight, breathable, fully featured, durable||Lightweight, supple, breathable, versatile||High quality, lightweight, durable, great value|
|Cons||Less comfortable, less breathable, not ideal for mountain use||Expensive, still made of lighter and somewhat less durable fabric||Not the lightest on the market||Thinner fabric, less features||Less features, somewhat less versatile|
|Bottom Line||Okay for a variety of tasks, but not ideal for any with reduced breathability and shortchanged features.||The Beta SL Hybrid retains an impressive focus on light weight while introducing key features to make it highly versatile.||An incredibly versatile model that is competent for a wide range of adventures.||The Drypoint is an excellent hardshell, lightweight and comfortable, which performs well for a variety of activities.||A great value; it is light, durable, and useful on many types of adventures.|
|Rating Categories||Marmot Eclipse - Women's||Beta SL Hybrid||Norrona Trollveggen Gore-Tex...||Drypoint GTX||Arc'teryx Zeta SL - Women's|
|Weather Protection (20%)|
|Specs||Marmot Eclipse -...||Beta SL Hybrid||Norrona...||Drypoint GTX||Arc'teryx Zeta SL...|
|Category||Athletic fit||Light weight, athletic fit||Mid weight, Regular fit||Mid/ light weight, regular fit||Mid wieght, regular fit|
|Length of back, from base of neck to bottom (inches)||26||26||28||27||27|
|Material||Membrain Eco 2.5 Lamination 100% Recycled Nylon Solution Dyed Plainweave 3.4 oz/ yd||N42p GORE-TEX fabric with Gore C-KNIT backer technology N40r GORE-TEX fabric with PACLITE® Plus product technology||40D GORE-TEX Pro fabric||20-denier ripstop nylon Gor-Tex coating||40-denier ripstop (N40r) GORE-TEX PACLITE Plus|
|Pockets||2 hand||2 hand||2 chest, 1 interior chest||2 hand||2 hand|
|Helmet Compatible Hood||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||No|
|Harness and Backpack Strap Compatible||Yes||Yes||Yes, high pockets||Yes||Yes|
|Draw cords||3 hood, 1 waist||3 hood, 2 waist||1 hood, 2 waist||3 hood, 2 waist||1 hood, 2 waist|
|Adjustable Cuffs||Yes, Velcro||Yes, Velcro||Yes, Velcro||Yes, Velcro||Yes, Velcro|
|Two-Way Front Zipper||Yes||No||No||No||No|
|Warranty Policy||Practical lifetime warranty - Material or workmanship defects will be replaced or repaired by Marmot's discretion||Practical lifetime warranty - Material or workmanship defects will be replaced or repaired at Arc'teryx's discretion||5 year - production and material defects||Lifetime Guarantee for manufacturer defects, 1 year return policy if you are disatisfied with your purchase||Practical lifetime warranty - Material or workmanship defects will be replaced or repaired at Arc'teryx's discretion|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Eclipse offers good protection from rain with its Membrain Eco 2.5 lamination made from 100% recycled nylon. It has a helmet compatible hood with three adjustment points, and a bottom hem with one cinching toggle to effectively keep the storm on the outside. For a burly hardshell made of 3-layer waterproof fabric, check out the Norrona Trollveggen or the excellent all-rounder, the Arc'teryx Beta AR.
The Eclipse offers decent mobility for a wide range of activities; Marmot suggests this is a shell for climbing and trekking. While all the parts are certainly there to make this a sensible companion on these types of backcountry trips, we were very disappointed to find that the interior feels much like their PreCip jacket, which can easily be found for under $100 (not the $250 of the Eclipse).
This clammy feeling fabric feels terrible when it is wet and humid outside, especially if we are working hard and generating some body heat. The Eclipse is a decent rain jacket, but we don't recommend it for general mountain use. It will work in a pinch if you already own it, but if you intend to spend a lot of time in the mountains, we recommend checking out the REI Drypoint GTX as a great and affordable entry into mountain-ready hardshells.
The inside of the Eclipse feels like the material in their PreCip jackets. We don't mind this on the PreCip because we don't intend to take that rain shell into the mountains, and it is a great deal for $100. But in a jacket that claims to be suitable for climbing and long mountain treks, and which is priced for $250, we expect more. This interior feels clammy when working hard in the mountains.
The Eclipse also has pit zips, but there is only one zipper, so it opens in only one direction, from the arm end toward the torso. We prefer a jacket that allows you to choose how to open the pit vents so that you can expel heat without letting rain or snow inside because the flap is too large or in the wrong spot as you swing your arms.
For improved breathability and venting, check out either of the Arc'teryx Beta SL and Hybrid or the impressively breathable REI Drypoint GTX.
The Eclipse is in the middle of the pack for weight. We really like the performance-to-weight ratio of any of the Arc'teryx models, depending on your needs from ultralight and breathable to burly expedition-ready. And if weight is your number one priority, check out the REI Drypoint or The North Face HyperAir GTX Trail if you're a runner.
The feature set of the Eclipse makes it useful for climbing, though we found it to be limited in mountain performance in some of the metrics above. However, the hood is helmet-compatible and adjustable with three cinching points and features a brim that helps keep precip out of your eyes. The jacket has two hand pockets with mesh inside so they can double as core vents, and they are high enough to be accessible above a harness or hip belt. It has pit vents, but they only unzip in one direction, and the bottom hem has one cinching adjustment point. The cuffs feature a Velcro closure to cinch them tighter under or over gloves.
The Eclipse is plenty durable. The face fabric is a little stiffer which we prefer because it resists snagging better than more supple fabrics. The zippers are smooth, and otherwise, the features of the Eclipse held up well in our testing. For the most durable jackets in this review, check out our expedition-ready models, the Mammut Nordwand and the Arc'teryx Alpha SV.
The Eclipse is not as versatile as we had hoped. Marmot suggests that it is mountain-ready, and while the feature set suggests this is true (and it will certainly be adequate for a trip or two) we found the interior and the breathability to be unpleasant, especially for a jacket that costs $250.
The Eclipse is capable of many activities, but while Marmot advertises it for climbing and long distance trekking, we think this is better viewed as an everyday urban or casual rain jacket that can be taken along on the occasional hike or climb in a pinch.
For $250, the Eclipse is a little disappointing. The main limiting factors were the breathability, weight vs. useful features, and the clammy feeling interior.
The Marmot Eclipse is overall a disappointing shell jacket. Marmot advertises it for climbing and long mountain treks, but we think it is better viewed as an active-urban or casual shell jacket that can be taken into the mountains in a pinch on an occasional hike. This is not a great shell for high output aerobic pursuits.
— Lyra Pierotti